Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2006 INSC 935
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act (not explicitly mentioned)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2006 INSC 935
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act (not explicitly mentioned)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The litigation concerns title to ancestral property that originally belonged to Durga Malakar. Durga executed a will on 8-10-1958 in favour of the present plaintiffs. His widow, Gandhari, later relied on a deed of gift dated 25-5-1959 (sic) and conveyed the land by sale deed dated 21-1-1960 to Hemchandra Malakar. Hemchandra then entered into a deed of exchange with Arvinda Sarma, whose successors are the present respondents, and their names were mutated in the revenue records.

Challenging these transfers, the plaintiffs filed Title Suit No. 111 of 1966 in the Court of the Munsif, Barpeta, seeking (i) confirmation of their title and possession, (ii) mutation of their names on the basis of the probate already obtained on 20-11-1973, and (iii) a perpetual injunction. The trial court decreed the suit, holding that Gandhari had no right to convey the land and that the defendants derived no title.

The defendants filed Title Appeal No. 46 of 1986 before the Assistant District Judge, Barpeta, who reversed the decree, principally on the ground that the suit land could not be correlated with the property described in the will, although he found that the deed of gift was not proved. The plaintiffs then preferred a second appeal to the High Court of Assam, which was dismissed on 21-8-1998. The present judgment addresses the plaintiffs’ challenge to that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the findings of the first appellate court were vitiated by an erroneous interpretation and misreading of documentary exhibits, particularly regarding the correlation between the suit land and the land described in the will of Durga Malakar.
  2. Whether the High Court correctly formulated and decided the substantial question of law in the second appeal.
  3. Whether the case should be remanded for a fresh decision on the merits of the second appeal.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The first appellate court’s finding that the plaint did not mention old Patta No. 57 was contrary to the record; Schedule ‘Ka’ in fact contained that patta number, matching the will.
  • The lower appellate court relied on isolated witness testimony instead of the complete documentary evidence, leading to a mistaken conclusion that the suit land did not tally with the will.
  • The High Court failed to examine these discrepancies and thereby erred in dismissing the second appeal.

The opinion does not detail any specific arguments advanced by the respondents.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a limited supervisory review of the High Court’s dismissal of the second appeal and the first appellate court’s factual findings.

  • It observed that the properties listed in the will (Patta No. 91 (old) = 254 (new), Dag No. 1628/548 and Patta No. 57 (old) = 368 (new), Dag No. 83) correspond to the properties described in Schedule ‘Ka’ of the plaint. Therefore, the first appellate court erred in ignoring this correlation.
  • The first appellate court should have evaluated the complete documentary record—including the full property descriptions—rather than relying solely on a single witness’s deposition.
  • The High Court, in formulating the substantial question of law and in dismissing the second appeal, failed to examine whether the lower appellate court had misread the exhibits. The court concluded that this amounted to a failure to consider the matter “from the correct perspective.”
  • Although the court was “not satisfied with the purported substantial question formulated by the High Court,” it determined that a full reconsideration of the second appeal on the merits was required. It therefore exercised its power to set aside the High Court’s judgment and remit the matter for fresh adjudication, expressly permitting the High Court to frame new substantial questions of law.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed; the High Court’s judgment dated 21-8-1998 is set aside, and the matter is remitted to the High Court for fresh consideration of the second appeal on its merits. No order as to costs.

Implications: The immediate consequence is that the second appeal will be reheard by the High Court, which may formulate new substantial questions of law and must re-evaluate the evidentiary correlation between the will and the suit land. The decision sets no new precedent; its effect is confined to restoring the appellate process for the parties involved.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Lankeshwar Malakar And Others v. R. Deka And Others

    Order

    1. The plaintiffs are before us questioning the correctness or otherwise of the judgment and order dated 21-8-1998 passed by a learned Single Judge of the High Court of Assam, whereby and whereunder the second appeal preferred by the appellant against a judgment and order dated 23-5-1988 passed by the Assistant District Judge, Barpeta, in Title Appeal No. 46 of 1986, was dismissed. The basic fact of the matter is not in dispute.

    2. The lands in suit and other lands belong to one Durga Malakar. He is the paternal uncle of the plaintiffs' father Nareswar Malakar. The exact date of death of Durga Malakar is not known. He left behind his widow, namely, Gandhari. The dispute between the parties revolves on the execution of a will by Durga Malakar in favour of the plaintiffs on 8-10-1958 and execution of a purported deed of gift dated 5-5-1958 (sic) which was in the name of his wife Gandhari.

    3. Before we advert to the questions raised before us we may notice that Gandhari by reason of a sale deed dated 21-1-1960 conveyed her right, title and interest in the properties in question purported to be based on the said deed of gift dated 25-5-1959 (sic) in favour of Hemchandra Malakar. Arvinda Sarma allegedly entered into a deed of exchange of land with the said Hemchandra, grandfather of the respondent herein; pursuant whereto the grandfather allegedly came in possession of the lands in question. The names of the respondents were entered into the revenue records of rights. The plaintiffs therefore filed a suit in the Court of Munsif, Barpeta, which was registered as Title Suit No. 111 of 1966. We may at this juncture notice that the plaintiffs filed an application for grant of probate in their favour which was allowed by order dated 20-11-1973.

    4. The learned trial Judge having regard to the pleadings of the parties inter alia framed the following issues:

    “1. Whether the court has got pecuniary jurisdiction to try this suit?
    2. Whether proper court fees have been paid?
    3. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties?
    4. Whether the plaintiff has got right, title and interest over the suit land?
    5. Whether Gandhari, wife of Durga Malakar has saleable interest over the suit land to sell it to one Hemchandra Malakar?
    6. Whether the defendants have acquired valid title over the suit land by means of ‘exchange’ as alleged in the written statement?
    7. To what relief, if any, are the parties entitled?
    8. Whether the suit is barred by limitation?”

    5. In the said suit the following prayers were made:

    “(i) that the plaintiffs' possession of the land in Schedule ‘Ka’ be confirmed on declaration of their title thereto and on declaration of the principal defendant's unlawful possession null and void;
    (ii) that necessary precept be issued to the SDC, Bajali Circle, for effecting mutation of the land in Schedule ‘Ka’ in favour of the plaintiffs on the basis of the probate and their long-term possession;
    (iii) that a perpetual prohibitory injunction be issued, restraining the principal defendants from causing hindrance to the possession of the land in Schedule ‘Ka’.”

    Schedule ‘Ka’ of the plaint was described as under:

    Schedule ‘Ka’
    (1) Land measuring 1 bigha 2 kathas with a revenue of Rs 2.24p in Dag No. 1628(new)/548(old) of K.P Patta No. 254(new)/91(old) and 4 kathas 6 lechas (revenue of Rs 1.12p) in Dag No. 1660(new)/476(old) of the same patta within following boundaries:

    North Hari Prasad South Nripen Sarma East Andhu Kalita West Arabinda Sarma

    Dag No. 1660/476

    North Ram Nareesh Sarma South Tularam Talukdar East Road West Kiron Sarma

    (2) Land measuring 2 kathas 16 lechas (revenue of Rs 1.12p) in Dag No. 883 of K.P Patta No. 57(old)/368(new) of Pathsala town, Mauza Uttar Bajali, within the following boundaries:

    North Kiron Sarma South Kiron Sarma East Andhu Kalita West Road

    Total land measuring 2 bighas 4 kathas 2 lechas in the two pattas in the suit land.

    6. The learned trial Judge decreed the suit inter alia on the premise that Gandhari did not have any legal right to convey the suit land in favour of the said Hemchandra Malakar and consequently the respondent-defendants did not derive any right, title and interest pursuant to and in furtherance of the said deed of sale or the deed of exchange executed in the year 1960. Learned first appellate court however reversed the said judgment, principally holding that the suit land and the lands described in the will could not be correlated by the plaintiffs but came to the conclusion that the deed of gift was not proved. The respondent-defendants did not prefer any appeal against the said findings before the High Court. The appellant-plaintiffs did. The High Court formulated the following substantial question of law:

    “Whether the findings of the lower appellate court are vitiated by erroneous interpreting and misleading of the exhibits?”

    7. Before the High Court, the contentions which inter alia had been raised were that the findings of the first appellate court were contrary to records as it proceeded on the basis that the appellant-plaintiffs in the plaint did not (sic make any) mention in regard to old Patta No. 57 in Schedule ‘Ka’ of the plaint.

    8. The properties mentioned in the will inter alia refer to Patta No. 91(old), which is equivalent to Patta No. 254(new), consisting of Dag No. 1628(new)/548(old) measuring an area of 1 bigha 2 kathas as also Patta No. 57(old)/368(new) being Dag No. 83, measuring 2 kathas and 16 lechas.

    9. The learned first appellate court, therefore, in our opinion, was not correct in ignoring the said fact.

    10. Furthermore, if the plaintiffs had given full description of the properties in the plaint vis-à-vis the properties which were the subject-matter of the will, we are of the view that the first appellate court should have recorded the findings on the basis of the materials on records. It only refers to the deposition of one of the witnesses examined on behalf of the plaintiff and on the basis thereof, came to the conclusion that the suit lands as described in Schedule ‘Ka’ did not tally with the lands which were the subject-matter of the will. In our opinion, the High Court should have considered this question from the correct perspective.

    11. Although we are not satisfied with the purported substantial question formulated by the High Court, having regard to the fact that the High Court failed to determine the question in the proper perspective, it is necessary that the second appeal be directed to be considered afresh on merit. We, therefore, set aside the impugned judgment passed by the High Court and remit the matter back to it for consideration thereof afresh. It will be open to the High Court to formulate fresh question/questions of law.

    12. The appeal is allowed accordingly. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Lankeshwar Malakar And Others v. R. Deka And Others
    (Nov 30, 2006)