AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2000 INSC 67
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Clause (k) of Section 2 of the Act
  • Section 12(5) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
  • The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
  • Section 10(1) of the Act
  • Clause (s) of Section 2 of the Act
  • Section 10 of the Act
  • Section 10(1) read with Section 12(5) of the Act
  • Section 12 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2000 INSC 67
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Clause (k) of Section 2 of the Act
  • Section 12(5) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
  • The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
  • Section 10(1) of the Act
  • Clause (s) of Section 2 of the Act
  • Section 10 of the Act
  • Section 10(1) read with Section 12(5) of the Act
  • Section 12 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent 1, originally appointed as Assistant Secretary and later promoted to Joint Secretary of the Indian Tea Association (“the appellant”), was dismissed on 27-11-1995 for refusing to comply with a transfer order. He lodged a complaint with the Labour Commissioner, West Bengal, triggering conciliation proceedings under Section 12 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (“the Act”). The appellant contended during conciliation that Respondent 1 was not a “workman.” A failure report dated 2-7-1997 nonetheless recommended reference of the dispute for adjudication.

When the State Government failed to act, Respondent 1 approached the Calcutta High Court, which directed the Government to decide the matter under Section 12(5). By order dated 14-7-1998 the Government declined to refer the dispute, concluding that Respondent 1 was not a workman. Respondent 1 again invoked writ jurisdiction; a Single Judge ordered the Government to make a reference, and a Division Bench affirmed that order on 17-3-1999. The present appeal by the employer challenges those High Court directions before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State Government’s refusal, under Section 12(5) read with Section 10(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, to refer the dispute for adjudication was an administrative decision immune from judicial interference absent irrelevant or extraneous considerations.
  2. Consequently, whether the Calcutta High Court erred in issuing a writ of mandamus directing the Government to make a reference on the question of Respondent 1’s status as a workman.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Citing State of Madras v. C.P. Sarathy, Prem Kakar v. State of Haryana and Sultan Singh v. State of Haryana, counsel contended that the Government’s decision under Sections 10/12 is purely administrative; courts cannot reassess the sufficiency of material considered.
  • The Government examined Respondent 1’s salary, allowances and powers of sanction and correctly concluded that he formed part of management, excluding him from the definition of “workman.”
  • No irrelevant or foreign considerations tainted the Government’s order; therefore the High Court lacked grounds to compel a reference.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Maintained that the question whether he is a workman is factual and legal, requiring adjudication by an Industrial Tribunal, not by the State Government.
  • Relied on Abad Dairy Dudh Vitran Kendra Sanchalak Mandal v. Abad Dairy to suggest that such disputes demand detailed investigation of evidence.
  • Invoked an earlier job advertisement to show the non-managerial nature of his duties and alleged that his submissions before the Conciliation Officer were ignored by the Government.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Madras v. C.P. Sarathy, AIR 1953 SC 53 Government’s decision under Section 10(1) is administrative; courts cannot re-weigh material unless irrelevant factors are shown. Relied upon to hold that the High Court exceeded its jurisdiction in scrutinising the Government’s refusal to refer.
Prem Kakar v. State of Haryana, (1976) 3 SCC 433 Determination of “workman” status by Government is permissible; writ court cannot sit in appeal unless irrelevant considerations are present. Treated as directly governing the present dispute and supporting the validity of the Government’s order.
Sultan Singh v. State of Haryana, (1996) 2 SCC 66 Order under Section 10 is based on Government’s subjective satisfaction; no lis is involved. Cited in the summary of governing principles to reinforce the administrative nature of the order.
Abad Dairy Dudh Vitran Kendra Sanchalak Mandal v. Abad Dairy, 1999 SCC (L&S) 1079 Where voluminous evidence is needed, the question of “workman” status should be left to the Tribunal. Distinguished on facts; Supreme Court found no comparable complexity in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court first reaffirmed settled law that a reference decision under Sections 10 and 12 of the Act is administrative in character. It reviewed the Government’s speaking order, which detailed Respondent 1’s pay structure, managerial allowances, sanctioning powers and legal responsibilities. On these undisputed facts, the Government concluded that Respondent 1 belonged to management and therefore fell outside the statutory definition of “workman” under Section 2(s)(iii)–(iv).

The Court noted that Respondent 1 did not challenge the factual data on salary and perquisites; his contention focused only on the character of duties. The record, including a 30-3-1994 internal circular, demonstrated that his functions involved legal matters, labour policy and sanction of litigation expenses—indicative of managerial or supervisory status.

Applying the jurisprudence in C.P. Sarathy and Prem Kakar, the Court held that unless irrelevant or extraneous factors intrude, courts cannot compel a reference. No such impropriety was shown; the Government’s opinion was formed on material germane to Section 2(s). Consequently, both the Single Judge and the Division Bench erred in substituting their views through a writ of mandamus.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; High Court judgments set aside. The Supreme Court upheld the State Government’s decision refusing to refer the dispute, and no costs were awarded.

Implications: The judgment reiterates that the appropriate Government may determine “workman” status while considering reference, and judicial review is confined to detecting irrelevant or foreign considerations. The decision reinforces administrative autonomy under Sections 10 and 12 without creating new substantive precedent.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Secretary, Indian Tea Association v. Ajit Kumar Barat And Others

    S.N Phukan, J.— Leave granted.

    2. This appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 17-3-1999 of the Calcutta High Court in appellate jurisdiction whereby order of the learned Single Judge dated 24-7-1998 passed in WP No. 155 of 1998 was affirmed. The learned Single Judge directed the State Government to make reference under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.

    3. Briefly stated the facts are as follows:

    Respondent 1 was employed as Joint Secretary of Indian Tea Association, the appellant. On 27-11-1995, Respondent 1 was dismissed from service for disobeying an order of transfer. He complained of his dismissal to the Labour Commissioner, Government of West Bengal. Conciliation proceedings under Section 12 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (for short “the Act”) were held and the appellant submitted its comments stating that Respondent 1 was not a workman. A failure report dated 2-7-1997 was submitted by the Joint Labour Commissioner, recommending a reference, as according to him, the question whether Respondent 1 was a workman required adjudication. The Government did not act, therefore, Respondent 1 moved the Calcutta High Court. The High Court directed the Government to take a decision under Section 12(5) of the Act within the time fixed. By order dated 14-7-1998 the Government communicated its decision in writing wherein it regretted its inability to make a reference as Respondent 1 was not a workman. Again Respondent 1 moved the High Court against the said order of the State Government. The learned Single Judge directed the appropriate Government to make a reference as to whether Respondent 1 was a workman. The appeal filed by the appellant was dismissed by the impugned judgment and the State Government was directed to make an appropriate reference, keeping in view the nature of the dispute raised by Respondent 1. Hence this appeal.

    4. Mr Dipankar Gupta, learned counsel for the appellant relying on the decision of this Court in State of Madras v. C.P Sarathy AIR 1953 SC 53, 1953 SCR 334, (1953) 1 LLJ 174 has urged that while discharging its function under Section 10(1) of the Act, the Government was performing an administrative act, therefore, the Court could not have come to the finding that the refusal to refer the matter was bad. We quote below the relevant paragraph of the judgment:

    “This is, however, not to say that the Government will be justified in making a reference under Section 10(1) without satisfying itself on the facts and circumstances brought to its notice that an industrial dispute exists or is apprehended in relation to an establishment or a definite group of establishments engaged in a particular industry. It is also desirable that the Government should, wherever possible, indicate the nature of the dispute in the order of reference. But, it must be remembered that in making a reference under Section 10(1) the Government is doing an administrative act and the fact that it has to form an opinion as to the factual existence of an industrial dispute as a preliminary step to the discharge of its function does not make it any the less administrative in character. The Court cannot, therefore, canvass the order of reference closely to see if there was any material before the Government to support its conclusion, as if it was a judicial or quasi-judicial determination. No doubt, it will be open to a party seeking to impugn the resulting award to show that what was referred by the Government was not an industrial dispute within the meaning of the Act, and that, therefore, the Tribunal had no jurisdiction to make the award. But, if the dispute was an industrial dispute as defined in the Act, its factual existence and the expediency of making a reference in the circumstances of a particular case are matters entirely for the Government to decide upon, and it will not be competent for the Court to hold the reference bad and quash the proceedings for want of jurisdiction merely because there was, in its opinion, no material before the Government on which it could have come to an affirmative conclusion on those matters.”

    5. We may also refer to the decision of this Court in Prem Kakar v. State of Haryana (1976) 3 SCC 433, (1976) 3 SCR 1010. In that case a question arose whether an employee was a workman. The Government informed the workman that his case was not covered by the definition of the term “workman” under the Act, therefore, it refused to make a reference. The workman approached the High Court for a writ of mandamus which was dismissed. This Court was approached and the appeal was dismissed. In appeal it was contended before this Court that the question whether an employee was a workman is a disputed question of facts and law and, therefore, could only be decided by the Labour Court on a reference and not by the State Government while exercising its powers under Section 12(5) of the Act, which was rejected. The Court also held that the order of the Government acting under Section 10(1) read with Section 12(5) of the Act passed after subjective satisfaction is an administrative order and not a judicial or a quasi-judicial one. It was also held that in entertaining a writ of mandamus against such an order the court does not sit in appeal and is not entitled to consider the propriety or the satisfactory character of the reasons. However, if it appears from the reasons given in the order that the appropriate Government has taken into account any consideration which is irrelevant or foreign, then the court may in a given case consider the case of a writ of mandamus.

    6. In Sultan Singh v. State of Haryana (1996) 2 SCC 66, (1996) 32 ATC 847 this Court held that an order issued under Section 10 of the Act is an administrative order and the Government is entitled to go into the question whether an industrial dispute exists or is apprehended and it will be only a subjective satisfaction on the basis of the material on record and being an administrative order no lis is involved.

    7. The law on the point may briefly be summarised as follows:

    1. The appropriate Government would not be justified in making a reference under Section 10 of the Act without satisfying itself on the facts and circumstances brought to its notice that an industrial dispute exists or is apprehended and if such a reference is made it is desirable wherever possible, for the Government to indicate the nature of dispute in the order of reference.
    2. The order of the appropriate Government making a reference under Section 10 of the Act is an administrative order and not a judicial or quasi-judicial one and the court, therefore, cannot canvass the order of the reference closely to see if there was any material before the Government to support its conclusion, as if it was a judicial or quasi-judicial order.
    3. An order made by the appropriate Government under Section 10 of the Act being an administrative order no lis is involved, as such an order is made on the subjective satisfaction of the Government.
    4. If it appears from the reasons given that the appropriate Government took into account any consideration irrelevant or foreign material, the court may in a given case consider the case for a writ of mandamus.
    5. It would, however, be open to a party to show that what was referred by the Government was not an industrial dispute within the meaning of the Act.

    8. We extract below the order of the State Government, which is a speaking one:

    “I am directed to say that in terms of the Hon'ble High Court's order dated 24-11-1997 in Writ Petition No. 22878 (W) of 1997 in the case of Ajit Kumar Barat v. State of W.B Government has examined the matter in detail.
    After examination, it reveals that you were first appointed as Assistant Secretary in Indian Tea Association and subsequently promoted to the post of Joint Secretary. Besides the basic pay you are given child allowance, house rent subsidy, furnishing allowance, house maintenance allowance, transport subsidy, reimbursement of fuel and electricity charges, entertainment expenses, reimbursement of servant's wages, monthly club subscription, leave travel allowance and reimbursement of hospitality expenses. Your duties also included power of sanction of expenses on behalf of Indian Tea Association.
    So your pay and perquisites and the status enjoyed by you in the organisation and also the power of sanction of expenses suggest that you were a part of the management. Hence you cannot be treated as a workman within the purview of the Industrial Disputes Act.
    Government, therefore, regrets its inability to refer your dispute to any Industrial Tribunal/Court under Section 12(5) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.”

    9. The appropriate Government would be justified in making a reference under Section 10 of the Act, if it is satisfied on the facts and circumstances brought to its notice that an industrial dispute exists or is apprehended and “industrial dispute” as per clause (k) of Section 2 of the Act means, inter alia, a dispute or difference between employers and employers, or between employers and workmen. Clause (s) of Section 2 of the Act defines “workman” but does not include any such person—

    “2. (s) (i)-(ii) ***
    (iii) who is employed mainly in a managerial or administrative capacity; or
    (iv) who, being employed in a supervisory capacity, draws wages exceeding one thousand six hundred rupees per mensem or exercises, either by the nature of the duties attached to the office or by reason of the powers vested in him, functions mainly of a managerial nature.”

    10. Before making a reference under Section 10 of the Act the appropriate Government has to form an opinion whether an employee is a workman and thereafter has to consider as to whether an industrial dispute exists or is apprehended.

    11. In the present appeal we find that the State Government rightly approached the question whether Respondent 1 was a workman. Unless this condition is satisfied no reference can be made.

    12. From the order of the State Government we find that while deciding the question whether Respondent 1 was a workman, it took into consideration the salary and allowances of Respondent 1 drawn at the relevant time and also the nature of work. Respondent 1 who has appeared in person did not dispute the salary and allowances etc. as indicated in the order of the Government but urged that his responsibilities were neither supervisory nor managerial in nature.

    13. Mr Gupta, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant has drawn our attention to the circular dated 30-3-1994 issued by the appellant Association. This circular indicates the duties of Respondent 1 who was functioning as a Joint Secretary at the relevant time and we find that his duties were to deal with all legal matters and court proceedings, labour and land laws and publications (labour legislations labour welfare). We also find from the records that Respondent 1 had power to sanction expenses incurred in litigation by the appellant. On the above materials on record the State Government rightly formed the opinion that Respondent 1 was not a workman.

    14. Respondent 1 has not been able to show that while passing the above administrative order, the State Government took into consideration any irrelevant or foreign matter. We, therefore, hold that the above administrative order was passed by the State Government after taking into consideration the material available on record and it could not be faulted.

    15. Mr Barat has urged that the question whether he was a workman is a disputed question of fact and can be decided only by the Industrial Tribunal and not by the State Government. In this connection, he has placed reliance on a decision of this Court in Abad Dairy Dudh Vitran Kendra Sanchalak Mandal v. Abad Dairy 1999 SCC (L&S) 1079, (1993) 3 LLJ (Supp) 855. This Court observed as follows:

    “Having regard to the facts and voluminous evidence sought to be adduced by both parties, the question whether the appellants are workmen requires detailed investigation of facts. The issue requires detailed examination and can be satisfactorily adjudicated upon only by a Tribunal.”

    16. Thus it appears that in that case the question required detailed investigation in view of voluminous evidence sought to be adduced but it is not so in the case in hand. Therefore, the above decision is not relevant for our purpose. The ratio laid down by this Court in Prem Kakar (1976) 3 SCC 433, (1976) 3 SCR 1010 squarely covers this appeal as it does not appear from the order that the State Government took into consideration any irrelevant or foreign material.

    17. Drawing our attention to the advertisement issued by the appellant Association calling for application for the post of Assistant Secretary, Mr Barat has urged that this advertisement would show the nature of the work to be performed. In our opinion this advertisement could not help Respondent 1 inasmuch as it was for the post of Assistant Secretary to which post Respondent 1 was initially appointed but subsequently he was promoted to the post of Joint Secretary. That apart we are concerned with actual duties performed by Respondent 1 at the time of his dismissal from service which we have already indicated and were also taken into account by the State Government.

    18. Mr Barat has further contended that his letter filed before the Conciliation Officer was not considered by the State Government. We may state here that the records were not placed by the State Government before the High Court but were made available by Ms A. Subhashini before this Court. From the record we find that in the failure report the Conciliation Officer has indicated all the contentions raised by Respondent 1 in his letter. Therefore, this contention has no force.

    19. For the reasons stated above we hold that both the appellate court and the learned Single Judge of the High Court erred in law in issuing a mandamus directing the State Government to make an appropriate reference, therefore, the judgment of the learned Single Judge passed in Writ Petition No. 155 of 1998 and the judgment of the appellate court are hereby set aside.

    20. In the result we find merit in the present appeal and accordingly it is allowed. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case we direct the parties to bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Secretary, Indian Tea Association v. Ajit Kumar Barat And Others
    (Feb 14, 2000)