AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • clause (viii) of Rule 5 of the Punjab Civil Services (Punishment and Appeal) Rules, 1970 (for short, the Rules')
  • Rule 9 (Sub-rule (5)(a)]. Clauses (b) and (c) of sub-rule (5) and sub-rules (6) to (23) of Rule 8
  • Article 311(2) of the Constitution and Rule 9 of the Rules
  • provisions contained in Article 311 of the Constitution
  • Rule 8 of the Punjab Civil Services (P&A) Rules, 1970
  • Rules 8 and 9 of the Rules and the provisions
  • provisions of Article 311 of the Constitution
  • Rules and the provisions of the Constitution
  • provisions of Rules 8 and 9 of the Rules
  • Public Servants (Inquiries) Act, 1850
  • Sub-rules (3) and (4) of Rule 8
  • Rule 11 of the Rules
  • Sub-rule (1) of Rule 8
  • Rule 8 of the Rules,
  • Rule 5 of the Rules
  • Act. Sub-rule (2)
  • Rules. Rule 15
  • Sub-rule (5)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • clause (viii) of Rule 5 of the Punjab Civil Services (Punishment and Appeal) Rules, 1970 (for short, the Rules')
  • Rule 9 (Sub-rule (5)(a)]. Clauses (b) and (c) of sub-rule (5) and sub-rules (6) to (23) of Rule 8
  • Article 311(2) of the Constitution and Rule 9 of the Rules
  • provisions contained in Article 311 of the Constitution
  • Rule 8 of the Punjab Civil Services (P&A) Rules, 1970
  • Rules 8 and 9 of the Rules and the provisions
  • provisions of Article 311 of the Constitution
  • Rules and the provisions of the Constitution
  • provisions of Rules 8 and 9 of the Rules
  • Public Servants (Inquiries) Act, 1850
  • Sub-rules (3) and (4) of Rule 8
  • Rule 11 of the Rules
  • Sub-rule (1) of Rule 8
  • Rule 8 of the Rules,
  • Rule 5 of the Rules
  • Act. Sub-rule (2)
  • Rules. Rule 15
  • Sub-rule (5)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (G.S. Singhvi, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This summary is limited to facts and procedure as recited in the provided opinion.

Dr. Ved Parkash Pathak (the petitioner) joined the Punjab Civil Medical Service on 19.8.1963 and held progressive appointments up to Associate Professor of Pathology. He was absent from duty from 23.6.1983. The petitioner sought leave for periods in 1982–83 to attend to his ailing father; some leave was sanctioned but subsequent requests were rejected. After nearly two years of absence, the petitioner wrote on 22.3.1985 seeking to be allowed to join duty (a copy of that letter was not placed on record).

The State initiated a departmental enquiry. Dr. Balwant Singh Tung was appointed as enquiry officer by government letter dated 14.1.1985 and sent a communication dated 9.4.1985 requiring the petitioner to appear on 23.4.1985. The petitioner wrote on 13.4.1985 seeking an adjournment. A registered letter dated 22.4.1985 sent to the petitioner's last known address was returned undelivered.

On 27.4.1987 the State Government (Department of Health and Family Welfare) issued Annexure P4 removing the petitioner from service on the grounds of prolonged absence, stating he had been given reasonable opportunity to explain his position and that the Punjab Public Service Commission agreed to his removal. The petitioner filed a writ petition challenging Annexure P4 on the principal ground that the removal was effected in violation of Rules 8 and 9 of the Punjab Civil Services (Punishment & Appeal) Rules, 1970 and Article 311 of the Constitution, without reasonable opportunity of defence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order of removal dated 27.4.1987 (Annexure P4) was passed in violation of Rules 8 and 9 of the Punjab Civil Services (Punishment & Appeal) Rules, 1970 such that it is void for want of compliance with the mandatory disciplinary procedure.
  2. Whether the petitioner was denied reasonable opportunity of defence and the protections under Article 311 of the Constitution in the disciplinary process that led to his removal.
  3. Whether, having regard to any procedural defects, the removal order should be quashed and what relief should follow.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • The punishment of removal is vitiated by wholesale violation of Rule 8 of the Rules: no charge-sheet was issued to enable the petitioner to submit a reply; there was no proper notice after 13.4.1985; any enquiry report, if prepared, was not made available to him; and he was not given a show cause notice or an opportunity to make representation against any adverse findings and the proposed punishment.
  • The order also contravenes Article 311 of the Constitution and fundamental rules of natural justice because the petitioner was not given an opportunity to defend himself at any stage.

Respondent's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • The Deputy Advocate General could not demonstrate whether a charge-sheet was issued, whether evidence was recorded, whether an enquiry report was submitted, or whether a show cause notice was issued; nevertheless she emphasized that the petitioner had been absent from duty for almost two years.
  • It was pointed out in explanation that a registered letter dated 22.4.1985, sent to the petitioner's last available address, was returned undelivered—offered as a factor in justification of the procedure followed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Khem Chand v. Union of India, AIR 1958 SC 300 Authority supporting that infraction of prescribed disciplinary procedure/natural justice vitiates imposition of major penalties. Cited as part of the body of authority establishing that breach of mandatory disciplinary procedure and denial of reasonable opportunity can invalidate punishment.
State of Madhya Pradesh v. Chintaman Sadashiva Waishampayan, AIR 1961 SC 1623 Same general principle: procedural compliance in disciplinary cases is essential. Relied upon to support the court's conclusion that procedural lapses can nullify disciplinary action.
Major U.R. Bhatt v. Union of India, AIR 1962 SC 1344 Reinforces requirement of adherence to statutory disciplinary procedures and natural justice. Used to corroborate the finding that non-observance of mandatory steps vitiates punishment.
The State of Mysore v. K. Manche Gowda, AIR 1964 SC 506 Principle that statutorily prescribed disciplinary procedure must be followed; protective scope of Article 311. Cited to demonstrate established jurisprudence favouring quashing of orders passed in breach of required procedure.
Moti Ram Deka v. General Manager, North East Frontier Railway, AIR 1964 SC 600 Supports the proposition that procedural violations affecting the delinquent warrant quashing of disciplinary action. Cited as further authority for the court's view on mandatory nature of disciplinary rules.
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Om Parkash Gupta, 1969 3 SCC 775 Emphasises mandatory compliance with procedural safeguards in service law and Article 311. Referred to as part of the jurisprudential foundation for quashing Annexure P4 due to procedural breaches.
Uttar Pradesh Government v. Sabir Hussain, 1975 4 SCC 703 Affirms that failure to follow procedural rules can render disciplinary action invalid. Included among precedents relied upon to support nullification of the impugned order.
Kashinath Dikshita v. Union of India, AIR 1968 SC 2118 Another authority on the protective scope of statutory procedure and principles of natural justice in service dismissals. Quoted to reinforce the court's conclusion that the impugned removal was invalid for procedural non-compliance.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis follows directly from the statutory framework and the facts as alleged in the petition:

  1. Statutory and procedural framework: The court first set out the statutory scheme in the Punjab Civil Services (Punishment & Appeal) Rules, 1970, particularly Rules 5, 8 and 9, explaining that removal from service is a major penalty and that Rules 8 and 9 prescribe the detailed, stepwise procedure for imposing such penalties (framing and delivery of charges, statement of imputations, lists of documents and witnesses, opportunity to file written defence and to be heard, recording of evidence, cross-examination, preparation and submission of report, and consideration by the punishing authority).
  2. Mandatory character and nexus with Article 311: The court emphasized that the procedure under Rules 8 and 9 is mandatory and embodies the rules of natural justice and the reasonable opportunity guaranteed by Article 311 of the Constitution. Therefore compliance is a condition precedent to imposing major penalties.
  3. Assessment of procedural compliance: Drawing on the petitioner's averments and the respondent's inability to demonstrate compliance, the court found that the disciplinary procedure had been vitiated at every stage: (a) no charge-sheet served enabling a written defence; (b) no list of documents and witnesses provided; (c) no effective opportunity to appear before the enquiry officer; (d) if an enquiry report was prepared it was not made available to the petitioner; (e) no show cause notice was issued; and (f) no opportunity was given to make representation against any adverse findings or against the proposed punishment.
  4. Effect of wholesale procedural infraction: The court explained that while breach of one or another procedural step may not in every case invalidate a penalty, where the procedure is vitiated at every stage and such breaches result in prejudice to the delinquent employee (as found to be the case here), the only available remedy is to nullify the punitive order.
  5. Reliance on precedent: The court cited several Supreme Court authorities that establish and illustrate the rule that infraction of mandatory disciplinary procedure and denial of reasonable opportunity under Article 311 vitiate dismissal or removal, and used that body of case law to support the conclusion reached in this case.
  6. No need to decide other points: Having reached this conclusion on procedural grounds, the court declined to adjudicate other points raised in the petition.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed and the impugned order Annexure P4 dated 27.4.1987 removing Dr. Ved Parkash Pathak from service is quashed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The order of removal (Annexure P4) is set aside. The State Government is left free to take further action in accordance with law; i.e., the court's decision does not preclude the State from conducting a fresh disciplinary process compliant with Rules 8 and 9 and Article 311.
  • On precedent and broader law: The opinion applies established Supreme Court principles (as cited) regarding the mandatory nature of statutory disciplinary procedures and the protections of Article 311; the court did not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond applying those authorities to the facts of this case.
Order quashed; petition allowed.

    Dr. Ved Parkash Pathak v. State Of Punjab And Another

    G.S Singhvi, J.:— Removal from service is one of the major penalties specified in clause (viii) of Rule 5 of the Punjab Civil Services (Punishment and Appeal) Rules, 1970 (for short, the Rules') which the government can impose on a delinquent employee for good and sufficient reasons. Rules 8 and 9 of the Rules contain the procedure for imposing major penalties. Sub-rule (1) of Rule 8 declares that no order imposing any of the penalties specified in clauses (v) to (ix) of Rule 5 shall be made except after an enquiry held, as far as may be in the manner provided in this rule and Rule 9 or in the manner provided by the Public Servants (Inquiries) Act, 1850 where such enquiry is held under that Act. Sub-rule (2) of lays down that whenever the punishing authority is of the opinion that there are grounds for enquiring into the truth of any imputation of misconduct or misbehaviour against a government employee, it may itself enquire into or appoint an officer to make enquiry. Sub-rules (3) and (4) of Rule 8 postulate framing of charges and delivery thereof to the employee concerned together with the statement of imputation of misconduct or misbehaviour and a list of documents and witnesses by which each article of charge is proposed to be sustained. The concerned employee is required to be told that he can submit written statement of defence and also state whether he desires to be heard in person. Sub-rule (5) lays that on receipt of the written statement of defence, the punishing authority may itself enquire into such of the articles of charge as are not admitted or appoint an enquiring authority for the purpose. If all articles of charge are admitted by the employee, then the punishing authority can record the finding on each charge and act in the manner laid down in Rule 9 (Sub-rule (5)(a)]. Clauses (b) and (c) of Sub-rule (5) and sub-rules (6) to (23) of Rule 8 envisage various steps to be taken by the enquiring authority and/or the punishing authority. These include recording of evidence in the presence of the delinquent employee, giving of opportunity to him to cross-examine the witnesses and produce defence evidence: recording of findings by the enquiry authority: submission of enquiry report to the punishing authority: consideration of report by the punishing authority and passing of final order of penalty, Rule 11 of the Rules provides for communication of the order of punishment to the delinquent employee. Rule 13 provides for special procedure in certain cases where any penalty is imposed on a delinquent employee on the ground of conduct which has led to conviction on a criminal charge or where the punishing authority is satisfied for the reasons to be recorded in writing that it is not reasonably practicable to hold an enquiry in the manner provided in the Rules or the Governor is satisfied that in the interest of the State, it is not expedient to hold any enquiry in the manner provided under the Rules. Rule 15 provides for appeal, Rule 21 contains a non-obstante clause and lays down that the Governor or the Appellate Authority or any other authority specified in this behalf may review the order of punishment.

    2. I have prefaced the disposal of this writ petition by making a reference to the detailed procedure contained in Rules 8 and 9 of the Rules and the provisions relating to special cases, appeal and review because the main ground on which the petitioner has challenged order Annexure P4 dated 27.4.1987 passed by the Government of Punjab, Department of Health and Family Welfare vide which he was removed from service is that the same was passed in violation of the provisions of Rules 8 and 9 of the Rules and without giving him reasonable opportunity of defence.

    3. For deciding the legality of the order impugned in the writ petition, it will be appropriate to briefly notice the facts.

    4. After passing MBBS the petitioner joined Punjab Civil Medical Service on 19.8.1963 He was appointed as Demonstrator in Pathology on 1.5.1965 He was promoted as Lecturer on 28.10.1966: as Assistant Professor on 1.5.1973 and as Associate Professor on 22.12.1979 From 14.9.1982 to 29.12.1982, he worked Professor in Pathology. In June, 1982 the petitioner applied for leave to attend his ailing father, who was operated for pro-static enlargement at Medical College, Amritsar. His father was shifted to Post Graduate Institute of Medical Science and Research, Chandigarh, in October, 1982. There he was operated thrice but without success. He was discharged in January, 1983. During this period, the petitioner applied for leave which was sanctioned up to 22.6.1983 However, his prayer for the vacation leave from 23.6.1983 to 31.7.1983 rejected. His further prayer for grant of leave from 1.8.1983 to 29.10.1983 was also rejected.

    5. After remaining absent from duty for almost two years, the petitioner sent letter dated 22.3.1985 for being allowed to joint duty. (For the reasons best known to the petitioner, he has not placed on record a copy of that letter). The concerned authority did not respond to his letter apparently because a departmental enquiry had been initiated against him. Dr. Balwant Singh Tung, Principal Medical College, Amritsar, who was appointed as enquiry officer vide government letter dated 14.1.1985, sent communication dated 9.4.1985 (Annexure PI) to the petitioner requiring him to appear on 23.4.1985 at 10.00 a.m in connection with the enquiry. On receipt of Annexure P1, the petitioner sent letter dated 13.4.1985 (Annexure P2) to the enquiry officer for adjournment by stating that he had to take his father to some good Urology Centre for further treatment. Thereupon, the enquiry officer sent letter dated 22.4.1985 to the petitioner at his last given address, but the same was returned undelivered.

    6. Thereafter the State Government passed order dated 27.4.1987 removing the petitioner from service. The relevant portion of that order is reproduced below:—

    “Whereas Dr. Ved Parkash Pathak, Associate Professor or Pathology while posted at Medical College, Amritsar has been absent from duty since 23.6.1983

    And whereas he has not joined duty in spite of repeated instructions of the State Govt. for resuming duty and is therefore guilty of gross misconduct.

    And whereas he has been given reasonable opportunity to explain his position.

    And whereas the Punjab Public Service Commission on consideration of the circumstances of the case has agreed to his removal from service.

    Now therefore, in exercise of the powers conferred by Rule 8 of the Punjab Civil Services (P&A) Rules, 1970 and all other powers enabling him in this behalf the Governor of Punjab is pleased to impose upon Dr. Ved Parkash Pathak the penalty of removal from services with immediate effect.”

    7. Dr. Balram K. Gupta, Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner invited our attention to the averments contained in paragraphs 7 and 8 of the writ petition and argued that the punishment of removal imposed upon his client is liable to be voided on the ground of wholesale violation of Rule 8 of the Rules, inasmuch as, the punishing authority, namely, the State Government, did not issue the charge sheet so as to enable him to submit reply to the allegations on which the enquiry was proposed to be held: the enquiry officer did not give notice after 13.4.1985: the copy of enquiry report, if any, submitted by the enquiry officer was not make available to him and he was not given show cause notice and opportunity to make representation against the adverse finding, if any, recorded by the enquiry officer and the proposed punishment. Dr. Gupta further argued that the order of punishment is also vitiated due to violation of the provisions contained in Article 311 of the Constitution and basic rules of natural justice because at no stage the petitioner was given opportunity to defence himself.

    8. Ms. Rita Kohli, learned Deputy Advocate General, Punjab expressed her inability to show whether any charge sheet was issued to the petitioner in terms of Rule 8(3) and (4) of the Rules: whether Dr. Balwant Singh Tung recorded any evidence: whether the enquiry officer submitted report: whether the show cause notice was issued to the petitioner in terms of Article 311(2) of the Constitution and Rule 9 of the Rules (unamended); but tried to defend the impugned order by laying emphasis on the fact that he had absented from duty for a period of almost two years. She also tried to justify the procedure adopted by the enquiry officer by pointing out that registered letter dated 22.4.1985 sent at the last available address of the petitioner was returned undelivered.

    9. In my opinion, there is no merit in the submission of the learned Deputy Advocate General. The procedure prescribed under Rules 8 and 9 of the Rules for holding enquiry which constitutes a condition precedent for imposition of any of the major penalties specified in Rule 5 of the Rules is mandatory and represents the statutory embodiment of the rules of natural justice and concept of reasonable opportunity enshrined in Article 311 of the Constitution. Therefore, the wholesale infraction of the procedure laid down by the rule-making authority has the effect of vitiating the order of punishment. At rival violation of one or the other steps envisaged under Rules 8 and 9 of the Rules may not be sufficient to invalidate the order of punishment, but where the procedure is vitiated at every stage and results in prejudice to the delinquent, as has happened in the present case, there is no choice left with the Court except to nullify the order of punishment.

    10. At the cost of repetition. I deem it proper to observe that in the petitioner's case, the procedure contained in Rules 8 and 9 of the Rules for holding an enquiry for major penalty and provisions of Article 311 of the Constitution were vitiated at every stage, he was not served with the charge-sheet so as to enable him to file written statement of defence; he was not given list of documents and witnesses: he was not given effective opportunity to appear before the enquiry officer; the copy of enquiry report, if any, prepared by the enquiry officer was not made available to him; no show cause notice was given to him and he was not given opportunity to make representation against the adverse findings, if any, recorded by the enquiry officer and the punishing authority or the proposed punishment. It is, thus, evident that the impugned order was passed in gross violation of the Rules and the provisions of the Constitution and on that ground, it is liable to be quashed Khem Chand v. Union of India AIR 1958 SC 300,; State Of Madhya Pradesh v. Chintaman Sadashiva Waishampayan AIR 1961 SC 1623,; Major U.R Bhatt v. Union Of India AIR 1962 SC 1344,; The State of Mysore v. K. Manche Gowda AIR 1964 SC 506,; Moti Ram Deka v. General Manager, North East Frontier Railway AIR 1964 SC 600,; State of Uttar Pradesh v. Om Parkash Gupta 1969 3 SCC 775,; Uttar Pradesh Government v. Sabir Hussain 1975 4 SCC 703, and Kashinath Dikshita v. Union of India AIR 1968 SC 2118,.

    11. In view of the above conclusion, I do not deem it necessary to deal with other points raised in the petition.

    12. For the reasons mentioned above, the writ petition is allowed. Order Annexure P4 is quashed leaving the State Government free to take further action in accordance with law.

    R.M.S
    Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dr. Ved Parkash Pathak v. State Of Punjab And Another
    (Jan 7, 2004)