AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2000 INSC 22
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 100(3)(c) of the Act
  • Section 109 of the Act
  • Section 110 of the Act
  • Section 80, read with Section 80-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2000 INSC 22
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 100(3)(c) of the Act
  • Section 109 of the Act
  • Section 110 of the Act
  • Section 80, read with Section 80-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Mohammed Idris Ali (Respondent 16) filed Election Petition No. 7 of 1996 in the Gauhati High Court under Sections 80 and 80-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 (“the Act”), challenging the election of Shri Mustafa Shahidul Islam (Respondent 1) from the 83-Dhing Legislative Assembly Constituency in the 1996 Assam elections. The petition sought a recount of votes, a declaration that the election was void under Section 100(1)(d)(iii) and (iv), and consequentially a declaration that the petitioner was duly elected.

The petitioner had contested as a nominee of the All-India Congress (Tiwari) and the returned candidate as a nominee of the Indian National Congress (I). After the two parties merged, both individuals became members of the same party. Consequently, on 29 April 1997, the election petitioner moved an application under Section 109 of the Act to withdraw the election petition.

Notices of withdrawal were issued and published on 14 July 1997, and the High Court allowed the withdrawal on 2 September 1997. Withdrawal notifications appeared in “The Assam Tribune” on 12 September 1997 and in the Government Gazette on 20 September 1997.

The present appellant filed applications on 30 September 1997 and 3 October 1997 seeking substitution under Section 110(3)(c) of the Act to continue the petition. The Gauhati High Court dismissed both applications as time-barred, computing limitation from the newspaper publication date (12 September 1997). The appellant obtained special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, which now decides the matter.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the substitution applications filed by the appellant were within the fourteen-day limitation period prescribed by Section 110(3)(c) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951.
  2. Whether the limitation period begins from the date of publication of the withdrawal notice in a newspaper or from its publication in the Official Gazette.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reproduced Section 110 of the Act and focused on sub-clauses (3)(b) and (3)(c). It underscored that:

  • Publication of the withdrawal notice in the Official Gazette is mandatory; any additional publication (e.g., in a newspaper) is supplementary, not substitutive.
  • The statutory fourteen-day window for filing a substitution application commences only after the notice has been published in the Official Gazette.
  • In the present case, although the notice appeared in “The Assam Tribune” on 12 September 1997, the Official Gazette publication occurred on 20 September 1997. Thus, the limitation period began on 20 September 1997.
  • Both substitution applications—filed on 30 September 1997 and 3 October 1997—fell within fourteen days of 20 September 1997 and were therefore timely.

Accordingly, the High Court erred in calculating limitation from the newspaper publication date and in dismissing the applications as time-barred.

Holding and Implications

HELD: The appeal is allowed; the impugned Gauhati High Court order dismissing the substitution applications is set aside. The case is remanded to the High Court, which must treat the appellant’s substitution application as filed within limitation and proceed expeditiously.

Implications: The decision reinstates the appellant’s right to pursue the election petition. It clarifies that, under Section 110 of the Act, the limitation period for substitution begins only upon publication of the withdrawal notice in the Official Gazette. The ruling affects the parties in this case but sets no new precedent beyond the statutory interpretation applied.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Mohd. Abubakkar Siddique v. Mustafa Shahidul Islam And Others

    Order

    1. Mohammed Idris Ali, Respondent 16 in this appeal by special leave, filed an election petition under Section 80, read with Section 80-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”), calling in question the election of Respondent 1 Shri Mustafa Shahidul Islam, as a Member of the Assam Legislative Assembly from 83, Dhing Legislative Constituency Assembly in the general elections held in 1996. Various allegations were made in the election petition with a prayer for a direction for re-counting of votes polled in the election and thereafter to declare the election of Respondent 1 as void under Section 100(1)(d)(iii) and (iv) and to declare the election petitioner to have been duly elected from the said assembly constituency. The election petition came to be registered as Election Petition No. 7 of 1996 in the Gauhati High Court. The election petition was resisted by the returned candidate. Some of the other candidates, who had filed their nomination papers and contested the elections, however, remained ex parte in the High Court.

    2. The election petitioner had contested the election as a candidate nominated by the All-India Congress (Tiwari), while the returned candidate — Respondent 1 contested the elections sponsored by the Indian National Congress (I). It appears that in the meanwhile the All-India Congress (Tiwari) and the Indian National Congress (I) merged and on account of that merger, both the election petitioner and the returned candidate became members of the same political party. At this stage, the election petitioner filed an application under Section 109 of the Act seeking to withdraw the election petition. This application was filed on 29-4-1997. On 14-7-1997, notices of the withdrawal application were issued and published in the Official Gazette as well as in local English newspapers. On 2-9-1997, the withdrawal application was allowed and as mandated by Section 110 of the Act, a notification about the same was published. The notification came to be published in the newspaper The Assam Tribune, Ex. P-3 on 12-9-1997. It was also published in the Government Gazette, Ex. P-4, on 20-9-1997.

    3. On 30-9-1997 the appellant filed an application seeking permission for substitution to be able to carry the proceedings in the election petition under Section 100(3)(c) of the Act. In this application reference is made to the withdrawal notice published in The Assam Tribune in its issue dated 12-9-1997. It transpires that on 3-10-1997 the appellant also filed another application for the same relief (registered as Miscellaneous Case No. 125 of 1997). In this application, reference is made to the withdrawal notice published in The Assam Tribune dated 12-9-1997 as also to the notice published in the Government Gazette dated 20-9-1997. The returned candidate resisted the substitution application. By the order impugned in this appeal both the applications filed by the appellant were dismissed on the ground that the applications were barred by limitation as prescribed under Section 110 of the Act.

    4. We have heard learned counsel for the appellant.

    5. Learned Advocate-on-Record for the contesting respondent submitted that the brief of the case was no longer available with her and was unable to offer any assistance. She has at no point of time sought discharge in the case from the Court. There is none else representing Respondent 1 either. Respondent 1 is also not present personally. The other respondents have already been set ex parte. We are, therefore, disposing of this appeal after hearing learned counsel for the appellant and carefully perusing the record including the counter-affidavit filed by Respondent 1 in response to the notice at the stage of the special leave petition.

    6. Section 110 of the Act provides:

    “110. Procedure for withdrawal of election petitions.—(1) If there are more petitioners than one, no application to withdraw an election petition shall be made except with the consent of all the petitioners.
    (2) No application for withdrawal shall be granted if, in the opinion of the High Court, such application has been induced by any bargain or consideration which ought not to be allowed.
    (3) If the application is granted—
    (a) the petitioner shall be ordered to pay the costs of the respondents theretofore incurred or such portion thereof as the High Court may think fit;
    (b) the High Court shall direct that the notice of withdrawal shall be published in the Official Gazette and in such other manner as it may specify and thereupon the notice shall be published accordingly;
    (c) a person who might himself have been a petitioner may, within fourteen days of such publication, apply to be substituted as petitioner in place of the party withdrawing, and upon compliance with the conditions, if any, as to security, shall be entitled to be so substituted and to continue the proceedings upon such terms as the High Court may deem fit.”

    7. A bare perusal of Section 110(3)(b) shows that the High Court shall direct the notice of the withdrawal (of the election petition) to be published in the Official Gazette and in such other manner as it may specify. Clause (c) of Section (3) provides that within 14 days of such publication, a person who might himself have been a petitioner may apply to be substituted as a petitioner in place of the party withdrawing the election petition and upon compliance with such conditions as may be imposed by the High Court, he may be permitted to continue the proceedings.

    8. Clause (b), thus, unmistakably suggests that it is a mandatory requirement that the High Court shall cause the notice of withdrawal to be published in the Official Gazette. Apart from publication of the notice in the Official Gazette, the notice may also be published in such other manner as the High Court may specify. The expression “in the Official Gazette and in such other manner as it may specify” (emphasis supplied by us) clearly suggests that publication in the newspaper or in any other manner is in addition to the publication of the notice in the Official Gazette and not in substitution of it. If the date of publication in any other manner precedes the date of publication in the Official Gazette, the period of 14 days prescribed in clause (c) within which a person may apply to be substituted in place of the original election petitioner would ordinarily not commence unless publication in the Official Gazette has also taken place as in the present case. The High Court erroneously calculated the period of limitation from the publication of the notice in the English daily The Assam Tribune of 12-9-1997 rather than from the date of publication in the Official Gazette, Ex. P-4. The period of 14 days ought to have been calculated from the date of publication of the withdrawal notice in the Official Gazette i.e 20-9-1997 and so calculated we find that the application which was filed by the appellant (Miscellaneous Case No. 125 of 1997) as also the earlier application (Miscellaneous Case No. … of 1997) filed by him were both within the statutory period of 14 days calculated from the date of publication of the notice in the Official Gazette.

    9. The High Court, under the circumstances, fell in error in dismissing the substitution applications filed by the appellant on the ground of limitation only. The impugned order of the High Court, thus, cannot be sustained and the same is hereby set aside. The case is remanded to the High Court for proceeding further treating the substitution application to have been filed under Section 110 of the Act within the prescribed period of limitation. The High Court shall take further appropriate steps expeditiously.

    10. The appeal succeeds and is accordingly allowed. There shall, however, be no order as to costs insofar as this appeal is concerned.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Mohd. Abubakkar Siddique v. Mustafa Shahidul Islam And Others
    (Jan 18, 2000)