Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
  • provisions of Order 6 Rule 17 CPC
  • Order VI Rule 7 of the Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
  • provisions of Order 6 Rule 17 CPC
  • Order VI Rule 7 of the Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Article 227 of the Constitution challenges the order dated 9.10.2004 by the Additional District Judge, Chandigarh, which declined the defendant-petitioner’s application to amend the written statement under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. The defendant-petitioner had filed an appeal against the judgment and decree dated 16.8.2001 by the Civil Judge (Jr. Division), Chandigarh, which decreed the plaintiff-respondents’ suit. During the pendency of this appeal, the defendant-petitioner sought to amend the written statement to raise the issue of non-joinder of Thakurdwara as a necessary party and to introduce facts regarding the management and ownership of the suit property by members of the Mahant family. The Additional District Judge dismissed the amendment application, finding the delay unjustified and the amendment lacking bona fide intention.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendant-petitioner can be permitted to amend the written statement at the appellate stage under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, after a long delay and after judgment at trial.
  2. Whether non-joinder of Thakurdwara as a party is fatal to the plaintiff-respondents’ suit and whether Thakurdwara should be impleaded at the appellate stage.
  3. Whether the High Court should interfere under Article 227 of the Constitution against the order declining amendment when no grave and manifest injustice is shown.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant-Petitioner’s Arguments

  • Non-joinder of Thakurdwara, to whom the suit property was gifted by the ancestors of the plaintiffs in the 19th Century, is fatal to the suit and Thakurdwara is a necessary party.
  • The property is maintained by Mahants of the Bairagi Ramandi Sect, currently managed by Mahant Sukhdass and others, with Urmila Devi managing as a family member, which should be reflected in the pleadings.
  • The application for amendment was filed during the pendency of the appeal to bring out these facts.
  • Reliance on Sampath Kumar v. Ayyakannu to support the amendment and impleadment of necessary parties despite delay.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shakuntala v. Devendra Kumar Mool Chand, 2003 (3) CCC 167 (Rajasthan High Court) Amended provisions of Order VI Rule 17 CPC disallow amendments at appellate stage. Supported the view that no amendment is permissible at appellate stage without cogent reasons.
Inderpal Singh v. Bankey Bihari, 2003 (4) RCR (Civil) 210 (P&H) : 2003 (3) CCC 707 No amendment after trial commencement unless matter was not known or could not be ascertained with due diligence. Applied to reject amendment application due to lack of due diligence and delay.
Sampath Kumar v. Ayyakannu, 2002 (4) RCR (Civil) 566 (SC) : 2002 (3) Civil Court Cases 364 Delay alone is not fatal for amendment under Order VI Rule 7 if amendment is within limitation period. Distinguished as inapplicable since objection was raised after rights crystallized and judgment passed.
Anokhe Lal v. Radhamohan Bansal, 1991 Supp (2) SCC 605 : AIR 1991 SC 257 Implieadment of party causing de novo trial should not be permitted. Applied to deny impleadment of Thakurdwara to avoid de novo trial.
Behari Lal v. Bhuri Devi, 1997 (2) SCC 279 Failure to raise objection in written statement or trial waives the objection. Applied to hold that non-joinder objection was waived by defendant-petitioner’s conduct.
Ouseph Mathus v. M. Abdul Khadir, 2002 (1) SCC 319 High Court’s jurisdiction under Article 227 to interfere only if grave and manifest injustice is shown. Applied to refuse interference in absence of grave injustice to defendant-petitioner.
Virendra Kashinath Ravat v. Vinayak N. Noshi, 1999 (1) RCR (Civil) 24 (SC) : 1999 (1) SCC 47 Similar principle on interference under Article 227 requiring grave and manifest injustice. Reinforced refusal to interfere with impugned order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the defendant-petitioner’s application for amendment at the appellate stage and found it lacked due diligence and bona fide intention. The defendant-petitioner sought to introduce new facts and a plea of non-joinder of a necessary party (Thakurdwara) after more than 14 years since the suit was filed and after judgment and decree were passed at trial. The court noted that inadvertence and illiteracy were insufficient grounds for amendment under the amended provisions of Order VI Rule 17 CPC, which require that the matter sought to be raised could not have been raised earlier despite due diligence.

The court agreed with the Additional District Judge’s observation that the amendment was a tactic to delay the litigation and bring the matter back to square one. It also held that allowing impleadment of Thakurdwara would necessitate a de novo trial, which is impermissible. The defendant-petitioner’s failure to raise the objection earlier amounted to waiver. The court further held that interference under Article 227 requires grave and manifest injustice, which was not demonstrated here. The delay and conduct of the defendant-petitioner were held to be lacking bona fide intention, thus justifying dismissal of the amendment application and the petition.

Holding and Implications

The petition is dismissed with costs.

The court’s decision directly denies the defendant-petitioner’s request to amend the written statement and to implead Thakurdwara as a necessary party at the appellate stage. The ruling reinforces the principle that amendments at this late stage require cogent reasons and due diligence, and that attempts to delay proceedings without bona fide grounds will be rejected. No new precedent was established; the decision applies settled legal principles to the facts, preserving the finality of the trial court’s judgment and protecting the plaintiff-respondents’ rights after a protracted litigation period.

    Smt. Urmila Devi v. Nar Singh And Others

    M.M Kumar, J.:— This petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution is directed against order dated 9.10.2004 passed by the Additional District Judge, Chandigarh declining the application of the defendant-petitioner in which prayer was made for amendment of the written statement under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for brevity, ‘the Code’). It is appropriate to mention that the defendant-petitioner has filed an appeal against the judgment and decree dated 16.8.2001 passed by the Civil Judge (Jr. Division), Union Territory, Chandigarh in Civil Suit No. 26 of 1987 whereby the suit of the plaintiff-respondents has been decreed against the defendant-appellant. During the pendency of the appeal, prayer for amendment of the written statement has been made. The following amendments have been sought : (a) that the non-joinder of Thakurdwara by the plaintiff-respondents is fatal to the suit of the plaintiff-respondents as it was a necessary party. The aforementioned ground was sought to be set up on the plea that Thakurdwara to whom the suit property was gifted by the ancestors of the plaintiff-respondents in 19th Century and the land revenue was remitted; (b) that the property being maintained by Mahants of Bairagi Ramandi Sect and presently Mahant Sukhdass Chela Mahant Raghubir Dass Chela Mahant Laxmi Dass Mahant Chela Harnam Dass is the present Mahant and Urmila Devi is managing the suit property as member of the family of Mahants.

    2. The learned Additional District Judge considering the rival contentions has dismissed the application by recording the impugned order, the operative part of which reads as under:—

    “It is of utmost importance to be aware of the fact that apart from the suit filed against her by Nar Singh and others, Kamla Devi has also filed a suit against Nar Singh and others. In that suit of hers Kamla Devi did not plead that suit property was gifted to Thakurdwara by ancestors of Nar Singh and others, rather her version was of her husband Luxmi Dass being one of the muafidaars qua the land in dispute. It is urged by ld. counsel for the plaintiffs that without asking for amendment of her plaint in the connected suit, which has been consolidated with this suit, the plea sought to be added by way of amendment in the written statement would be at variance with her pleadings in the other suit.

    Inadvertence and illiteracy are the two reasons given by Urmila Devi which prevented Kamla Devi and her from taking this plea earlier. Inadvertence is anti-thesis to due diligence and as the amended provisions of CPC require that no amendment is to be allowed unless the Court comes to the conclusion that the matter sought to be raised by way of amendment could not be raised by the concerned party inspite due diligence, the proposed amendment based upon inadvertence pleadings perfunctorily only that inspite due diligence such matter could not be rased earlier, I find hardly any worthwhile reason to conclude in terms of the requisites laid down by the amended CPC. In Shakuntala v. Devendra Kumar Mool Chand, 2003 (3) CCC 167 the Honourable Rajasthan High Court has held that in view of the amended provisions of Order 6 Rule 17 CPC no amendment seems possible at appellate stage. In Inderpal Singh v. Bankey Bihari, 2003 (4) RCR (Civil) 210 (P&H) : 2003 (3) CCC 707 the Honourable High Court of Punjab and Haryana has held that no amendment of pleadings is to be permitted after the commencement of trial unless cogent reasons are shown by such a party that the matter sought to be incorporated by amendment was not within his knowledge or could not be ascertained with due diligence.

    It is only ritually pleaded by the applicant that inspite of due diligence she could not take the plea she intends to introduce by way of amendment. Illiteracy is not the ground which can be forwarded by her which incapacitated her from taking such a plea earlier than now. She was always assisted by lawyer/counsel and if she was earlier illiterate she had not now turned literate enough to know intricacies of law.

    Although delay alone is not considered enough to decline a relief of amendment if it is otherwise found justifiable yet when the very intention appears to drag the litigation further, in attempt to bring the clock back to the year 1987 and the proceedings to square one, despite the fact that it is already 14 years old and the applicant has ended up losing in the trial Court and has waited for about three years even in the Appellate Court before coming up with this application only when the appeal came up for arguments, the intention does not sound bona fide and for this reason and for the reasons already deceased above, the application for amendment in written statement at appellate stage is found without merit and is declined, without meaning to express any opinion on merits of the case.”

    3. Mr. Vijay Lath, learned counsel for the defendant-petitioner has confined his prayer only to preliminary objection that Thakurdwara was required to be impleaded as a party respondent as it was a necessary party and non-impleadment of the same would be fatal to their suit. In support of his submission, the learned counsel has placed reliance on a judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Sampath Kumar v. Ayyakannu, 2002 (4) RCR (Civil) 566 (SC) : 2002 (3) Civil Court Cases 364.

    4. Having heard the learned counsel at a considerable length, I am not able to persuade myself to accept the submissions made by the learned counsel because the suit was filed in the year 1987 and after more than 14 years the judgment and decree was passed by the learned Civil Judge on 16.8.2001 Thereafter, the appeal was preferred being C.A No. 45 on 26.9.2001 During this period, no objection with regard to requirement of impleadment of necessary party was taken nor any application was filed. However, for the first time an application was filed on 27.1.2004 when the case was posted for arguments before the learned Additional District Judge. Such a conduct does not augur well the judicial system especially when the rights of the plaintiff-respondents have crystalised. I am in agreement with the observations made by the learned Additional District Judge that the prayer made by the defendant-petitioner lacks bona fide and is a device to delay the decision of the appeal. Therefore, the instant petition is liable to be dismissed.

    5. Even otherwise I am of the view that if the defendant-petitioner is permitted to implead ‘Thakurdwara’ as a party respondent, it would necessarily result into a de novo trial. It is a settled proposition of law that if the resultant effect of impleadment of a party is a de novo trial, then such a party should not be permitted to be impleaded. For the aforementioned view reliance can be placed on a judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Anokhe Lal v. Radhamohan Bansal, 1991 Supp (2) SCC 605 : AIR 1991 SC 257. Moreover, if no objection has been raised in the written statement nor any argument was addressed when the judgment and decree by trial Court has been passed, then the objection is deemed to be waived. For the aforementioned view reliance could be placed on a judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Behari Lal v. Bhuri Devi, 1997 (2) SCC 279.

    6. It is also well settled that while exercising jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution this could interfere in the orders of the Subordinate Courts only if grave and manifest injustice is shown to have been caused. The aforementioned view has been taken by the Supreme Court in the case of Ouseph Mathus v. M. Abdul Khadir, 2002 (1) SCC 319 and Virendra Kashinath Ravat v. Vinayak N. Noshi, 1999 (1) RCR (Civil) 24 (SC) : 1999 (1) SCC 47. No such grave and manifest injustice is shown to have been caused to the defendant-petitioner warranting exercise of jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution. In fact allowing the impleadment of a party at this stage would result into grave injustice to the plaintiff-respondents who have been awaiting for justice since 1987.

    7. The judgment of the Supreme Court in Sampath Kumar's case (supra) on which reliance has been placed by the learned counsel does not require any detailed examination because in that case it has been held that delay alone is not fatal for granting prayer for amendment under Order VI Rule 7 of the Code provided the amendment sought would not be hit by the law of limitation. It has further been held that the amended plaint was deemed to be filed on the date of filing the application for amendment. However, the aforementioned enunciation of law has no application on the facts of the present case because in this case more than 17 years ago a suit was filed and the objection with regard to non-joining of necessary parties was available at that time. The objection is sought to be taken after the right of the parties have already crystalised by virtue of judgment and decree dated 16.8.2001 Therefore, I do not find any substance in the aforementioned argument.

    8. For the aforementioned reasons, this petition fails and the same is dismissed with costs.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Smt. Urmila Devi v. Nar Singh And Others
    (Jan 6, 2005)