AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
007 INSC 1121
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 4-A(1) and (2) of the Central Excise Act
  • Section 4-A of the Act
  • Section 2(b) of the SWM Act and the Rules made thereunder
  • Section 4 of the Act
  • Central Excise Act (for short “the Act”)
  • SWM Act and the SWM (PC) Rules
  • SWM Act or the Rules made thereunder
  • Sections 4-A(1) and (2) of the Act
  • Standards of Weights and Measures Act, 1976
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
007 INSC 1121
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 4-A(1) and (2) of the Central Excise Act
  • Section 4-A of the Act
  • Section 2(b) of the SWM Act and the Rules made thereunder
  • Section 4 of the Act
  • Central Excise Act (for short “the Act”)
  • SWM Act and the SWM (PC) Rules
  • SWM Act or the Rules made thereunder
  • Sections 4-A(1) and (2) of the Act
  • Standards of Weights and Measures Act, 1976
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant manufactures refrigerators. Central Government Notification No. 9/2000 dated 1-3-2000, issued under Sections 4-A(1) and (2) of the Central Excise Act, 1944, brought refrigerators within the valuation regime based on Maximum Retail Price (MRP) with 40 % abatement. Although the appellant accepted valuation under Section 4-A, it objected to the obligation to print MRP on refrigerator packages, contending that refrigerators are not “packaged commodities.” A writ petition filed before the Punjab and Haryana High Court sought to restrain authorities from enforcing the MRP declaration requirement. The High Court dismissed the petition, prompting the present civil appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a refrigerator, when sold by the manufacturer, constitutes a “packaged commodity” or “pre-packed commodity” under the Standards of Weights and Measures Act, 1976, and the Standards of Weights and Measures (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 1977.
  2. If answered in the affirmative, whether the inclusion of refrigerators in Notification No. 9/2000 validly mandates the declaration of MRP on their packages.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Refrigerators are not sold in a true “package”; dealers normally open any coverings for customer inspection, negating a “packaged” status.
  • The Standards of Weights and Measures Act and the 1977 Rules therefore do not apply, making the requirement to print MRP inapplicable.
  • MRP varies by geographical area, further demonstrating that a single printed price on the outer covering is impractical.

Respondent Authorities' Arguments

  • Refrigerators are supplied in polythene covers, thermocol and hard-board cartons, qualifying them as “pre-packed commodities.”
  • All pre-packed commodities fall within the SWM Act and Rules, which mandate disclosure of MRP on the package.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jayanti Food Processing (P) Ltd. v. CCE (2007) 8 SCC 34 Refrigerators must be assessed under Section 4-A of the Central Excise Act rather than Section 4. Quoted to show that refrigerators are already judicially recognised as assessable under Section 4-A; however, the specific “packaged commodity” issue was not raised in that case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined statutory definitions. Section 2(b) of the SWM Act defines “commodity in packaged form” to include goods packaged “in units suitable for sale … whether wholesale or retail,” using the expansive phrase “or otherwise.” Rule 2(l) of the SWM (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 1977 defines “pre-packed commodity,” and Explanation I clarifies that opening a package for testing does not alter its status as a pre-packed commodity.

It was undisputed that the appellant sells refrigerators enclosed in polythene, thermocol and hard-board cartons, a configuration squarely fitting these definitions. Because refrigerators are sold in retail, Chapter II of the 1977 Rules applies, particularly Rule 6, which mandates that specified information—including MRP—appear on retail packages.

The Court rejected the appellant’s contention that customer inspection destroys the package, noting that Explanation I explicitly covers goods that require opening for testing. Variations in regional prices did not absolve the manufacturer from the statutory duty to declare MRP. Since the notification’s general validity was not attacked, and refrigerators clearly fall within the statutory meaning of “packaged commodities,” inclusion of refrigerators in Notification No. 9/2000 was legally sound.

Holding and Implications

Appeal dismissed with costs; judgment of the High Court affirmed.

Consequently, refrigerators are definitively treated as “packaged commodities” under the SWM Act and Rules. Manufacturers must print MRP on refrigerator packages in compliance with Rule 6. The decision reinforces existing statutory obligations but does not announce a new independent legal test beyond confirming that large consumer durables sold in cartons fall within the packaged-commodity regime.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Whirlpool Of India Limited v. Union Of India And Others

    V.S Sirpurkar, J.— The short but interesting question as to whether refrigerator is a “packaged commodity” falls for consideration in this appeal. The appellant is engaged in manufacturing refrigerators. The Central Government issued Notification No. 9 of 2000 dated 1-3-2000 under Sections 4-A(1) and (2) of the Central Excise Act (for short “the Act”) and specified the goods mentioned in Column 3 of the said notification. Entry 48 pertains to the refrigerators whereby the refrigerators invited valuation under Section 4-A of the Central Excise Act with the abatement of 40%. Sections 4-A(1) and (2) of the Central Excise Act require that any goods included in the notification shall be valued on the basis of the maximum retail price (for short “MRP”) which is required to be printed on the packages of such goods. The five conditions for inclusion of the goods are:

    “(i) The goods should be excisable goods;
    (ii) They should be such as are sold in the package;
    (iii) There should be requirement in the SWM Act or the Rules made thereunder or any other law to declare the price of such goods relating to their retail price on the package;
    (iv) The Central Government must have specified such goods by notification in the Official Gazette;
    (v) The valuation of such goods would be as per the declared retail sale price on the packages less the amount of abatement.”

    2. The appellant felt aggrieved by the fact that the refrigerators were covered and included in the aforementioned Notification dated 1-3-2000 as, according to the appellant, the refrigerator is not such a commodity which is sold in a package. Significantly, the appellant is not aggrieved by its valuation being under Sections 4-A(1) and (2) of the Act. The only complaint that the appellant made is that the appellant should not be required to print MRP on the package of the refrigerator manufactured by it. The appellant, therefore, filed a writ petition before the High Court of Punjab and Haryana praying, inter alia, for a writ of certiorarified mandamus restraining the authorities for taking any coercive measures against the appellant or its Directors, officers, servants or agents for not declaring MRP on the refrigerators manufactured and cleared by the appellant from its factory. The Notification dated 1-3-2000 was challenged to this limited extent only. Before the High Court the appellant pleaded that refrigerator is not such a commodity which can be termed to be a “packaged commodity” and further the provisions of the Standards of Weights and Measures Act, 1976 (for short “the SWM Act”) or the Rules made thereunder are not applicable to the refrigerator at all. It was, therefore, prayed that the notification was liable to be quashed only to the extent that it included the refrigerator and the requirement of declaring MRP on the refrigerator.

    3. The respondent authorities, however, maintained that the refrigerator was in fact sold in a package of polythene cover, thermocol, hardboard cartons, etc. and thus it falls in the category of “pre-packed commodity”. On that basis it was contended that since every packaged commodity was included in the SWM Act and the Rules made thereunder, there can be no escape from printing MRP on the package. The High Court rejected the contention and dismissed the petition filed by the appellant. Hence the present appeal before us.

    4. Learned counsel very vehemently contended that a refrigerator, as a matter of fact, is not sold in a packaged form. The thrust of the argument is that even if it is sold in the packaged form, when it is displayed by the dealers, it is not in the packaged form and the customers can take the inspection of the refrigerator and at least for that purpose the package has to be opened and, therefore, there would be no question of the refrigerator being included in the SWM Act or the Rules made thereunder. The submission is quite incorrect. When we see various provisions of the SWM Act and the Rules made thereunder, it is clear that Section 2(b) defines “commodity in packaged form”. The definition says:

    “2. (b) ‘commodity in packaged form’ means commodity packaged, whether in any bottle, tin, wrapper or otherwise, in units suitable for sale, whether wholesale or retail.”

    5. It was not disputed before the High Court and also before us that the appellant manufacturer has to sell the refrigerators which are packed in polythene cover, thermocol, etc. and placed in hardboard cartons. In fact the appellant had so pleaded before the High Court in para 3 to which a reference has been made by the High Court. Once that position is clear, then the refrigerator clearly becomes a commodity in the packaged form. The use of the term “or otherwise” in the definition would suggest that a commodity if packed in any manner in units suitable for sale, whether wholesale or retail, becomes a “commodity in packed form”. In the year 1977 the Standards of Weights and Measures (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 1977 [for short “the SWM (PC) Rules”] (sic came into force). Rule 2(l) defines “pre-packed commodity” which is as under:

    “2. (l) ‘pre-packed commodity’ with its grammatical variations and cognate expressions, means a commodity or article or articles which, without the purchaser being present, is placed in a package of whatever nature, so that the quantity of the product contained therein has a predetermined value and such value cannot be altered without the package or its lid or cap, as the case may be, being opened or undergoing a perceptible modification, and the expression ‘package’, wherever it occurs, shall be construed as a package containing a pre-packed commodity;
    Explanation I.— Where, by reason merely of the opening of a package, no alteration is caused to the name, quantity, nature or characteristic of the commodity contained therein, such commodity shall be deemed, for the purposes of these Rules, to be a pre-packed commodity, for example, an electric bulb or fluorescent tube is a pre-packed commodity, even though the package containing it is required to be opened for testing the commodity.
    Explanation II.—[Not relevant.]”

    6. A glance at this provision and more particularly to Explanation I would suggest that the refrigerator is covered under the term “pre-packed commodity”. Even if the package of the refrigerator is required to be opened for testing, even then the refrigerator would continue to be a “pre-packed commodity”. There are various types of packages defined under the Rules and ultimately Rule 3 specifically suggests that the provisions of Chapter II would apply to the packages intended for “retail sale” and the expression “package” would be construed accordingly.

    7. It is not disputed before us that the sale of the refrigerator is covered under the “retail sale”. Once that position is clear Rule 6 would specifically include the refrigerator and would carry along with it the requirements by that Rule of printing certain information including the sale price on the package. Thus it is clear that by being sold by the manufacturer in a packaged form, the refrigerator would be covered by the provisions of the SWM Act and the SWM (PC) Rules and it would be imperative that MRP has to be printed in terms of Rule 6 which has been referred to above.

    8. The High Court has also made a reference to Rule 2(l) and more particularly, the Explanation to which we have referred to earlier. In our view the reliance by the High Court on Rule 2(l) is correct. Learned counsel tried to urge that every customer would like to open the package before finalising to purchase the refrigerator. He would at least get it tested and for that purpose the package would be destroyed. That may be so but it does not change the position as rightly observed by the High Court.

    9. It was tried to be suggested that MRP would be different depending upon the area in which it is being sold. That may be so, however, that cannot absolve the manufacturer from displaying the price i.e MRP on the package in which the refrigerator is packed. Whatever be the situation, it is clear that a refrigerator is a “packaged commodity” and thus is covered under the SWM Act and the SWM (PC) Rules and, therefore, the Notification dated 1-3-2000 cannot be faulted on that ground. It is significant to note that the appellant has not otherwise challenged the validity of the Notification dated 1-3-2000 on any other ground. All that is challenged is the applicability of the commodity like the refrigerator.

    10. Once the notification included the refrigerator, unless the validity of the notification was challenged, the appellant cannot get out of the scope of the notification. The notification cannot be faulted merely because the appellant feels that the refrigerator is not a packaged commodity. We have already shown that the refrigerator is a “packaged commodity” and once it is included in the notification, unless the notification is faulted on any other ground, the effect of the notification would remain intact insofar as refrigerator is concerned. On that ground also the appeal has to be rejected.

    11. In fact the question regarding the assessment of the refrigerator was considered by this Court in Jayanti Food Processing (P) Ltd. v. CCE (2007) 8 SCC 34, (2007) 10 Scale 223 where it was held that the refrigerators have to be assessed under Section 4-A of the Act and not under Section 4 of the Act. The present contention, however, was not raised in that case.

    12. In the result the judgment of the High Court is confirmed and the appeal is dismissed with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Whirlpool Of India Limited v. Union Of India And Others
    (Nov 2, 2007)