Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2002 INSC 319
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act is not present in the text. However, it's mentioned that guns were licensed and cannot be said to have been deliberately taken for the incident.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2002 INSC 319
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act is not present in the text. However, it's mentioned that guns were licensed and cannot be said to have been deliberately taken for the incident.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 14 March 1980 at about 12:30 p.m., officials from the Tubewell Irrigation Department were surveying irrigated fields near Village Baburahi, Police Station Shahabad, District Hardoi (Uttar Pradesh). During the inspection, a dispute arose between the group and accused Ram Swarup over whether his field had been irrigated. Present were the deceased Mangali (armed with a lathi), his brother Shri Krishna (PW-1), villagers Rampal (PW-2), Ram Autar (not examined) and Asharfi Lal (PW-3), as well as the accused Ram Swarup, Raja Ram (each armed with a licensed gun), Babu Ram and Deshraj (each armed with a lathi), and Dularey Prasad.

After a heated verbal exchange, Dularey allegedly exhorted the others; Babu Ram and Deshraj beat Mangali with lathis, whereupon Ram Swarup and Raja Ram fired their guns. Mangali suffered a fatal firearm injury and multiple lathi wounds, dying on the spot. Shri Krishna promptly lodged the FIR at 2:30 p.m.

The trial court convicted all five accused under Sections 147/148/302 read with 149 IPC, sentencing Ram Swarup and Raja Ram to life imprisonment plus two years for rioting, and the remaining three to life plus one year. On appeal, the High Court acquitted Dularey Prasad and, holding that no unlawful assembly existed, altered the conviction of the remaining four to Section 302/34 IPC, maintaining the life sentences. Ram Swarup and Raja Ram (Cr.A. 256/2001) and Babu Ram and Deshraj (Cr.A. 255/2001) then appealed to the Supreme Court by special leave.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the evidence of the prosecution witnesses, particularly Shri Krishna (PW-1), was reliable despite alleged inconsistencies and his relationship to the deceased.
  2. Whether non-examination of an eyewitness (Ram Autar) and failure to send the seized guns for ballistic examination fatally undermined the prosecution case.
  3. Whether, after the High Court found no unlawful assembly, the four remaining accused could be held liable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC, i.e., did they share a common intention to murder Mangali?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • Shri Krishna (PW-1) was an interested witness with strained relations to the accused; discrepancies between his statement about breakfast (dal-roti) and the post-mortem finding of semi-digested rice showed he was not present.
  • Non-examination of independent eyewitness Ram Autar warranted an adverse inference against the prosecution.
  • Failure to obtain ballistic opinion on the seized guns constituted a serious evidentiary lapse.
  • Because the High Court found no unlawful assembly, conviction under Section 34 IPC was unsustainable for all four accused.

State's Response

  • The prompt FIR, corroborative medical evidence, and testimony of independent witness Rampal (PW-2) established reliability.
  • Non-examination of Ram Autar caused no prejudice; PW-3’s hostility showed local witnesses feared the accused, and Ram Autar would likely have been similarly unco-operative.
  • Sending the guns for ballistic analysis 11 days after the incident would have been futile because no bullet or pellet had been recovered.
  • Common intention between Ram Swarup and Raja Ram was evident from their simultaneous gunfire; differing roles of Babu Ram and Deshraj required separate consideration.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mahbub Shah v. Emperor, AIR 1945 PC 118 Common intention under Section 34 IPC requires a pre-arranged plan; liability arises when the criminal act is done in furtherance of that common intention. Used to stress that proof of a concerted plan is necessary before Section 34 liability can attach.
Shankarlal Kacharabhai v. State of Gujarat, AIR 1965 SC 1260 When several accused act in concert and the result is in furtherance of their common intention, each is liable as if he alone committed the act. Relied on to affirm Section 302/34 conviction of Ram Swarup and Raja Ram, who fired simultaneously with intent to kill.
Mithu Singh v. State of Punjab, (2001) 4 SCC 193 Distinction between “common intention” and “same or similar intention”; inference of common intention must be drawn with certainty. Applied to hold that Babu Ram and Deshraj did not share the common intention to kill, limiting their liability to grievous hurt.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Assessment of Evidence: The Court found Shri Krishna’s testimony credible, noting his prompt FIR, medical corroboration, and support from independent witness Rampal (PW-2). Minor inconsistencies regarding food did not erode his reliability, and the Court rejected the contention that his familial relationship rendered him untrustworthy.

Non-examination and Ballistics: The Court held that failure to examine Ram Autar or to obtain ballistic reports did not impair the prosecution case. The guns were seized 11 days after the incident with no projectile available for comparison, making ballistic testing inconsequential.

Nature of Common Intention: After the High Court’s finding that Dularey had not participated, Section 149 IPC was inapplicable. The Supreme Court analysed whether Section 34 could apply:

  • Babu Ram and Deshraj had completed their lathi assault before any gunshot was fired, and there was no evidence they foresaw or intended the shooting.
  • Ram Swarup and Raja Ram, both armed with guns, fired almost simultaneously and therefore shared common intention to kill.

Applying the principles from Mahbub Shah, Shankarlal and Mithu Singh, the Court concluded that common intention could be imputed only to the two gunmen, not to the lathi-wielders. Consequently, Babu Ram and Deshraj were liable merely for voluntarily causing grievous hurt (Section 325/34 IPC).

Holding and Implications

Holding:

  • Criminal Appeal No. 256/2001 (Ram Swarup & Raja Ram) – DISMISSED; conviction under Section 302/34 IPC and life sentences affirmed.
  • Criminal Appeal No. 255/2001 (Babu Ram & Deshraj) – PARTLY ALLOWED; Section 302/34 conviction set aside; substituted with conviction under Section 325/34 IPC and sentence of three years’ rigorous imprisonment plus ₹1,000 fine (three months’ default imprisonment).

Implications: The judgment clarifies the distinction between Section 149 and Section 34 IPC where fewer than five participants remain after acquittal, reiterating that common intention requires demonstrable concerted action. It also underscores that evidentiary lapses such as non-examination of certain witnesses or absence of ballistic testing are not fatal if other credible evidence is available. No new legal doctrine is created, but the decision reinforces existing principles on common intention and evidentiary evaluation.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Babu Ram And Another v. State Of U.P And Others

    R.C Lahoti, J.— Ram Swarup, Raja Ram, Babu Ram, Deshraj and Dularey Prasad, the five accused persons were tried on charges under Sections 302/149, 148 and 147 IPC. The trial court convicted Ram Swarup and Raja Ram for the offences under Sections 148 and 302/149 IPC and sentenced them to suffer two years' rigorous imprisonment and imprisonment for life respectively. Babu Ram, Deshraj and Dularey were convicted under Sections 147 and 302/149 IPC and sentenced respectively to one year's rigorous imprisonment and imprisonment for life. All the accused persons preferred an appeal before the High Court. The High Court has held the accused Dularey not to have participated in the incident at all and therefore there was no unlawful assembly of the accused persons. Accordingly, Dularey Prasad has been completely exonerated and acquitted. The conviction of all the other accused persons insofar as referable to Sections 147, 148 and 302/149 IPC has been set aside. Instead Ram Swarup, Raja Ram, Babu Ram, Deshraj have been held guilty of an offence punishable under Sections 302/34 IPC and sentenced to imprisonment for life each. Feeling aggrieved by their conviction as ordered by the High Court, the accused Babu Ram and Deshraj have preferred Criminal Appeal No. 255 of 2001 and Ram Swarup and Raja Ram have preferred Criminal Appeal No. 256 of 2001, both by special leave.

    2. The occurrence took place on 14-3-1980 at about 12.30 p.m on the outskirts of Village Baburahi, PS Shahabad, District Hardoi of Uttar Pradesh. Shri Krishna, PW 1 is the brother of late Mangali who died in the occurrence. It appears that tubewell operator Ram Autar (not examined) and Asharfi Lal, the Tubewell Amin, PW 3, accompanied by villagers Ram Pal, Shri Krishna and Mangali were taking a round of the village fields for making a survey of such fields as were irrigated from the tubewell in that season so as to make record of the same and levy irrigation charges. When they reached the field of accused Ram Swarup, Mangali said that Ram Swarup's fields have been irrigated by tubewell whereas Ram Swarup denied the same. Other accused-appellants were present. Accused Deshraj and Babu Ram were armed with lathis. The deceased Mangali also had a lathi with him. The accused Ram Swarup and Raja Ram had licensed guns with them. On Ram Swarup, accused vehemently denying his fields having been irrigated, a verbal exchange followed by hot words ensued between late Mangali and accused Ram Swarup. Dularey exhorted the accused persons whereupon appellant Deshraj and Babu Ram dealt lathi-blows on Mangali. Mangali too wielded his lathi in his defence. Ram Autar and Asharfi Lal, PW 3 being public servants and obviously not interested in involving themselves in the feud between the private parties thought it better to slip away from the scene and did so. Shri Krishna, PW 1 tried to intervene and pacify the parties engaged in the altercation. At this point of time, appellants Ram Swarup and Raja Ram opened fire with their respective guns aiming at Mangali. Mangali sustained a firearm injury and fell down. He died on the spot. The dead body was then removed by the villagers to the village.

    3. Shri Krishna, PW 1 lodged first information report of the incident at about 2.30 p.m at Police Station Shahabad situated at a distance of a little more than two miles from the village. The report was registered by Om Hari Sharma, Sub-Inspector present at the police station. He registered a cognizable offence and commenced investigation. The dead body of the deceased was referred for post-mortem examination which was performed by Dr U.D Kapoor, PW 5 on 15-3-1980 at 1 p.m The following injuries were found on the body of the deceased:

    1. Firearm wound of entry of the size of 2.5 cm × 2.5 cm × cranial-cavity-deep, on the left side of forehead, 2 cm above the outer end of left eyebrow, margins of the wound are lacerated and inverted. Blackening, charring present.
    2. One firearm wound of exit 4.5 × 3.5 cm × margin are irregular and averted. This wound is communicating with the wound of Entry 1. The skull bone broken into pieces are visible both from entry and exit wounds.
    3. Contusion, 6 cm × 2 cm on the right side of face middle part, just in front of right ear.
    4. Abrasion, 3 cm × 2 cm on left cheek.
    5. Contusion, 3 cm × 2 cm on right cheek below right eye.
    6. Lacerated wound 3 cm × 1 cm × bone-deep behind right ear.
    7. Lacerated wound 1 cm × 0.5 cm × bone-deep on left eye.
    8. Lacerated wound 1 cm × 0.5 cm × bone-deep in the middle of front of nose. Underlying nasal bone is fractured.
    9. Lacerated wound 5 cm × 2 cm × bone-deep on left side of chin. Underlying bone is fractured.
    10. Lacerated wound 3 cm × 1 cm × bone-deep on right side of chin 6 cm below right angle of mouth. Right-side mandible bone is fractured.
    11. Lacerated wound 2 cm × 1 cm × muscle-deep, in the middle of lower lip.
    12. Lacerated wound 6 cm × 1 cm × bone-deep, on right side of head, 10 cm above the right ear. Right parietal bone of skull is fractured.

    4. All the injuries were ante-mortem. On internal examination, frontal bone under Injuries 1 and 2 was found to have been fractured. Undigested food and pieces of rice were found in the intestine. The cause of death was shock and haemorrhage as a result of the ante-mortem injuries. Dr Kapoor when examined in the Court stated that after sustaining four to five injuries out of Injuries 3 to 12 the injured would not have remained in standing position and would have fallen down. Injuries 3 to 12 were not enough even cumulatively to cause death. So far as Injuries 1 and 2 are concerned, they were caused by one gunshot.

    5. The ocular evidence adduced on behalf of the prosecution proves beyond reasonable doubt the prosecution story including the role assigned to each of the accused persons excepting Dularey who has been acquitted by the High Court and there is no challenge laid to Dularey's acquittal before us. Shri Krishna, PW 1 is the brother of the deceased. His testimony has been criticized by the learned Senior Counsel for the appellants on two counts mainly. Firstly, it is submitted that Shri Krishna is the brother of the deceased and therefore a witness “interested” in prosecution and at the same time there is a background of strained relationship available between the accused and the deceased. Secondly, it is submitted that according to Shri Krishna his brother Mangali, the deceased and he had taken breakfast which consisted of dal-roti but according to the post-mortem report the semi-digested food in the intestine of the deceased consisted of rice and that shows that Shri Krishna, PW 1 was not with the deceased. We have noted this submission but we cannot go that far as the learned counsel for the appellants proposes us to carry inasmuch as we are of the opinion that none of the grounds can be enough for discarding overboard the testimony of Shri Krishna. His being a relation of the deceased and having strained relationship with the accused persons since before the incident can persuade the court of facts to be on its guard and be cautious while evaluating the worth of his testimony. So far as the other submission is concerned, that has only to be rejected. The post-mortem report states the contents in the stomach of the deceased to be semi-digested food and pieces of rice. The post-mortem report does not say that the contents consisted exclusively of rice only. The doctor conducting the autopsy was not asked any question in this regard by the defence. According to Shri Krishna, PW 1 the breakfast consisted of dal-roti but he has not specifically denied any rice having been served as a part of the breakfast in the morning. It is common knowledge that in Central India rice in small quantity is generally cooked and served along with dal-roti and rice is not the principal meal or eaten exclusively. We could have appreciated and assigned some weight to the submission of the learned counsel for the appellants if the doctor conducting the autopsy would have been emphatic in saying that the stomach contents of the deceased were rice only while Shri Krishna, PW 1 would have been specific in saying or admitting that the breakfast did not have any rice.

    6. The evidence of Shri Krishna finds corroboration from the promptly lodged FIR and the medical evidence. He is also supported with all force by Rampal, PW 2, who is a villager and an independent witness and as to whom it is not even suggested why he would tell a lie and implicate the accused persons falsely. Asharfi Lal, PW 3, the Tubewell Amin has turned hostile. He was declared so and cross-examined by the Public Prosecutor. However, even Asharfi Lal, PW 3 has admitted the presence of Mangali, the deceased and a dispute having taken place with him during the inspection visit of the witness and the use of lathis and gun by the assailants of Mangali though he did not identify or describe the assailants. He admitted during cross-examination that on the date of incident he had left the place of the incident for fear of his life. He further admitted that he has to perform field duties and he has a fear from the accused persons and therefore he was not inclined to give full statement of the incident which had occurred.

    7. It was submitted by the learned counsel for the appellants that Ram Autar, an independent eyewitness present at the scene of occurrence according to the prosecution case and a government servant has not been examined, and therefore, an adverse inference should be drawn against the prosecution. It is settled law that non-examination of an eyewitness cannot be pressed into service like a ritualistic formula for discarding the prosecution case with a stroke of the pen. An effort should be made at appreciating the worth of such evidence as has been adduced. If the evidence coming from the mouth of the eyewitnesses examined in the case is found to be trustworthy and worth being relied on so as to form a safe basis for recording a finding of guilt of the accused persons then non-examination of yet another witness who would have merely repeated the same story as has already been narrated by other reliable witnesses would not cause any dent or infirmity in the prosecution case. In the case at hand we additionally find from the testimony of Asharfi Lal that in spite of being a government servant and not involved in local village disputes he is afraid of deposing against the accused persons and there is substance in the submission of the learned counsel for the State that Ram Autar if tendered in the witness box would have followed the same track as was chosen by Asharfi Lal, PW 3.

    8. The Sessions Court as also the High Court have dealt with the testimony of each of the witnesses examined in the case and chosen to place reliance on the eyewitness account of Shri Krishna and Ram Pal holding that their testimony could safely be relied on for founding the verdict of guilt. We find no reason to take a different view. Thus, we agree with the High Court and the Sessions Court in holding that in the occurrence Babu Ram and Deshraj caused injuries on the person of deceased Mangali by lathis. We also agree with the finding arrived at that Ram Swarup and Raja Ram were armed with guns and both of them fired shots at the deceased Mangali. One of the shots hit Mangali causing a wound of entry and a wound of exit.

    9. It was submitted by the learned counsel for the appellants that the guns seized from Ram Swarup and Raja Ram should have been sent for forensic examination by ballistic experts and the failure of the prosecution to do so is another infirmity in the prosecution case. In this case the occurrence had taken place on 14-3-1980. Accused Ram Swarup and Raja Ram voluntarily surrendered in the court and were arrested on 25-3-1980 i.e after a lapse of about 11 days. The guns are licensed guns of the two accused persons. Examination of guns by the ballistic expert after a lapse of 11 days would not have made any material difference. It would have been different if any bullet or pellet would have been found and recovered either from the body of Mangali or from the scene of occurrence in which case the ballistic expert would have been expected to conduct test-fires and determine whether the bullet or pellet was fired from the seized guns or any one of them. But that is not the case before us.

    10. We do not find the prosecution case suffering from any infirmity insofar as the accused-appellants before us are concerned.

    11. What remains to be examined is the nature of offence committed by the accused persons. The High Court has rejected the prosecution case to the extent of participation of Dularey, the fifth accused. Thus, there was no unlawful assembly and the question of holding any of the accused persons guilty with the aid of Section 149 IPC does not arise. The High Court has held all the accused-appellants guilty of offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC. It has to be seen whether all the accused persons can be attributed with common intention to cause the death of Mangali.

    12. The prosecution case itself is that there was no prior meeting of minds of all the four accused-appellants. The villagers including the prosecution witnesses and some of the accused persons were accompanying the officials of the Tubewell Irrigation Department for the purpose of surveying the irrigated fields and in this process they reached the field of accused Ram Swarup. Feelings mounted and verbal exchange got heated resulting in wielding of weapons like lathis and guns on the spur of the moment. Villagers in our country are routinely accompanied by lathis. The guns were licensed guns and it cannot be said that Ram Swarup and Raja Ram had deliberately taken the guns with them with the previous idea of utilizing the weapons in the unfortunate incident which was certainly not preconceived and premeditated. The wielding of lathis by Babu Ram and Deshraj is the earlier part of the incident. While Babu Ram and Deshraj inflicted lathi-blows, Mangali, the deceased also wielded his lathi though in his defence as stated by Shri Krishna, PW 1. Mangali fell down. It was at a point of time when Mangali was about to fall down or was falling down or had already fallen when Ram Swarup and Raja Ram fired. The exact position in which the victim was when the guns were fired has not come in the prosecution evidence. However, what is certain is that Babu Ram and Deshraj have not dealt any blow on the person of the deceased nor are they attributed with any overt act after the guns were fired. According to PW 1 and PW 2, guns were fired at a point of time when assault by lathis was over. The two guns by the two accused persons are said to have been fired almost simultaneously. In short, so far as the assault by Babu Ram and Deshraj is concerned, it had come to an end before the guns were fired; howsoever negligible may be the intervening gap. There is no direct or circumstantial evidence available on record for drawing an inference that Babu Ram and Deshraj could have, while assaulting Mangali with lathis, anticipated that Ram Swarup and Raja Ram or any one of them would fire at Mangali and fatally injure him. We cannot hold Babu Ram and Deshraj, accused-appellants sharing common intention with Ram Swarup and Raja Ram to cause the death of Mangali. They can be attributed only with the intention of causing grievous hurt to Mangali. The injuries caused by them have resulted in fractures on the body of the deceased. The medical evidence is clear and specific. None of the lathi injuries either individually or collectively were enough to cause the death of the victim.

    13. In Mahbub Shah v. Emperor AIR 1945 PC 118 Sir Madhavan Nair so stated the law as to common intention, speaking for Their Lordships of the Privy Council: (AIR p. 120)

    “[T]he essence of that liability is to be found in the existence of a common intention animating the accused leading to the doing of a criminal act in furtherance of such intention. To invoke the aid of Section 34 successfully, it must be shown that the criminal act complained against was done by one of the accused persons in the furtherance of the common intention of all; if this is shown, then liability for the crime may be imposed on any one of the persons in the same manner as if the act were done by him alone. This being the principle, it is clear to Their Lordships that common intention within the meaning of the section implies a pre-arranged plan, and to convict the accused of an offence applying the section it should be proved that the criminal act was done in concert pursuant to the pre-arranged plan. As has been often observed, it is difficult if not impossible to procure direct evidence to prove the intention of an individual; in most cases it has to be inferred from his act or conduct or other relevant circumstances of the case.”

    14. Following the abovesaid statement of law, this Court held in Shankarlal Kacharabhai v. State of Gujarat AIR 1965 SC 1260, (1965) 1 SCR 287, (1965) 2 Cri LJ 266: (SCR p. 290 E)

    “[T]he criminal act mentioned in Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code is the result of the concerted action of more than one person; if the said result was reached in furtherance of the common intention, each person is liable for the result as if he had done it himself.”

    15. Thus, it is clear that in order to hold an accused guilty of criminal act by reference of Section 34 IPC the court should be able to draw an inference that the result reached was the consequence of the concerted action of the person said to be held liable. Recently, this Court has held in Mithu Singh v. State of Punjab (2001) 4 SCC 193:

    “Common intention has to be distinguished from same or similar intention. It is true that it is difficult, if not impossible, to collect and produce direct evidence in proof of the intention of the accused and mostly an inference as to intention shall have to be drawn from the acts or conduct of the accused or other relevant circumstances, as available. An inference as to common intention shall not be readily drawn; the culpable liability can arise only if such inference can be drawn with a certain degree of assurance.”

    16. Looking at the narration of incident by the eyewitnesses it is difficult to draw an inference that the act, which caused the death of the victim was the result of the concerted action of Babu Ram and Deshraj. They cannot be attributed with sharing common intention to cause the death of Mangali with Ram Swarup and Raja Ram. Babu Ram and Deshraj can therefore be held liable only for offence punishable under Section 325 read with Section 34 IPC.

    17. So far as Ram Swarup and Raja Ram are concerned, both were there armed with guns. Both have fired at the deceased Mangali and almost simultaneously. Shot by one of them has fatally hit the deceased. It is clear that both shared the common intention of causing the death of Mangali. In Shankarlal case AIR 1965 SC 1260, (1965) 1 SCR 287, (1965) 2 Cri LJ 266 it was held that if four accused with common intention to kill someone were shooting at him they were certainly doing a criminal act in furtherance of the common intention to kill him within the meaning of Section 34. If such shooting results in the death of the persons aimed at, all are liable to be convicted under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC. The trial court and the High Court have not, therefore, erred in holding the accused Ram Swarup and Raja Ram guilty under Sections 302/34 IPC.

    18. For the foregoing reasons, Criminal Appeal No. 256 of 2001 filed by Ram Swarup and Raja Ram is dismissed. Their conviction under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC is maintained. They shall serve out the sentence as passed by the trial court and upheld by the High Court.

    19. Criminal Appeal No. 255 of 2001 filed by Babu Ram and Deshraj is partly allowed. The conviction of these accused-appellants under Sections 302/34 IPC and the sentence of imprisonment for life passed on each of them is set aside. Instead they are held guilty of offence punishable under Sections 325/34 IPC. Each one of the accused is sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of three years and also to pay a fine of Rs 1000 and in default of the payment of fine to undergo simple imprisonment for three months each. These two appellants were directed to be released on bail. They shall surrender to their bail bond to serve out the remaining part of the sentence subject to adjustment under Section 428 CrPC.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Babu Ram And Another v. State Of U.P And Others
    (Aug 1, 2002)