AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 226 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 6-A of the Act
  • the amendment made in the enactment in 1985
  • Madhya Pradesh Sales Tax Act
  • Clause (ii) of Section 6-A, that is, either consumption of such goods in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act
  • Section 6-A of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957
  • Section 5 or Section 6 of this Act
  • Section 6-A(ii)(a) of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 226 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 6-A of the Act
  • the amendment made in the enactment in 1985
  • Madhya Pradesh Sales Tax Act
  • Clause (ii) of Section 6-A, that is, either consumption of such goods in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act
  • Section 6-A of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957
  • Section 5 or Section 6 of this Act
  • Section 6-A(ii)(a) of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondents are builders who construct and sell flats and houses. For this purpose they purchase construction materials such as sand, bricks and granite from persons who are not registered dealers under the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957 (“the Act”). Because the sellers are unregistered, these purchases had not borne sales tax.

On 19 January 1982 the Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Enforcement) issued a notice requiring the respondents to produce their purchase accounts from 1 April 1977. The respondents replied that they were not dealers, did not trade in goods, and that Section 6-A of the Act was inapplicable. A further notice dated 22 March 1982 was issued under Section 28, again demanding production of books and purchase bills.

Challenging the jurisdiction to tax them, the respondents filed writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution before the High Court. The High Court rejected their pleas of discrimination and non-dealer status but, relying on earlier Supreme Court authority, held that Section 6-A did not cover mere consumption of building materials in construction. The State appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether purchasers of goods from unregistered dealers who consume those goods in the construction of immovable property fall within Section 6-A(ii)(a) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957.
  2. Which of the two conflicting Supreme Court interpretations of identical statutory language—Ganesh Prasad Dixit v. CST versus CST v. Pio Food Packers—correctly states the law.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants (State/Tax Department)

  • Section 6-A(ii)(a) covers consumption of goods “in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise”; the phrase “or otherwise” is disjunctive and extends the levy to any consumption, not merely manufacture.
  • Relied on Ganesh Prasad Dixit v. CST and on Hotel Balaji v. State of A.P. to show the legislative intent to tax raw materials used by consumers irrespective of subsequent manufacture.
  • Submitted that the 1985 amendment to Section 6-A is clarificatory and supports their interpretation.

Respondents (Builders)

  • Materials like sand and bricks are incorporated into immovable property; they do not manufacture “other goods” for sale, so Section 6-A is not attracted.
  • Invoked CST v. Pio Food Packers and its approval in CST v. Thomas Stephen & Co. Ltd. to argue that “otherwise” qualifies only the words “for sale”, meaning the clause applies only where goods are consumed in manufacture.
  • Contended that, if two interpretations are possible, the one favouring the assessee should prevail.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ganesh Prasad Dixit v. CST (1969 1 SCC 492) The words “for sale or otherwise” show that any consumption—whether in manufacture for sale or in any other manner—attracts purchase tax. Followed and approved; treated as laying down the correct interpretation of Section 6-A(ii)(a).
CST v. Pio Food Packers (1980 Supp SCC 174) Narrow reading: “otherwise” qualifies “for sale”; tax arises only when goods are consumed in manufacture of other goods. Expressly overruled to the extent it conflicts with the broader interpretation adopted.
CST v. Thomas Stephen & Co. Ltd. (1988 2 SCC 264) Applied the Pio Food Packers view. Implicitly disapproved; not followed.
Hotel Balaji v. State of A.P. (1993 Supp (4) SCC 536) Purpose of Section 6-A is to levy purchase tax on raw materials used by consumers, whether or not they are manufacturers. Cited in support of the State’s submission and consistent with the Court’s final interpretation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that Section 6-A(ii) is designed to tax purchases from unregistered sellers when the goods cease to exist in their original form within the State. Examining the statutory text, it held that:

  • The clause “either consumes such goods in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise” creates two distinct taxable events: (a) consumption in manufacture for sale, and (b) consumption otherwise.
  • The interpretation in Pio Food Packers, which confined “otherwise” to the words “for sale”, is grammatically and contextually unsound because it defeats the legislative object of capturing all forms of consumption.
  • Adopting the reasoning in Ganesh Prasad Dixit, the Court concluded that once goods are incorporated into buildings they disappear as saleable goods and therefore trigger the purchase-tax liability.
  • Accordingly, the High Court erred in exempting the respondents; its reliance on Pio Food Packers was misplaced.

Holding and Implications

Held: The appeal is allowed, the High Court’s judgment is set aside, and the writ petitions filed by the respondents are dismissed. The Department may proceed with assessment after giving the respondents an opportunity to be heard; no order as to costs.

Implications: The Supreme Court clarifies that Section 6-A(ii)(a) of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act applies to any consumption of goods purchased from unregistered dealers, whether or not the goods are used in manufacturing other goods for sale. By overruling Pio Food Packers, the decision establishes a broader tax base for similar purchase-tax provisions and resolves conflicting authority on the meaning of “or otherwise.”

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Assistant Commissioner (Intelligence) v. Nandanam Construction Co. .

    S. Rajendra Babu, J.— The respondents are engaged in building of flats and houses for which purpose they buy materials such as sand, bricks and granite from persons other than registered dealers. These items have not suffered any sales tax.

    2. The Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Enforcement, called upon the respondents by a notice dated 19-1-1982 to appear before him with their accounts relating to purchase of raw materials effected by them commencing from 1-4-1977. The respondents sent a reply to him stating that they do not trade in any goods; that they construct and sell flats; that they are not registered dealers; that the said purchases do not attract tax under Section 6-A of the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 1957 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”). Not being satisfied with the reply filed by the respondents, the Assistant Commissioner of Commercial Taxes issued a notice on 22-3-1982 under Section 28 of the Act calling upon the respondents to produce books of accounts and purchase bills and to file the details relating to the purchase of raw materials effected by them for the period commencing from 1-4-1977. Aggrieved by the said notice the respondents filed writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India questioning the jurisdiction of the appellants to assess them under the Act.

    3. Several contentions had been raised before the High Court such as discrimination between registered and unregistered dealers and that the respondents are not dealers and that in order to attract Section 6-A a dealer must have purchased goods from unregistered dealers and consumed such goods in the manufacture of other goods for sale or disposed of such goods either within or outside the State. The first two contentions stood rejected and that part of the order is not challenged before us. Therefore, we have to confine ourselves to the question whether the respondents who purchased goods from persons other than registered dealers fall within the scope of Section 6-A of the Act.

    4. Section 6-A of the Act reads as follows:

    “6-A. Levy of tax on turnover relating to purchase of certain goods.—Every dealer, who in the course of business—

    (i) purchases any goods (the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax under this Act) from a registered dealer in circumstances in which no tax is payable under Section 5 or under Section 6, as the case may be, or

    (ii) purchases any goods (the sale or purchase of which is liable to tax under this Act) from a person other than a registered dealer, and

    (a) either consumes such goods in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise, or

    (b) disposes of such goods in any manner other than by way of sale in the State, or

    (c) despatches them to a place outside the State except as a direct result of sale or purchase in the course of inter-State trade or commerce,

    shall pay tax on the turnover relating to purchase aforesaid at the same rate at which but for the existence of the aforementioned circumstances, the tax would have been leviable on such goods under Section 5 or Section 6.”

    5. The respondents' contention is that the goods such as sand and bricks purchased by them are not consumed in the manufacture of other goods for sale inasmuch as they deal in the construction of flats which are in the nature of immovable property. The respondents are also not manufacturing any other goods for sale or any other purposes. Thus, they contend that Section 6-A of the Act is not attracted. The contention put forth on behalf of the appellants is that even goods consumed for building purposes other than in the manufacture of other goods are also covered by clause (ii)(a) of Section 6-A. The High Court found that there is a conflict between the decisions in Ganesh Prasad Dixit v. CST (1969) 1 SCC 492, (1969) 3 SCR 490 and CST v. Pio Food Packers 1980 Supp SCC 174, (1980) 3 SCR 1271. The High Court is of the view that the said two decisions having been rendered by an identical composition of a Bench of three Judges, the latter decision was binding upon them and held that in order to attract the provisions of Section 6-A(ii)(a) of the Act there must be consumption of the original goods for the purpose of manufacture of other goods for sale or for purposes other than sale and in the absence of such consumption the respondents were not liable to tax. The matter is brought up before this Court by way of appeal by special leave.

    6. The matter is set down before us as a Bench of three Judges referred the matter to a larger Bench in view of the conflict between the two decisions of this Court.

    7. The appellants contend that Section 6-A(ii)(a) of the Act is attracted to consumption of original goods in the manufacture of the other goods for sale or consumption of original goods otherwise and placed reliance upon the decision in Ganesh Prasad Dixit (1969) 1 SCC 492, (1969) 3 SCR 490. The learned counsel also referred to the decision in Hotel Balaji v. State of A.P 1993 Supp (4) SCC 536, 1992 Supp (2) SCR 182 to contend that the object of the provision under Section 6-A of the Act is to levy purchase tax on the purchase of raw material used by a consumer be that a manufacturer or otherwise. He also sought to place reliance on the amendment made in the enactment in 1985 as clarificatory and covering the present case also.

    8. The learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the view taken in Pio Food Packers 1980 Supp SCC 174, (1980) 3 SCR 1271 which has been followed in CST v. Thomas Stephen & Co. Ltd. (1988) 2 SCC 264 must be accepted and at any rate if two views are possible, the assessee should get the benefit of doubt and tax ought not be imposed. The subsequent amendment to the enactment would make the position clear and, therefore, the expression “otherwise” cannot be read as “in any other manner”.

    9. Construing identical provisions in the Madhya Pradesh Sales Tax Act, this Court in the decision in Ganesh Prasad Dixit (1969) 1 SCC 492, (1969) 3 SCR 490 stated as follows:

    “6. Mr Chagla for the appellants urged that the expression ‘or otherwise’ is intended to denote a conjunctive introducing specific alternative to the words ‘for sale’ immediately preceding. The clause in which it occurs means, says Mr Chagla, that by Section 7 the price paid for buying goods consumed in the manufacture of other goods, intended to be sold or otherwise disposed of, alone is taxable. We do not think that that is a reasonable interpretation of the expression ‘either consumes such goods in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise’. It is intended by the legislature that consumption of goods renders the price paid for their purchase taxable, if the goods are used in the manufacture of other goods for sale or if the goods are consumed otherwise.”

    10. Subsequently this Court in Pio Food Packers 1980 Supp SCC 174, (1980) 3 SCR 1271 considered identical words in the Kerala General Sales Tax Act in another manner as follows:

    “13. Learned counsel for the Revenue contends that even if no manufacturing process is involved, the case still falls within Section 5-A(1)(a) of the Kerala General Sales Tax Act, because the statutory provision speaks not only of goods consumed in the manufacture of other goods for sale but also goods consumed otherwise. There is a fallacy in the submission. The clause, truly read, speaks of goods consumed in the manufacture of other goods for sale or goods consumed in the manufacture of other goods for purposes other than sale.”

    11. We are concerned in this case only with sub-clause (a) of clause (ii) of Section 6-A, that is, either consumption of such goods in the manufacture of other goods for sale or otherwise. Clause (ii) of Section 6-A of the Act postulates levy of tax on purchase of goods from a person other than a registered dealer for consumption or disposal or despatch of goods outside the State. So the scheme of clause (ii) of Section 6-A of the Act is that when the goods cease to exist in the original form or cease to be available in the State for sale or purchase, the purchasing dealer of such goods is liable to tax if the seller is not or cannot be taxed. To our mind, it appears that the object of Section 6-A(ii)(a) of the Act is to levy purchase tax on goods consumed either for the purpose of manufacture of other goods for sale or consumed otherwise. If the view in Pio Food Packers 1980 Supp SCC 174, (1980) 3 SCR 1271 is accepted the result would be that the expression “otherwise” will qualify the expression “sale” and not the expression “manufacture”, which appears to us to be erroneous on a plain construction of the provision. The intention of the legislature, it appears to us, is to bring to purchase tax in either event of consumption of goods in the manufacture of goods for sale or consumption of goods in any other manner. Once the goods are utilised in the construction of buildings the goods cease to exist or cease to be available in that form for sale or purchase so as to attract the tax and, therefore, the correct meaning to be attributed to the said provision would be that tax will be attracted when such goods are consumed in the manufacture of other goods or are consumed otherwise. Therefore, while agreeing with the view in Ganesh Prasad Dixit (1969) 1 SCC 492, (1969) 3 SCR 490 on this aspect, we overrule to this extent the view expressed in Pio Food Packers 1980 Supp SCC 174, (1980) 3 SCR 1271.

    12. Consequently, we set aside the impugned order made by the High Court and dismiss the writ petitions. It is now up to the Department to proceed with the assessment after giving due opportunity to the respondents to file their objections. Considering the nature and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Assistant Commissioner (Intelligence) v. Nandanam Construction Co. .
    (Sep 21, 1999)