Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2003 INSC 253
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2003 INSC 253
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Government of Andhra Pradesh issued a notification to recruit 1,715 Excise Constables. Interviews were scheduled for 19–23 October 1994 and verification of certificates for 25–29 October 1994. Before the process concluded, the announcement of State Legislative Assembly elections on 1 November 1994 halted recruitment. Subsequently, a memorandum dated 21 December 1994 cancelled the entire process because the State decided to introduce total prohibition, reducing the perceived need for Excise Constables. No results were declared and no select list was published.

The respondents first approached the Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal and, in 1998, filed a writ petition in the High Court seeking a mandamus for their appointment. A Division Bench allowed relief by directing the State to consider their appointment, relying on a submission by the Government Pleader that their cases would be considered for existing vacancies. The State of Andhra Pradesh appealed this judgment, leading to the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether candidates acquire a vested right to appointment when the selection process stops short of publishing a select list.
  2. Whether the State can lawfully cancel an ongoing recruitment exercise pursuant to a policy decision (introduction of prohibition) and decline to fill the advertised vacancies.
  3. Whether the High Court was justified in directing the State to consider the respondents for appointment despite the cancellation of the recruitment process.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant State’s Arguments

  • The selection process was incomplete; no select list existed, so respondents had no enforceable right to appointment.
  • The State retains discretion to decide whether to fill vacancies, especially when a subsequent policy decision (total prohibition) renders the posts unnecessary.
  • The High Court exceeded its jurisdiction by directing consideration for appointment in the absence of a completed selection.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The recruitment process was substantially complete—tests and interviews were finished—and only publication of the select list remained.
  • Failure to issue appointment orders after completing evaluations was arbitrary and unfair.
  • The High Court merely directed the State to “consider” their appointment and did not issue a mandatory order to appoint.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted a “serious dispute” over whether the selection process had actually reached completion. It found no documentary proof that a select list was ever prepared and observed that the respondents themselves acknowledged cancellation at the “last stage.” On that basis, the Court concluded that the selection process was not complete.

Even assuming completion, the Court emphasized that inclusion in a select list does not confer a vested right to appointment. Recruitment remains subject to the employer’s discretion and to broader governmental policy. The State’s decision to impose prohibition constituted a legitimate policy choice that obviated the need for additional Excise Constables. Absent allegations of mala fides, the cancellation could not be branded arbitrary.

The Court further held that the High Court’s reliance on a concession by the Government Pleader could not create rights not otherwise vested in the respondents. Accordingly, the impugned order lacked legal sustainability.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed; High Court order set aside. However, the Court directed that, in any future recruitment for Excise Constables, the respondents may apply without facing an age bar, provided they meet all other eligibility requirements.

Implications: The decision restores the State’s discretion to cancel incomplete recruitment based on policy considerations. It affords limited equitable relief to the respondents but sets no new precedent beyond reaffirming that a select list does not create an automatic right to appointment.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of A.P And Others v. D. Dastagiri And Others

    Order

    1. The State of Andhra Pradesh is before us in these appeals questioning the validity and correctness of the judgment and order passed by the Division Bench of the High Court. The appellant State Government issued a notification containing guidelines and procedure for recruitment to the post of 1715 Excise Constables, pursuant to which the Commissioner of Excise notified the vacancies to the employment exchange initiating the process of recruitment. Dates for interview were scheduled between 19-10-1994 and 23-10-1994 and dates were fixed for verification of original certificates between 25-10-1994 and 29-10-1994. Thereafter, on account of announcement of general elections to the Legislative Assembly, recruitment process was stopped as election notification had been issued on 1-11-1994. By the memo dated 21-12-1994, in the light of the decision of introducing total prohibition in the State of Andhra Pradesh, the process for recruitment of 1715 Excise Constables was cancelled. The results of the interview were not declared and no selection list was published. The respondents filed writ petition in the High Court in the year 1998 seeking mandamus directing the appellants to appoint them. Before filing the writ petition, the respondents had approached the Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal. The Division Bench of the High Court disposed of the writ petition granting relief to the respondents, taking note of the submission made by the learned Government Pleader that the cases of the respondents will be considered for appointment in the existing vacancies. Aggrieved by the orders passed by the Division Bench, these appeals are filed by the State of Andhra Pradesh, as already stated above.

    2. Learned counsel for the appellants contended that the High Court committed a serious error in issuing direction to the appellants to consider the cases of the respondents for appointment to the post of Excise Constables, when the selection process itself was not complete and no select list had been published; the respondents could not claim appointments as a matter of right merely on the basis of the so-called selection made; it was open to the State Government to make or not to make appointments to the existing vacancies. He also submitted that it was open to the State to make a policy decision either to fill up those posts or not to fill up those posts, depending upon the requirement of the State.

    3. In opposition, learned counsel for the respondents made submissions supporting the impugned judgment of the High Court. He contended that the selection process was over inasmuch as the requisite tests were conducted, interviews were held, only select list was not published; having completed the selection process after holding necessary tests and taking interviews, the appellants were not at all justified in not issuing appointment orders; the action of the appellants in not issuing appointment orders was arbitrary and unfair. According to him, the High Court did not issue a mandamus to appoint the respondents; the High Court had only directed the appellants to consider the case of the respondents to appoint them.

    4. In the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents in Civil Appeal No. 915 of 2000, in para 16 it is stated that the process of selection was cancelled at the last stage i.e before publishing the list of selected candidates on the sole ground that the State Government wanted to introduce prohibition and obviously the Government felt that there was no need of Excise Constables during imposition of prohibition in the State. There is serious dispute as to the completion of selection process. According to the appellants, the selection process was not complete. No record has been placed before us to show that the selection process was complete, but, it is not disputed that the select list was not published. In para 16 of the counter-affidavit, referred above, the respondents themselves had admitted that the selection process was cancelled at the last stage. In the absence of publication of select list, we are inclined to think that the selection process was not complete. Be that as it may, even if the selection process was complete and assuming that only select list remained to be published, that does not advance the case of the respondents for the simple reason that even the candidates who are selected and whose names find place in the select list, do not get vested right to claim appointment based on the select list. It was open to the State Government to take a policy decision either to have prohibition or not to have prohibition in the State. Certainly, the Government had right to take a policy decision. If pursuant to a policy decision taken to impose prohibition in the State there was no requirement for the recruitment of Constables in the Excise Department, nobody can insist that they must appoint the candidates as Excise Constables. It is not the case of the respondents that there was any mala fides on the part of the appellants in refusing the appointment to the respondents after the selection process was complete. The only claim was that the action of the appellants, in not appointing the respondents as Excise Constables, was arbitrary. In the light of the facts that we have stated above, when it was open to the Government to take a policy decision, we fail to understand as to how the respondents can dub the action of the respondents as arbitrary, particularly, when they did not have any right as such to claim appointments. In the absence of selection and publication of select list, mere concession or submission made by the learned Government Pleader on behalf of the appellant State cannot improve the case of the respondents. Similarly, such a submission cannot confer right on the respondents, which they otherwise did not have.

    5. Under these circumstances, we find it difficult to sustain the impugned judgment and order. However, having regard to the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case and that the respondents had the benefit of the order of the High Court, we think it is just and appropriate that as and when any fresh selection takes place to the post of Excise Constables, the respondents may apply for regular recruitment. In that event, age bar will not be put against them, but, they shall satisfy other eligibility conditions and requirements, including qualification.

    6. Under the circumstances, the impugned orders are set aside, subject to what is stated above. The appeals are allowed accordingly. No costs.

    7. At this stage, the learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the Government is even now considering the cases of the similarly placed respondents for appointment. If that be so, this order of ours will not come in the way of the State Government considering the cases of the respondents.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of A.P And Others v. D. Dastagiri And Others
    (Apr 23, 2003)