AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 12(4) of the Cinematograph Act, 1952
  • Article 133(1) of the Constitution
  • The Act under the above notification
  • Article 226 of the Constitution
  • Section 12(4) of the Act, States Reorganisation Act, 1956
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 12(4) of the Cinematograph Act, 1952
  • Article 133(1) of the Constitution
  • The Act under the above notification
  • Article 226 of the Constitution
  • Section 12(4) of the Act, States Reorganisation Act, 1956
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, a cinema exhibitor operating “Royal Talkies” in Beawar, held licences under the Cinematograph Act, 1952. Acting under Section 12(4) of the Act, the Chief Commissioner of Ajmer issued a notification dated 23-11-1954 requiring exhibitors to screen certain “approved” films (largely educational, scientific, news, or documentary in nature) in a fixed proportion to commercial films. The notification took effect on 1-12-1954 and was incorporated verbatim as Condition 22 in the respondent’s renewed licence; another clause, Condition 15, required free exhibition of government-supplied films.

On 25-7-1956 the Films Division demanded Rs 274/1 from the respondent for approved films supplied between 3-3-1956 and 5-8-1956, threatening to withhold future supplies and to cancel the licence upon non-payment. Contending that the demand lacked contractual basis and challenging the legality of the licence conditions, the respondent filed a writ petition under Article 226 before the Judicial Commissioner, Ajmer. After State re-organisation, the case was heard by the Rajasthan High Court, which on 14-5-1958 upheld Section 12(4) itself but struck down Conditions 15 and 22 as ultra vires the section. The State obtained a certificate under Article 133(1) and appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the notification dated 23-11-1954—and consequently Licence Condition 22—was authorised by Section 12(4) of the Cinematograph Act, 1952.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (State) Arguments

  • Accepted the High Court’s decision that Condition 15 was invalid, limiting the appeal solely to Condition 22.
  • Contended that Section 12(4) empowered the Central Government to ensure “adequate opportunity” for cultural and indigenous films; therefore, specifying that approved cultural films be “produced in India” fell squarely within the statutory remit.
  • Argued that the High Court erred in reading the two categories listed in Section 12(4)—(a) cultural films and (b) indigenous films—as mutually exclusive.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the text of Section 12(4), which lists two categories: (1) scientific, educational, news, current-events and documentary (“cultural”) films, and (2) “indigenous films.” The High Court had treated these as alternatives, concluding that adding the requirement “produced in India” to cultural films was an impermissible restriction.

Justice Venkatarama Aiyar rejected that interpretation:

  • The phrase “indigenous films” is broad and unqualified, naturally encompassing cultural as well as other films. Reading it as “indigenous films other than cultural films” would add words not used by Parliament.
  • Legislative policy plainly aims to encourage both cultural and indigenous films; an indigenous film may also be cultural. Hence the two categories are not mutually exclusive.
  • Consequently, the words “produced in India” in the notification and in Condition 22 are properly referable to the second statutory category (indigenous films) and are intra vires Section 12(4).

Because Condition 22 merely implements a valid notification, it too is valid.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed in Part; Condition 22 upheld, Condition 15 remains invalid.

The Supreme Court modified the High Court’s order, declaring the 23-11-1954 notification and Licence Condition 22 intra vires Section 12(4). The respondent’s licence therefore continues to be subject to the requirement that approved, India-produced cultural films be screened in the prescribed proportion. No costs were awarded. The decision clarifies the scope of Section 12(4) but sets no new precedent beyond affirming the government’s statutory power to mandate exhibition of indigenous cultural films.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Chief Commissioner, Ajmer (Now The State Of Rajasthan) And Another v. Brijniwas Das .

    Venkatarama aiyar, J.— This is an appeal against the judgment of the High Court of Rajasthan, on a certificate granted by that Court under Article 133(1) of the Constitution. The respondent carries on the business of exhibiting films in premises called the Royal Talkies at Beawar under licences granted by the appropriate authorities under the Cinematograph Act, 1952 (37 of 1952) hereinafter referred to as “the Act”. Acting in exercise of the powers conferred by Section 12(4) of the Act, the Chief Commissioner of Ajmer issued on 23-11-1954, a notification which, omitting what is not material, is as follows:

    “(1) The licensee shall so regulate the exhibition of cinematograph films that at every performance open to the public, approved films are exhibited, the approved films to be exhibited in relation to other films at every such performance being in the same proportion as one is to five or the nearest lower or higher approximation thereto.
    (2) Only such films produced in India as are certified by the Central Government with the previous approval of the Film Advisory Board, Bombay, to be scientific films, films intended for education purposes, films dealing with news, current events or documentary films shall be deemed to be approved films for the purposes of these directions.”
    This notification came into force on 1-12-1954. On 24-11-1955 the District Magistrate of Ajmer being the licensing authority under the Act sent to the respondent a statement of conditions of licence revised in accordance with the above notification. We are concerned in this appeal with two of them Conditions 15 and 22. They are, so far as they are material, as follows:
    “15. The licensee shall, when and so often as the Chief Commissioner may require, exhibit free of charge or on such terms as regards remuneration as the Chief Commissioner may determine, films and lantern slides provided by the Chief Commissioner:
    Provided that the licensee shall not be required to exhibit at one entertainment films or lantern slides the exhibition of which will take more than fifteen minutes in all or to exhibit film or slides unless they are delivered to him at least twenty-four hours before the entertainment at which they are to be shown is due to begin.
    22. (a) The licensee shall so regulate the exhibition of cinematograph films that at every performance open to the public, approved films are exhibited, the approved films to be exhibited in relation to other films at every such performance being in the same proportion as one is to five or the nearest lower or higher approximation thereto.
    (b) Only such films produced in India as are certified by the Central Government with the previous approval of the Film Advisory Board, Bombay, to be scientific films, films intended for education purposes, films dealing with news, current events or documentary films shall be deemed to be approved films for the purposes of these directions.”

    2. On 25-7-1956 the Films Division, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India, made a demand on the respondent for a sum of Rs 274/1 on account of supplies of approved films made to him during the period 3-3-1956 to 5-8-1956 and further informed him that if the above demand was not complied with, further supplies of approved films would be stopped. The respondent disputed his liability to pay the amount on the ground that the supply was made not in pursuance of any contract entered into by him but voluntarily by the Government. A correspondence then followed and eventually the respondent was told that if the amount was not paid as demanded, further supplies of approved films would be stopped and the licence cancelled. Thereupon he filed the writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution, out of which this present appeal arises, in the Court of the Judicial Commissioner, Ajmer, challenging the vires of Section 12(4) of the Act, the notification dated 23-11-1954 issued thereunder and Conditions 15 and 22 inserted in the licence in accordance therewith. The petition was heard by a Bench of the High Court of Rajasthan to which it stood transferred under the provisions of the States Reorganisation Act, 1956, and by their judgment dated 14-5-1958 the learned Judges sustained the validity of Section 12(4) but struck down the impugned Conditions 15 and 22 as not authorised by Section 12(4) of the Act. It is against this judgment that the present appeal, on certificate, has been preferred by the Government.

    3. Before us the learned Additional Solicitor-General who appeared for the appellant did not contest the correctness of the decision of the High Court insofar as it held that Condition 15 was not valid, but he contended that the learned Judges were not right in holding that Condition 22 was not authorised by Section 12(4) of the Act. The sole point for determination in this appeal is therefore whether the notification dated 23-11-1954 is within the terms of Section 12(4). If it is, then Condition 22 which gives effect to it is valid. If not, both the notification and the condition must be struck down as ultra vires.

    4. Section 12(4) of the Act runs as follows:

    “The Central Government may, from time to time, issue directions to licensees generally or to any licensee in particular for the purpose of regulating the exhibition of any film or class of films, so that scientific films, films intended for educational purposes, films dealing with news and current events, documentary films or indigenous films secure an adequate opportunity of being exhibited, and where any such directions have been issued those directions shall be deemed to be additional conditions and restrictions subject to which the licence haw been granted.”
    It will be seen that the enactment comprises two categories of films, one consisting of scientific films, films intended for educational purposes, films dealing with news and current events and documentary films or what for conciseness may be called “cultural films”, and the other, of “indigenous films”. The learned Judges of the High Court were of the opinion that these two categories were alternative as indicated by the disjunctive “or” and consequently the provision that cultural films should have been produced in India was to introduce a restriction in Category 1 which is not authorised by the statute, and that in consequence the words “produced in India” in Condition 22 were unauthorised and ultra vires.

    5. This view does not commend itself to us. It is true that the enactment classifies films into two categories but we do not read them as mutually exclusive. The words “indigenous films” are general and unqualified in their contents, and must include in their ordinary and accepted sense cultural as well as other films. If the two categories of films are to be construed as mutually exclusive, then we must read the words “indigenous films” as meaning “indigenous films other than cultural films”. That would be to cut down the plain and ordinary sense of the words, and to import into the enactment words which are not there. Such a construction must, if that is possible, be avoided. We must proceed on the basis that the legislature meant precisely what it said.

    6. This conclusion is further reinforced when regard is had to the policy underlying the enactment, which is to encourage exhibition of two classess of films (1) cultural, and (2) indigenous, and so far as indigenous films are concerned they may be cultural film or they may not be. In this view the words “produced in India” in the impugned notification, and Condition 22 are not to be read as a qualification annexed to the first category of films, but as referable to the second category, and would be perfectly intra vires under Section 12(4). We must accordingly hold that the notification dated 23-11-1954 insofar as it requires that cultural films should have been produced in India is within Section 12(4) and Condition 22 which has been framed in accordance therewith is valid. The order of the court below will be modified to this extent. As the respondent does not appear, there will be no order as to costs in this Court.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chief Commissioner, Ajmer (Now The State Of Rajasthan) And Another v. Brijniwas Das .
    (Apr 17, 1962)