Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of sec. 13 and 37 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955,
  • TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • INDIAN REGISTRATION ACT
  • sec. 17(1)(b) of the Indian Registration Act,
  • sec. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act.
  • sec. 17 of the Indian Registration Act,
  • sec. 37 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act.
  • Order 21, Rule 103 C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 63 C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 58 C.P.C
  • Order 51, Rule 63 C.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of sec. 13 and 37 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955,
  • TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • INDIAN REGISTRATION ACT
  • sec. 17(1)(b) of the Indian Registration Act,
  • sec. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act.
  • sec. 17 of the Indian Registration Act,
  • sec. 37 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act.
  • Order 21, Rule 103 C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 63 C.P.C
  • Order 21, Rule 58 C.P.C
  • Order 51, Rule 63 C.P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a suit filed by decree-holders Govind Singh, Nahar Singh, and Bhagwat Singh, sons of Ugrasingh, who was the Jagirdar of Thikana Agria. Moti Lal and Kesrimal, holding a decree against Shri Ugra Singhji for Rs. 24,081/- from 1950, executed their decree by attaching disputed lands. The plaintiffs objected under Order 21, Rule 58 C.P.C, but their objection was dismissed. Subsequently, they filed a suit for declaration of ownership over the disputed lands based on two unregistered pattas dated October 26, 1948, granting Bapadari rights to Bhagwat Singh and Mst. Ranawatji, the Jagirdar’s second wife. The trial court dismissed the suit, finding the pattas were granted to defraud creditors but acknowledged the applicability of Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act. On appeal, the District Judge reversed the dismissal, holding the lands were not liable for execution under Sections 13 and 37 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955, and that the pattas were bona fide transfers with consideration. The question of registration and applicability of Section 53-A was not decided. The decree-holders then filed this Second Appeal. During the appeal, Ugrasingh died and his legal representatives were brought on record.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the pattas dated 1948 transferring Bapadari rights were required to be registered under the Indian Registration Act as adapted by the United State of Rajasthan Ordinance No. 1 of 1948.
  2. Whether the plaintiffs could invoke the doctrine of part performance under Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act to protect their rights over the disputed land despite the pattas being unregistered.
  3. Whether the plaintiffs' suit seeking declaration of title could succeed given the pattas were allegedly executed to defraud creditors.
  4. Whether the lands were liable to attachment and sale in execution of the decree under the provisions of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955.
  5. Whether the plaintiffs could raise for the first time in the Second Appeal the claim of khatedari rights in the disputed land.
  6. Whether the lands vested in the plaintiffs upon the death of Shri Ugrasingh and were protected from attachment under Section 37 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The pattas were executed after the United State of Rajasthan Ordinance No. 1 of 1948, which applied the Indian Registration Act with adaptations, requiring registration of such documents transferring immovable property of value Rs. 100 or more.
  • The pattas should have been registered under Section 17 of the Indian Registration Act.

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • Despite the pattas being unregistered, having paid the consideration, they acquired rights under the doctrine of part performance as embodied in Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act.
  • They relied on precedents supporting the view that a transferee can invoke Section 53-A even as a plaintiff in a suit under Order 21, Rule 63 C.P.C.
  • They claimed title based on the pattas and also raised a claim of khatedari rights (though this was not pleaded initially).
  • They contended that the lands vested in them upon the death of Shri Ugrasingh and thus were not attachable under Section 37 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ariff v. Jadunath (Privy Council) Rejection of English law principle of part performance in Indian context, leading to enactment of Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act. Supported the statutory framework of Section 53-A limiting the doctrine of part performance.
Ewaz Ali v. Mst. Firdous Jehan & Co. Doctrine of part performance under Section 53-A applicable to transferee defending possession under Order 21, Rule 103 C.P.C. Used to argue that plaintiffs could invoke Section 53-A when defending possession.
Gulab Chand Subh Karan v. Madholal Sadha Suit under Order 21, Rule 63 C.P.C is a defensive proceeding and allows invocation of Section 53-A. Supported the plaintiffs’ position that Section 53-A could be invoked in such suits.
Yenugu Achayya v. Ernaki Venkata Subba Rao & Co. Section 53-A protection is available to transferee both as plaintiff and defendant, as a shield but not a sword. Clarified that the transferee can resist transferor’s claims regardless of party status.
Padmalabha Panda v. Appalanarasamma (Orissa High Court) Section 53-A should not be extended to allow plaintiffs in suits under Order 21, Rule 63 C.P.C to claim its benefit. Supported the view that plaintiffs cannot invoke Section 53-A in such suits; the attaching creditor is not legal representative of judgment-debtor.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the applicability of the Indian Registration Act as adapted by the United State of Rajasthan Ordinance, concluding that the pattas, transferring Bapadari rights with consideration over Rs. 100, were required to be registered under Section 17(1)(b) of the Indian Registration Act. The unregistered pattas were thus invalid for the purpose of proving title.

Regarding Section 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act, the Court examined the doctrine of part performance and its statutory embodiment. It recognized that Section 53-A bars the transferor or persons claiming under him from enforcing rights against a transferee who has taken possession with consideration, but emphasized that this protection is primarily defensive and available to defendants, not plaintiffs seeking declaratory relief.

The Court reviewed conflicting case law and found the view of the Orissa High Court in Padmalabha Panda persuasive, holding that plaintiffs in a suit under Order 21, Rule 63 C.P.C cannot invoke Section 53-A as a shield. The Court reasoned that the plaintiffs were essentially seeking to establish title rather than defending possession, and thus could not benefit from Section 53-A.

The Court further held that the plaintiffs’ claim of khatedari rights was not pleaded and could not be raised for the first time in the Second Appeal. It also found that the question of attachment under Section 37 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act was improperly decided by the lower appellate court and should be left to the executing court to decide if properly raised.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed. The judgment and decree of the District Judge, Udaipur dated 18th July 1957 are set aside, and the plaintiffs' suit is dismissed with costs in all three courts.

The direct effect of this decision is that the plaintiffs fail to establish title over the disputed lands due to the unregistered pattas and inability to invoke Section 53-A as plaintiffs. No new precedent is set beyond affirming the limited scope of Section 53-A and the registration requirement. The question of attachment under the Rajasthan Tenancy Act remains open for determination by the executing court.

    Motilal v. Jaswant Singh

    Bhandari, J.:— This is Civil Second Appeal in a suit under Order 51, Rule 63 C.P.C filed by the decree-holders Govind Singh and Nahar Singh and Bhagwat Singh, sons of Ugrasingh, who was the Jagirdar of Thikana Agria in Tehsil Amet. Moti Lal and Kesrimal (Defendants Nos. 1 and 2) had a decree against Shri Ugra Singhji, the amount of which had accumulated to the tune of Rs. 24,081/- in the year 1950. They put their decree in execution and attached disputed lands described in the list attached to the plaint. Thereupon, the plaintiffs filed an objection under Order 21, Rule 58 C.P.C which was dismissed on the 19th of April, 1955. The plaintiffs then brought the suit for declaration that the disputed land belonged to them on the 19th of May, 1955 in the court of the Civil Judge, Udaipur. The plaintiffs based their claim on two pattas both dated Kartik Badi 9, Sambat 2005 corresponding to the 26th of October, 1948. These pattas are Exhibits 11 and 12 on the record and that both the documents are un-registered. Under Ex. 11 Bapadari rights in the land measuring 170 Bighas-6 Biswas were granted to Bhagwat Singh (Plaintiff No. 3) in payment of Rs. 401/- while under Ex. 12 Bapadari rights in the land 169 Bighas-8 Biswas were granted in favour of Mst. Ranawatji, the second wife of the said Jagirdar in consideration of Rs. 301/-. It may be mentioned that all the plaintiffs are the sons of Chhoti Ranawatji who died sometime after the grant of the said patta. The plaintiffs stated in the plaint that though both the pattas were un-registered, yet by application of the doctrine of part performance as enunciated in sec. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act, they had acquired right, title and interest in the said land as mentioned in the said pattas.

    2. The decree-holders contested the suit and denied that any patta was granted by Shri Ugrasinghji either to Shri Bhagwatsinghji or to Chhoti Ranawatji. The suit was also contested on the ground that the aforesaid pattas were made in order to defeat and defraud the creditors by the said judgmentdebtor. The trial court held that the plaintiffs could take advantage of sec. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act but as in this case, the pattas were granted to defeat and defraud the creditors, the suit could not be decreed. With this finding the suit was dismissed. The plaintiffs filed an appeal before the District Judge, Udaipur. The learned District Judge took the view that because of the provisions of sec. 13 and 37 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955, the lands were not liable to be sold in execution of the decree. He also held that the pattas granted were bonafide transfers with consideration. He decreed the suit. He, however, did not decide the question whether the pattas were required to be registered or not and whether the plaintiffs were entitled to take advantage of sec. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act. The decree holders have come in the Second Appeal to this Court. During the pendency of the appeal, Ugrasingh died and his legal representatives have been brought on record.

    3. It is urged on behalf of the appellants that the aforesaid two pattas (Exhibits 11 and 12) were executed on the 27th of September, 1948 after the coming into force of the United State of Rajasthan Ordinance No. 1 of 1948 (hereinafter called “the Ordinance”). The Ordinance applied to the whole of the United State of Rajasthan, the provisions of the Indian Registration Act with such adaptation as are mentioned in the schedule and under sec. 17 of the Indian Registration Act, the pattas should have been registered.

    4. In my opinion, this contention is sound as under sec. 17(1)(b) of the Indian Registration Act, the documents which transfer any right, title or interest of the value of Rs. 100/- or upwards and immovable are to be registered. In this case consideration for each of these two documents was more than Rs. 100/-. Certain rights in the land called ‘Bapadari’ rights were transferred by these two documents. Both of these pattas ought to have been registered.

    5. It is however, urged on behalf of the plaintiffs that as they had paid the consideration for the pattas, under sec. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act, they could protect their rights over the land in dispute against the attaching decree-holder who must be taken to the legal representative of the judgment-debtor.

    6. In English law, the principle of part performance is available to either party to the suit but their Lordships of the Privy Council in Ariff v. Jadunath(1) discountenanced the adoption of English law by Indian courts on this points by pointing out that the statutory law in India could not be so modified. This led to enactment of sec. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act. This section clearly lays down that the transferor or any person claiming under him shall be debarred from enforcing against the transferee and persons claiming under him any right in respect of the property of which the transferee has taken or continued in possession. To my mind, the language is clear and must be construed as debarring any person coming to a court of law from enforcing any right against the transferee. This section does not give any right to the transferee. This view of law has been taken in a number of cases wherein it has been observed that the doctrine of part performance as embodied in sec. 53-A is available only to the defendant. In some cases, however, the view taken is that a suit under O. 21, R. 63 or O. 21, R. 103 C.P.C filed by a claimant is really protecting his right in the property which is transferred to him by the judgment-debtor and as such even though such a claimant is the plaintiff he is entitled to the benefit of sec. 53-A of the Transfer of Property Act. In Ewaz Ali v. Mst. Firdous Jehan & Co. (2), it was held that—

    “Where by the nature of the case as disclosed by the trans by the pleadings or otherwise, it is apparent that the transferee comes to Court to defend his possession against the invasion of it feror he is entitled to invoke the aid of the equitable doctrine therein embodied.”

    It was further laid down that the suit under Order 21, Rule 103 C.P.C is for protecting possession and the capacity in which the plaintiff comes to the Court in such a case is in reality one of defence and the plaintiff can take advantage of sec. 53-A. In Gulab Chand Subh Karan v. Madholal Sadha(3), it was pointed out that a suit under Order 21, Rule 63 C.P.C should be deemed to be a defensive proceeding in continuation of the proceeding under O. 21, R. 58 C.P.C and the plaintiff in such a suit can invoke the aid of Sec. 53-A. In Yenugu Achayya v. Ernaki Venkata Subba Rao & Co.(4), Subba Rao, C.J as he then was, observed, as follows:—

    “The section does not either expressly or by necessary implication indicate that the rights conferred on the transferee thereunder can only be invoked as a defendant and not as a plaintiff Under the terms of the section the transferor is debarred from enforcing against the transferee only rights in respect of the property and this bar does not depend upon the array of the parties. The transferee can resist any attempt on the part of the transferor to enforce his rights in respect of the property whatever position he may occupy in the field of litigation. In one sense, it is a statutory recognition of the defensive equity. It enables the transferee to use it as a shield against any attempt on the part of the transferor to enforce his rights against the property.

    Where the transferee occupies the position of a plaintiff or a defendant, he can resist the transferor's claim against the property. Conversely, whether the transferor is the plaintiff or the defendant, he cannot enforce his rights in respect of the property against the transferee. The utility of the section or the rights conferred thereunder should not be made to depend on the manoeuvering for positions in a Court of law, otherwise a powerful transferor can always defeat the salutary provisions of the section by dispossessing the transferee by force and compelling him to go to a Court as a plaintiff. Doubtless, the right conveyed under the section can be relied upon only as a shield and not as a sword but the protection is available to the transferee both as a plaintiff and as a defendant so long as he uses it as a shield.”

    7. Contrary to these decisions is the Division Bench judgment of the Orissa High Court in Padmalabha Panda v. Appalanarasamma(5). The Bench consisted of Ray, C.J and Jagannadhadas, J. It was pointed out by the learned Chief Justice that—

    “Every action, more or less, presupposes some sort of invasion or interference with the plaintiff's right and every suit of a plaintiff, therefore, can be said to be defensive. To accede to this contention would amount to a misuse of the statute by extending its application to cases outside its ambit.”

    Their Lordships refused to construe this section in such a manner as to give advantage of it to a plaintiff in a suit under O. 21, R. 63 C.P.C Their Lordships further pointed out that the attaching creditor cannot be said to be the legal representative of the judgment-debtor. Leaving this aspect of the matter apart, I am of the view that on the construction of sec. 53-A the view taken by the Orissa High Court is sound. One has to stretch the plain meaning of the section in order to uphold the view that a particular plaintiff is really defending his right to the property as against transferor. It cannot be denied that if without filing an objection under O. 21, R. 58 C.P.C the transferee comes in a court of law to seek a declaration of the title to his property, he cannot take advantage of sec. 53A. Is the position in any way different if he happens to file an objection under O. 21, R. 58 C.P.C and that objection is dismissed? Essentially in both the cases the transferee is seeking to get a decision of his rights in the property and it is a matter of no consequence if he comes after filing an objection petition under Order 21, Rule 58 C.P.C Nor are the provision of sec. 53-A to be construed differently in these two cases. Whatever be the nature of the cause of action, sec. 53A is applicable only when the defendant seeks to debar the transferor from enforcing his right against the transferee in the property which he has transferred with consideration and has parted with possession but has not executed a registered document. In this view of the matter, I am of the opinion that the plaintiffs in this case cannot be granted advantage of sec. 53A of the Transfer of Property Act.

    8. The plaintiffs have claimed title in the lands on the basis of the pattas Exhibits 11 and 12. Their suit for declaration must fail as these two pattas are unregistered.

    9. It has been urged that the plaintiffs have acquired khatedari rights in the land in dispute. This point has not been specifically raised in the plaint and it cannot be heard for the first time in the Second Appeal.

    10. It is also urged that even if the property belonged to Shri Ugrasingh, now that he is dead, the lands vested in the plaintiffs and they cannot be attached under sec. 37 of the Rajasthan Tenancy Act. This objection can properly be raised by the plaintiffs as judgment-debtors under sec. 74 C.P.C The lower appellate court should not have decided this point, in an appeal in a suit filed under Order 21, Rule 63 C.P.C This point is left open and the executing court may decide this point if it thinks proper as and when an objection is filed by the plaintiffs as judgment-debtors.

    11. In this view of the matter, the appeal is allowed and the judgment and decree of the District Judge, Udaipur dated 18th of July, 1957 are set aside and the plaintiffs' suit is dismissed with costs in all the three courts.

    12. Counsel for the respondent prays for leave to appeal to a Division Bench. This prayer is refused.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Motilal v. Jaswant Singh
    (Mar 16, 1963)