Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1980 INSC 30
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 3(1) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974
  • Article 32 of the Constitution of India
  • Constitution of India, Vol. I, p. 542, para 12.82
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1980 INSC 30
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 3(1) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974
  • Article 32 of the Constitution of India
  • Constitution of India, Vol. I, p. 542, para 12.82
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Ramchandra A. Kamat, was detained on 5 September 1979 pursuant to an order dated 31 August 1979 issued under Section 3(1) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 (COFEPOSA) by the Additional Secretary, Ministry of Finance (the second respondent). Grounds of detention were served the same day.
Through counsel, the petitioner sought copies of all statements and documents referred to in those grounds on 7 September 1979 to prepare a representation. Correspondence ensued among the petitioner’s advocate, the Deputy Secretary in the Ministry of Finance, and the Deputy Director, Directorate of Enforcement, Bombay. Copies were ultimately supplied piecemeal on 26, 27 and 28 September 1979, and the petitioner’s representation was made on 5 October 1979.
Alleging unreasonable delay that vitiated his constitutional right under Article 22(5) to make an effective representation, the petitioner invoked Article 32 of the Constitution seeking a writ of habeas corpus. The Supreme Court issued an interim order directing his release and delivered the present reasons.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the delay between the petitioner’s request for documents and their eventual supply violated the constitutional requirement to enable a detenu to make an effective and expeditious representation under Article 22(5).
  2. Consequently, whether the continued detention of the petitioner was in accordance with “procedure established by law” as mandated by the Constitution.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The detaining authority failed to furnish, with reasonable expedition, copies of statements and documents referred to in the grounds of detention, thereby defeating the petitioner’s right to make an effective representation.
  • The unexplained and unjustified delay rendered the detention illegal and contrary to constitutional safeguards.

Detaining Authority’s Response

  • It was not incumbent to supply all relied-upon documents within five days; the grounds themselves were “sufficiently detailed” for an effective representation.
  • All reasonable steps were taken to comply with the petitioner’s request “as expeditiously as possible.”

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jayanarayan Sukul v. State of West Bengal, (1970) 1 SCC 219; (1970) 3 SCR 225 The appropriate government must consider a detenu’s representation “as expeditiously as possible”; delay is unconstitutional. The Court relied on this case to emphasise that any unexplained delay in processing a detenu’s representation or supplying requisite documents violates Article 22(5).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. The Court reaffirmed that the right to make a representation against preventive detention is a fundamental right. For that right to be meaningful, the detenu must receive, with reasonable expedition, copies of documents referred to in the grounds of detention once requested.

2. Assessing the chronology, the Court noted: (i) The request reached the detaining authority on 10 September 1979.
(ii) The authority did not itself respond; instead, a Deputy Secretary merely advised the Deputy Director, Enforcement, to furnish documents.
(iii) No prompt action followed; only on 22 September 1979 did the Deputy Director offer mere inspection rather than copies.
(iv) Copies were ultimately delivered over 26-28 September — a lapse of approximately 16–18 days from the initial request.

3. The Court found no satisfactory explanation for this delay. The detaining authority’s contention that detailed grounds obviated the need for copies was rejected as contrary to the constitutional mandate.

4. Citing Jayanarayan Sukul, the Bench held that such delay amounted to denial of the constitutional safeguard, rendering the detention order procedurally defective.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The detention was not in accordance with the procedure contemplated by law; the petitioner’s continued detention was unwarranted, and an order for his release was issued.

Implications: The decision directly results in the petitioner’s liberation and reiterates the duty of detaining authorities to supply relied-upon documents with reasonable expedition. No new legal doctrine was created, but the judgment reinforces existing precedents on prompt consideration of detenu representations.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Ramchandra A. Kamat v. Union Of India And Others

    P.S Kailasam, J.— The Petitioner Ramchandra A. Kamat has preferred this petition under Article 32 of the Constitution of India praying for the issue of writ of Habeas Corpus directing his release by quashing the order of his detention dated August 31, 1979 passed by second respondent. Additional Secretary to the Government of India, Ministry of Finance.

    2. The petitioner was detained by an order dated August 31, 1979 under Section 3(1) of the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974. In pursuance of the order, the petitioner was arrested on September 5, 1979. He was served with the grounds of detention on the same day. The petitioner through his Advocate by a letter dated September 7, 1979 wrote to the second respondent stating that it was found that the detaining authority relied upon a number of statements of various persons including the detenu as well as documents referred to in the grounds, but the detenu was not furnished with the copies of the same. The Advocate stated that the detenu desires to make a representation against the order of detention but found that without the copies of documents referred to in the grounds of detention order it is not possible to make an effective representation. A reply to his letter was sent to the Advocate by Mr Thawani, Deputy Secretary to the Government of India, wherein he acknowledged the receipt of the letter of the Advocate dated September 7, 1979. By this letter the Deputy Secretary requested the Advocate to contact the Deputy Director, Directorate of Enforcement, Bombay, who it was stated, had been suitably advised regarding supply of copies of statements and documents, relied upon in the detention order dated August 31, 1979. It may be noted that the detaining authority, the second respondent did not acknowledge the letter from the detenu's Advocate or take any action by himself but directed the Deputy Secretary to address the communication dated September 10, 1979 referred to above. Though the letter states that the Deputy Director, Bombay has been suitably advised regarding the request for supply of copies of statements and documents relied on in the detention order nothing further was done by the Deputy Director of Enforcement, Bombay. On September 14, 1979, the Advocate not having received any communication, addressed a letter to the Deputy Director enclosing a copy of the letter which he received from the Deputy Secretary and requested the Deputy Director to supply him on behalf of his client copies of the relevant statements and documents referred to and relied upon in the order of detention at an early date. In reply to the letter of September 14, 1979 by the Advocate, the Deputy Director in his communication dated September 22, 1979 requested the Advocate to see the Deputy Director on September 24, 1979 at 1430 hours to take inspection of the documents. On inspecting the documents the Advocate was not satisfied and insisted on supply of copies of documents and ultimately copies were supplied on 3 days, namely, on September 26, 28 and 29, 1979. The representation was made by the detenu on October 5, 1979.

    3. It is settled law that the appropriate authority is bound to give an opportunity to the detenu to make representation and to consider the representation of the detenu as early as possible. There should not be any delay in the matter of consideration.

    4. The Constitutional Bench of this Court in Jayanarayan Sukul v. State of W.B (1970) 1 SCC 219, (1970) 3 SCR 225 has held that the fundamental right of the detenu to have representation considered by the appropriate government will render meaningless if the government will not deal with the matter expeditiously. The court observed:

    “It is established beyond any measure of doubt that the appropriate authority is bound to consider the representation of the detenu as early as possible. The appropriate government itself is bound to consider the representation as expeditiously as possible. The reason for immediate consideration of the representation is too obvious to be stressed. The personal liberty of a person is at stake. Any delay would not only be an irresponsible act on the part of the appropriate authority but also unconstitutional because the Constitution enshrines the fundamental right of a detenu to have his representation considered and it is imperative that when the liberty of a person is in peril Immediate action should be taken by the relevant authorities.”

    5. The same view has been expressed by this Court in a number of cases vide Seervai's Constitutional Law of India, Vol. I, p. 542, para 12.82

    6. The right to make a representation is a fundamental right. The representation thus made should be considered expeditiously by the government. In order to make an effective representation, the detenu is entitled to obtain information relating to the grounds of detention. When the grounds of detention are served on the detenu, he is entitled to ask for copies of the statements and documents referred to in the grounds of detention to enable him to make an effective representation. When the detenu makes a request for such documents, they should be supplied to him expeditiously. The detaining authority in preparing the grounds would have referred to the statements and documents relied on in the grounds of detention and would be ordinarily available with him — when copies of such documents are asked for by the detenu the detaining authority should be in a position to supply them with reasonable expedition. What is reasonable expedition will depend on the facts of each case.

    7. It is alleged by the detenu that there had been unreasonable delay in furnishing of the statements and documents referred to in the grounds of detention. It is the duty of the detaining authority to satisfactorily explain the delay, if any, in furnishing of these documents. We are in this context not referring to the statements and documents not referred to in the grounds of detention for it may be that they are not in the possession of the detaining authority and that reasonable time may be required for furnishing copies of the relevant documents, which may not be in his possession.

    8. If there is undue delay in furnishing the statements and documents referred to in the grounds of detention the right to make effective representation is denied. The detention cannot be said to be according to the procedure prescribed by law. When the Act contemplates the furnishing of grounds of detention ordinarily within five days of the order of detention, the intention is clear that the statements and documents which are referred to in the grounds of detention and which are required by the detenu and are expected to be in possession of the detaining authority should be furnished with reasonable expedition.

    9. It will have to be considered on the facts of the case whether there was any unexplained delay in furnishing the statements and documents relied on in the grounds of detention. The detenu was arrested on September 5, 1979 and his Advocate by a letter dated September 7, 1979 Annexure “C” to the writ petition wrote to the detaining authority stating that for making an effective representation, he must have copies of statements and documents referred to in the detention order. He prayed that the copies of the statements and documents may be furnished to him. This letter was received by the detaining authority on September 10, 1979 and a communication was addressed not by the detaining authority but by Mr Thawani, Deputy Secretary on the same date. It is not clear whether the detaining authority applied his mind and realised the necessity for furnishing of the documents to the detenu expeditiously. The communication was addressed by the Deputy Secretary to the Advocate of the detenu informing him that the Deputy Director of Enforcement at Bombay had been suitably advised regarding the request for supply of copies of statements and documents relied on in the detention order. One would have expected that the detaining authority or the Deputy Secretary acting on his behalf, to have directed the Deputy Director of Enforcement, Bombay to furnish the necessary documents expeditiously to the Advocate as requested or to the detenu himself. The direction in the communication from the Deputy Secretary was not immediately complied with. The Advocate for the detenu wrote again on September 14, 1979 reminding the Deputy Director of the communication, he had received from the Deputy Secretary. The Advocate requested that the copies of the relevant statements and documents referred to and relied upon in the detention order may be supplied to him. This letter was replied by the Deputy Director on September 22, 1979 in which the Advocate was asked to have inspection of the documents in his premises between 1430 hours on September 24, 1979. The copies of the statements and documents requested by the Advocate for the detenu and directed by the Deputy Secretary to be furnished to the Advocate were not furnished to him instead the Deputy Director asked the Advocate to have inspection at the Deputy Director's office. After inspecting the documents on September 22, 24, 25, 1979, he insisted on having copies which were supplied on September 26, 27 and 28, 1979.

    10. The explanation given by the detaining authority regarding the delay in furnishing copies as seen in his counter-affidavit is that the constitutional right of the petitioner to make effective representation had not been infringed. According to the detaining authority “it was not incumbent upon the detaining authority to supply copies of all the documents relied upon in the grounds of detention to the petitioner along with the grounds within 5 days of detention as petitioner has contended. In this context it would be relevant to state that the grounds were sufficiently detailed so as to enable the petitioner to make an effective representation against the detention”. He further stated that all steps were taken to comply as expeditiously as possible. It may not be necessary for the detaining authority to supply copies of all the documents relied upon in the grounds of detention at the time when the grounds are furnished to the detenu but once the detenu states that for effective representation it is necessary that he should have copies of the statements and documents referred to in the grounds of detention, it is the duty of the detaining authority to furnish them with reasonable expedition. The detaining authority cannot decline to furnish copies of the documents on the ground that the grounds were sufficiently detailed to enable the petitioner to make an effective representation. In this case, the detaining authority should have been taken reasonable steps to provide the detenu or his Advocate with the statements and documents as early as possible. The reply to the detenu was not sent by the detaining authority and it is not clear whether he appreciated the necessity to act expeditiously. As noted already, a communication was sent by the Deputy Secretary to the Deputy Director, who did not comply with the direction and furnish copies of the statements and documents. After a lapse of 12 days i.e on September 22, 1979, the Deputy Director offered inspection.

    11. Taking into account the facts and circumstances of the case and explanation furnished by the detaining authority, we are of the view that the detaining authority failed to act with reasonable expedition in furnishing the statements and documents referred to in the grounds of detention. On the facts of the case, therefore, we are satisfied that the detention is not in accordance with the procedure contemplated under law. The continued detention is not warranted. The order of his release has already been issued by this Court.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramchandra A. Kamat v. Union Of India And Others
    (Feb 20, 1980)