Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2000 INSC 494
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 299 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 304, Section 308 and Section 120-B of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 5 of TADA (Terrorists and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987)
  • Section 4(b) of the Explosive Substances Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2000 INSC 494
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 299 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 304, Section 308 and Section 120-B of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 5 of TADA (Terrorists and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987)
  • Section 4(b) of the Explosive Substances Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

In the early morning hours of 2 November 1989, a bomb exploded in J.J. Colony, Shakurpur (Delhi), killing three people, injuring nineteen, and causing four nearby multi-storeyed houses to collapse. The prosecution alleged that the explosion occurred because the appellant, Shamsher Khan, in concert with Babu Khan and others, had manufactured and stored bombs in his own house as part of a larger conspiracy to arm themselves against a perceived communal threat following an inflammatory procession by the Bajrang Dal.

The appellant and three co-accused were tried before a Designated Court under the Terrorists and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 (TADA). He was convicted under Sections 304, 308 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, Section 5 of TADA, and Section 4(b) of the Explosive Substances Act, receiving sentences ranging from five to ten years’ rigorous imprisonment and fines. The co-accused were acquitted. The appellant appealed as of right under Section 19 of TADA.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant’s acts of manufacturing and storing bombs brought his conduct within the definition of “culpable homicide” under Section 299 IPC, thereby sustaining his convictions under Sections 304 and 308 IPC.
  2. Whether the evidence—principally the testimony of accomplice-turned-approver PW 2 Shahabudin, corroborated by other witnesses and physical circumstances—was sufficient to affirm the appellant’s convictions on the remaining counts under TADA, the Explosive Substances Act and Section 120-B IPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Questioned the credibility of PW 21, noting that he had not personally witnessed the Bajrang Dal procession and therefore could not corroborate the alleged communal motive.
  • Did not dispute that the explosion occurred in his house but disputed having the requisite knowledge or intent to bring the case within culpable homicide under Section 299 IPC.

Respondent State’s Arguments

  • Sought to justify the convictions under Sections 304 and 308 IPC by invoking the third limb of Section 299 IPC—i.e., that the appellant acted “with the knowledge that he is likely, by such act, to cause death.”
  • Relied on PW 2’s approver testimony, corroborated by PW 22 and physical evidence, to prove the appellant’s role in manufacturing and storing bombs.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

Credibility of PW 2 (Approver): The Court acknowledged that PW 2 was an accomplice but found his testimony reliable after locating several pieces of corroboration:

  • PW 22 Hasina confirmed that the appellant and Babu Khan attempted to manufacture bombs in her house before moving their activity to the appellant’s residence.
  • The undisputed fact that the fatal explosion occurred in the appellant’s house supported PW 2’s narrative.
  • A police search (PW 38) uncovered chemical packets in PW 2’s house, confirming preliminary bomb-making activity there.

Analysis under Section 299 IPC: The Court focused on whether the appellant possessed the requisite knowledge that merely manufacturing and storing bombs was “likely to cause death.” It observed:

  • No evidence showed that bomb-making, by itself and without a further triggering act, was likely to cause death.
  • The record was silent on what additional act caused the detonation and whether the appellant performed that act.
  • Consequently, the prosecution failed to satisfy even the third alternative of Section 299 IPC (“knowledge” limb). The Court therefore found “no scope to bring the proved facts within the ambit of Section 299 IPC.”

Other Offences: The Court found the same evidence sufficient to sustain convictions for conspiracy (Section 120-B IPC), possession/manufacture of explosives (Section 4(b) Explosive Substances Act) and violation of Section 5 TADA.

Holding and Implications

PARTLY ALLOWED / DISPOSED OF: Convictions and sentences under Sections 304 and 308 IPC were set aside. Convictions and sentences under Section 5 TADA, Section 4(b) Explosive Substances Act and Section 120-B IPC were affirmed.

Implications: The decision narrows criminal liability by strictly applying the mental-element requirements of Section 299 IPC. While it provides no new precedent, it underscores that mere manufacture and storage of bombs, without proof of knowledge that death is a likely consequence, does not automatically constitute culpable homicide. The appellant remains incarcerated on the terrorism- and explosives-related counts.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Shamsher Khan v. State (Nct Of Delhi) .

    Judgment

    1. During the wee hours on 2-11-1989 a shuddering bomb explosion took place at J.J Colony in Shakurpur (Delhi). Three persons died in the explosion almost instantaneously and 19 others were injured, some of them very seriously. The impact of the explosion was such that four adjoining multi-storeyed houses collapsed. The investigating agency concluded that the explosion was the aftermath of stalking bombs in the house of the appellant which was done by himself in association with one of the victims (Babu Khan) and some others including the co-accused. They further found that there was a criminal conspiracy to manufacture explosive bombs to be used on an appropriate occasion.

    2. The appellant Shamsher Khan was one of the four persons arraigned before a Designated Court constituted under the Terrorists and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 (‘TADA’ for short). They were charged for offences under Sections 304, 308 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code besides Section 5 of TADA and Section 4(b) of the Explosive Substances Act. The appellant alone was convicted of all the offences and the rest of the accused were acquitted by the trial court. On the first count he was sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for 10 years for the offence under TADA and the Explosive Substances Act. He was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 7 years. For Section 308 IPC he was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 5 years. Apart from the aforesaid substantive sentences fine has also been imposed on the various counts. This appeal has been filed by the appellant as of right under Section 19 of TADA.

    3. According to the prosecution, the appellant enlisted the other persons for the purpose of manufacturing bombs, to arm themselves to make an onslaught on the members of another community. The background was that a procession was staged by an organisation called Bajrang Dal a few days earlier, calling out slogans, some of which were so inflammable that they instilled fear in the mind of the appellant that unless he and his companions arm themselves with lethal weapons they might be victims of an attack. The appellant first contacted PW 2 Shahabudin for securing the services of Babu Khan who knew how to manufacture bombs. After acquiring the necessary equipment and materials Shahabudin's house was selected as the venue for manufacturing bombs. But the task could not be carried out at that house on account of the forceful resistance offered by Shahabudin's wife Hasina (PW 22) and thereupon the venue was shifted to the house of the appellant. Babu Khan manufactured bombs and stored them in that house. One of those bombs (or more than one) exploded at about 3.00 a.m on 2-11-1989 resulting in the catastrophe mentioned above.

    4. PW 2 Shahabudin was originally included in the array of the accused. However, pardon was tendered to him and he was converted into an approver. His evidence in the court is in full support of the prosecution case as narrated above. It is unnecessary to repeat the evidence given by PW 2 as we have stated the case in the foregoing paragraphs.

    5. If the testimony of PW 2 is believable, there can be little doubt that the appellant had caused explosive bombs to be manufactured and stored them in his house. But PW 2 Shahabudin, on the showing of the prosecution itself, is an accomplice and therefore we would seek corroborative materials to give assurance to us that the testimony is true, despite the inherent drawback of that witness.

    6. We came across a number of items of evidence which are corroborative materials as for the testimony of PW 2. The foremost among them is the evidence of PW 22 Hasina herself. She said that Babu Khan and the appellant brought some materials to her house and when she realised that they were about to manufacture bombs she did not permit that to be done in her house. Because of her forceful opposition Babu Khan and the appellant had shifted their activities to the house of the appellant. The testimony of PW 22 was believed by the trial court although she was treated as hostile by the prosecution on account of a minor aspect of the case.

    7. PW 21 gave evidence that on coming to know of a procession staged by Bajrang Dal he lodged a complaint with the police. Learned counsel contended that PW 21 did not himself witness the procession and therefore his evidence is of no avail. The procession staged by Bajrang Dal is not the main issue in this case and therefore we are not persuaded by the said arguments. The evidence of PW 21 is useful for the limited purpose of showing that he lodged a complaint with the police on being informed of the staging of the procession.

    8. The most important circumstance which corroborates the evidence of PW 2 is the very fact that an explosion took place in the house of the appellant, which was proved to be the consequence of storing explosive bombs. Learned counsel for the appellant has candidly conceded that such an explosion took place in the house of the appellant in the early hours of 2-11-1989. PW 38 J. Singh (Inspector of Police) said that he made a search in the house of PW 2 Shahabudin on 3-11-1989 and traced out some packets containing chemicals, besides certain other articles. This would show that the version of PW 2 that Babu Khan had been to his house with the materials for starting the work to manufacture bombs and did some work there (sic is true).

    9. All the above circumstances and materials would ensure confidence in our mind that the testimony given by PW 2 regarding the involvement of the appellant in the manufacture of bomb in his house is a true version. The trial court has rightly placed reliance on the aforesaid testimony.

    10. The appellant was convicted under Sections 304 and 308 IPC. Both the offences relate to commission and attempt to commit culpable homicide respectively. So culpable homicide is the common factor in both the courts. Section 299 of the Indian Penal Code defines culpable homicide, which has three alternative requirements. They are:

    1. doing an act with the intention of causing death of a person, or
    2. doing an act with the intention of causing such bodily injury as is likely to cause such death, or
    3. doing an act with the knowledge that he is likely by such an act to cause death of another person.

    11. Learned counsel for the respondent State made an endeavour to bring the case within the ambit of the third alternative, as the case cannot possibly be brought under any of the other two. The act proved to have been committed by the appellant along with Babu Khan in this case is manufacture of explosive substances like bombs. Hence what is to be established is, the above act must have been done with the knowledge that such act by itself was likely to cause death. If some other act had intervened which the offender did not do consciously which triggered the explosions that could not be counted as the act for that offender. No evidence had been let in by the prosecution to show that mere manufacture of such bombs is likely to cause death of any person, nor has any evidence let in for showing that the appellant had the knowledge that by manufacturing bombs death would possibly be caused to any human being without any other act being done.

    12. We may also point out that the prosecution has not brought out any circumstance by which the Court could remotely attribute knowledge to the appellant that by manufacturing and possessing bombs death of any person was a likely consequence. By manufacturing a bomb alone no one can normally think that it would explode without anything more being done. Here something more would have happened which caused the explosion, what was that additional act is unknown to us. At any rate there is no material to show that the appellant had done that additional act.

    13. In view of the aforesaid legal position we find no scope to bring the proved facts within the ambit of Section 299 IPC. If so, the question of culpable homicide would stand at bay. We, therefore, find it legally difficult to confirm the conviction either for the offences under Section 304 or for Section 308 IPC. As a corollary we set aside the conviction and sentence passed on the appellant in regard to those two counts.

    14. But the appellant cannot escape from the other counts for which he was convicted and sentenced. We confirm the conviction and sentence in regard to those counts.

    15. The appeal is disposed of accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shamsher Khan v. State (Nct Of Delhi) .
    (Oct 19, 2000)