Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Members of Ashray Adhikar Abhiyan addressed a letter to the Chief Justice of India complaining that homeless persons who die are not given a decent burial or cremation, thereby questioning the right of a deceased homeless person to a dignified last rite and the State’s corresponding obligation. The letter was treated as a writ petition, notices were issued, and affidavits were filed.

The Deputy Commissioner of Police (Headquarters) submitted a counter-affidavit outlining the police role in such cases. On behalf of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD), Dr. Satpal, Deputy Municipal Health Officer, filed an affidavit stating that unclaimed bodies found on the streets are handed over to MCD by Delhi Police and then cremated at the Bela Road electric crematorium free of cost by MCD’s Health Department; if the deceased is Muslim, the body is buried at a burial ground near Delhi Gate by the Waqf Board, with expenses borne by MCD. The petitioner filed a rejoinder and, at the Court’s request, submitted proposed guidelines. After hearing, the Court assessed whether further directions were necessary.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a deceased homeless person has a right to a decent burial or cremation in accordance with their religious belief, and what corresponding obligation the State bears toward such persons.
  2. Whether the Court should issue further directions or guidelines to ensure dignified last rites for unclaimed homeless deceased, including operational measures proposed by the petitioner.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Submissions (Ashray Adhikar Abhiyan)

  • Sought Court intervention to ensure that persons dying on the road receive a decent burial or cremation as members of society.
  • Proposed guidelines extending beyond the basic prayer, including:
    • A direction that at least two police constables reach the spot immediately and that an ambulance be called so the body can be taken to the nearest hospital.
    • Telecasting details of the deceased found by police on the national Doordarshan network at least twice at a two-week interval.

Respondents' Submissions (Delhi Police and Municipal Corporation of Delhi)

  • Affidavit evidence (MCD): When a person dies on the streets and the body remains unclaimed, Delhi Police hand over the body to MCD; MCD then:
    • Cremates the body at the Bela Road electric crematorium free of cost, through MCD’s Health Department, or
    • If the deceased is Muslim, ensures burial at a burial ground near Delhi Gate by the Waqf Board, with MCD bearing expenses.
  • Submissions by learned Senior Counsel for MCD (on instructions):
    • Police promptly reach the spot upon information of an unclaimed dead body.
    • Steps are taken to identify the body and establish the cause of death; the body is photographed and sent to the mortuary for post-mortem; intimation is sent to the Sub-Divisional Magistrate.
    • For identification, a wireless message with a complete description is sent across India; intimation is given for newspaper publication; a pro forma with photograph is sent to the Missing Persons Squad and published in the Police Gazette.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first considered the scope of the petitioner’s request. While the matter originated in the fundamental concern for a decent burial or cremation of homeless deceased, the proposed guidelines submitted by the petitioner were found to extend beyond the original prayer and to cover a “vast field.” The Court specifically considered two proposals and found them unsuitable for judicial directions:

  • The demand that at least two police constables immediately reach every such spot and that an ambulance be called was deemed impracticable and not an order the Court could issue.
  • The suggestion to telecast details of the deceased on Doordarshan twice at two-week intervals was rejected as it would require retaining the body for more than two weeks.

Turning to the record, the Court evaluated the affidavits and submissions from the police and MCD. The material demonstrated an established protocol: prompt police response; steps for identification and cause-of-death determination; photographic documentation; post-mortem; SDM intimation; wide circulation of identifying information (wireless messages, newspaper intimation, Police Gazette, Missing Persons Squad); and, for unclaimed bodies, cremation free of cost at the Bela Road electric crematorium, or burial for Muslims at the Delhi Gate burial ground by the Waqf Board, with expenses borne by MCD.

On these materials, the Court was satisfied that MCD was taking all possible steps to ensure a decent burial or cremation of unclaimed bodies found on the road. Given this satisfaction and the impracticality or overbreadth of the petitioner’s proposed guidelines, the Court concluded that issuing any further direction was unnecessary and unwarranted.

Holding and Implications

NO FURTHER DIRECTIONS ISSUED.

Consequences: The existing procedures described by the police and MCD continue to govern the handling of unclaimed bodies found on the streets of Delhi, including identification efforts, post-mortem, and provision of cremation or burial (with religious accommodation and expenses borne as stated). The Court declined to mandate the operational measures proposed by the petitioner (e.g., immediate deployment of two police constables, ambulance dispatch, or Doordarshan telecasts). The decision has a direct effect on the parties and sets no broader precedent beyond the Court’s acceptance of the sufficiency of the current administrative practice on the record presented.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Ashray Adhikar Abhiyan v. Union Of India And Others

    G.B Pattanaik, J.— A letter was addressed to the Hon'ble the Chief Justice of India by the members of Ashray Adhikar Abhiyan, making a complaint that homeless persons, when meet death, are not cared for and are not given a decent burial, thereby questioning the right of a deceased homeless person to a decent burial. On the basis of that letter, an important question as to the right of homeless deceased, to have a decent burial, as per their religious belief and the corresponding obligation of the State towards such people having arisen, the letter was treated as a writ petition and was listed for hearing. The letter prayed for an intervention by this Court and to issue necessary directions to all those concerned, so that a person dying on the road, can at least claim for a decent burial or cremation as a person belonging to the society. On the basis of that letter, notices have been issued. The Deputy Commissioner of Police (Headquarters) has filed a counter-affidavit, indicating the role of the police in such matters. On behalf of Municipal Corporation of Delhi, Dr Satpal, Deputy Municipal Health Officer has filed an affidavit, indicating therein that when a person dies on the streets and the dead body remains unclaimed, it is handed over to MCD by the Delhi Police and thereafter the dead body is cremated at electric crematorium, Bela Road by the Health Department of MCD, free of cost. In case the dead body is that of a Muslim, then the same is buried in a burial ground near Delhi Gate by the Waqf Board and Municipal Corporation of Delhi bears the expenses. On behalf of the Ashray Adhikar Abhiyan, a rejoinder-affidavit was filed. In course of hearing, the Court wanted from the petitioner, as to what guidelines the petitioner wants from the Court and pursuant to the same, the proposed guidelines were submitted by the petitioner. On going through those guidelines, we find that apart from claiming a decent burial, the proposed guidelines cover a vast field, which we apprehend, would not come within the purview of the original prayer. In this country, to expect that at least two police constables should reach the spot immediately and an ambulance should be called for, so that the body can be taken to the nearest hospital, is something which possibly cannot be directed by the Court. The petitioner has also suggested that the details of the person dying whose body is found by the police should be telecast on the national network of Doordarshan at least two times at an interval of two weeks is also not a suggestion which can be accepted and in which case, the dead body has to be kept for more than two weeks.

    2. Mr B.A Mohanti, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for Municipal Corporation of Delhi, submitted on instructions that the police reaches the spot of occurrence as soon as it is made known that a dead body not being claimed is there on the road and then steps are taken to identify the dead body and to establish the reasons of the death. The dead body is photographed, whereafter, it is sent to the mortuary for post-mortem. An intimation is also sent to the Sub-Divisional Magistrate. In the matter of identification, wireless message giving complete description of the dead body is sent all over India and intimation is given for its publication in newspapers. There is also a pro forma, which is sent along with the photograph to the Missing Persons Squad and the same is published in the Police Gazette. Apart from other steps taken in this regard, since the affidavit filed indicates that the unclaimed dead body is cremated in the electric crematorium, we do not think it necessary to issue any further directions in that regard. On the materials on record, we are satisfied that Municipal Corporation of Delhi is taking all possible steps for a decent burial of the unclaimed dead bodies found on the road and, therefore, question of issuing any further direction in that regard does not arise.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ashray Adhikar Abhiyan v. Union Of India And Others
    (Jan 9, 2002)