Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
007 INSC 1018
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 147 and 308/149 of the Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act (not mentioned in the text)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
007 INSC 1018
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 147 and 308/149 of the Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act (not mentioned in the text)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 30 September 1984, at approximately 6:30 p.m., Harish Bhatt was assaulted with lathis by six individuals—Arjun Singh, Shivraj, Govind Singh, Bhairav Dutt (now deceased), and the present appellants Bishan Singh and Govind Ballabh—while returning to his village. The assailants also removed ₹400 from his pocket. Harish Bhatt’s brother, Ghanshyam Dutt Bhatt, intervened. Medical examination revealed eight injuries, seven of which were simple; the grievous injury was a fracture–dislocation of the wrist.

A First Information Report was lodged under Sections 147 and 323 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The police, however, filed a charge-sheet under Section 308 IPC as well. The trial court convicted the two surviving accused under Sections 147 and 308/149 IPC, imposing one year of rigorous imprisonment (RI) for Section 147 and four years’ RI for Section 308/149. The High Court affirmed the convictions and sentences. The appellants sought relief before the Supreme Court of India.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution proved the requisite intention or knowledge to sustain a conviction under Section 308 read with Section 149 IPC.
  2. Consequently, whether the conviction should instead fall under the lesser offences of Sections 323 and 325 IPC.
  3. If the conviction is altered, what punishment is just in the circumstances, given the passage of time and the appellants’ conduct on bail.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court emphasised that Section 308 IPC requires proof that the accused acted with the intention or knowledge that their act was likely to cause culpable homicide. The trial court had relied almost exclusively on the First Information Report, without analysing whether such intention or knowledge existed. The High Court repeated this error, presuming intent from past enmity and the use of lathis.

Analysing the evidentiary record, the Court noted:

  • Only one of the eight injuries was grievous, a fracture on the arm—not a vital part of the body.
  • No witness statement established that the assailants intended to kill Harish Bhatt.
  • The mere presence of enmity and lathis did not automatically satisfy the mental element required by Section 308.

Accordingly, the conduct more appropriately constituted offences under Sections 323 (voluntarily causing hurt) and 325 (voluntarily causing grievous hurt) IPC, not Section 308.

As to sentencing, the Court took a “lenient view” based on:

  • The incident occurred 23 years earlier (in 1984).
  • The appellants had been on bail throughout and had not misused that liberty.
  • They had already spent over five months in custody.
  • The attack, though wrongful, did not display exceptional cruelty or “mental depravity.”

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed in Part. The conviction under Section 308/149 IPC was set aside and the conduct re-classified under Sections 323 and 325 IPC. The substantive sentence was reduced to the period already undergone. Each appellant must pay a fine of ₹15,000, with a default sentence of one year’s simple imprisonment. From the amount realised, ₹25,000 is to be paid to the informant. The appellants are to be released forthwith if not required in any other case.

Implications: The decision offers no new precedent but underscores that courts must explicitly examine the mental element—intention or knowledge—before upholding a conviction under Section 308 IPC. Sentencing was moderated due to substantial delay and satisfactory conduct while on bail.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Bishan Singh And Another v. State .

    S.B Sinha, J.— Leave granted.

    2. Bishan Singh, son of Bachchi Singh and Govind Ballabh, son of Krishnanand, the two surviving accused, who were tried and convicted for commission of an offence under Sections 147 and 308/149 of the Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) are before us; the other four accused, namely, Arjun Singh, Shivraj, Govind Singh and Bhairav Dutt having expired.

    3. One Harish Bhatt was the complainant. On 30-9-1984 at about 6.30 p.m when he was going towards his village, the accused persons allegedly assaulted him with lathis and took out a sum of Rs 400 from his pocket. His brother Ghanshyam Dutt Bhatt intervened. It was alleged that the accused persons were inimically disposed towards the injured and had attacked him with an intention to cause his death. The injuries suffered by Harish Bhatt as per the injury report prepared by Dr. J.S Pangti (PW 6) are as under:

    “1. Lacerated wound 3 cm × 1 cm on scalp at right parietal region, 14 cm above the right eyebrow. Scalp-deep. Fresh bleeding present.
    2. Lacerated wound 5 cm × ½ cm × scalp-deep on scalp, at right parietal area, 19 cm above the right eyebrow.
    3. Lacerated wound 3 cm × ¼ cm × skin-deep, 4 cm above the right eyebrow at right forehead, 6 cm × 7 cm swelling around the wound.
    4. Abrasion 1 cm × ½ cm, at upper lip, 3 cm from the right angle of the mouth.
    4.1. Abrasion 1 cm × ½ cm at lower lip right angle of mouth.
    5. Contusion mark 10 cm × 5 cm above right shoulder reddish in colour. Swelling 2 cm around the wound.
    6. Contusion mark 6 cm × 6.5 cm on above and front and middle of left arm, 13 cm below the shoulder joint 1 cm swelling around the injury.
    7. Contusion 12 cm × 10 cm at forearm, 8 cm from the left wrist joint ½ cm swelling around the injury.
    8. Complain of pain in both lower legs and thigh, but no injury seen.”

    4. Admittedly, all the injuries except Injury 7 were simple ones. Injury 7 being a fracture with dislocation of wrist joint was found to be grievous one. The injured witness examined himself as PW 5. In his deposition, he alleged:

    “… I used to stop the accused from fighting with the poor people and I was witness against the accused persons in the litigation between Shanti Joshi and accused persons. That is why the accused beat me. My head was wounded. My kurta was full of blood and seizure report of kurta had been made in the hospital….”

    5. The learned trial Judge relying on or on the basis of the testimonies of the said witness as also his brother, convicted the appellants for commission of an offence under Sections 147 and 308/149 IPC and sentenced them to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year for the offence punishable under Section 147 IPC and rigorous imprisonment for four years for the offence punishable under Sections 308/149 IPC.

    6. Although in the first information report, the informant had alleged that all the six accused had earlier threatened to kill him as also burn his hut and the said attack was with an intention to kill him, but the offence recorded therein was under Sections 147 and 323 IPC. The charge-sheet was, however, submitted, inter alia, under Section 308 IPC.

    7. We have noticed hereinbefore that in his deposition PW 5 stated about the existing enmity between the parties. It does not appear from his deposition that he had made any statement to the effect that the accused had attacked him with an intention to kill. The learned trial Judge in his judgment solely relying upon the allegations made in the first information report opined that a case under Section 308 IPC was made out.

    8. Interestingly, the learned trial Judge observed that the charge under Section 308 IPC read with Section 149 thereof was proved, because the eyewitnesses had clearly stated that they were armed with lathis.

    9. The learned trial Judge did not notice the ingredients of Section 308 IPC which provides for existence of an intention or knowledge.

    10. The High Court also dismissed the appeal, opining:

    “33. From perusal of record it has been established that the intention of the accused persons was to commit culpable homicide. They had enmity with the injured Harish Bhatt. Threats were also given to him by the accused persons to ruin his life. PW 4, Ghanshyam Dutt has clearly stated that when he reached at the spot he saw that the accused persons were beating the injured recklessly with lathis-dandas. Injuries were also caused on scalp. Looking to the seat of injuries and the fact and circumstances of the case the prosecution has been able to prove the offence under Sections 308/149 IPC against the accused persons. The finding of the trial court is just and proper and need no interference by the appellate court.”

    11. Before an accused can be held to be guilty under Section 308 IPC, it was necessary to arrive at a finding that the ingredients thereof, namely, requisite intention or knowledge was existing. There cannot be any doubt whatsoever that such an intention or knowledge on the part of the accused to cause culpable homicide is required to be proved. Six persons allegedly accosted the injured. They had previous enmity. Although overt act had been attributed against each of the accused who were having lathis, only seven injuries had been caused and out of them only one was grievous, being a fracture on the arm, which was not on the vital part of the body.

    12. The accused, therefore, in our opinion, could not be said to have committed any offence under Section 308 IPC. The same would fall under Sections 323 and 325 thereof.

    13. The question now is what punishment should be awarded.

    14. While imposing punishment in a case of this nature, the court is required to take into consideration the factors which may weigh with the court for taking a lenient view in the matter. The incident is of 1984. 23 years have elapsed. The appellants had all along remained on bail. It is not stated that they had ever misused the privilege of bail. The incident does not reflect any cruelty on their part or any mental depravity. They had been in custody for more than five months. In a situation of this nature, we are of the opinion that it may not be proper for this Court to send the accused persons back to prison. However, the injured had suffered pains at the hands of the appellants. We are, therefore, of the opinion that while their substantive sentence may be reduced to the period undergone, they should pay a fine of Rs 15,000 (Rupees fifteen thousand) each; failing which they should undergo simple imprisonment for a period of one year each. If the aforementioned amount is realised, a sum of Rs 25,000 (Rupees twenty-five thousand) out of the sum, may be paid to the informant.

    15. The appellants who are in custody shall be released forthwith, if not required in connection with any other case, subject to the aforementioned conditions.

    16. The appeal is allowed to the aforementioned extent.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bishan Singh And Another v. State .
    (Oct 9, 2007)