Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 115(7) of the States Reorganisation Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 115(7) of the States Reorganisation Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal, brought by special leave, challenges the judgment of the Punjab & Haryana High Court dated 8 September 1971. The dispute concerns the relative seniority of Inspectors who were originally serving in the erstwhile Patiala & East Punjab States Union (Pepsu) and those from the pre-existing State of Punjab following the State’s reorganisation on 1 November 1956.

Key chronological facts drawn from the opinion are:

  • 20 October 1956 – Appellants (then Sub-Inspectors) were promoted to Inspectors in Pepsu.
  • 1 November 1956 – Pepsu merged with Punjab; all Inspectors, including appellants and respondents, were integrated into a common cadre.
  • 1 March 1957 – Appellants were reverted to Sub-Inspectors.
  • 11 April 1957 – Appellants were re-promoted to Inspectors.
  • 11 March 1966 – A gradation list was published, ranking officers by seniority pursuant to the Punjab Cooperative Subordinate Service Rules, 1936 (“1936 Rules”).

The High Court upheld the gradation list, resulting in this further appeal to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after State reorganisation, the appellants could be shown as junior to the respondents on the basis of the 1936 Rules which linked seniority to the date of passing a departmental examination.
  2. Whether application of the 1936 Rules to the appellants varied their conditions of service to their disadvantage without prior approval of the Central Government, contrary to Section 115(7) of the States Reorganisation Act, 1956.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The 1936 Rules were inapplicable to Pepsu employees prior to merger; applying them post-merger unlawfully altered service conditions.
  • Section 115(7) of the States Reorganisation Act required prior Central Government approval before any such disadvantageous change, and no such approval was obtained.
  • They also claimed loss of seniority equal to the period (1 month 11 days) of their reversion in 1957.

The opinion does not detail the respondents’ specific arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
N. Raghavendra Rao v. Deputy Commissioner, South Kanara, AIR 1965 SC 136; (1964) 7 SCR 549 The Central Government memorandum dated 11 May 1957 constitutes “previous approval” under the proviso to Section 115(7) of the States Reorganisation Act. Used to hold that the Punjab Government could validly rely on the memorandum as prior approval for altering promotional criteria, including the requirement of passing a departmental examination.
Mohammad Shujat Ali v. Union of India, 1974 SCC (L&S) 454 Affirmed and applied the principle that the 11 May 1957 memorandum supplies prior approval under Section 115(7). Cited to reinforce the binding authority of Raghavendra Rao on the question of prior approval.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court rejected the appellants’ claim that their service conditions were altered without statutory approval. It reasoned as follows:

  1. The Central Government memorandum of 11 May 1957 expressly allowed State Governments to revise conditions relating to “departmental promotion,” and authorised them to assume Central Government approval for such changes.
  2. Passing the departmental examination is a condition tied to departmental promotion; hence, the Punjab Government’s insistence on applying the 1936 Rules enjoyed deemed prior approval.
  3. Raghavendra Rao conclusively held that the same memorandum satisfied Section 115(7); that ruling was reaffirmed in Mohammad Shujat Ali and is fully applicable to the present case.
  4. All respondents passed the departmental examination earlier and were confirmed earlier; therefore, under Rules 6 and 7 of the 1936 Rules, they rightly ranked senior.
  5. The appellants participated in the same examination process and suffered no legal disadvantage beyond their own later success; their contention of prejudice therefore fails.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. The Court affirmed the High Court’s decision that the appellants are junior to the respondents under the 1936 Rules.

Implications: The ruling confirms that the Central Government’s 1957 memorandum provides deemed approval for post-reorganisation alterations in promotion criteria. It reinforces the authority of Raghavendra Rao and leaves the parties to bear their own costs, establishing no new substantive precedent beyond the confirmed principle.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Bishan Chand And Others v. Sarbjit Singh And Others

    A.N Ray, C.J— This appeal is by special leave from the judgment dated September 8, 1971 of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana.

    2. The principal question raised in this appeal is whether the appellants are wrongly shown as junior to the respondents.

    3. The respondents have been treated to be senior to the appellants on the basis of the Punjab Cooperative Subordinate Service Rules, 1936 hereinafter referred to as “the 1936 Rules”. Under the 1936 Rules seniority is dependent on the passing of departmental examination. The appellants passed the departmental examination after the respondents had done so. Therefore, the appellants are treated as junior to the respondents.

    4. The appellants belonged to Pepsu Service. On October 20, 1956 the appellants had been promoted from the position of Sub-Inspectors to Inspector. On November 1, 1956 there was the reorganisation of the State of Punjab. Pepsu became merged in Punjab. The appellants became integrated with other Inspectors working in the State of Punjab.

    5. On March 1, 1957, the appellants were reverted from the position of Inspector to Sub-Inspector. On April 11, 1957, the appellants were promoted again to the position of Inspector.

    6. The appellants contend that the 1936 Rules did not apply to Pepsu before the merger, and, therefore, the conditions of service could not be varied to their disadvantage after the integration without the previous approval of the Central Government as provided by Section 115(7) of the States Reorganisation Act. The appellants also contend that they have lost one month and eleven days on account of reversion from the position of Inspector to Sub-Inspector between March 1, 1957 and April 11, 1957.

    7. The gradation list was published on March 11, 1966. The seniority list was prepared on the basis of 1936 Rules. Rule 5 of the 1936 Rules states that all candidates for the post of Inspectors and Sub-Inspectors of Cooperative Industrial Societies shall undergo such training and shall pass such examination as the Registrar may prescribe. Rule 6 of the 1936 Rules, inter alia, states that the seniority of Inspector candidates recruited from Sub-Inspectors of Cooperative Industrial Societies and Sub-Inspectors of the Punjab Cooperative Union will first be determined by the date of passing the departmental examination. If two or more candidates passed the examination on the same date, seniority will be determined by the length of service as Sub-Inspector. Rule 7 of the 1936 Rules states that the seniority of Inspectors in the fourth grade will be determined by the date of confirmation. In the third and higher grades of Inspectors, seniority will be determined by the date of confirmation in the respective grades.

    8. On November 1, 1956 the appellants as well as the respondents were all officiating Inspectors. Some of the appellants passed their departmental examination in January, 1959 and some in May, 1961. Some of the respondents passed their departmental examination in February, 1957 and the others in March, 1958. All the respondents who were shown senior to the appellants in the gradation list dated March 11, 1966 had passed their departmental examination before the appellants passed their examination.

    9. The respondents were all confirmed earlier than the appellants. The confirmation of the respondents took place before 1964. In the High Court it was conceded by the appellants that the respondents had been confirmed earlier than the appellants. The High Court found that the seniority list was prepared on this basis. In the case of confirmed Inspectors the date of confirmation gives the seniority. In the case of Inspectors who were not confirmed the date of passing the departmental examination was taken to be the basis of seniority. The position of Inspectors in the integrated seniority list of the former Punjab and Pepsu employees as on November 1, 1956 was kept intact. In the case of promoted Inspectors selected in the same batch seniority on the basis of the seniority position as Sub-Inspectors was fixed. All the respondents who were shown senior to the appellants passed their departmental examination long before the appellants did.

    10. The contention of the appellants that conditions of service have been varied to their disadvantage without the previous approval of the Central Government is utterly unsound.

    11. The Central Government on May 11, 1957 addressed a Memorandum No. S.O.SRDI-I-ARM-57 to all State Governments. Para 2 of the memorandum states that the question of protection to be afforded in the matter of various service conditions to personnel affected by reorganisation was discussed with the State representatives at conferences held with them. After careful consideration of the views expressed at these conferences, the Central Government had decided that the conditions of service in regard to substantive pay of permanent and temporary employees, special pay, leave rules, pension, provident fund and dearness allowance applicable to personnel affected by the reorganisation immediately prior to the appointed day should be protected. But so far as conditions of service in regard to travelling allowances, discipline, control, classification, appeal, conduct, probation and departmental promotion were concerned, it would not be appropriate to provide any protection in the matter of these conditions. That is stated in para 3 of the memorandum. Para 6 of the memorandum stated that in respect of conditions of service as had been specifically dealt with in the proceedings paragraphs of the memorandum, it would be open to the State Governments to take action in accordance with the decisions conveyed therein and so long as the State Governments acted in conformity with those decisions, they might assume the Central Government approval in terms of the proviso to Section 115(7) of the States Reorganisation Act. In all other cases involving conditions of service not specifically covered in the proceeding paragraphs, it would be necessary for the State Government in terms of Section 115(7) of the States Reorganisation Act before any action was taken to vary the previous conditions of service of an employee to his disadvantage. (sic)

    12. It therefore follows from paras 2, 3 and 6 of the aforesaid memorandum that as far as departmental promotion is concerned the Central Government told the State Governments that they might, if they so desired, change the conditions of service and for this purpose they might assume the previous approval of the Central Government as required by the proviso to Section 115(7) of the States Reorganisation Act.

    13. In N. Raghavendra Rao v. Deputy Commissioner South Kanara, Mangalore AIR 1965 SC 136, (1964) 7 SCR 549, (1965) 1 SCJ 327 a question arose as to whether the Mysore Government Services (Revenue Subordinate Branch) Recruitment Rules, 1959 were made with the previous approval of the Central Government under the proviso to Section 115 sub-section (7) of the States Reorganisation Act. It was held there that the memorandum of the Central Government dated May 11, 1957 amounted to previous approval within the meaning of Section 115(7) of the States Reorganisation Act. The Mysore General Services (Revenue Subordinate Branch) Recruitment Rules, 1959, were therefore held to be validly made.

    14. The decision in Raghavendra Rao case has been relied on and applied in the recent decision in Mohammad Shujat Ali v. Union of India 1974 SCC (L&S) 454.

    15. The condition of service in regard to passing of departmental examination for the purpose of promotion is, therefore, fully clothed with the previous approval of the Central Government. The appellants also appeared in the examination. They availed of the same method of promotion. They have suffered no prejudice because they passed the departmental examination later than the respondents.

    16. For these reasons, we are of opinion that there is no merit in the contention of the appellants. They have been rightly treated as junior to the respondents. That is the correct position in law as well as in the facts and circumstances of the case. In view of the fact that the parties were directed to bear their own costs throughout in the High Court we make a similar order that they will pay and bear their own costs in this appeal.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bishan Chand And Others v. Sarbjit Singh And Others
    (Aug 27, 1974)