Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 307 and 148, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 302, read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 307, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 307, read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 302, read with Section 34, Indian Penal Code
  • Sections 34 and 149, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 307, read with Section 149 and Section 147, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 302, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 307, read with Section 149 and Section 148, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 302, Section 302 read with Section 149, Section 307, Section 307 read with Section 149, Section 148 and Section 147, Indian Penal Code
  • Article 136 of the Constitution
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 307 and 148, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 302, read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 307, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 307, read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 302, read with Section 34, Indian Penal Code
  • Sections 34 and 149, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 307, read with Section 149 and Section 147, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 302, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 307, read with Section 149 and Section 148, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 302, Section 302 read with Section 149, Section 307, Section 307 read with Section 149, Section 148 and Section 147, Indian Penal Code
  • Article 136 of the Constitution
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Seven men—Arjun Singh, his son Sheoram Singh (also known as Bhure Singh), Jagatpal Singh, Ganga Deen, Ram Nath, Sheo Prasad and Jumman—were tried before the Additional Sessions Judge, Unnao, for offences under Sections 302, 307, 148, 147 and the allied provisions of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The trial court acquitted all accused on grounds that the prosecution evidence was partisan and the investigation tainted.

The State of Uttar Pradesh appealed. The Allahabad High Court reversed the acquittals, convicting:

  • Arjun Singh under Sections 302, 307/149 and 148 IPC (life imprisonment and lesser concurrent sentences);
  • Sheoram Singh under Sections 302/149, 307 and 148 IPC (life imprisonment and lesser concurrent sentences);
  • The remaining five accused under Sections 307/149 and 147 IPC (rigorous imprisonment for five and one years respectively).

Pursuant to Article 136 of the Constitution, Arjun Singh, Sheoram Singh and Jumman sought special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. Leave was refused to Arjun Singh but granted to Sheoram Singh and Jumman, limited to “the section under which they can be convicted including the applicability of Sections 34 and 149, IPC”.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction of Sheoram Singh for murder under Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC, as affirmed by the High Court, was legally sustainable.
  2. If not, whether liability for that murder could nonetheless be fastened on Sheoram Singh under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC on the ground of common intention with Arjun Singh.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments (Sheoram Singh & Jumman)

  • Conviction of Sheoram Singh under Section 302/149 IPC is unsustainable because the common object of the unlawful assembly was limited to killing Ram Dularey Singh; the death of Har Narain Singh resulted from an independent act of Arjun Singh not in furtherance of that object.
  • No challenge was pressed against (i) Jumman’s convictions under Sections 307/149 and 147 IPC, or (ii) Sheoram Singh’s convictions under Sections 307 and 148 IPC.

State’s Arguments

  • Even if Section 149 cannot apply, Sheoram Singh is liable for murder under Section 302/34 IPC because Arjun Singh’s shot at Har Narain Singh was fired in furtherance of their common intention.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court scrutinised the record and the High Court’s findings, focusing on the assembly’s common object and any shared intention between Arjun Singh and Sheoram Singh:

  • Common Object (Section 149): Evidence showed the unlawful assembly’s object was to kill Ram Dularey Singh, not Har Narain Singh. None of the accused, including Sheoram Singh, bore enmity towards Har Narain Singh. The murder resulted from an unanticipated development—Arjun Singh’s unilateral decision to fire at Har Narain Singh.
  • The High Court itself acquitted the other five co-accused of murder under Section 302/149 IPC for this very reason. The same reasoning logically extended to Sheoram Singh; therefore, maintaining his conviction on this count was inconsistent.
  • Common Intention (Section 34): The State’s fallback reliance on Section 34 IPC was rejected. The Court found:
    • No exhortation or encouragement by Sheoram Singh to shoot Har Narain Singh.
    • No material indicating that Sheoram Singh shared Arjun Singh’s intention to kill Har Narain Singh; his own shot was exclusively aimed at Ram Dularey Singh, for which he remains convicted under Section 307 IPC.
    • While common intention can evolve during an incident, cogent evidence is required, which was lacking here.

Holding and Implications

PARTLY ALLOWED — The Supreme Court set aside Sheoram Singh’s conviction and life sentence under Section 302 read with Section 149 IPC. His convictions under Sections 307 and 148 IPC were affirmed. The appeal of Jumman was dismissed in toto.

Implications: The decision reduces Sheoram Singh’s liability from murder to attempted murder and rioting but sets no new legal precedent; it applies established principles regarding vicarious liability under Sections 149 and 34 IPC to the specific facts of the case.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sheoram Singh And Another v. State Of U.P .

    H.R Khanna, J.— Arjun Singh (47), his son Sheoram Singh alias Bhure Singh (27), Jagatpal Singh (29), Ganga Deen (29), Ram Nath (39), Sheo Prasad (30) and Jumman (30) were tried in the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Unnao, for offences under Section 302, Section 302 read with Section 149, Section 307, Section 307 read with Section 149, Section 148 and Section 147, Indian Penal Code and were acquitted. On appeal by the State of Uttar Pradesh, the Allahabad High Court convicted Arjun Singh under Section 302, Section 307 read with Section 149, and Section 148, Indian Penal Code, and sentenced him to undergo imprisonment for life on the first count, rigorous imprisonment for a period of five years on the second count and rigorous imprisonment for a period of two years on the third count. Sheoram Singh was convicted under Section 302 read with Section 149, Section 307 and Section 148, Indian Penal Code, and was sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life on the first count, rigorous imprisonment for a period of five years on the second count and rigorous imprisonment for a period of two years on the third count. The remaining accused were convicted under Section 307 read with Section 149, and Section 147, Indian Penal Code, and each of them was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of five years on the first count and rigorous imprisonment for a period of one year on the second count. The sentences in the case of each of the accused were ordered to run concurrently. Arjun Singh, Sheoram Singh and Jumman thereafter applied to this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution for special leave to appeal against the judgment of the High Court. This Court declined to grant leave to Arjun Singh and dismissed the application insofar as it related to him. Sheoram Singh and Jumman were granted leave “limited to the section under which they can be convicted including the applicability of Sections 34 and 149, Indian Penal Code”.

    2. The prosecution case is that Arjun Singh, Jumman, Ganga Deen and Sheo Prasad accused were inimical towards Ram Dularey Singh as he was taking interest in a magisterial enquiry relating to the death in police custody of one Jameel who had been severely beaten by the aforesaid accused in Sirosi before his arrest by the police. On November 4, 1964, at about 4.30 p.m, it is stated, Dularey Singh (PW 4) was sitting in front of his house in village Chilaula. Rampal Singh (PW 1) and his cousin Chandrapal Singh were sitting in the courtyard in front of their house beneath a tree. The houses of Rampal Singh and Ram Dularey Singh are close to each other. The seven accused then came there. Out of them, Arjun Singh and Sheoram Singh were armed with guns, while the remaining accused carried lathis. Arjun Singh then shouted to his companions to kill Ram Dularey Singh. Ram Dularey Singh raised alarm and rushed towards the house of Rampal Singh and closed the door from inside. Rampal Singh and Chandrapal Singh tried to pacify the accused and asked them not to quarrel on that day as it was a day of Paraiva which follows Deepawali. The accused then stood at a short distance from the house of Ram Dularey Singh. Har Narain Singh deceased, who was brother of Chandrapal Singh, was inside the house at that time. Har Narain Singh along with Ram Dularey Singh then went to the eastern roof of the house. Har Narain Singh too asked the accused to abstain from abusing Ram Dularey Singh. Arjun Singh then asked Har Narain Singh to turn out Ram Dularey Singh from his house. When Har Narain Singh declined, Arjun Singh shouted that it would be bad for him also. On the instigation of the other accused, Arjun Singh then fired his gun at Har Narain Singh. Sheoram Singh immediately thereafter fired at Ram Dularey Singh. Both Har Narain Singh and Ram Dularey Singh fell down on the roof on receipt of gun shot injuries. The accused then ran away. The occurrence, it is stated, was witnessed by Rampal Singh (PW 1), Raghunandan Pandey (PW 2), Gajodhar Singh (PW 6) and Suraj Bali (PW 8). Rampal Singh after getting the door of his house opened went to the roof. Har Narain Singh was found to be lying dead there, while Ram Dularey Singh was groaning with pain. Rampal Singh then went to police station Kotwali at a distance of six miles from the place of occurrence and lodged report at 8.40 p.m Sub-Inspector Sri Ram Bau Chauhan then came to the place of occurrence and took over the investigation of the case. The Sub-Inspector prepared the inquest report relating to the dead body of Har Narain Singh and took into possession various articles. Ram Dularey Singh was got examined from Dr S.N Tandon at 12.15 a.m on November 5, 1964. He was found to have gun shot wounds on the front of the chest, abdomen, right elbow, right forearm and the right palm. Post-mortem examination on the dead body of Har Narain Singh was performed by Dr B.N De at 3.30 p.m on November 5, 1964. Gun shot wounds were found in the chest cavity, left shoulder, lower left arm and right arm on the body of Har Narain Singh. A number of ribs were found to have been fractured under the gun shot wounds in the chest cavity. Death of Har Narain Singh, in the opinion of the doctor, was due to shock and haemorrhage.

    3. At the trial the accused denied the prosecution allegations. The plea of Arjun Singh and Sheoram Singh was that on November 4, 1964, Arjun Singh went at 2.00 or 2.45 p.m to railway station Magarwara to see off his son Sheoram Singh accused, who had to go to Ferozepur on duty. Sheoram Singh is employed in the army. Sheoram Singh's train left the railway station at 4.10 p.m and Arjun Singh returned to his house at about sunset. According further to Arjun Singh, he was asked by the police to come to the police station along with his guns and cartridges. He was thereafter put under arrest. The plea of the remaining accused was denial simpliciter.

    4. The Additional Sessions Judge acquitted the accused because he was of the view that the evidence adduced by the prosecution was of a partisan character. It was also held that the investigation of the case was tainted. On appeal the High Court considered the evidence of Rampal Singh (PW 1), Ram Dularey Singh (PW 4) and Gajodhar Singh (PW 6) to be free from blemish. The ocular evidence adduced by the prosecution was accepted. The High Court, however, found the evidence regarding the exhortation by the other accused to Arjun Singh to kill Har Narain Singh and Ram Dularey Singh to be not very convincing. It was held by the High Court that the death of Har Narain Singh took place as a result of firing by Arjun Singh. Arjun Singh was convicted under Section 302, Indian Penal Code. He was also found to be guilty of the offences under Section 307, read with Section 149 and Section 148, Indian Penal Code. Sheoram Singh, who was alleged to have injured Ram Dularey Singh, PW by firing a shot at him, was convicted on that account under Section 307, Indian Penal Code. Sheoram Singh was further convicted under Section 302, read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code in connection with the death of Har Narain Singh and also under Section 148, Indian Penal Code for the offence of rioting with deadly weapon. Regarding the other accused, the High Court was of the view that they were guilty under Section 147, Indian Penal Code for the offence of rioting while being members of an unlawful assembly. Their common object, in the opinion of the High Court, was to kill Ram Dularey Singh. As such, they were also found to be guilty of the offence under Section 307, read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code. It was not the object of the unlawful assembly, in the opinion of the High Court, to cause the death of Har Narain Singh. The case under Section 302, read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code against those accused was held to have not been proved.

    5. Mr Goyal on behalf of the appellants has not challenged before us the conviction of Jumman appellant for the offences under Section 307, read with Section 149 and Section 147, Indian Penal Code. Learned counsel has further not challenged the conviction of Sheoram Singh appellant for offences under Sections 307 and 148, Indian Penal Code. The only contention which has been advanced by Mr Goyal before us is that the conviction of Sheoram Singh appellant for the offence under Section 302, read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code is not well founded. There is, in our opinion, considerable force in this contention. It would appear from the resume of facts given above that the common object of the unlawful assembly, of which Sheoram Singh and other accused were members, was to cause the death of Ram Dularey Singh. None of them had any enmity with Har Narain Singh or any motive to kill him. Har Narain Singh, no doubt, was killed as a result of the shot fired by Arjun Singh, but there is nothing on the record to show that Arjun Singh fired the shot at Har Narain Singh in prosecution of the common object of the unlawful assembly. The High Court has acquitted the accused, other than Arjun Singh and Sheoram Singh, for the offence under Section 302 read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code on the ground that the murder of Har Narain Singh was not the initial object of the unlawful assembly and the firing at him was the result of developments which could not have been anticipated. If the other five accused were acquitted and not found guilty of the offence under Section 302, read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code in connection with the death of Har Narain Singh, it is not clear as to how the conviction of Sheoram Singh for the said offence could be sustained. The reasons which led to the acquittal of the other five accused for the offence under Section 302, read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code held equally good for the acquittal for that offence of Sheoram Singh.

    6. Mr Uniyal on behalf of the State has argued that even if the connection of Sheoram Singh for the offence under Section 302, read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code cannot be sustained, he is guilty of the offence under Section 302, read with Section 34, Indian Penal Code because the circumstances of the case show that Arjun Singh fired the shot at Har Narain Singh in furtherance of the common intention of Arjun Singh and Sheoram Singh. This submission, in our opinion, is not well founded. There is nothing to show that there was any exhortation by Sheoram Singh to Arjun Singh to fire at Har Narain Singh. Indeed, the High Court has not accepted the evidence of exhortation to Arjun Singh by any of the other accused before Arjun Singh fired at Har Narain Singh. The prosecution has, no doubt, led evidence to show that Arjun Singh before firing the shot at Har Narain Singh told him that if he did not turn out Ram Dularey Singh from his house, it would be bad for him (Har Narain Singh) also. These words, undoubtedly, indicate the attitude of Arjun Singh and show that he was not willing to spare Har Narain Singh if the latter was not prepared to turn out from his house Ram Dularey Singh. It is, however, difficult to infer from that exclamation of Arjun Singh that Sheoram Singh shared the intention of Arjun Singh and that the shot was fired by Arjun Singh at Har Narain Singh in furtherance of the common intention of Arjun Singh and Sheoram Singh. There is, indeed, nothing on the record to indicate that Sheoram Singh in any way encouraged his father, Arjun Singh, to kill Har Narain Singh. Sheoram Singh, no doubt, fired a shot at Ram Dularey Singh and for that he has been convicted under Section 307, Indian Penal Code, but it does not follow from that that the shot at Har Narain Singh by Arjun Singh was also fired in furtherance of the intention of Sheoram Singh. It is undeniable that common intention can develop during the course of an occurrence, but there has to be cogent material on the basis of which the court can arrive at that finding and hold an accused vicariously liable for the act of the other accused by invoking Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code.

    7. As a result of the above, we accept the appeal of Sheoram Singh to the extent of setting aside his conviction and sentence for the offence under Section 302, read with Section 149, Indian Penal Code. In other respects the appeal of Sheoram Singh is dismissed. The appeal regarding Jumman has not been pressed and is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sheoram Singh And Another v. State Of U.P .
    (Aug 23, 1972)