Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sections 323, 324, 326 read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code.
  • Sections 324, 323 read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code.
  • Section 319 Cr.P.C
  • Section 313 Cr.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sections 323, 324, 326 read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code.
  • Sections 324, 323 read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code.
  • Section 319 Cr.P.C
  • Section 313 Cr.P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

An F.I.R. No. 48 was registered on 5 March 1988 at 11:30 A.M. under Sections 324 and 323 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, on the basis of a statement by Shri Baljit Singh. Baljit's statement described an incident on 4 March 1988 in which he and his father were allegedly assaulted by Attar (son of Jamna Jat), Saranjit (son of Mukhtiar Jat) and Mukhtiar (son of Dulia Jat); Baljit alleged he received a deep cut on his foot from a blow of a kassi and his father was also struck.

Following investigation, a challan was filed and Attar Singh and Mukhtiar Singh were tried under Sections 323, 324, 326 read with Section 34 IPC. Saranjit was initially summoned under Section 319 Cr.P.C. but was said to be subject to Court Martial, so prosecution proceeded only against Attar and Mukhtiar. The prosecution examined eight witnesses (PW1–PW8). Statements under Section 313 Cr.P.C. of the accused were recorded; the accused examined two witnesses and one defence witness (DW2) was declared hostile. The learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Jhajjar, by judgment dated 17 September 1992, acquitted all the accused.

The State appealed against the acquittal. By order dated 6 April 1993, the Division Bench admitted the appeal only as to Attar Singh and dismissed the appeal qua Mukhtiar Singh. The present opinion addresses the appeal against Attar Singh's acquittal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution had proved the offence(s) against the accused beyond reasonable doubt, in light of contradictions in witness statements and other evidentiary gaps.
  2. Whether the statement of the accused recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C. amounted to an admission sufficient to sustain conviction.
  3. Whether the appellate court should interfere with the trial court's acquittal when the trial court's view is plausible and legally sustainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (State)'s Arguments

  • The State placed heavy reliance upon the statement of Attar Singh under Section 313 Cr.P.C., contending that it showed Mukhtiar Singh was present at the scene and that the injury was caused by a kassi, thereby supporting the prosecution's case.

Respondents / Accused (as reflected in the record)

  • Attar Singh's statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C., as recorded, denied culpability: he stated that Baljit himself was armed with a kassi and that Baljit sustained the kassi blow himself while Attar moved aside; Attar asserted Mukhtiar Singh and Saranjit were not present at the spot.
  • The trial court relied on contradictions in the prosecution witnesses (particularly between PW1 and PW3 and inconsistencies in PW1's earlier complaint and his later court statement) and deficiencies in the investigation (e.g., non-recovery of the alleged weapon and failure to collect potentially relevant material such as blood-stained earth) to acquit the accused.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Nirmal Pasi & Anr. v. State of Bihar (J.T. 2002 (6) SC 28) Authority regarding the use of statements recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C. — that such admissions may be noted and used by the court where appropriate. The court relied on this authority to explain the proper role of Section 313 admissions: they can be taken into account but must be read in their entirety and not selectively.
State of U.P. v. Lakhmi, 1998 (1) RCR (Cr.) 754 (SC) : J.T. 1998 (1) S.C. 679 Authority on the principles governing reliance on statements under Section 313 Cr.P.C. The court cited this case alongside Nirmal Pasi to underscore that incriminating admissions under Section 313 may be used but only after considering the statement wholly and in context.
Bhim Singh Rup Singh v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 1974 Supreme Court 286 Principle that an appellate court has power to review evidence in an appeal against acquittal but should not disturb a trial court's acquittal if the trial court's view is plausible and legally sustainable; if two reasonable conclusions are possible, the benefit should go to the accused. The court applied this principle to decline interference with the trial court's acquittal, finding the trial court's reasoning plausible and not perverse.
Chandrakant Ganpat Sovitkar etc. v. State of Maharashtra, A.I.R. 1974 S.C. 1290 Cited as supporting authority similar in principle to Bhim Singh regarding appellate review of acquittals. Used to reinforce the proposition that the High Court should not normally overturn an acquittal where the trial court's view is legally sustainable.
AIR 1961 SC 715 and AIR 1971 SC 460 (referenced in the Bhim Singh discussion) These authorities were referenced by way of judicial consistency in the explanation of the appellate court's approach to acquittals (as cited in the Bhim Singh passage). Mentioned in the judgment quote relied upon to explain the limits on appellate interference with acquittals; they supported the same appellate principle cited above.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the evidentiary record and the nature of the accused's statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C., and applied settled legal principles on admission and appellate interference with acquittals.

  1. The court noted that the trial court's acquittal was primarily based on material contradictions in the prosecution case — notably inconsistencies between PW1's complaint and his court statement about the nature of the blow (kassi versus phali), and contradictions among PW1, PW5 and PW6. The court treated these contradictions as relating to material facts and not merely informal discrepancies.
  2. The court examined Attar Singh's statement under Section 313 and found that the State had misread it. Rather than implicating the accused, Attar expressly stated that Baljit was armed with a kassi and that Baljit injured himself when he struck out with the kassi; Attar also stated that Mukhtiar and Saranjit were not present. On that basis the court concluded the statement did not supply the incriminating admission the State sought to rely upon.
  3. The court observed investigative and evidentiary deficiencies: the weapon allegedly used (kassi) was not recovered and no material evidence such as blood-stained earth was collected by the Investigating Officer, preventing the production of corroborative expert evidence. While the medico-legal report showed grievous injuries, that fact alone did not establish who inflicted the injury.
  4. The court reiterated the legal principle that statements recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C. must be considered in their entirety; courts cannot isolate a sentence or phrase from its context to found a conviction, particularly where the prosecution has otherwise failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt.
  5. The court applied the appellate principle (as expounded in Bhim Singh and related authorities) that an appellate court should not disturb a trial court's acquittal if the trial court's conclusion is plausible, possible and legally sustainable. Because the trial court's view met this threshold and was not perverse, appellate interference was not warranted.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED — The appeal against the acquittal was dismissed.

Direct effect: The acquittal of the accused(s) by the trial court stands and is not disturbed. The court found that the prosecution failed to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt and that the relied-upon statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. did not amount to a valid admission implicating the accused.

Broader implications: The judgment applies existing principles (as cited) concerning the proper use of Section 313 statements and the limited circumstances in which an appellate court may overturn an acquittal. The opinion does not purport to lay down any new precedent beyond reiterating these established principles.

    State Of Haryana v. Attar Singh S

    Swatanter Kumar, J. (Oral) — An F.I.R No. 48 was registered on 5th March, 1988 at 11.30 A.M under Sections 324, 323 read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code. It was recorded on the basis of statement of one Shri Baljit Singh, who stated as under :—

    “I am resident of Village Surethi and doing 10th class as a private student. Yesterday i.e, on 4.3.1988, I along with my father was going with a bicycle and I was following my father at a distance of about 15-20 yards. At about 1.30 P.M, when my father was about to cross his Gitwar, then Attar s/o Jamna Jat and Saranjit s/o Mukhtiar Jat came from the opposite directions. All of sudden, Attar Singh gave a fist blow on the mouth of my father who fell down with his bicycle. On raising a hue and cry, I ran towards them and Saranjit caught hold of me in his arms when I reached there. At this, Sh. Ram Kishan s/o Sarup Lal Jat advised not to fight but in the meantime, Mukhtiar son of Dulia Jat reached there and exhorted by saying “leave aside the old man and set the boy right”. On hearing this, Attar Singh who was holding a Kassi, gave a blow of it, a little above my left ankle. On receiving the Kassi blow, I fell down and there was a deep cut on my feet. On an alarm raised by us, all the said three persons together with the Kassi fled away and entered the house of Sh. Rattan. Thereafter, Sh. Ram Kishan and my father brought me home and afterward, got me admitted in the hospital at Jhajjar. Earlier, on 2.9.1985, Attar etc. had a fight with us, in which my brother Sarup and father sustained injuries. A case was registered. In the year 1987, the villagers got effected the compromise between both the parties in the Sessions Court, Rohtak. But Attar etc. harboured grudge despite the compromise and deliberately caused injuries in order to suffer my studies. I was intervening into the matter to avert any untoward incident and due to festival. Sh. Ram Kishan has helped me after coming out of his house and has seen the occurrence. I have heard the statement and the same is correct.”

    2. After investigation, a challan was filed in the court of competent jurisdiction and the accused Attar Singh and Mukhtiar Singh were set to face trial under sections 323, 324, 326 read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code. Vide order dated 9.3.1989, learned trial Court had summoned Saranjit under Section 319 Cr.P.C However, subsequently, it was informed to the learned trial court that Saranjit belongs to armed forces and was being subjected to trial by the Court Martial for the offences, as such, vide order dated 7.12.1989, the prosecution progressed only against two accused Attar Singh and Mukhtiar Singh. The prosecution has examined Baljit Singh PW.1, Dr. A.K Bhutani PW2, Dr. S.K Gosain PW3, Dharam Pal PW.4, Balle Ram PW5, Ram Kishan PW6, Rajinder Singh PW7 and I.O Ram Kumar PW8, to prove its case. The statements of the accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C were recorded by’ the court and they also examined two witnesses. However, DW2 was declared hostile during his examination. Learned Judicial Magistrate Ist Class, Jhajjar, vide his judgment dated 17.9.1992 acquitted all the accused.

    3. The State preferred an appeal against the acquittal of both the accused. However, vide order dated 6th April, 1993, the Division Bench while admitting the appeal granted leave to appeal only against Attar Singh and dismissed the appeal qua Mukhtiar Singh.

    4. We may notice that acquittal of the accused by the learned trial court was mainly based upon contradictory statements of PW.1 and PW.3 and the fact that the injured himself in the complaint had stated that the injuries were caused by Kassi while in his statement before the Court he had stated that injuries were caused by Phali blow. The reasoning given by the learned trial court for acquitting both the accused does not in any way appear to be contrary to the settled canons of law and certainly the prosecution had failed to prove its case against the accused. Learned counsel appearing for the State places heavy reliance upon the statement of Attar Singh under Section 313 Cr.P.C to contend that Mukhtiar Singh was present at the site and he also stated that injury was caused by Kassi and as such the case of the prosecution is fully supported even by the statement of accused under section 313 of the Cr.P.C

    5. This argument of the learned counsel for the State suffers from basic fallacy. The counsel has failed to read the statement of the accused in its entirety. The statement of Attar Singh does not implicate himself. On the contrary, it is specifically stated by him as under :—

    “…In the meantime, Sh. Baljit armed with a kassi who was returning from the field, also reached there. When he gave a blow of Kassi to me, I moved to other side to ward off the blow and as such he sustained the Kassi blow on his feet by himself. I went to the house of Sh. Rattan. Mukhtiar Singh and Saranjit were not present at the spot…”

    6. The above statement of Attar Singh is clear on two facts; firstly that none of the accused was armed with kassi and secondly none of them was responsible for the injury suffered by Baljit Singh. It is also not disputed before us even by the learned counsel for the State that the weapon of offence (kassi) was not recovered. Material and cogent evidence in the shape of blood stain earth was not even collected by the Investigating Officer and as such the expert evidence in that regard could not be produced by the prosecution. In light of these facts, we cannot accept the contention of the State that statement of Attar Singh should be taken to be admission in evidence, entire or in part. There are material discrepancies and contradiction in the statements of the different witnesses particularly PW. 1, PW.5 and PW.6 Learned trial court has rightly observed that to some extent they lend support to the case put forward by the defence. According to the prosecution accused Saranjit caught hold of Baljit while accused Attar Singh gave Kassi blow on the left leg of Baljit and when the complainant rushed to rescue his father then, the accused Attar Singh gave fist blow to him and he fell down. However, in his earlier statement, he had stated that accused Saranjit Singh caught hold of me and accused Attar Singh, who was holding Kassi in his hands gave its below on his ankle as a result of which he fell down on the ground and his leg was cut. According to the statement of PW. 1 in court, he has stated that Saranjit Singh caught hold of him from behind and accused Attar Singh gave a Phali blow on his left leg due to which his leg was cut. This clearly shows that contradiction relates to material facts of the prosecution case. There was only one major injury allegedly suffered by Baljit Singh, which too was on his leg, as such, he was expected to state one and the same version at all relevant point of time which ought to be the truth. The contradictions and discrepancies are not of informal nature. The medical evidence, as reflected in the medico legal report exhibit P.4 shows grievous injuries on the person of Baljit Singh but that by itself would not render the accused guilty of the offence. The prosecution must prove commission of the offence beyond reasonable doubt and ought to establish the fact that injury in question was caused by Attar Singh.

    7. We may also notice that object of recording the statement of the accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C is to put all incriminating evidence against the accused so as to provide him an opportunity to explain such incriminating circumstances appearing in the evidence against him/them. At the same time, it is also correct that an incriminating circumstance which accused admitted in his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C in that event the court could take note of such admission and they need not be ignored by the court and can be used for arriving at a finding that the accused had committed the offence. Reference in this regard can be made to the cases of Nirmal Pasi & Anr. v. State of Bihar, J.T 2002 (6) SC 28 and State Of U.P v. Lakhmi, 1998 (1) RCR (Cr.) 754 (SC) : J.T 1998 (1) S.C 679.

    8. Applying these principles to the facts of the present case, at best, it can be said that Attar Singh admitted the occurrence and the fact that Baljit Singh suffered an injury with the Kassi which he was carrying. The admission of the accused has to be taken in its entirety and the court cannot pick up one sentence and read the same de hors the entire paragraph and make the same as basis for conviction of the accused, more particularly and despite the fact that where prosecution has failed to prove its case. Furthermore, on the basis of the evidence produced on record, learned trial court acquitted the accused. The view taken by the learned trial court cannot be termed as perverse or contrary to the evidence on record. The judgment is also in consonance with the settled principle of law. Once the trial court has taken a view which is plausible, possible and is legally sustainable, the High Court would not normally interfere in such a view only for the reason that another view could not be taken. Advantage thereof must go to the accused. Reference in this regard can also be made to the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case Bhim Singh Rup Singh v. State Of Maharashtra , AIR 1974 Supreme Court 286 and Chandrakant Ganpat Sovitkar etc. v. State of Maharashtra, A.I.R 1974 S.C 1290. In Bhim Singh Rup Singh's case (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under :—

    “…. The appellate court has power to review the entire evidence and to come to its own conclusion in an appeal against acquittal. In exercising this power the appellate court, should not only consider every matter on record having a bearing on the questions of fact and the reasons given by the court below in support of its order of acquittal but it must express its reasons in its judgment which led it to hold that the acquittal is not justified. The appellate court must bear in mind the fact that the trial court had the benefit of seeing the witnesses in the witness box and the presumption of innocence is not weakened by the order of acquittal. Therefore, if two reasonable conclusions can be reached on the basis of the evidence on record, the appellate court should not disturb the findings of the trial court. AIR 1961 SC 715 and AIR 1971 SC 460, Rel. on.”

    9. For the reasons afore-stated, we find no merit in this appeal against acquittal. The same is dismissed.

    Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Haryana v. Attar Singh S
    (Jan 6, 2003)