AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 63 of the Act
  • Section [not specified] of the [Act not specified]
  • the provisions of the Act
  • Section 84(2) of the Act
  • Section 43 of the Tenancy Act
  • Section 32 of the Tenancy Act
  • Section 43-G of the Act
  • Section 85-A of the Act
  • Sections 29 and 31 of the Act
  • Article 227 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 32-G, Section 32-M of the Act
  • Section 64(8) of the Act
  • Section 32-G, Section 32-M read with Section 43 of the Act
  • Section 32-G of the Tenancy Act
  • Section 32 of the Act
  • Section 43(2) of the Act
  • Section 64 of the Act
  • Section 31 read with Section 29 of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 63 of the Act
  • Section [not specified] of the [Act not specified]
  • the provisions of the Act
  • Section 84(2) of the Act
  • Section 43 of the Tenancy Act
  • Section 32 of the Tenancy Act
  • Section 43-G of the Act
  • Section 85-A of the Act
  • Sections 29 and 31 of the Act
  • Article 227 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 32-G, Section 32-M of the Act
  • Section 64(8) of the Act
  • Section 32-G, Section 32-M read with Section 43 of the Act
  • Section 32-G of the Tenancy Act
  • Section 32 of the Act
  • Section 43(2) of the Act
  • Section 64 of the Act
  • Section 31 read with Section 29 of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Anant Gopal Prabhu owned 3 acres 25 gunthas of agricultural land in Village Ingali, Kolhapur District, which was cultivated by his tenant Rau. After Rau's death, his four sons—Dadu, Mahadu, Ganpati and Shripati—succeeded to the tenancy.

The landlord initiated eviction proceedings under Sections 31 and 29 of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948 (“the Act”), but those proceedings were dismissed on 24 May 1961. Meanwhile, on 27 April 1961, Prabhu privately sold the land to the tenants. A later partition led Mahadu to sell his share to Himmat Patel (the respondent) on 11 May 1966.

Proceedings under Section 32-G began in 1969. On 21 December 1969, the Tahsildar regularised the 1961 sale, declared the tenants purchasers, and struck Patel’s name from the revenue records as the 1966 transfer violated the Act. The Assistant Collector affirmed this decision on 23 October 1971.

Patel succeeded in revision before the Maharashtra Revenue Tribunal, which validated the 1966 sale. A petition under Article 227 of the Constitution was dismissed by the Bombay High Court, albeit on grounds different from the Tribunal. The present appeal challenges that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the sale deed executed by Mahadu in favour of Himmat Patel on 11 May 1966 is invalid under the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948, particularly in light of Sections 64(8) and 43(2).
  2. Whether the tenants acquired ownership by the private sale of 27 April 1961 or only upon the statutory proceedings culminating in the order dated 21 December 1969 under Section 32-M.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments (Legal representatives of Dadu Rau)

  • The High Court erred in treating the private sale of 27 April 1961 as valid; Section 64(8) renders void any transfer by a landlord after the tillers’ day.
  • The tenants obtained title only on 21 December 1969 when the Tahsildar regularised the sale under Section 32-M; hence Mahadu had no transferable interest on 11 May 1966.
  • Even if title were deemed to vest earlier, the sale to Patel is barred by Section 43(2) because it is a transfer by a purchaser under the Act made without statutory permission.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Special C.A. No. 605 of 1961 (referenced in Gadgil, Tenancy Law Digest, 1965) Sale by a landlord to a tenant in contravention of Section 64 is not covered by Section 43. Relied upon by the Revenue Tribunal to uphold the 1966 sale to Patel; the Supreme Court found the reliance misplaced.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court held that Section 64(8) expressly voids any transfer by a landlord after the tillers’ day; therefore, the 27 April 1961 sale by Prabhu to the tenants conferred no immediate title. Title vested in the tenants only when the Tahsildar's order under Section 32-M was passed on 21 December 1969.

On 11 May 1966, when Mahadu purported to sell his share to Patel, he possessed no legal title. Even if the subsequent conferment of title were deemed to relate back to May 24 1961, Mahadu, as a purchaser under the Act, was prohibited by Section 43(2) from transferring the land without requisite permission. Consequently, the 1966 sale was void.

The Court criticised both the Revenue Tribunal and the High Court for overlooking Section 64(8) and for misapplying Section 43. It reinstated the concurrent factual and legal findings of the Tahsildar and Assistant Collector that had declared the Patel sale invalid.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; orders of the High Court and Revenue Tribunal set aside; orders of the Tahsildar and Assistant Collector restored.

Immediate Effect: The sale deed dated 11 May 1966 in favour of Himmat Patel is declared invalid. The civil court will now proceed in the pending suit consistent with this determination. No broader precedent was set beyond reaffirming the statutory bar on post-tillers’ day transfers and the restrictions under Section 43.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Dadu Rau Yelavade (Dead) By His Heirs And Lrs. v. Himmat Rasul Patel .

    S. Ranganathan, J.— This is an appeal from a judgment of the Bombay High Court dismissing a petition filed by Dadu Rau Yelavade (now represented by his legal representatives) under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

    2. One Anant Gopal Prabhu (‘Prabhu’, for short) was the owner of 3 acres 25 gunthas of land bearing Survey No. 54 in village Ingali in Hatakanangale Taluka of Kolhapur district. The lands were under the cultivation of one Rau, who was the father of the petitioner before the High Court. The landlord instituted proceedings under Section 31 read with Section 29 of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948 (hereinafter called ‘the Act’) against the tenant Rau. During the pendency of these proceedings, Rau died and his tenancy rights were inherited by his four sons, Dadu (predecessor of the present appellants), Mahadu, Ganpati and Shripati. These proceedings came to an end eventually by an order dated May 24, 1961, on which date the petition under Section 29 read with Section 31 was dismissed. Subsequently, proceedings were initiated by the Tahsildar under Section 32-G of the Tenancy Act. This was sometime in 1969 and will be referred to later. In the meantime, on April 27, 1961, the landlord Prabhu had decided to sell the suit land to the fourth son of Rau, who effected a partition of the property and Mahadu, one of the other sons of Rau, sold his share in the suit land in favour of the present respondent Patel by a registered document dated May 11, 1966. In view of this, the proceedings under Section 32-G, initiated by the Tahsildar, came to an end with an order of the Tahsildar declaring the fourth son of Rau as the purchaser. His order was passed on December 21, 1969. After discussing the questions whether the tenants were in lawful possession of the suit land, whether they were entitled to purchase the suit land and whether the purchase price fixed in the voluntary sale between Prabhu and Rau's fourth son was reasonable and whether the sale effected between the landlord and tenants could be regularised, the Tahsildar decided to regularise the purchase of the suit land by the tenants, and directed that a certificate under Section 32-M read with Section 43 of the Act should be issued to the tenants Dadu Rau and his brothers. In the course of his order, he also discussed the alleged sale in respect of Patel, on whom notice had been served and who had participated in the proceedings. He came to the conclusion that the sale effected by Mahadu in favour of Patel, being contrary to law, was illegal and directed that his name should be removed from the revenue record.

    3. In the meanwhile, the petitioner, one of the sons of Rau, had initiated a suit against Patel for an injunction restraining him from obstructing his possession of the property. Patel resisted the suit claiming to be the purchaser of share of Mahadu and, therefore, entitled to remain in possession as a co-owner along with the petitioner. In view of the rival contentions of the parties, the Civil Court referred the following two issues for determination of the tenancy authorities as contemplated by provisions of Section 85-A of the Act:

    (1) Was the plaintiff a tenant of the suit property and did he subsequently become its deemed purchaser?
    (2) Is the sale deed by Mahadu to Patel invalid under the Act?

    4. In the proceedings before the revenue authorities, the Tahsildar answered both questions in the affirmative. He held that the plaintiffs were the deemed purchasers of the land on April 1, 1959 and he also came to the conclusion that the transfer by Mahadu in favour of Patel was hit by the provisions of Section 43 of the Tenancy Act. According to him, therefore, Patel had no right or title to the portion of the land in suit which Mahadu had sold him. This order was confirmed in appeal, on October 23, 1971, by the Assistant Collector.

    5. Patel thereupon filed a revision before the Revenue Tribunal which set aside the order of the authorities below and held that the sale deed by Mahadu in favour of respondent 1 was not invalid under the provisions of the Act. The Revenue Tribunal agreed that the sons of Rau became deemed purchasers only on May 24, 1961 and became actual purchasers only on December 21, 1969 when the sale in their favour was regularised under Section 32-M of the Act. However, in regard to the sale by Mahadu, it observed:

    “But, the important point to be gone into in this case is, whether the sale of such a land by Mahadu, one of the sons of deceased Rau, to Himmat was hit by the provisions of Section 43 of the Act. It is nobody's case that the sale to Himmat by Mahadu was after December 21, 1969. According to Himmat, it is on May 11, 1966. This is not challenged. It will be thus seen that this sale to Himmat, of his share in the suit land by Mahadu is dated May 11, 1966 long before Mahadu and his brothers came to be regarded as purchasers under Section 32 of the Act. Section 43 of the Act, according to me, applied to transfers subsequently effected by purchasers under Section 32, 32-F, 31-I, 320, 3-C or 41-D. Similarly, restriction contained in Section 43-G of the Act, applied to transfers by persons, after the land was sold to them under Section 32-P or 64 of the Act. In this case, it is clear that while selling his share in the property, Mahadu was not a landlord intending to sell the tenanted land. So a sale by him to Himmat could not be said to be a sale in contravention of Section 64 of the Act. The point, whether Himmat Patel was an agriculturist or non-agriculturist or whether he was or was not an agriculturist labourer is not enquired into even if it is held for some time, that he was a person to whom the land could not be sold under Section 63 of the Act. But Mahadu ventured to do so. The sale by Mahadu would be at the most hit by Section 63 of the Act. This section (43 of the Act) does not mention Section 63 of the Act. Therefore, it is not possible to uphold the findings of the first two Courts with regard to the transfer of a portion of land by Mahadu to Himmat Patel. This sale effected in favour of Himmat Patel by Mahadu in 1966 is of date prior to Mahadu, and his brothers came to be regarded as purchasers of the land under Section 32 of the Act.
    We have seen that originally the sale in favour of Rau's sons by Prabhu was in contravention of Section 64 of the Act. But such sale is not covered by Section 43 of the Act. This view can be fortified by following Special C.A No. 605 of 1961 referred to on page 179 of Tenancy Law Digest (reported and unreported cases) by Gadgil, 1965. It is observed that to such a sale even, Section 43 of the Act does not apply. Such a sale, even if it is validated under provision to Section 84(2) cannot be regarded as a sale under Section 64 of the Act. Where a sale is made in favour of a tenant by the landlord in contravention of Section 64, it may be regularised by the Mamlatdar. Where the same is sold by the tenant to some other person, such a sale is valid and is not affected by provisions of Section 43 of the Act.”

    In this view of the matter, the Revenue Tribunal answered the questions referred by saying (a) that the plaintiff and his brothers had become deemed purchasers on the postponed day under the Act and (b) that the sale deed by Mahadu in favour of Patel was not invalid.

    6. The present appellants preferred a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution. The High Court endorsed the conclusion of the Revenue Tribunal but on a ground somewhat different from the one on which the Tribunal allowed the revision petition. It was pointed out the Revenue Tribunal had proceeded on the footing that the tenants (including Mahadu) had become purchasers of the suit land under the provisions of Section 32 of the Tenancy Act on May 24, 1961 when proceedings under Section 31 came to end. But this ignored the fact that, during the pendency of the proceedings under Sections 29 and 31 of the Act, the landlord and the tenants by a private agreement had transferred the ownership of the property in favour of the tenants on April 27, 1961. The tenants, therefore, became owners not on May 24, 1961 but on April 27, 1961. Section 64 did not, in the opinion of the Court, prohibit the landlord from selling his land to the tenants by a private agreement. It only required the owner, in case he desired to sell, to have a reasonable price fixed therefor by moving the Land Tribunal. This being so, the ownership rights of the tenants had been acquired not under the provisions of Section 32 of the Act but by virtue of a sale between the landlord and the tenants. Since the transfer in favour of the tenants was not one under Section 32, the provisions of Section 43 of the Act were not attracted by the sale of May 11, 1966. In this view of the matter, the revision petition before the High Court was also dismissed.

    7. Dadu Rau is in appeal from the order of the High Court. Though the proceedings have had a chequered history, the issue before us is a very simple one : Does the sale by Mahadu to Patel on May 11, 1966 confer on the latter any valid title to the land in question? The High Court has answered this question in the affirmative by upholding the sale by Prabhu to his tenants on April 27, 1961. Shri Ganpule argues, and rightly in our opinion, that the High Court erred in holding that the sale in favour of the tenants was not affected by Section 64 of the Act. The High Court has overlooked the clear provisions of Section 64(8), which declare that any transfer by a landlord after tiller's day would be void. The tenants could not, therefore, have acquired any right or title under the sale deed executed by the landlords. It is no doubt true that ultimately the proceedings under Section 32-G went in their favour and the sale certificate issued in their favour was regularised. Though the order under Section 32-G purports to ratify the earlier transaction of sale by the landlord to the tenants, the transaction acquires its validity not by virtue of the sale deed of April 27, 1961 but only by virtue of the order under Section 32-M dated December 21, 1969. On May 11, 1966, — the date of the sale to Patel presently impugned — the tenants (including Mahadu) had no title to the property which they could validly convey in favour of Patel. That title vested in them only on December 21, 1969, when the order under Section 32-G was passed. This being so, the logic of the Tribunal and High Court that the transfer in favour of Patel was not of property acquired under Section 32 but of a property acquired by a voluntary process is not correct. As we have already pointed out, on the date of the sale deed in favour of Patel, the vendor had no title to the land in view of the provisions of Section 64(8). Even if the subsequent conferment of title on them by the order under Section 32-G be treated to date back to May 24, 1961, still Mahadu, being a tenant who acquired title under the Act, his sale to Patel will fail in view of the provisions of Section 43(2) of the Act. We may indeed point out that this decision had already been given by the revenue authorities in the order dated December 21, 1969. There is a reference in the order of the Assistant Collector to an appeal claimed to have been preferred by Patel from this order but we are informed that no such appeal was filed or is pending. But this circumstance apart, Patel's claim cannot be upheld for the reasons given above.

    8. We are, therefore, of the opinion that the High Court erred in upholding the order of the Revenue Tribunal. The orders of the High Court and the Revenue Tribunal are therefore set aside and the order of the lower revenue authorities restored. The questions referred to the tenancy courts by the civil court have to be answered accordingly by saying that the sale deed by Mahadu in favour of Patel is invalid under the provisions of the Act. The appeal is disposed of accordingly and the matter will go back to the civil court for the disposal of the civil suit filed before it in the light of the answers given to the referred questions set out above. In the circumstances of the case we make no order regarding costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dadu Rau Yelavade (Dead) By His Heirs And Lrs. v. Himmat Rasul Patel .
    (Mar 10, 1992)