Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2005 INSC 511
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 10(m) of the Central Reserve Police Force Act
  • Section 11(1) of the Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949
  • Section 11(1), Rule 27 under the Act
  • Section 10(m) of the Act, Rule 27
  • Section 11 of the Act
  • Rule 27 of the Act
  • Section 11(1) of the Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2005 INSC 511
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 10(m) of the Central Reserve Police Force Act
  • Section 11(1) of the Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949
  • Section 11(1), Rule 27 under the Act
  • Section 10(m) of the Act, Rule 27
  • Section 11 of the Act
  • Rule 27 of the Act
  • Section 11(1) of the Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, a Constable in the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), was detailed for duty at Srinagar after training in Assam. He applied for leave on 18-01-1992, which was duly sanctioned, but failed to report back until 08-12-1992—an overstay of 315 days without authorisation. Departmental proceedings were initiated for this misconduct, and on 21-06-1993 the Commandant, acting under Section 11(1) of the Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949 and Rule 27 of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955, ordered his removal from service.

The respondent challenged the removal before the Jammu & Kashmir High Court. On 05-08-1997, a learned Single Judge quashed the removal, holding that proceedings should have been under Section 10(m) (which the High Court viewed as providing only “minor” punishment) and that removal was therefore without jurisdiction. The Union of India and its functionaries appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Section 11(1) of the CRPF Act, read with Rule 27 of the CRPF Rules, empowers the Commandant to impose the punishment of removal from service for the misconduct of unauthorised overstay.
  2. Whether the Jammu & Kashmir High Court erred in treating Section 10(m) as limiting punishment to “minor” penalties and in holding that removal was without jurisdiction.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants (Union of India)

  • Section 11(1) does not confine itself to “minor” punishments; it expressly contemplates suspension or dismissal in addition to the enumerated penalties.
  • Rule 27 explicitly lists “Dismissal or removal from the Force” as a punishment that may be imposed after a formal departmental enquiry by the competent authority.
  • The High Court’s interpretation that Section 10(m) precludes removal is legally untenable.

There was no appearance and therefore no argument advanced on behalf of the respondent.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dattatraya Mahadev Nadkarni (Dr.) v. Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay, (1992) 2 SCC 547 Removal and dismissal stand on the same footing; dismissal has more serious consequences. Used to establish that “removal” is a form of “dismissal,” supporting the view that Section 11 empowers the authority to remove a delinquent member.
State of U.P. v. Ashok Kumar Singh, (1996) 1 SCC 302 Indiscipline in disciplined forces must be dealt with sternly; the delinquent must show disproportionality of penalty. Reinforced that strict penalties, including dismissal, are justified for serious indiscipline such as prolonged unauthorised absence.
Mithilesh Singh v. Union of India, (2003) 3 SCC 309 In appropriate cases, dismissal from service cannot be faulted. Cited to affirm that the punishment of removal is not disproportionate in the circumstances of more than 300 days’ unauthorised absence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. The Court closely examined Section 11(1) and observed that the phrase “in lieu of, or in addition to, suspension or dismissal” precedes the list of punishments in clauses (a)–(e). This language confers power on the prescribed authority to order suspension or dismissal itself, and not merely the enumerated lesser penalties.

2. Rule 27, framed under the Act, corroborates this interpretation by expressly including “Dismissal or removal from the Force” as a punishment that the Commandant may impose after a formal departmental enquiry.

3. The High Court’s assumption that Section 10(m) confines the punishment for unauthorised absence to “minor” penalties was rejected. Section 10(m) merely classifies the misconduct; it does not limit the range of disciplinary punishments that can be imposed in departmental proceedings under Section 11.

4. Relying on Dattatraya Mahadev Nadkarni, the Court reiterated that “removal” is essentially a form of “dismissal,” differing only in its consequential bar on future employment; thus, the statutory scheme logically allows removal where dismissal is envisaged.

5. Applying Ashok Kumar Singh and Mithilesh Singh, the Court emphasised that members of disciplined forces must maintain strict standards. An overstay of more than 300 days without justification constitutes grave indiscipline warranting severe punishment, and no mitigating circumstances were advanced to show disproportionality.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed – Order of the High Court Set Aside; removal from service of the respondent stands restored.

Implications: The judgment clarifies that Section 11(1) of the CRPF Act, complemented by Rule 27, empowers competent authorities to impose the punishment of removal (or dismissal) even for offences catalogued under Section 10(m). It reinforces the Supreme Court’s consistent stance that serious indiscipline in uniformed services justifies stern penalties. No broader doctrinal shift or new precedent was created beyond affirming the statutory interpretation and disciplinary principles applicable to armed forces personnel.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Union Of India And Others v. Ghulam Mohd. Bhat .

    Arijit Pasayat, J.— Challenge in this appeal is by the Union of India and its functionaries to the judgment rendered by a learned Single Judge of the Jammu and Kashmir High Court holding that the order of removal from service passed by the departmental authorities in terms of Section 11(1) of the Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949 (in short “the Act”) read with Rule 27 of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955 (in short “the Rules”) is without jurisdiction.

    2. The background facts need to be noted in brief:

    The respondent as a Constable in Central Reserve Police Force (in short “CRPF”) joined the duty at Srinagar after being detailed for duty from Assam along with a group of fresh trainees. He applied for leave on 18-1-1992 which was sanctioned. He reported for duty long after the sanctioned leave period was over on 8-12-1992. Departmental proceedings were initiated for misconduct on account of overstay beyond sanctioned leave for 315 days without prior permission or sanction from the competent authority. On 21-6-1993 on the basis of the report of the inquiry officer, the competent authority passed order of removal from service. The same was challenged by the respondent by filing a writ petition in the Jammu and Kashmir High Court. By the impugned order dated 5-8-1997 a learned Single Judge held that since the respondent was proceeded against in terms of Section 10(m) of the Act read with Rule 27 of the Rules, the order of removal is without jurisdiction. It was observed that Section 10(m) only provided for minor punishment and did not provide for the punishment of removal from service. Accordingly the order of removal was quashed but, however, liberty was given to proceed in accordance with the provisions of the Act and the Rules.

    3. Learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for the appellants submitted that the view taken by the High Court is clearly indefensible. It was submitted that Section 11 did not provide for only minor punishment. It provided that the enumerated punishments were in lieu of or in addition to order of suspension or dismissal as the case may be. Rule 27 clearly permitted the order of removal from service and no interference by the High Court was called for. There is no appearance on behalf of the respondent in spite of service.

    4. The scope and ambit of Section 11 and Rule 27 has been called for determination in this appeal. A few provisions having relevance need to be noted. Undisputedly, overstay without sanctioned leave is dealt with in Section 10(m) of the Act. It relates to lesser offences. Section 11(1) and Rule 27 read as follows:

    “11. Minor punishments.—(1) The Commandant or any other authority or officer as may be prescribed, may, subject to any rules made under this Act, award in lieu of, or in addition to, suspension or dismissal any one or more of the following punishments to any member of the Force whom he considers to be guilty of disobedience, neglect of duty, or remissness in the discharge of any duty or of other misconduct in his capacity as a member of the Force, that is to say,—
    (a) reduced in rank;
    (b) fine of any amount not exceeding one month's pay and allowances;
    (c) confinement to quarters, lines or camp for a term not exceeding one month;
    (d) confinement in the quarter guard for not more than twenty-eight days, with or without punishment drill or extra guard, fatigue or other duty; and
    (e) removal from any office of distinction or special emolument in the Force.”
    (underlined for emphasis)
    “27. Procedure for the award of punishment.—(a) The punishments shown as Items 1 to 11 in column 2 of the Table below may be inflicted on non-gazetted officers and men of the various ranks shown in each of the headings of columns 3 to 6, by the authorities named below such headings under the conditions mentioned in column 7:
    Sl. No. Punishment Subedar (Inspector) Sub-Inspector Others except Const. & enrolled followers Const. & enrolled followers Remarks 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 1. Dismissal or removal from the Force. DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt. To be inflicted after formal departmental enquiry. 2. Reduction to a lower timescale of pay, grade, post or service. DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt. To be inflicted after formal departmental enquiry. 3. Reduction to a lower stage in the timescale of pay for a specified period. DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt. -do- 4. Compulsory retirement. DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt. -do- 5. Fine of any amount not exceeding one month's pay and allowances. DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt. -do- 6. Confinement in the quarter guard exceeding seven days but not more than twenty-eight days with or without punishment drill or extra guard, fatigue or other duty. - - - Comdt. -do- 7. Stoppage of increment. DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt. -do- 8. Removal from any office of distinction or special emolument in the Force. DIGP DIGP Comdt. Comdt. May be inflicted without a formal depart-mental enquiry. 9. Censure Comdt. Comdt. Asstt. Comdt. or Coy Comdr. A Comdt. or Coy Comdr. 10. Confinement to quarter guard for not more than seven days with or without punishment or extra guard, fatigue or other duty. - - - Comdt. 11. Confinement to quarters, lines, camp, punishment drill, fatigue duties etc. for a term not exceeding one month. - - - Comdt.”

    5. A bare perusal of Section 11 shows that it deals with minor punishment as compared to the major punishments prescribed in the preceding section. It lays down that the Commandant or any other authority or officer, as may be prescribed, may, subject to any rules made under the Act, award any one or more of the punishments to any member of the Force who is found guilty of disobedience, neglect of duty or remissness in the discharge of his duty or of other misconduct in his capacity as a member of the Force. According to the High Court the only punishments which can be awarded under this section are reduction in rank, fine, confinement to quarters and removal from any office of distinction or special emolument in the Force. In our opinion, the interpretation is not correct, because the section says that these punishments may be awarded in lieu of, or in addition to, suspension or dismissal.

    6. The use of the words “in lieu of, or in addition to, suspension or dismissal”, appearing in sub-section (1) of Section 11 before clauses (a) to (e) shows that the authorities mentioned therein are empowered to award punishment of dismissal or suspension to the member of the Force who is found guilty and in addition to, or in lieu thereof, the punishment mentioned in clauses (a) to (e) may also be awarded.

    7. It may be noted that Section 9 of the Act mentions serious or heinous offences and also prescribes penalty which may be awarded for them. Section 10 deals with less heinous offences and clause (m) thereof shows that absence of a member of the Force without leave or without sufficient cause or overstay without sufficient cause, is also mentioned as less heinous offence and for that also a sentence of imprisonment is provided. It is, therefore, clear that Section 11 deals with only those minor punishments which may be awarded in a departmental inquiry and a plain reading thereof makes it quite clear that a punishment of dismissal can certainly be awarded thereunder even if the delinquent is not prosecuted for an offence under Section 9 or Section 10.

    8. It is fairly well-settled position in law that removal is a form of dismissal. This Court in Dattatraya Mahadev Nadkarni (Dr.) v. Municipal Corpn. of Greater Bombay (1992) 2 SCC 547, (1992) 20 ATC 275, AIR 1992 SC 786 explained that removal and dismissal from service stand on the same footing and both bring about termination of service though every termination of service does not amount to removal or dismissal. The only difference between the two is that in the case of dismissal the employee is disqualified from future employment while in the case of removal he is not debarred from getting future employment. Therefore, dismissal has more serious consequences in comparison to removal. In any event, Section 11(1) refers to the Rules made under the Act under which action can be taken. Rule 27 is part of the Rules made under the Act. Rule 27 clearly permits removal by the competent authority. In the instant case the Commandant who had passed the order of removal was the competent authority to pass the order.

    9. This Court had occasion to deal with the cases of overstay by persons belonging to disciplined forces. In State of U.P v. Ashok Kumar Singh (1996) 1 SCC 302, (1996) 32 ATC 239 the employee was a police constable and it was held that an act of indiscipline by such a person needs to be dealt with sternly. It is for the employee concerned to show how that penalty was disproportionate to the proved charges. No mitigating circumstance has been placed by the appellant to show as to how the punishment could be characterised as disproportionate and/or shocking. (See Mithilesh Singh v. Union of India (2003) 3 SCC 309.) It has been categorically held that in a given case the order of dismissal from service cannot be faulted. In the instant case the period is more than 300 days and that too without any justifiable reason. That being so the order of removal from service suffers from no infirmity. The High Court was not justified in interfering with the same. The order of the High Court is set aside. The appeal is allowed but under the circumstances there shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Others v. Ghulam Mohd. Bhat .
    (Oct 20, 2005)