AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • General Development Corporation Ltd.Allotment of Industrial Shed Rules, 1977 (for short, the Allotment Rules)
  • section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (for short the Act),
  • sections 3 and 4 of the Indian Income-tax Act.
  • case.7. Rule 5 of the Allotment Rules
  • clause (e) of rule 5(ii)
  • Rule 5(ii)(b)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • General Development Corporation Ltd.Allotment of Industrial Shed Rules, 1977 (for short, the Allotment Rules)
  • section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (for short the Act),
  • sections 3 and 4 of the Indian Income-tax Act.
  • case.7. Rule 5 of the Allotment Rules
  • clause (e) of rule 5(ii)
  • Rule 5(ii)(b)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, by its order dated 23 July 1993 in I.T.A. No. 207.Chd/1988 referred a question of law under section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 to this Court for the assessment year 1983-84. The question asked whether the Tribunal was right in law in allowing the assessee's income to be taxed on a receipt basis rather than on an accrual basis even though the assessee followed the mercantile system of accounting.

The assessee-corporation developed and sold industrial sheds constructed on land provided by the State of Punjab. Under the allotment terms, 25% of the price was payable at allotment and the remaining 75% in ten annual instalments; the land was allotted for 99 years and leasehold rights were to be finally transferred after 15 years from allotment provided there were no arrears. During the relevant year the assessee allotted industrial sheds (49 measuring 5 marlas and an equal number measuring 15 marlas) and declared profit at 15% on the allotment money actually received. The Assessing Officer determined higher profits; the assessee appealed and the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) accepted the assessee's claim that income should be assessed on receipt basis. The Tribunal upheld the Commissioner (Appeals) and dismissed the Revenue's appeal. The matter was then referred to this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal was right in law in allowing the income of the assessee to be taxed on receipt basis and not on accrual basis even though the assessee was following the mercantile system of accountancy?

Arguments of the Parties

Revenue's Arguments

  • The 15% profit on the gross capital cost of the industrial sheds (and not on instalment money actually received) should be treated as the assessee's income because the assessee follows the mercantile system of accounting.
  • Under the mercantile system, it is the income which accrues or arises that is exigible to tax; actual receipt is not determinative.

Assessee's Arguments

  • The gross capital cost was recovered over ten years in equated annual instalments; the assessee did not receive the entire price in the assessment year and therefore the income was not exigible to tax in that year.
  • The sale was not complete at allotment because, under the terms, the allottee's right was not finally transferred until the last instalment was paid; in case of default the assessee could resume the sheds and could not forcibly recover the balance.
  • The allottees were not permitted to transfer the sheds without the assessee's permission and had only a right of possession until completion of payments; reliance was placed on the Chandigarh Industrial and General Development Corporation Ltd. — Allotment of Industrial Shed Rules, 1977.
  • The assessee had followed a consistent method since 1979 under which profits from allotment were accepted by the Department on a year-to-year basis as instalments were received.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner of Income Tax, Gujarat v. Ashokbhai Chimanbhai, [1965] 56 ITR 42 (SC) The distinction between "accrue/arise" and "receive"; income is taxable on accrual only after the taxpayer's right to it accrues; "accrue" contrasted with "receive". The Court used this decision to explain the meaning of accrual under the mercantile system and to support that accrual requires a vested right to receive the income.
Municipal Corporation of Hyderabad v. P.N. Murthy, [1987] 167 ITR 204 (SC) Title passes when payment of instalments of sale price is paid; until all instalments are paid the title may still vest in vendor. The Court relied on this decision to support that title/right passes on payment of instalments and that incomplete payments can mean title remains with the vendor.
CIT v. Hindustan Housing and Land Development Trust Ltd., [1986] 161 ITR 524 (SC) An inchoate right to receive income does not result in taxable income. The Court cited this to reinforce that inchoate rights (not fully vested) do not create taxable accrual.
Rama Bai v. CIT, [1990] 181 ITR 400 (SC) Interest accruing on compensation should be spread over the years to which it relates (treatment of accrual over time). Referred to as a similar view on spreading accruals over relevant years where appropriate.
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Ace Builders Pvt. Ltd., [1993] 202 ITR 324 (Bom) Income accrues only when the assessee acquires a right to receive the income; an entire agreed sum does not accrue on execution if the agreement provides payment over years. The Court relied on this High Court decision to show that where payments are contractually deferred, the entire amount does not accrue immediately on agreement execution.
State Bank Of Travancore v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Kerala, [1986] 158 ITR 102 (SC) Under mercantile system, income which accrues or arises is liable to income-tax. The Court acknowledged the principle but observed that in the present facts accrual occurs year-to-year as instalments are received, so this precedent did not advance the Revenue's case.
Bison Field A Estate v. IAC, [2001] 248 ITR 341 (SC) Recognizes that under the mercantile system taxation is on income which accrues/arises. Noted by the Court as stating the general principle but held not decisive because the assessee's right to receive premium accrued only year-to-year.
CIT v. Ram Chand Kanshi Ram, [1989] 180 ITR 114 (P & H) Principle that under mercantile accounting income which accrues/arises is chargeable to tax. Also cited by the Court as a recognized principle which nevertheless did not advance the Revenue's position in the facts of this case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first examined the relevant provisions of the Allotment Rules (Chandigarh Industrial and General Development Corporation Ltd. — Allotment Rules, 1977), particularly Rule 5(ii)(b) and Rule 5(ii)(e). Rule 5(ii)(b) provided that leasehold rights in industrial sheds would be transferred to the lessee after 15 years from allotment provided there were no arrears; Rule 5(ii)(e) allowed the managing director to resume the plot on non-payment of instalments, interest or ground rent, and provided that the lessee was not entitled to a refund or compensation on resumption.

From those rules the Court concluded that the transfer of rights to the allottee was not absolute until the final instalment was paid: the assessee could resume the property on default but could not forcibly recover the unpaid balance. Thus the assessee's right to receive the balance premium before final payment was at best inchoate.

The Court then turned to accounting law: under the mercantile system, taxability depends on accrual or arising of income. Applying the Supreme Court's guidance in Commissioner of Income Tax, Gujarat v. Ashokbhai Chimanbhai and other decisions, the Court reiterated that accrual requires a vested right to receive income. The Court summarized authorities holding that an inchoate right is not taxable and that where agreements provide payment over years, amounts do not accrue immediately on execution of the agreement.

Applying those principles to the facts, the Court found that the right to receive premium accrued year-to-year as instalments were paid; until the last instalment was paid, the right was not absolute. The Tribunal's approach—taxing profits on a receipt/instalment basis year-to-year—therefore conformed with the law and prior decisions. The Court observed that the Department had, since 1979, treated accrual of profits on a yearly instalment basis and there was no justification to deviate from that approach.

The Court also considered precedents relied on by the Revenue (State Bank Of Travancore, Bison Field A Estate, CIT v. Ram Chand Kanshi Ram) which reiterate the mercantile principle that accrual is the touchstone; however, the Court held those authorities did not assist the Revenue because in the present case the right to receive premium accrued only as instalments fell due.

Holding and Implications

Answer: The question was answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue.

Direct effect on the parties: The Court upheld the Tribunal's conclusion that even under the mercantile system of accounting the assessee's income from allotment of industrial sheds would be taken to accrue on receipt of annual instalments year-to-year (i.e., taxed on the receipt/instalment basis for the years in which instalments were received), and not on accrual at the time of allotment when the right to receive the entire premium had not vested.

Broader implications: The opinion applies established principles on accrual and inchoate rights to the facts; it does not purport to lay down a new general principle beyond the application of existing authorities to these facts. No costs were awarded.

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Chandigarh Industrial And General Development Corporation Ltd.

    Ajay Kumar Mittal, J.:— At the instance of the Revenue, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, Chandigarh (for brevity “the Tribunal”), vide its order dated July 23, 1993, in I.T.A No. 207.Chd/1988 has referred the following question of law to this court for its opinion under section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (for short “the Act”), for the assessment year 1983-84:

    “Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal was right in law in allowing the income of the assessee to be taxed on receipt basis and not on accrual basis even though the assessee was following the mercantile system of accountancy?”

    2. The facts as narrated in the statement of the case are that the assessee-corporation is engaged in the business of development and sale of industrial sheds. The assessee raised certain construction in the form of industrial sheds on the land provided by the State of Punjab and made allotments to the entrepreneurs. As per the conditions of the allotment, 25 per cent, of the price was to be paid by the allottees at the time of allotment and remaining 75 per cent, was payable in ten annual instalments and the land was to be allotted for 99 years on lease. The leasehold rights were to be finally transferred after 15 years from the date of allotment. During the assessment year under consideration, the assessee allotted 49 industrial sheds measuring 5 marlas and an equal number of sheds measuring 15 marlas. The assessee declared 15 per cent, profit on the allotment money received. The assessee claimed that the income on receipt basis must be assessed and not on accrual basis and the assessee declared profit at Rs. 1,16,987 but it was calculated at Rs. 4,85,100 in respect of industrial sheds measuring 5 marlas. Similarly, the profit declared by the assessee to the tune of Rs. 3,99,091 in respect of industrial sheds measuring 15 marlas but was determined by the Assessing Officer at Rs. 14,04,188. The assessee took the matter in appeal and the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) accepted the appeal and held that the income on receipt basis must be brought to tax in view of the nature of the transactions. Feeling dissatisfied, the Revenue filed appeal before the Tribunal and the Tribunal upholding the view of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) dismissed the appeal, vide its order dated July 23, 1993. We have heard learned counsel for the parties.

    3. According to learned counsel for the Revenue, the 15 per cent, profit on the gross capital cost of the industrial sheds and not on the instalment money actually received by the assessee was to be treated as income of the assessee as it was following the mercantile system of accounting. Learned counsel argued that it is the accrued income which is exigible to tax under the mercantile system of accounting and the actual receipt is of no consequence.

    4. Learned counsel for the assessee very vehemently controverted the submission of the Revenue and argued that the gross capital cost of the land was realized in a period of ten years in equated annual instalments and the assessee did not receive the entire price of industrial sheds and in that eventuality it was not exigible to tax in this year. Elaborating further, it was contended that the sale of the industrial sheds was not complete at the time of allotment in view of the terms and conditions and in case any person defaulted in making payment of the annual instalments or violated any terms and conditions, the industrial sheds were liable to be resumed by the assessee and, therefore, the right in the land did not stand transferred to the allottees finally till the last instalment was paid. Further, the allottees were not permitted to transfer the industrial sheds without the permission of the assessee and they had only right of possession. Learned counsel relied upon the Chandigarh Industrial and General Development Corporation Ltd.—Allotment of Industrial Shed Rules, 1977 (for short, “the Allotment Rules”) in support of her submission. It was further submitted that according to the consistent method adopted by the assessee since 1979, the profits accruing on the allotment of industrial sheds have been accepted by the Department on the basis of accrual of profits from year to year till the final instalment is paid.

    5. After giving our thoughtful consideration to the respective submissions, we have not felt impressed by the submission of learned counsel for the Revenue.

    6. Before proceeding further, it would be apposite to view the relevant allotment rules which are material for adjudication of controversy involved in the present case.

    7. Rule 5 of the Allotment Rules provides for allotment of industrial sheds. Rule 5(ii)(b) which is relevant for the present purposes reads thus:

    “5.(ii)(b) Leasehold rights in the industrial sheds of the corporation shall be transferred in favour of the lessee after the expiry of 15 years from the date of allotment provided there are no arrears against the lessee on account of premium interest or ground rent. Even after the transfer of land in favour of the lessee, he shall be liable to pay ground rent at the prescribed rate.”

    8. Further, clause (e) of rule 5(ii) stipulates that in the event of failure on the part of the allottee/lessee in making payment of instalment, the managing director of the assessee-corporation shall be entitled to resume the plot. However, an option has been given to the allottee/lessee to make the payment of the premium along with interest. The said rule is reproduced for ready reference:

    “5.(ii)(e). In the event of non-payment of any instalment of premium, interest due thereon or annual ground rent, it shall be lawful for the managing director of the Chandigarh Industrial and General Development Corporation Ltd., Chandigarh, notwithstanding the waiver of any previous cause or right for re-entry thereon or any part thereof and to repossess, retain and enjoy the same as to his former estate and the lessee will not be entitled to refund of premium or any part thereof or to any compensation whatsoever on account of such resumption.”

    9. After a careful analysis of the aforesaid rules, it emerges that the transfer of rights in favour of the allottee was not complete till the payment of the last instalment and in the event of default on his part, the assessee could not recover the balance amount forcibly though it had a right to cancel the allotment and resume the land or industrial shed. This clearly shows that the right transferred to the allottees were not an absolute right in respect of land or industrial sheds till the payment of the final instalment.

    10. The assessee is following the mercantile system of accountancy. Under the mercantile system of accounting, the assessee is liable to pay tax on the income that “accrues” or “arises” during the year of accounting. The apex court in Commissioner Of Income Tax, Gujarat v. Ashokbhai Chimanbhai, [1965] 56 ITR 42 (SC) while considering the scope of “accrue” or “arise” held that the words “accrue” or “arise” are used to contradistinguish the word “receive”. Income is said to be received when it reaches the assessee when the right to receive the income becomes vested in the assessee, it is said to accrue or arise. The apex court further held as under (headnote):

    “Income becomes taxable on the footing of accrual only after the right of the taxpayer to the income accrues or arises, and in the case of an agreement which makes profits receivable at or on the happening of a contingency, the fact that the profits are the result of transactions spread over a period which covers a period preceding the happening of that contingency would not make the receipt liable to be paid to persons other than those who are entitled to receive it on the date on which it is actually received or became receivable.”

    11. It was also observed thus (headnote):

    “In the gross receipts of a business day after day or from transaction to transaction lies embedded or dormant profit or loss. On such dormant profit or loss undoubtedly taxable profits, if any, of the business will be computed, but dormant profits cannot be equated to profits charged to tax under sections 3 and 4 of the Indian Income-tax Act. The concept of accrual of profits of a business involves their determination by the method of accounting at the end of the accounting year or any shorter period determined by law.”

    12. In Municipal Corporation of Hyderabad v. P.N Murthy, [1987] 167 ITR 204 (SC) the hon'ble Supreme Court on the issue as to what point of time the property passes to an allottee in case of payment by instalment held that the title passes when payment of the instalment of sale price is paid by the allottee/lessee. The relevant observations of the apex court reads thus (page 207):

    “It is no doubt true that until all the instalments under the hire purchase agreement were paid, the allottees would not become the owners of the houses for the title would vest unto them only upon the payment of all the instalments as per the stipulations contained in the agreement. At the relevant point of time, the instalments had not yet been fully paid. The title in regard to the houses, therefore, continued to vest unto the municipal corporation at the relevant time.”

    13. In CIT v. Hindustan Housing and Land Development Trust Ltd., [1986] 161 ITR 524 (SC) while analysing the scope of accrual of income, the hon'ble Supreme Court categorically held that in case of an inchoate right to receive income, it does not result in taxable income. A similar view had been expressed in Rama Bai v. CIT, [1990] 181 ITR 400 (SC) wherein the apex court went on to hold that interest which accrues on compensation as a result of acquisition of land by virtue of court order is to be spread over a number of years to which it relates.

    14. A Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Ace Builders Pvt. Ltd., [1993] 202 ITR 324 (Bom), while considering the similar situation as in the present case, held as under (page 331):

    “From a plain reading of this clause it is clear that it was the total guaranteed profit that was determined at Rs. 8 lakhs. From the agreement it is also evident that the work in connection with which the guaranteed profits were to be given to the assessee was not expected to be completed immediately on execution of the agreement or within the previous year during which the agreement was executed. It was to take a number of years. It is in this context that the profits were bifurcated and different dates were fixed when the amounts became payable. A sum of Rs. 85,000 was paid before execution of the agreement. A sum of Rs. 1,00,000 was to be paid before April 1, 1971. A further amount of Rs. 1,50,000 was to be paid before May 1, 1971. Another amount of Rs. 3,50,000 was to be paid before May 1, 1972. Thereafter, other amounts mentioned in the said clause were payable before the dates mentioned therein. There is no doubt that the entire amount did not become due to the assessee on the execution of the agreement. The assessee had no right to claim the amount from the builders or to enforce the claim before the date specified in the agreement. In such a situation it is difficult to accept the submission of the Revenue that the entire amount of Rs. 8 lakhs accrued to the assessee immediately on execution of the agreement. The principles to determine as to when the income is said to have accrued or arisen are already well settled by a catena of decisions of the Supreme Court and need no reiteration. It is well settled that the income is held to accrue only when the assessee acquires a right to receive that income. In other words, or to say it differently, income can be said to accrue on a date when the debt becomes due. As observed by the Supreme Court in Commissioner Of Income Tax, Gujarat v. Ashokbhai Chimanbhai, [1965] 56 ITR 42, unless the right to profits comes into existence there is no accrual of profits. In the instant case, in the face of the clear agreement between the parties contained in clause 9 of the agreement, it cannot be said that the entire amount of Rs. 8 lakhs accrued to the assessee on the date of the agreement.”

    15. Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present case, it is undisputed that the assessee allots an industrial shed on leasehold basis in which premium is required to be paid over 10 years period and the rights are transferred in favour of the allottee/lessee on the payment of final instalment. Further, till the assessee received payment of annual instalment during the year, it is an inchoate right in favour of the assessee as in the event of failure on the part of the allottee/lessee, the managing director of the corporation has only a right to resume but cannot enforce the payment of the balance amount. Still further, the Revenue since 1979 had been treating the accrual of profits on yearly basis on instalments due till the payment of last instalment was made and there is no justification for the Revenue in deviating from the said approach which is in conformity with law. Viewed from this, the approach of the Tribunal was correct and it had rightly held that even under the mercantile system of accounting, the income would accrue on receipt of instalment on year to year basis and not on the allotment of land or industrial sheds. In all fairness to learned counsel for the Revenue, we make a reference to the decisions relied upon by him, viz., State Bank Of Travancore v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Kerala , [1986] 158 ITR 102 (SC), Bison Field A Estate v. IAC, [2001] 248 ITR 341 (SC) and CIT v. Ram Chand Kanshi Ram, [1989] 180 ITR 114 (P & H). In the aforesaid judgments, it has been held that under the mercantile system of accountancy, it is the income which accrues or arises to an assessee which is liable to income-tax. The said principle is well recognized. However, as observed earlier, in the present case the right to receive premium accrues or arises in favour of the assessee on yearly basis till the payment of the final instalment is made and, therefore, the aforesaid decisions do not advance the case of the Revenue.

    16. Accordingly, the question posed is answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Chandigarh Industrial And General Development Corporation Ltd.
    (Nov 1, 2007)