Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute traces back to a partition suit among the descendants of Shri Bhukhalal Singh, who had two sons, Ramnandan Singh and Ramautar Singh. Naga Singh (from Ramautar’s branch) sought a partition of the ancestral estate. The trial court decreed the suit on 22-12-1975. Ramnandan Singh and his branch appealed to the High Court in First Appeal No. 165 of 1976.

During the appeal Ramnandan Singh died on 20-12-1978 and his legal representatives—including his three sons, wife Tetari Keur, and four daughters—were substituted. Later, Appellants 1(d) and 1(e) (two daughters) and Appellant 1(a) (the widow) also died. Applications were filed to substitute their legal representatives. While substitution for the widow was allowed on 12-9-1997, substitution for the two deceased daughters was refused on 5-2-1998. The Single Judge dismissed both the substitution application and the entire first appeal; a Division Bench affirmed that order on 23-11-2000. The present Supreme Court appeal challenges those High Court orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court erred in refusing to condone the delay and in rejecting the application to substitute legal representatives for Appellants 1(d) and 1(e).
  2. Consequently, whether dismissal of the entire first appeal for want of proper substitution was justified.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The High Court should have condoned the delay in filing the substitution application in the interest of substantial justice.
  • Death certificates later obtained from the Gram Sewak support the appellants’ timeline and should have been considered in review.
  • The estate of Ramnandan Singh was already adequately represented by his three sons who remained on record; female members were brought in only because of procedural necessity after his death.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Appellants 1(d) and 1(e) actually died on 10-12-1982 and 2-10-1993, making the substitution application hopelessly time-barred.
  • The appellants made incorrect statements and failed to file any rejoinder to the respondents’ affidavit, warranting rejection of their application.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court observed that:

  • All contesting coparceners were already parties to the litigation; the deceased daughters had been impleaded only as legal representatives of Ramnandan Singh.
  • The substitution of the widow’s legal representatives had been allowed, and the same individuals could potentially represent the interests of the deceased daughters.
  • Even if there were uncertainty about the exact dates of death, dismissing the entire appeal on that ground would defeat adjudication on the merits in a suit pending since 1974.
  • In such circumstances the High Court should have exercised discretion to condone any delay and, if necessary, compensate the respondents with costs rather than terminate the appeal.

Accordingly, the Court held that refusing substitution was an improper exercise of discretion and contrary to the “interest of justice” standard that guides procedural rulings on abatement and substitution.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed. The application to substitute legal representatives for Appellants 1(d) (Dharohar Devi) and 1(e) (Deojhari Devi) is granted, and any abatement is set aside. The appellants must pay the respondents Rs 5,000 in costs.

Implications: The first appeal in the High Court is revived and will proceed on the merits with all necessary parties properly represented. The decision turns on equitable considerations rather than establishing new substantive precedent.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Nagina Singh And Others v. Naga Singh And Others

    Bisheshwar Prasad Singh, J.— Special leave granted.

    2. Heard learned counsel for the parties.

    3. In this appeal the appellants have impugned the order of the High Court of Judicature at Patna in LPA No. 829 of 1998 dated 23-11-2000, whereby a Division Bench of the High Court affirmed the order of a learned Single Judge in First Appeal No. 165 of 1976 dated 5-2-1998, dismissing the application for substitution of legal representatives of Appellants 1(d) and 1(e). Consequently, the first appeal was also dismissed as being incompetent in the absence of the legal representatives of the aforesaid appellants.

    4. The appellants and the respondents herein are the descendants of one Shri Bhukhalal Singh, who had two sons, namely, Ramnandan Singh and Ramautar Singh. According to the appellants, the two branches of the family separated on 5-9-1947 and thereafter managed their affairs separately. The branch of Ramnandan Singh had acquired some more properties after partition and prospered. Out of sheer greed, Naga Singh, son of Ramautar Singh belonging to the other branch filed a partition suit for partition of the properties left by his grandfather Bhukhalal Singh. In the said suit Ramnandan Singh was arrayed as Defendant 1, his father Ramautar Singh as Defendant 2 and the three sons of Ramnandan Singh as the remaining defendants. During the pendency of the suit Ramautar Singh, father of the plaintiff died and his legal representatives were brought on record. The suit was ultimately decreed on 22-12-1975. The appellants herein preferred an appeal to the High Court against the decree passed by the trial court which was registered as First Appeal No. 165 of 1976. On 20-12-1978 Appellant 1 Ramnandan Singh died. His legal representatives who were brought on record included his three sons who were already on record as party-appellants, his wife Tetari Keur, and his four daughters who were substituted as Appellants 1(a) to 1(e).

    5. According to the appellants, on 26-4-1996, 27-5-1996 and 21-12-1996 respectively Appellants 1(d), 1(a) and 1(e) died. An application was filed to bring on record the legal representatives of the aforesaid deceased appellants. It may be noticed that Appellants 1(d) and 1(e) were the daughters of Ramnandan Singh while Appellant 1(a) was the wife of Ramnandan Singh, who were brought on record as legal representatives of Ramnandan Singh along with the sons of Ramnandan Singh who were already on record as appellants in the appeal.

    6. The application for substitution was contested by the respondents who contended that Appellants 1(d) and 1(e) had died as early as on 10-12-1982 and 2-10-1993. The counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents stating these facts does not appear to have been challenged by the appellants by filing a rejoinder. However by an order dated 12-9-1997 the substitution as regards Appellant 1(a) was allowed, but the application to bring on record the legal representatives of Appellants 1(d) and 1(e) was deferred for consideration along with the appeal.

    7. The appeal came up for hearing before the learned Judge who by order dated 5-2-1998 refused to allow the application for substitution to bring on record the legal representatives of Appellants 1(d) and 1(e). The learned Judge observed that the facts mentioned in the application for substitution had been controverted by the respondents, and since no rejoinder was filed, there was no justification for condoning the delay and setting aside the abatement, and the appellants were guilty of making wrong statements before the Court. Accordingly, he dismissed the application for substitution of the legal representatives of Respondents 1(d) and 1(e) and consequently dismissed the first appeal itself holding that the appeal could not be proceeded with in the absence of the legal representatives of Appellants 1(d) and 1(e). The judgment and order of the learned Judge has been affirmed in appeal by a Division Bench in LPA No. 829 of 1998.

    8. Counsel for the appellants submitted that the High Court ought to have condoned the delay in filing the application for substitution of the legal representatives of deceased Appellants 1(d) and 1(e) having regard to the interest of justice. It is further submitted that though the appellants were remiss in not producing relevant material disputing the dates of death given by the respondents, they were able to obtain the death certificate issued by the Gram Sewak later. On the basis of the death certificates granted by the Gram Sewak they filed a review application before the High Court which was unfortunately dismissed. It was also submitted that the estate of Ramnandan Singh was adequately represented inasmuch as his three sons were already on record as the appellants. Ramnandan Singh was himself Appellant 1, and upon his death the female members of the family were brought on record. In the suit itself the female members were not necessary parties though it became necessary for them to be brought on record upon the death of Ramnandan Singh, father of the appellants.

    9. We have given the matter our serious consideration. The case of the appellants in the appeal is that there was a previous partition and a second partition is not permissible. It is not in dispute that all the coparceners were parties in the suit, and earlier whenever deaths took place the legal representatives were brought on record by the appellants. All the three deceased appellants were female members of the family, and while substitution of the legal representatives of the mother Tetari Keur was allowed, substitution of the legal representatives of Appellants 1(d) and 1(e) was refused. We may notice at this stage that the legal representatives of the deceased Ramnandan Singh, and his wife Tetari Keur, Appellant 1(a) may be the same persons, and substitution of the legal representatives of Tetari Keur, Appellant 1(a) has been allowed.

    10. Though there is a serious dispute as to the dates of death of Appellants 1(d) and 1(e), we are of the considered view that in the facts and circumstances of this case, the application for substitution of legal representatives of the aforesaid appellants should not have been rejected, having regard to the fact that all the contesting parties were on record and these appellants were brought on record only as legal representatives of Appellant 1 who had died during the pendency of the appeal. Having regard to the facts of the case and the interest of justice, the High Court ought to have condoned the delay, if any, in filing of the application for substitution and could have compensated the respondents by award of cost. This we consider appropriate, having regard to the interest of justice. The parties have litigated since the year 1974 and it is only fair that there should be adjudication on merit.

    11. We do not consider it necessary to express any opinion on the question whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the appeal would abate as a whole in the absence of legal representatives of Appellants 1(d) and 1(e).

    12. In the result this appeal is allowed and the application filed for substitution of legal representatives of Appellant 1(d) Dharohar Devi and Appellant 1(e) Deojhari Devi is allowed. The abatement, if any, is set aside. The appellants shall pay to the respondents a sum of Rs 5000 (Rupees five thousand) by way of cost.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nagina Singh And Others v. Naga Singh And Others
    (Aug 13, 2002)