AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • U.P Women's & Children Institutions (Control) Act, 1956
  • Article 136 of the Constitution
  • Section not specified, U.P Public Services (Tribunal) Act, 1976
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • U.P Women's & Children Institutions (Control) Act, 1956
  • Article 136 of the Constitution
  • Section not specified, U.P Public Services (Tribunal) Act, 1976
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The second appellant is an Administrative Board established under the U.P. Women’s & Children Institutions (Control) Act, 1956, tasked with controlling and supervising orphanages and other institutions for destitute children and women in Uttar Pradesh, funded through public donations and State aid. The first respondent was appointed on September 29, 1958 to a temporary post of Licensing Inspector on a specified pay scale with allowances admissible to State Government employees.

After the ‘Holi’ holidays, the first respondent was required to return to duty by March 26, 1970 but did not do so even by July 1970 despite a notice. On July 15, 1970, the Board issued an order terminating his services with effect from March 26, 1970, stating that he would receive one month’s salary in lieu of notice.

In 1971, the first respondent filed a suit in the Munsif Court at Meerut seeking (i) a declaration that the termination order was void and (ii) a mandatory injunction for reinstatement. The suit was dismissed on December 4, 1974. His civil appeal in the District Court at Kanpur was transferred to the U.P. Public Services Tribunal upon the coming into force of the U.P. Public Services (Tribunal) Act, 1976. By order dated July 7, 1978, the Tribunal dismissed the appeal, holding inter alia that the termination could not be invalidated since the respondent had undisputedly received a notice dated May 6, 1970 to return to duty and failed to respond.

The first respondent then filed a writ petition before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad. A learned Single Judge, holding that even a temporary employee’s services could not be terminated without an opportunity of being heard, allowed the writ petition on November 27, 1991, quashed the Munsif Court and Tribunal decisions as well as the termination order, and granted salary and permissible allowances from the date of termination until the date of retirement (reinstatement being declined on the ground that the respondent had attained superannuation during the writ proceedings).

In the present appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution, the legality of the High Court’s order was questioned. Special leave was granted, and the appeal was heard on merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in granting the first respondent salary and allowances from the date of termination to the date of retirement in the writ petition, despite the nature of the original civil suit and the absence of findings relevant to such monetary relief.
  2. Whether, in the circumstances of the termination (including the respondent’s non-response to a notice to resume duty), the relief granted by the High Court required modification and, if so, what relief would be just and reasonable.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court focused on the propriety of the High Court’s monetary relief. It reasoned that the High Court’s direction to pay past salary and allowances (from termination to retirement) was not sustainable for multiple stated reasons:

  • Mismatch with the relief claimed in the original suit: The Court held that relief relating to past salary could not have been granted even if the first respondent had succeeded in his suit, because the suit was not framed as one for recovery of arrears of salary.
  • Absence of necessary factual finding on gainful employment: The Court observed that arrears of salary could not be granted without a finding that the first respondent was not otherwise gainfully employed during the relevant period.
  • Conduct of the first respondent contributing to termination: The Court noted that the respondent was not free from blame because the termination occurred due to his admitted non-response to the Board’s notice asking him to return and resume duties.

Having identified these constraints on awarding full back wages/arrears, the Court concluded that it would be just and reasonable, in the circumstances, to substitute the High Court’s direction with a lump-sum payment. It therefore directed payment of Rs 25,000 by the second appellant to the first respondent within three months, in lieu of the salary and allowances ordered by the High Court.

Holding and Implications

PARTLY ALLOWED: The appeal was partly allowed. The Court modified the High Court’s relief by directing the second appellant-Board to pay the first respondent a lump sum of Rs 25,000 within three months, in lieu of all his claims against the Board for the alleged wrongful termination of his services as Licensing Inspector.

Implications: The High Court’s direction to pay salary and allowances from termination to retirement was effectively replaced with a one-time lump sum compensation. The order settled the respondent’s claims against the Board arising from the alleged wrongful termination. The Court made no order as to costs, and the opinion does not indicate that any new precedent or broader rule of law was laid down beyond the case-specific modification of relief.

    State Of U.P And Another v. Atal Behari Shastri And Another

    N. Venkatachala, J.— Special leave is granted and the appeal is heard on merits.

    2. The second appellant is the Administrative Board established under the U.P Women's & Children Institutions (Control) Act, 1956 for properly controlling and supervising orphanages and other institutions of destitute children and women in the State, with the funds to be received by way of donations from the public and aid from the State Government. The first respondent was appointed on September 29, 1958 in a temporary post of Licensing Inspector in the establishment of the Administrative Board, on a pay scale of Rs 120-8-200 EB 10-300 plus dearness and other allowances as admissible to State Government employees. The first respondent who should have returned to duty by March 26, 1970 after availing of the ‘Holi’ Holidays, failed to do so even by the month of July 1970 despite a notice served upon him in that regard. This situation led to the issuing of an order dated July 15, 1970 by the Administrative Board terminating the services of the first respondent as its Licensing Inspector with effect from March 26, 1970 by informing him that he would get one month's salary in lieu of notice. The first respondent's suit, filed in the Munsif Court at Meerut in the year 1971 seeking the reliefs of declaration that the order of the Administrative Board by which his services were terminated was void and of the mandatory injunction for his reinstatement, was dismissed on December 4, 1974. Civil appeal preferred by the first respondent in the District Court at Kanpur against the dismissal of his suit was transferred by that court to the U.P Public Services Tribunal for disposal on the coming into force of the U.P Public Services (Tribunal) Act, 1976. But, that Tribunal, by its order dated July 7, 1978 dismissed the appeal finding, inter alia, that the order of termination of services of the respondent by the Administrative Board cannot be held to be invalid when the first respondent who had undisputably received a notice dated May 6, 1970 by which he was called upon to return to duty, had failed to respond to the same. The non-success of first respondent's appeal before the Tribunal, led him to the filing of a writ petition in the matter before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad. A learned Single Judge of that High Court, who took the view that although the first respondent was a holder of a temporary post, his services could not have been terminated without affording him an opportunity of being heard in the matter, allowed the writ petition by his order dated November 27, 1991, quashed the impugned decisions of the Court of Munsif and of the Service Tribunal, besides the impugned order of first respondent's termination and granted to first respondent a relief in the following terms:

    “In the affidavit sworn in support of the writ petition filed in 1978, the petitioner has given his age as 54 years. It is thus obvious that during the pendency of the writ petition he has attained the age of superannuation. For this reason, although the writ petition is being allowed his reinstatement in service cannot be ordered. However, he is entitled to his salary from the date of the order of termination to the date of his retirement. Salary and other permissible allowances for the aforesaid period shall be paid to the petitioner within three months from the date of presentation of a certified copy of this order.”

    3. In the present appeal preferred under Article 136 of the Constitution, the legality of the said order of the High Court is questioned.

    4. The relief relating to his past salary could not have been granted to the first respondent even if he had succeeded in his suit, for the suit was not for recovery of arrears of salary as such. Besides no arrears of salary of first respondent could have been granted in the absence of a finding recorded by the Court that the first respondent was not otherwise gainfully employed during the relevant period. Moreover, the first respondent is not free from blame, for the termination of his services was due to his admitted non-response to the notice of the Advisory Board asking him to return and resume the duties of his office.

    5. In the circumstances, it would be just and reasonable to direct the second appellant-Advisory Board to pay a lump sum of Rs 25,000 (twenty-five thousand only) to first respondent within three months from today instead of salary and allowances ordered to be paid by the High Court in its order in appeal.

    6. In the result, we allow the appeal partly and direct the second appellant-Advisory Board to pay to first respondent Atal Behari Shastri a lump sum of Rs 25,000 within three months from today in lieu of all his claims against the second appellant-Advisory Board for the alleged wrongful termination of his services as Licensing Inspector. In the peculiar circumstances of this appeal we make no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of U.P And Another v. Atal Behari Shastri And Another
    (Sep 16, 1992)