AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, a final-semester student at the Regional Engineering College, Hamirpur, fell short of the mandatory 75 % attendance requirement. The College posted a notice (19-2-1998) and personally informed him (5-4-1998) of his deficiency. Despite this, he absented himself from classes between 3-4-1998 and 7-4-1998 and applied for condonation only on 2-5-1998—three months after the semester began.

The Principal, applying Chapter 4 of the College’s Academic Regulations, refused condonation because the shortage (11 % after the automatic 25 % deduction) exceeded the discretionary 10 % limit. The student successfully challenged this refusal before the High Court, which directed the Principal to condone 12 % and declare the examination result. The College appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Chapter 4 of the Academic Regulations permits the Principal to condone attendance shortage in excess of 10 % after the automatic 25 % deduction.
  2. Whether the respondent’s failure to submit a formal application with supporting documents, as mandated by Regulations 4.2 and 4.3, bars condonation.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Under Regulation 4.1 read with Regulations 4.2 and 4.3, the Principal can condone only up to 10 % shortage beyond the 25 % allowance, and only for the specific contingencies listed.
  • The respondent’s case did not fall within those contingencies, and he never applied in the prescribed pro forma.

Respondent’s Arguments

The opinion does not record any arguments by the respondent, who remained ex parte.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

The Court conducted a textual analysis of Chapter 4:

  • Regulation 4.1 requires 75 % attendance to sit for end-semester examinations.
  • Regulation 4.2 enumerates specific activities (e.g., NCC camps, competitive examinations) for which a Principal may grant additional credit, capped at 10 % of total classes.
  • Regulation 4.3 expressly limits such condonation to a maximum of 10 % and mandates a prescribed application supported by documents.

Applying these provisions, the Court found:

  • The respondent attended only 29 of 46 lectures; even after the 25 % automatic allowance, he still lacked 11 %—beyond the permissible 10 % discretionary limit.
  • No application in the required pro forma was submitted; hence the regulatory conditions for condonation were unmet.
  • The High Court, by directing a 12 % condonation, exceeded the statutory ceiling and thus erred.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; High Court judgment set aside.

Direct Effect: The respondent’s shortage cannot be condoned beyond 10 %, and the High Court’s directive to declare his result is nullified. The decision reinforces strict adherence to the attendance regulations but explicitly refrains from setting a broader precedent.

    Regional Engineering College, Hamirpur And Another v. Ashutosh Pandey .

    Order

    1. This is an appeal preferred by Regional Engineering College, Hamirpur, Himachal Pradesh.

    2. The respondent before this Court was a student of the appellant College. He fell short of attendance in the last semester. About this, information was furnished to the respondent by placing a notice on the notice board on 19-2-1998. He was also informed personally on 5-4-1998 that he was short of attendance in Computer Application classes. It appears, in spite of it, the respondent absented himself from the classes. Further, in the month of April from 3-4-1998 to 7-4-1998 he remained absent and did not apply for condonation. It was only on 2-5-1998 after a lapse of 3 months he made an application for condonation of shortage of attendance in the lectures. His case was considered by the Principal of the College. The Principal refused to grant condonation inasmuch as after deducting the admissible absence of 25%, the Principal was entitled to condone only a further absence of 10% under Regulation 4.1 of Chapter 4 of the Academic Regulations of the College. The Principal felt that after deducting 25%, the absence of the respondent was in excess of the discretionary percentage of 10% and therefore the respondent could not be granted condonation.

    3. The respondent filed a writ petition in the High Court questioning the rejection of condonation of excess absence. The same was allowed by the Division Bench on the ground that the petitioner — (respondent herein) — had good academic record from the first semester to the seventh semester and that shortage occurred in the sixth semester and that too because the respondent was to go to Delhi for appearing in examination/interview for his better prospects after informing the Training and Placement Officer. The Court noticed that the respondent had informed the Training and Placement Officer, though he had not specifically applied for condonation to the said officer and felt that the respondent was within the permissible level of absence. The writ petition was allowed. The High Court directed that the result of the examination be declared. It further directed the Principal to consider the case of the respondent for condonation of shortage in lectures to the extent of 12% (even though it was in excess of 10%) and that the shortage should be condoned by the Principal. The Principal was to pass an order within four weeks and thereafter the result of the respondent's papers in Digital Signal of the eighth semester was to be declared. It was also stated that this decision was being rendered in the peculiar facts of the case and would not be a precedent in other cases where shortage in lectures would exceed 10% in addition to 25%.

    4. In this appeal, learned counsel for the appellant has contended that the Principal is entitled to condonation of shortage in lectures only up to 10% (in excess of 25%) and that too in the specific contingencies mentioned in Regulation 4.1 This was not a case falling within the purview of Regulation 4.1 The respondent has remained ex parte.

    5. On the facts, we find that out of 46 lectures in the semester, the respondent had attended only 29 lectures. Giving him the benefit of deduction of 25%, he should have attended 34.5 lectures i.e 35 lectures.

    6. The question for consideration is whether after giving the benefit of 25% a further shortage of 11% could be condoned or not. In our view, Chapter 4 does not give any scope for condonation in excess of 10% after giving the benefit of 25%.

    7. The relevant Regulation reads as follows:

    “chapter 4

    Attendance requirement

    4.1 (i) To appear in the end semester examination of a course, a candidate should have 75% of minimum attendance in that course.
    (ii) A candidate is likely to be detained in those subjects in which he/she will not possess 74% attendance.
    (iii) The attendant (sic) should be counted from the date of commencement of classwork for all the classes except first semester students who may be allowed relaxation in view of their late admission/nomination by other RECs and also because of extension of the last date of admission by the Government of India. Their attendance shall be counted from the date of their actual admission in the first semester.
    4.2 The candidate having deficient attendance on account of participation in—
    (i) inter-university, university or inter-college tournaments,
    (ii) NCC/NSS camps or college/university educational excursions or other curricular activities,
    (iii) mountaineering, skiing courses,
    (iv) competitive examinations, interviews held by government organisations/public limited companies, etc.
    (v) other genuine grounds.
    Subject to the approval and satisfaction of the Principal can also be given attendance credit to the extent of 10% of the total classes held in each course during the period of his/her participation in the abovesaid programmes/competitions. Prior approval of the competent authority/Principal in all the abovesaid cases should be obtained in order to avail the abovesaid attendance condonation.
    4.3 It is further provided that the condonation on account of reasons listed under Regulation 4.2 shall not exceed 10% of the total lectures delivered during the semester. To obtain this concession the students will have to apply to the Head of the Department concerned on a prescribed pro forma along with abovesaid reasons and documents in proof thereof. The condonation shall be granted by the Head of the Department concerned with the prior approval of the Principal.
    4.4 The list of all the candidates falling short of attendance shall be displayed on the notice board along with the subjects by the Head of the Department concerned before the commencement of end semester examinations.”

    8. A perusal of the Regulation shows that a candidate should first have 75% of minimum attendance in that course under Regulation 4.1 Regulation 4.2 mentions the circumstances under which further exemption can be granted by the Principal. The Principal can give further credit up to an extent of 10% of the total classes held in each course during the period of a student's participation in the programmes/competitions mentioned in Regulation 4.2 The Principal can exempt up to 10% of the total classes only in contingencies as mentioned in Regulation 4.2 Thus, 10% is the maximum in addition to 25%.

    9. In addition, Regulation 4.3 is specific that the condonation on account of reasons listed under Regulation 4.2 shall not exceed 10% of the total lectures delivered during the semester. It also states that a candidate will have to apply to the Head of the Department concerned on a prescribed pro forma along with the reasons and documents in proof of his absence. Condonation can be granted by the Head of the Department concerned with the prior approval of the Principal. Thus, 10% in excess of 25% alone is the maximum that can be condoned.

    10. In the present case, the respondent did not make any application in the prescribed pro forma. Therefore, it is not possible to say whether his case comes within the contingencies mentioned in Regulation 4.2 It is, no doubt, stated that the respondent has gone to Delhi to appear in the examination/interview, but it is not clear whether that was an examination/interview held by a government organization/public limited company. In any event, admittedly, after deducting admissible 25% exemption, further absence of the respondent comes to 11% which is more than the permissible discretionary percentage granted to the Principal. Therefore, the Principal was right in saying that he had no power to condone the absence in excess of 10%, in addition to 25%.

    11. We are, therefore, of the opinion that the High Court fell into an error in permitting condonation of absence beyond 10%, in addition to 25%. We, therefore, set aside the judgment of the High Court and the directions given therein.

    12. Pending this appeal there was stay of the impugned order and this Court also observed that it would be open to the respondent to appear in the examination in December 1998 provided he had complied with all other requirements for appearing in the supplementary examination.

    13. It appears that the respondent had appeared in supplementary examination. That is why, perhaps, he is not represented by counsel today.

    14. For the reasons aforementioned, the appeal is allowed. The judgment of the High Court is set aside. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Regional Engineering College, Hamirpur And Another v. Ashutosh Pandey .
    (Jul 26, 2000)