Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2007 INSC 184
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the Act is not mentioned but The Act is mentioned as 'the Act' in the text.
  • Section 10 of the Act
  • Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2007 INSC 184
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the Act is not mentioned but The Act is mentioned as 'the Act' in the text.
  • Section 10 of the Act
  • Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent–husband filed a petition under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 seeking a decree of divorce on the ground of cruelty. The parties were married on 17-04-1993 and had four children. According to the respondent, the appellant–wife repeatedly demanded money, threatened to file false dowry cases, abused and physically mistreated both him and their children, and on 05-04-2002 left the matrimonial home with three children who were later found dead in a well. The appellant was convicted under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code for that incident; her appeal against conviction is pending. The trial court granted a decree of divorce after finding multiple acts of mental and physical cruelty. The Rajasthan High Court, Jodhpur bench, dismissed the appellant’s statutory appeal under Section 28 of the Act. The present Supreme Court judgment resolves her further appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent–husband proved acts of mental and physical cruelty sufficient to justify a decree of divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
  2. Whether the pendency of the appellant’s criminal appeal against her conviction under Section 302 IPC should have restrained the courts from granting divorce.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The decree of divorce was improperly based on her criminal conviction, which is sub judice in appeal.
  • The respondent and his family had in fact demanded dowry and subjected her to harassment; police investigation into her dowry complaint was inadequate.
  • No money was ever taken by her or her family from the respondent.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The trial court and High Court relied on numerous proven instances of cruelty, independent of the appellant’s conviction.
  • The appellant’s conduct—including threats, physical abuse of the children, false dowry allegations, and violent behaviour—clearly satisfied the legal standard for cruelty.
  • Therefore, no ground exists for Supreme Court interference.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
(2005) 2 SCC 22 Comprehensive discussion of what constitutes “cruelty” (physical and mental) in matrimonial law, emphasising gravity, context, and impact on the complaining spouse. Quotations from this case supplied the definitional framework the Court applied to evaluate the appellant’s conduct.
Shobha Rani v. Madhukar Reddy, (1988) 1 SCC 105 Illustrates that inherently unlawful or illegal conduct may itself constitute cruelty without separate proof of its impact. Cited within the larger quotation to support the view that certain conduct is per se cruel once proved.
Dr. N.G. Dastane v. Mrs. S. Dastane, (1975) 2 SCC 326 Highlights the need for a realistic, non-technical approach when assessing matrimonial cruelty, recognising ordinary marital frictions should not be exaggerated. Relied upon to underscore the contextual evaluation required in determining cruelty.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court first recited the legal principles governing “cruelty,” quoting extensively from (2005) 2 SCC 22 and related precedents. It affirmed that cruelty may be mental or physical and must be assessed in light of the parties’ social milieu, the gravity of conduct, and its impact on the spouse.

Applying those principles, the Court endorsed the factual findings of the trial court and High Court, which had catalogued numerous acts by the appellant: persistent monetary demands, threats to falsely implicate the respondent in dowry cases, physical mistreatment of their children (including tying them with ropes and attempting to throw them from a rooftop), and threatening to kill the respondent even in the courtroom after her conviction. These acts, viewed cumulatively, created a reasonable apprehension for the respondent’s safety and mental wellbeing.

The Court expressly rejected the contention that the decree rested solely on the appellant’s homicide conviction; both lower courts had treated the conviction only as background, not as the foundation of their decision, recognising that the criminal appeal was pending.

Finding no legal or factual error in the concurrent findings below, the Court concluded that the appellant’s conduct met the threshold of cruelty under the Act.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. The decree of divorce granted by the trial court and affirmed by the High Court stands confirmed. No order as to costs.

Implications: The decision ends the marital relationship between the parties and reinforces existing jurisprudence that persistent abusive behaviour and serious threats—even apart from a disputed criminal conviction—constitute cruelty. The judgment applies established principles without creating new precedent.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Mayadevi (Smt) v. Jagdish Prasad .

    Dr. Arijit Pasayat, J.— Leave granted.

    2. Challenge in this appeal is to the judgment rendered by a learned Single Judge of the Rajasthan High Court at Jodhpur dismissing the appeal filed by the appellant under Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (in short “the Act”).

    3. Background facts in a nutshell are as follows:

    The respondent filed an application for divorce on the ground of cruelty alleging that because of the acts of cruelty on several occasions perpetuated by the appellant, the respondent husband was under apprehension that it would not be desirable and safe to stay with the appellant and to continue their marital relationship.

    4. It was, inter alia, stated in the divorce petition as follows:

    Parties got married according to the Hindu rites on 17-4-1993. The appellant's father was an employee in the Railway Department and the appellant used to make demands for money frequently and used to quarrel when money was not paid. She did not even provide food to her husband or the children and used to threaten the husband to falsely implicate him in a case of dowry demand and to kill the children and to put the blame on the respondent husband and his family members. On 23-10-1999 she took Rs 1,05,000 from the respondent and acknowledged the receipt of the money in the diary of the respondent husband. She used to borrow money from time to time at the behest of her parents. From the wedlock four children were born, namely, Neha, Anu, Khemraj and Vishnu Sagar. The appellant used to keep the children tied by ropes and she attempted to throw them down from the rooftop and used to physically torture them. She was temperamentally very cruel and used to behave cruelly with the children also. She always used to threaten that she will destroy the whole family of the respondent and that there would be no successor left in the family. On 5-4-2002 at about 12.00 noon she left her parental (sic matrimonial) home along with three children namely, Neha, Anu and Khemraj on the pretext that she was going to her parental house which was located in the same village. Since she did not return till evening as was told to the respondent husband, he started searching for her. During course of search the garments and slippers of the children and the appellant were found lying near the well of Ramialji. Police was informed and on search dead bodies of the three children were recovered from the well and the appellant was also taken out of the well. A criminal case was instituted and she was convicted for an offence under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (in short “IPC”). She was pregnant at that time and subsequently delivered a child. She filed an application for bail. While on bail, she filed a false case alleging dowry demand against the respondent husband and his family members. Final report was given by police and it was observed that a false case had been lodged.

    5. The appellant filed her response to the petition for divorce and contended that no amount was borrowed by her father or any of her family members. The respondent husband used to threaten her for dowry and she had never perpetuated any cruelty so far as the children and the husband were concerned. She did not know as to how the children fell into the well. She was herself unconscious and recovered after about four days. The husband, in fact, turned her out of matrimonial home on 5-4-2002 along with their three children. Unfortunately, she and the three children fell into the well. The appeal is pending against her conviction.

    6. The trial court found that the allegation of cruelty was established. Several instances were noted. One of them related to her behaviour on the date of judgment in the criminal case. After the judgment of conviction was pronounced, she threatened to kill the husband and prosecute him. It was also noted by the trial court that the allegation made by her alleging dowry demand was disbelieved and the police gave final report stating that the case was falsely lodged. The trial court granted the decree of divorce which was, as noted above, confirmed by the High Court in appeal by dismissing the appellant's appeal.

    7. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the foundation of decree for divorce is the alleged conviction for which the appeal is pending and, therefore, the High Court should not have disposed of the matter. In any event, it is submitted that it was the husband and his family members who were torturing her and being threatened by the husband she had not made any grievance with the police. Unfortunately, when she made the allegation, the police did not properly investigate the matter and gave a final report exonerating the husband.

    8. Learned counsel for the respondent on the other hand submitted that the instances highlighted by the trial court and analysed in great detail by the High Court clearly made out a case for dowry (sic cruelty) and no interference is called for in this appeal.

    9. “10. The expression ‘cruelty’ has not been defined in the Act. Cruelty can be physical or mental. Cruelty which is a ground for dissolution of marriage may be defined as wilful and unjustifiable conduct of such character as to cause danger to life, limb or health, bodily or mental, or as to give rise to a reasonable apprehension of such a danger. The question of mental cruelty has to be considered in the light of the norms of marital ties of the particular society to which the parties belong, their social values, status, environment in which they live. Cruelty, as noted above, includes mental cruelty, which falls within the purview of a matrimonial wrong. Cruelty need not be physical. If from the conduct of the spouse same is established and/or an inference can be legitimately drawn that the treatment of the spouse is such that it causes an apprehension in the mind of the other spouse, about his or her mental welfare then this conduct amounts to cruelty. In a delicate human relationship like matrimony, one has to see the probabilities of the case. The concept, proof beyond the shadow of doubt, is to be applied to criminal trials and not to civil matters and certainly not to matters of such delicate personal relationship as those of husband and wife. Therefore, one has to see what are the probabilities in a case and legal cruelty has to be found out, not merely as a matter of fact, but as the effect on the mind of the complainant spouse because of the acts or omissions of the other. Cruelty may be physical or corporeal or may be mental. In physical cruelty, there can be tangible and direct evidence, but in the case of mental cruelty there may not at the same time be direct evidence. In cases where there is no direct evidence, courts are required to probe into the mental process and mental effect of incidents that are brought out in evidence. It is in this view that one has to consider the evidence in matrimonial disputes.
    11. The expression ‘cruelty’ has been used in relation to human conduct or human behaviour. It is the conduct in relation to or in respect of matrimonial duties and obligations. Cruelty is a course or conduct of one, which is adversely affecting the other. The cruelty may be mental or physical, intentional or unintentional. If it is physical, the court will have no problem in determining it. It is a question of fact and degree. If it is mental, the problem presents difficulties. First, the enquiry must begin as to the nature of cruel treatment, second the impact of such treatment in the mind of the spouse, whether it caused reasonable apprehension that it would be harmful or injurious to live with the other. Ultimately, it is a matter of inference to be drawn by taking into account the nature of the conduct and its effect on the complaining spouse. However, there may be a case where the conduct complained of itself is bad enough and per se unlawful or illegal. Then the impact or injurious effect on the other spouse need not be enquired into or considered. In such cases, the cruelty will be established if the conduct itself is proved or admitted. (See Shobha Rani v. Madhukar Reddi (1988) 1 SCC 105, AIR 1988 SC 121.)” (2005) 2 SCC 22
    “12. To constitute cruelty, the conduct complained of should be ‘grave and weighty’ so as to come to the conclusion that the petitioner spouse cannot be reasonably expected to live with the other spouse. It must be something more serious than ‘ordinary wear and tear of married life’. The conduct, taking into consideration the circumstances and background has to be examined to reach the conclusion whether the conduct complained of amounts to cruelty in the matrimonial law. Conduct has to be considered, as noted above, in the background of several factors such as social status of parties, their education, physical and mental conditions, customs and traditions. It is difficult to lay down a precise definition or to give exhaustive description of the circumstances, which would constitute cruelty. It must be of the type as to satisfy the conscience of the court that the relationship between the parties had deteriorated to such an extent due to the conduct of the other spouse that it would be impossible for them to live together without mental agony, torture or distress, to entitle the complaining spouse to secure divorce. Physical violence is not absolutely essential to constitute cruelty and a consistent course of conduct inflicting immeasurable mental agony and torture may well constitute cruelty within the meaning of Section 10 of the Act. Mental cruelty may consist of verbal abuses and insults by using filthy and abusive language leading to constant disturbance of mental peace of the other party.
    13. The court dealing with the petition for divorce on the ground of cruelty has to bear in mind that the problems before it are those of human beings and the psychological changes in a spouse's conduct have to be borne in mind before disposing of the petition for divorce. However insignificant or trifling, such conduct may cause pain in the mind of another. But before the conduct can be called cruelty, it must touch a certain pitch of severity. It is for the court to weigh the gravity. It has to be seen whether the conduct was such that no reasonable person would tolerate it. It has to be considered whether the complainant should be called upon to endure as a part of normal human life. Every matrimonial conduct, which may cause annoyance to the other, may not amount to cruelty. Mere trivial irritations, quarrels between spouses, which happen in day-to-day married life, may also not amount to cruelty. Cruelty in matrimonial life may be of unfounded variety, which can be subtle or brutal. It may be words, gestures or by mere silence, violent or non-violent.
    14. The foundation of a sound marriage is tolerance, adjustment and respecting one another. Tolerance to each other's fault to a certain bearable extent has to be inherent in every marriage. Petty quibbles, trifling differences should not be exaggerated and magnified to destroy what is said to have been made in heaven. All quarrels must be weighed from that point of view in determining what constitutes cruelty in each particular case and as noted above, always keeping in view the physical and mental conditions of the parties, their character and social status. A too technical and hypersensitive approach would be counterproductive to the institution of marriage. The courts do not have to deal with ideal husbands and ideal wives. It has to deal with a particular man and woman before it. The ideal couple or a mere ideal one will probably have no occasion to go to matrimonial court. (See N.G Dastane (Dr.) v. S. Dastane (1975) 2 SCC 326, AIR 1975 SC 1534.)” (2005) 2 SCC 22

    10. The instances of cruelty highlighted by the trial court and also by the High Court clearly prove that the husband was subjected to mental and physical cruelty. It is not a fact as submitted by learned counsel for the appellant that the conviction in the criminal case was the foundation for the decree. On the contrary, the trial court clearly mentioned that the aspect was not taken note of as the appeal was pending.

    11. In view of what has been stated above, the inevitable result is dismissal of the appeal which we direct. There will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mayadevi (Smt) v. Jagdish Prasad .
    (Feb 21, 2007)