Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The State of Uttar Pradesh issued a Government Order dated 14-1-2004 creating a Special BTC Training Course, 2004—a six-month programme (including three months of practical work) intended to train 46,189 candidates holding B.Ed./L.T. qualifications. Eligibility criteria included completion of the requisite degree as a regular student from recognised institutions and an age range of 16–35 years (with limited relaxations for certain categories). The appellants, who had failed to secure admission to this training course, asserted entitlement to preferential selection because they had participated in a similar selection process for the Special BTC Course, 2001.

They filed a writ petition before the Allahabad High Court. A learned Single Judge dismissed the petition, and a Division Bench affirmed that dismissal on 14-5-2004 (Special Appeal No. 461 of 2004). The present appeals were brought before the Supreme Court challenging the High Court’s common judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the authorities were justified in refusing to select the appellants for admission to the Special BTC Training Course, 2004.
  2. Whether, in preparing the merit list for the course, candidates who completed their B.Ed./L.T. (or equivalent) training earlier should have been ranked higher than those who completed it later, purportedly in terms of Rule 14 of the U.P. Basic Education (Teachers) Service Rules, 1981.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The merit list should be organised year-wise so that candidates who completed their teacher-training course earlier receive higher placement.
  • Sub-rules (3)–(6) of Rule 14 of the U.P. Basic Education (Teachers) Service Rules, 1981—allegedly still in force—require such year-wise ordering, and therefore the High Court erred in holding those sub-rules deleted.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court analysed the appellants’ reliance on the U.P. Basic Education (Teachers) Service Rules, 1981 and found it misplaced for two principal reasons:

  • The 1981 Rules govern post-training recruitment to teaching posts, not the initial selection of candidates for a Basic Training Course. Consequently, Rule 14 has no application to admissions into the Special BTC Training Course, 2004.
  • Even assuming parts of Rule 14 remain operative, the policy decision embodied in the Government Order dated 14-1-2004 expressly outlines the selection criteria: a state-level merit list based on High-School percentage (with reservation norms) and prescribed age limits. The Court held that admissions must conform to these policy parameters, not to the recruitment-oriented framework of the 1981 Rules.

The Court further observed that:

  • The appellants neither challenged the validity of the policy decision of 14-1-2004 nor demonstrated that they satisfied the stipulated merit or age criteria.
  • The High Court correctly dismissed claims for relaxation of maximum age and for preferential placement based on the year of completing B.Ed./L.T. training.

Finding no legal basis to disturb the High Court’s ruling, the Supreme Court rejected the appellants’ contentions.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Dismissed.

The Supreme Court upheld the policy-based selection process for the Special BTC Training Course, 2004 and confirmed that the U.P. Basic Education (Teachers) Service Rules, 1981 do not govern admissions to that training programme. The decision leaves the appellants without relief and sustains the State’s criteria for future iterations of the Special BTC scheme; however, it does not establish new precedent beyond affirming the distinction between training-course selection and teacher recruitment.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Devendra Singh And Others v. State Of U.P And Others

    B. Sudershan Reddy, J.— Leave granted.

    2. These appeals have been preferred against the common judgment and order of the Allahabad High Court dated 14-5-2004 passed in Special Appeal No. 461 of 2004.

    3. We have elaborately heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the impugned judgment and the material made available on record.

    4. The facts leading to filing of these appeals are not required to be noticed in detail for a very short and simple question falls for consideration viz. as to whether the authorities were right in not selecting the appellants to undergo BTC Training Course, 2004.

    5. The State of Uttar Pradesh as a measure of policy decision has decided to arrange the Special BTC Training Course for a period of six months to as many as 46,189 candidates possessing BEd/LT course. The National Teachers Education Board accorded its approval to the proposal submitted by the State of Uttar Pradesh for arranging the Special BTC Training Course for a period of 6 months to all those candidates with a requisite qualification of BEd/LT course. The Government Order dated 14-1-2004 makes it abundantly clear that it is a Special BTC Training Course, 2004 which is a programme of training for six months, including a three months' practical schedule and in no manner deals with any selection and appointment of Assistant Teachers in the basic schools run by the U.P Basic Education Board in the State of Uttar Pradesh. Be it noted that none of the appellants in these appeals could secure admission to Special BTC Training Course, 2004. Their case is that they should be given preference in admission to Special BTC Course inasmuch as they had already appeared for selections in Special BTC Course, 2001. Their further case is that the appointments should be made on the basis of yearwise training course passed by the candidates, and the candidates who had passed the required training course earlier be placed above than those who had passed the training later.

    6. In order to resolve the controversy it is just and necessary to notice the salient features of the policy decision of the Government of Uttar Pradesh dated 14-1-2004. It is clear from a bare reading of the policy that the Government had resolved to arrange the Special BTC Training Course spread over a period of six months to all those 46,189 BEd/LT qualified candidates. The selection is for the purposes of imparting training and not recruitment into any service as such. Only such candidates who completed their training of BEd/LT as regular students in universities recognised by the National Teachers Education Board, recognised colleges and training institutes conducted by the State Government/Central Government alone were eligible for the selection into the course. The policy provides that the age of the applicant must be minimum of 16 years and not more than 35 years as on 1-7-2004. However, some relaxation has been made in favour of Scheduled Caste, Scheduled Tribe, Backward Class candidates and others with which we are not concerned in this case. The most important feature of the policy is that a State-level merit list is required to be prepared on the basis of percentage of marks obtained in High School considering the rules regarding reservation. The policy directs the payment of stipend of Rs 2500 per month to the selected candidates for the Special BTC Training until “he is duly appointed on the post of Assistant Teacher in the basic school after passing the written and practical examinations conducted by the Registrar, Departmental Examinations, Uttar Pradesh and obtaining the required certificate, under the control of the State Council for Education, Research and Training, on completing the required training in the merit process”.

    7. The Government Order dated 14-1-2004 was amended vide Government Order dated 20-2-2004 even while the writ petition filed by the appellants herein pending before the learned Single Judge. The amendments made CPEd, BPEd and DPEd qualified candidates also to be eligible along with BEd and LT candidates, provided they have taken training as institutional candidates from recognised universities and the State colleges and training colleges. The maximum age-limit was extended to 40 years with exemption to reserved category candidates.

    8. The record discloses that the primary contention of the appellants before the learned Single Judge was that the maximum age should be 45 years as provided for in the 1998 selections of Special BTC and that those candidates who were eligible to appear in the 2001 selections should be given exemptions on the ground that the National Council had not imposed any restriction with regard to the maximum age while granting approval to the said course. These contentions were rejected by the learned Single Judge as well as by the Division Bench.

    9. In these appeals the said contentions are not pressed. The learned counsel for the appellants mainly argued that the merit list should be arranged in such a manner so as to provide yearwise list on the basis of BEd training course or the other training courses as the case may be for the purposes of selection to the Special BTC Training Course, 2004. The learned counsel mainly relied upon the provisions of the U.P Basic Education (Teachers) Service Rules, 1981 (for short “the Rules”) in support of his submission. Rule 14 of the Rules provides for determination of vacancies and preparation of list for appointment by direct recruitment to the post of Mistress of nursery schools and Assistant Master or Assistant Mistress of junior basic schools. Rule 14 was amended by notification dated 28-6-1993. Sub-rule (4) of Rule 14 as it stood prior to its substitution provided that the names of the candidates in the list prepared under sub-rule (2) shall be arranged in such manner that the candidates who have passed the required training course earlier in point of time shall be placed higher than those who have passed the said training course later, and the candidates who have passed the training course shall be arranged in accordance with the quality point marks specified in the appendix. The High Court while dealing with the Rules in response to the submissions made by the appellants found that sub-rules (3) to (6) were deleted by notification dated 6-8-1997 and the amended Rules do not provide for any exemption and the selections were required to be based only upon the training qualification. It is for that reason the High Court found that there is no question of arranging the list in such a manner that the candidates who have passed the required training course earlier in point of time shall be placed higher than those who have passed the said training course later.

    10. The learned counsel for the appellants relying upon the statement made in the counter-affidavit filed in these appeals wherein it is conceded that sub-rules (3) to (6) of Rule 14 are not deleted, submitted that the matter should be sent back for reconsideration of the High Court by duly applying the effect of sub-rules (3) to (6) of Rule 14 of the Rules. The submission was that the merit list is required to be prepared in accordance with sub-rules (3) to (6) of Rule 14 of the Rules. The submission in our considered opinion is totally misconceived. We have already noticed that the U.P Basic Education (Teachers) Service Rules, 1981 deal with the post-training scenario. The Rules deal with the selection and appointment of teachers from amongst the candidates already possessing the training qualifications. The Rules do not deal with the selection of the candidates into Basic Training Course. The reliance placed upon the said Rules by the appellants in support of their contention is totally untenable and unsustainable. These Rules do not have any bearing in the matter of selection of candidates into Basic Training Course, 2004. The policy decision of the Government dated 14-1-2004 deals with the arrangement of the Special BTC Training Course for the period of six months for those 46,189 BEd/LT qualified candidates. The process of selection of the candidates for the said training and the arrangement of the training is required to be conducted in accordance with the guidelines, directions, conditions and restrictions incorporated thereunder. None of the appellants qualified themselves for undergoing the said training course inasmuch as they were not selected as they were not found meritorious or overaged as the case may be. It is not demonstrated as to how the appellants were entitled for selection to undergo Special BTC Training Course, 2004. The validity of the policy decision dated 14-1-2004 is not impugned in these appeals.

    11. No other contention is urged.

    12. For all the aforesaid reasons we find no merit in these appeals and they are accordingly dismissed.

    13. We make no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Devendra Singh And Others v. State Of U.P And Others
    (May 11, 2007)