Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 302, 147, 148 and 149 of the Indian Penal Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 302, 147, 148 and 149 of the Indian Penal Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Eight individuals were charged with offences under Sections 302, 147, 148 and 149 of the Indian Penal Code for the fatal attack on Zuber, an 18-year-old youth, on 23 June 1985 at about 6:15 p.m. near Kumar Medical Store, Miloniganj, Jabalpur. Two accused absconded after being released on temporary bail, necessitating a separate trial for them. The remaining six—Yunis alias Karri alias Kariya, Ballu alias Abdul Nayeem, Abdul Rauf, Daggi alias Rafique, Liyaquatullah and Mohammad Javed—were tried in Sessions Trial No. 274 of 1985. On 3 December 1987 the Sessions Judge, Jabalpur convicted all six under Sections 302/149 IPC; Abdul Nayeem also under Section 147 IPC (one year R.I.) and the other five under Section 148 IPC (two years R.I.).

The Madhya Pradesh High Court dismissed their appeals, affirming the convictions. Four of the convicts then approached the Supreme Court (these consolidated matters constitute the present decision).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether discrepancies between the eyewitness testimonies and the autopsy report were so material as to render the eyewitnesses unreliable.
  2. Whether the prosecution had established the exact place of occurrence beyond doubt.
  3. Whether failure to prove motive undermined the prosecution case.
  4. Whether reliance on an inquest report, viewed in light of Munshi Prasad v. State of Bihar, could vitiate the conviction.
  5. Whether appellant Liyaquatullah could be convicted under Section 149 IPC absent proof of a specific overt act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The number and location of injuries described by eyewitnesses (five) did not tally with the autopsy surgeon’s report (three), casting doubt on their presence and credibility.
  • The prosecution allegedly shifted the place of occurrence, citing inconsistent landmark descriptions by witnesses.
  • Absence of proof of motive weakened the prosecution narrative.
  • The entire incident transpired within about 30 seconds, making detailed observation by eyewitnesses improbable.
  • Under Munshi Prasad v. State of Bihar, an inquest report is not substantive evidence; therefore convictions could not rest on it.
  • (Specifically for Liyaquatullah) No overt act was attributed to him; conviction solely under Section 149 IPC was unsustainable.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Munshi Prasad v. State of Bihar (2002) 1 SCC 351 An inquest report is not substantive evidence and cannot, by itself, ground a conviction. The Court held the precedent to be irrelevant because the present conviction rested on “a whole lot of other convincing evidence,” not on the inquest report alone.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court systematically rejected each contention raised by the appellants:

  • Credibility of Eyewitnesses vs. Medical Evidence: Three injuries noted by the autopsy surgeon corresponded with those described by eyewitnesses and were by themselves sufficient to cause death. Any non-mentioned injuries could have been overlooked by the doctor; their omission did not erode the prosecution case.
  • Place of Occurrence: Spot maps and consistent overall descriptions showed all referenced landmarks (oil-mill shop, medical store, watch repair shop) lay in the same market area. Minor variances did not shift the locus delicti.
  • Observation Time: The attack occurred in broad daylight, in a public marketplace, and was carried out by eight armed assailants against a single victim. The Court found it entirely possible for multiple witnesses to observe the assault even if it lasted only half a minute.
  • Motive: Citing settled law, the Court reiterated that proof of motive is not a sine qua non for conviction when reliable ocular and corroborative evidence establish the offences.
  • Inquest Report: The conviction did not rely solely on the inquest report; hence the principle in Munshi Prasad did not assist the defence.
  • Section 149 Liability (Liyaquatullah): Presence as a member of an unlawful assembly that commits murder suffices for liability under Section 149 IPC; an individual overt act is unnecessary once common object is established.
  • Overall Assessment: Both lower courts had concurrently found the prosecution case proved beyond doubt, and the Supreme Court discerned no reason to depart from those findings.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Dismissed. The convictions and sentences imposed on all appellants stand affirmed.

Implications: The decision reinforces established principles that (i) minor inconsistencies between medical and ocular evidence do not necessarily vitiate a prosecution, (ii) proof of motive is not indispensable when direct evidence is compelling, and (iii) membership in an unlawful assembly is sufficient for conviction under Section 149 IPC even without an overt act. No new legal precedent was set, but existing doctrines were affirmed.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Yunis Alias Kariya v. State Of M.P .

    Arun Kumar, J.— Eight accused persons were charged for offences under Sections 302, 147, 148 and 149 of the Indian Penal Code. Out of the 8 accused persons, 2 had been released on temporary bail on different occasions during trial. They did not surrender and could not be arrested. Therefore, their trial had to be separated. They are Rafique, S/o Chand Khan and Aslam alias Mangole, s/o Salim. The remaining 6 accused viz. Yunis alias Karri alias Kariya, Ballu alias Abdul Nayeem, Abdul Rauf, Daggi alias Rafique, Liyaquatullah and Mohammad Javed were tried and convicted for offences under Sections 302/149 IPC. Abdul Nayeem, one of the accused was also convicted and sentenced to one year's rigorous imprisonment under Section 147 IPC while each one of the remaining five was additionally convicted and sentenced to two years' rigorous imprisonment. These convictions were as per the judgment of the Sessions Judge, Jabalpur in Sessions Trial No. 274 of 1985 decided on 3-12-1987. The six convicted accused filed appeals against the judgment of the Sessions Court in the High Court of Madhya Pradesh. The High Court was pleased to dismiss all the appeals. These 4 appeals arising from the common judgment of the High Court have been filed by the 4 convicts.

    2. Briefly, the facts are that on 23-6-1985 at about 6.15 p.m, the complainant Abdul Jabbar, s/o Sheikh Munir was going to purchase medicine from Kumar Medical Store, Miloniganj, Jabalpur. As soon as he reached near the shop he heard a noise and saw that his nephew Zuber was surrounded by Rafique, Daggi, Yunis alias Karri, Javed, Mangole, Liyaquat, Rauf Kunjda and Ballu alias Nayeem. These accused persons were armed with gupti, chhuris (knives), sword, baka etc. One of them Rauf Kunjda had a bomb. The other accused Rafique who had a gupti in his hands gave two blows with the gupti on the chest of Zuber while Liyaquat inflicted a knife-blow on the left side of the waist. One of them inflicted a sword-blow which Zuber tried to stop with his hand which resulted in the injury on his little finger of the right hand, a portion whereof was chopped off. Zuber shouted and started running but he was stopped by Ballu (Nayeem) and Rauf Kunjda when Daggi inflicted a knife-blow on the left side of the back of the buttock. On hearing the noise Saleem Quadir, Sharif and other persons collected. On seeing them, the accused persons left Zuber and ran away. Zuber was bleeding profusely and he was taken in a rickshaw to Victoria Hospital where he died soon thereafter. According to the prosecution case, Zuber died on account of injury received by him at the hands of the accused persons. FIR (Ext. P-10) was lodged by Adbul Jabbar. Inquest (P-13) was held, thereafter the autopsy was conducted on the body of Zuber by Dr D.K Sakalley (PW 14). Zuber was aged about 18 years. Dr Sakalley gave details of injuries suffered by the deceased which are as under:

    “(i) Stab-wound, 2 cm long, oblique with clear-cut margins and pointed ends situated on right side of chest, 6 cm above right nipple. The width was ½ cm, wound was elliptical in shape. The wound was going slightly upwards and laterally, in the muscles of chest up to 7 cm depth, but not penetrating the thoracic cage. The wound was gradually diminishing in dimensions and track was filled with clotted sticky blood. The wound was slightly inwards also.
    (ii) Stab-wound, transverse, situated on left side of chest, 15 cm below medial end of clavicle, 2 ½ cm left to midline on pericardial area, elliptical, 2 cm × ½ cm, lower margin shows slight bevelling, underneath 5th rib costal cartilage is cut; the direction of wound is inwards slightly upwards and medially. On further exploration, there is slit-like cut in pericardium, clots of blood present. In pericardial cavity also, about 10 cc of blood with clots was present. There was a transverse cut in the track on anterior wall of right ventricle of heart near upper margin in whole thickness, which is 0.3 cm. It is not penetrating the post side. This injury to heart is 0.8 cm broad with clear-cut margins and pointed ends. Up to this level, depth is 9 cm.
    (iii) Incised wound on lateral side of base of right little finger extending to postero-lateral aspect also oblique, 2 cm × ½ cm × ½ cm.”

    3. According to Dr Sakalley these injuries were ante-mortem and could be caused by sharp-edged weapons. The cause of death was injury to the heart. During investigation the weapons of offence were seized including a country-made bomb recovered from Abdul Rauf. The seized articles were got examined through the Chemical Examiner and the Serologist, Calcutta.

    4. The main thrust of argument advanced on behalf of the appellants by the learned counsel appearing for them was that the injuries mentioned by the eyewitnesses did not tally with the injuries mentioned by the Autopsy Surgeon. While the eyewitnesses referred to five injuries on the body of the deceased, the Autopsy Surgeon had mentioned only three. From this, the learned counsel sought to urge that the eyewitnesses were giving false evidence which showed that they were really not eyewitnesses and they had not witnessed the crime. An attempt was also made to suggest that the place of occurrence had been changed by the prosecution. Another argument sought to be raised was that the prosecution has failed to prove the motive of the crime. We do not find any merit whatsoever in any of the contentions raised on behalf of the appellants. In our view, the evidence i.e oral testimony of the eyewitnesses as well as medical and other evidence on record clearly establishes the commission of crime, the manner in which it was committed and the place where it was committed. A glaring fact in the present case is that the crime took place in broad daylight (in the summer month of June sunlight is still there at 6.15 p.m — which is given as the time of occurrence of crime). The crime was witnessed by so many persons since it was in a market area, three of them have appeared as eyewitnesses. One of the eyewitnesses is the uncle of the deceased whose presence on the spot appears to be natural. Spot maps prepared during investigation have been proved on record to show the place of occurrence. Abdul Jabbar, one of the eyewitnesses had also described the place of crime which tallies with the rest of the evidence on record. The appellants have tried to create confusion about the place of occurrence by picking up portions from the evidence of the eyewitnesses. One of the witnesses said that the place of occurrence may be near oil mill shop. As a matter of fact the oil mill shop, Kumar Medical Store and watch repairing shop mentioned by another eyewitness as landmarks where the incident took place happen to be in the same market and in the vicinity of each other. Therefore, different references to landmarks made by different eyewitnesses do not really change the place of occurrence. There is no scope for confusion, the moment reference is made to the spot maps proved on record.

    5. A doubt was thrown about the veracity of evidence of the eyewitnesses on the ground that the entire incident took place within half a minute and the witnesses could not have seen what was happening in such a short time. This argument, in our view, is wholly misconceived. Eight persons, each armed with weapons, attacked a single individual in broad daylight in a marketplace. Even if the incident took place in a very short span of time, it does not mean that the eyewitnesses could not have observed the same. The evidence of the eyewitnesses tallies with each other and we have no reason to doubt the same.

    6. Coming to the alleged discrepancy between medical evidence and evidence of the eyewitnesses, it is to be noted that at least three injuries referred to by the Autopsy Surgeon and forming part of the medical evidence and as stated by the eyewitnesses are common. These three injuries are by themselves sufficient to cause death. The Autopsy Surgeon has not mentioned the knife injury on the back side of the buttock and another injury. The mere non-mention of the two injuries by the Autopsy Surgeon does not and cannot lead to rejection of the prosecution case. The two injuries might have escaped the notice of the doctor. Both the courts below have found the prosecution case to be fully established and proved beyond any doubt whatsoever and we see no reason to take a different view.

    7. The prosecution in the present case has failed to prove the motive. Failure to prove motive for crime in our view is of no consequence. The role of the accused persons in the crime stands clearly established. The ocular evidence is very clear and convincing in this case. The illegal acts of the accused persons have resulted in the death of a young boy of 18 years. It is settled law that establishment of motive is not a sine qua non for proving the prosecution case. For all these reasons, we find no merits in these appeals.

    8. It was also argued that the inquest report is not substantive evidence and therefore, on its basis alone the prosecution could not succeed. For this reliance was placed on the case of Munshi Prasad v. State of Bihar (2002) 1 SCC 351. This case is of no relevance to the present case. Here the prosecution has the whole lot of other convincing evidence which has led to the conviction of the accused persons. It is not the inquest report alone which forms the basis for conviction.

    9. The learned counsel appearing for appellant Liyaquat argued that no overt act is imputed to his client and he was being implicated only on the basis of Section 149 IPC. This argument, in our view, has no merit. Even if no overt act is imputed to a particular person, when the charge is under Section 149 IPC, the presence of the accused as part of an unlawful assembly is sufficient for conviction. The fact that Liyaquat was a member of the unlawful assembly is sufficient to hold him guilty. The presence of Liyaquat has not been disputed.

    10. All the appeals are accordingly dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Yunis Alias Kariya v. State Of M.P .
    (Dec 10, 2002)