Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The challenge arises from the judgment dated May 1, 1999, of the Board of Revenue, which held that if during the pendency of a revenue suit a sale deed of the land is executed, it is governed by the doctrine of lis pendens and it is unnecessary to set aside the sale deed through a Civil Court. The case originated when Smt. Sobhag Devi (plaintiff) filed a suit for declaration, injunction, and possession against Prem Devi (defendant No. 1) in the Court of Assistant Collector Dudu. The suit concerned agricultural land jointly held by Padam Chand and Paras Mal, with Prem Devi's name substituted in the revenue record after Padam Chand's death. The plaintiff claimed entitlement to an equal share under the Hindu Succession Act as the mother of Prem Chand.

On November 26, 1990, the plaintiff filed an application under Order 1, Rule 10 read with Order 6, Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code to implead the purchasers of the land, Paras Mal and Pawan Kumar, who had acquired Prem Devi’s share by a sale deed dated October 15, 1990. The purchasers contended that the sale deed was valid and that relief could not be granted by the Revenue Court unless the sale deed was cancelled by a Civil Court. Ten issues were framed based on the pleadings, including whether the Revenue Court had jurisdiction to try the suit.

The Assistant Collector decided in favor of the plaintiff on the jurisdictional issue by an order dated January 17, 1998. This order was challenged by defendant Paras Mal before the Board of Revenue, which dismissed the revision petition on May 1, 1999. The defendants Nos. 2 and 3 then preferred the instant writ petition challenging the Board’s judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the doctrine of lis pendens applies to a sale deed executed during the pendency of a revenue suit, rendering the sale deed ineffective without the necessity of cancellation by a Civil Court.
  2. Whether the Revenue Court has jurisdiction to try a suit concerning title and possession of land when a sale deed has been executed during the pendency of the suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendants' Arguments

  • The sale deed executed by Prem Devi in favor of Paras Mal and Pawan Kumar was valid.
  • Until the sale deed is cancelled by a Civil Court, no relief could be granted by the Revenue Court.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The sale deed executed during the pendency of the suit is hit by the doctrine of lis pendens and is therefore ineffective.
  • It is unnecessary to seek cancellation of the sale deed separately in a Civil Court.
  • The Revenue Court has jurisdiction to try the suit based on these grounds.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sayar Bai v. Yashoda Bai (AIR 1983 Rajasthan 161) Doctrine of lis pendens prevents parties from circumventing court jurisdiction by alienating property during pendency of litigation. The Court relied on this precedent to emphasize that the sale deed executed during the pendency of the suit is ineffective against the litigation and protects the parties from alienations that frustrate the court's power.
Jaswant Singh v. Board of Revenue (1984 Raj LW 573) When a suit challenges possession treating a deed as void, a separate prayer for cancellation of the deed is unnecessary. The Court applied this principle to hold that the plaintiff need not file a separate suit for cancellation of the sale deed to challenge its validity during the pendency of the revenue suit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, which embodies the maxim "pendente lite nihil innovetur"—no change should be introduced during the pendency of litigation. The section defines “pendency” broadly, covering the entire period from filing to final satisfaction of the decree. The Court noted that Section 52 does not require notice of the pending suit to the purchaser; rather, it is the vendor's duty to inform the purchaser. The purpose is to protect the parties to litigation from alienations that could frustrate the suit’s outcome.

Relying on the precedent from Sayar Bai v. Yashoda Bai, the Court underscored that the doctrine of lis pendens strikes at attempts to circumvent court jurisdiction through private dealings. The sale deed executed by defendant No. 1 during the pendency of the suit was a deliberate attempt to circumvent the Revenue Court's jurisdiction. Following Jaswant Singh v. Board of Revenue, the Court held that since the suit treats the sale deed as void, no separate cancellation suit is needed. Consequently, the Revenue Court was competent to try the suit, and the sale deed was ineffective during the pendency of the litigation.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition challenging the judgment of the Board of Revenue dated May 1, 1999, is dismissed.

The Court upheld the Board of Revenue’s decision that the doctrine of lis pendens applies to sale deeds executed during the pendency of a revenue suit, rendering such deeds ineffective without requiring cancellation in Civil Court. The Revenue Court has jurisdiction to try the suit under these circumstances. The decision directly affects the parties by confirming the invalidity of the sale deed executed during litigation, but it does not establish any new legal precedent beyond the application of established principles.

    Paras Mal & Anr. v. Ms. Sobhag Devi & Ors.

    1. Challenge in this writ petition is to the judgment dated May 1, 1999 of the Board of Revenue whereby it was held that if during the pendency of revenue suit, sale deed of the land is executed it is hit by the doctrine of lis pendens and it is not necessary to get the sale deed set aside by Civil Court.

    2. Contextual facts depict that Smt. Sobhag Devi (plaintiff) filed a suit for declaration, injunction and possession initially against Prem Devi (defendant No. 1) in the Court of Assistant Collector Dudu with the averments that the agricultural land bearing khasra No. 1225 measuring 4 bighas 6 biswas and khasra No. 1232 measuring 4 bighas 14 biswas situated in village Dudu was in joint khatedari of Padam Chand and Paras Mal. After the death of Padam Chand name of his wife Prem Devi (defendant No. 1 was substituted in revenue record. The plaintiff claimed in the suit that being the mother of Prem Chand she was also entitled to equal share as per the provisions of Hindu Succession Act.

    3. On or about November 26, 1990 the plaintiff moved an application under Order 1, Rule 10 read with Order 6, Rule 17 Civil Procedure Code, wherein it was stated that Prem Devi executed sale deed on October 15, 1990 whereby she sold her share in the aforesaid agricultural land to Paras Mal and Pawan Kumar. The plaintiff sought impleadment of the purchasers of the land. The purchasers were impleaded as defendants and they filed written statement stating therein that sale deed was rightly executed and until and unless the sale deed was cancelled by the Civil Court no relief could be granted by Revenue Court. On the basis of pleadings of parties as many as 10 issues were framed, out which issue No. 9 was as under:—

    “Whether the revenue Court has jurisdiction to try the suit?”

    4. The Assistant Collector, Dudu decided issue No. 9 as preliminary issue vide order dated January 17, 1998 in favour of the plaintiff holding that revenue Court had jurisdiction to hear the suit. The order of Assistant Collector was assailed by defendant Paras Mal before the Board of Revenue by filing revision petition that was dismissed on May 1, 1999. It is against the judgment of the Board of Revenue that the instant writ petition has been preferred by defendant Nos. 2 & 3.

    5. I have heard the submissions and scanned the material on record.

    6. Section 52 of Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is expression of the principle of the maxim “pendente lite nihil innovetur” (pending a litigation nothing new should be introduced). “Pendency of any suit” occurring in Section 52 is defined under the explanation to the section as including the time of the presentation of the suit and extending up to the time when the final decree or order is passed therein and even to the time when the decree or order is completely satisfied or discharged. Section 52 does not envisage any notice of the pending proceedings to the subsequent purchaser. It is the duty of the vendor to inform the intending purchaser about the pendency. Section 52 intended to protect the parties to litigation against alienations by their opponents during the pendency of the suit.

    7. In Sayar Bai v. Yashoda Bai (AIR 1983 Rajasthan 161) this Court indicated as under:—

    “As a matter of fact, the doctrine of lis pendens is intended to strike at attempts by parties to a litigation to circumvent the jurisdiction of the Court when a dispute in respect of any right or interest in immovable property is pending. A party to the litigation cannot by private dealings remove the subject-matter of litigation from the ambit of the Court's power to decide a pending dispute or to frustrate the decree that may be passed in the suit. It could be effective against such third parties who are dealing with parties to the pending litigation.”

    8. In Jaswant Singh v. Board of Revenue (1984 Raj LW 573) it was indicated that if the suit was filed by the plaintiff for possession treating the deed as wholly void or a nullity then a prayer for cancellation of the deed was unnecessary and was not required to be made by the plaintiff, who could ignore the void document.

    9. In the instant case, the defendant No. 1 in making attempt to circumvent the jurisdiction of the revenue Court deliberately executed the sale deed. Therefore in view of the principle of lis pendens, the transfer was nullity and it was not necessary for the plaintiff to seek relief of cancellation of sale deed I by filing a suit in Civil Court. The Revenue I Court thus is competent to try the suit.

    10. For these reasons, I do not see any illegality in the impugned judgment of the Board of Revenue. The writ petition being devoid of merit stands dismissed without any order as to costs.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Paras Mal & Anr. v. Ms. Sobhag Devi & Ors.
    (Dec 14, 2006)