Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 489-A to 489-D, Indian Penal Code.
  • Section 489B or 489C, Indian Penal Code.
  • Sections 463 and 464, Indian Penal Code,
  • Section 28 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 420/511, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 420/511, Indian Panal Code,
  • Section 489C, Indian Penal Code,
  • Section 489B, Indian Penal Code,
  • Section 34, Indian Penal Code.
  • Section 28, Indian Penal Code,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 489-A to 489-D, Indian Penal Code.
  • Section 489B or 489C, Indian Penal Code.
  • Sections 463 and 464, Indian Penal Code,
  • Section 28 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 420/511, Indian Penal Code
  • Section 420/511, Indian Panal Code,
  • Section 489C, Indian Penal Code,
  • Section 489B, Indian Penal Code,
  • Section 34, Indian Penal Code.
  • Section 28, Indian Penal Code,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal by Bachan Singh (an iron-smith) and his wife Joginder Kaur, residents of Ludhiana, against convictions arising from an incident on 17-6-1978.

According to the trial court's findings (not seriously disputed on appeal): on 17-6-1978 Joginder Kaur approached Kundan Lai (P.W.1) to get a ten-rupee note (Exhibit P.1) changed. Kundan Lai noticed one side darker than the other and suspected the note was not genuine; his suspicion was confirmed by his son and a neighbouring shopkeeper, Dalip Singh (P.W.3). A police party led by Assistant Sub-Inspector Jagjit Singh (P.W.4) arrived, and Kundan Lai made a statement (Exhibit P.C.) that gave rise to the first information report. At that time Bachan Singh was with his wife. The Assistant Sub-Inspector arrested both; on personal search of Bachan Singh thirteen counterfeit currency notes (Exhibits P.2 to P.14) and "other 21 ten rupee notes" were recovered. The prosecution relied on the evidence of Kundan Lai, Dalip Singh and the Assistant Sub-Inspector; the trial judge convicted both appellants.

The appellants presented differing defences: Joginder Kaur said she alone was in the bazaar and offered Exhibit P.1 for change because she needed rickshaw fare, that Kundan Lai said the note was not genuine and that she was then taken to the police station and falsely implicated. Bachan Singh claimed he was at home when the police came, demanded money to secure his wife's release, beat him, took away Rs. 1,400 from his house and then implicated him; he had medical evidence and filed a complaint against the Assistant Sub-Inspector (Exhibit D.A.). The trial judge rejected the defence and convicted both appellants.

Trial convictions (as recorded in the opinion): Joginder Kaur: convicted under Section 420/511 IPC (two years RI + Rs.500 fine), Section 489B IPC (four years RI + Rs.500 fine) and Section 489C IPC (two years RI); sentences to run concurrently. Bachan Singh: convicted under Section 489C IPC (four years RI + Rs.500 fine).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether "made-up" notes (notes composed of parts of two different genuine notes joined together) can properly be described as "counterfeit" or "forged" for the purposes of Sections 489A–489D and the related offences in the Indian Penal Code.
  2. Whether mere possession of such made-up/forged notes is sufficient to convict under Section 489C (and related provisions), or whether the prosecution must also prove that the accused knew or had reason to believe the notes to be forged/counterfeit and intended to use them as genuine.
  3. Whether, on the facts of this case, prosecution evidence established the requisite knowledge and intent for conviction of (a) Joginder Kaur (who had one made-up note and was illiterate) and (b) Bachan Singh (who was found with thirteen made-up notes).

Arguments of the Parties

Prosecution's Case (as presented at trial and relied on by the trial judge)

  • The prosecution adduced testimony (Kundan Lai P.W.1, Dalip Singh P.W.3 and Assistant Sub-Inspector Jagjit Singh P.W.4) describing detection of a suspect ten-rupee note and subsequent arrest and recovery of multiple made-up notes from the accused (Exs. P.1–P.14 and additional ten-rupee notes).
  • The prosecution relied on the recoveries and the bank/expert report (Exhibit P.D.) regarding the nature of the notes to ground convictions under Sections 420/511, 489B and 489C IPC.

Defence Arguments

  • Joginder Kaur: she asserted that she alone went to the shop to change a note for rickshaw fare, was told the note was not genuine, offered another note, and was then taken to the police station and falsely implicated. She was illiterate and had only the single note on her person.
  • Bachan Singh: denied being present at the place when the note was tendered; claimed police misconduct at his house (demand for Rs.200, beating, and seizure of Rs.1,400) and asserted he was falsely involved; he produced a medical exam and a complaint (Exhibit D.A.) against the Assistant Sub-Inspector. He argued it was difficult to dislodge the prosecution on factual recoveries but advanced predominately legal contentions on appeal (challenging sufficiency of proof of knowledge/intent).
  • Learned counsel for appellants submitted that legal issues (knowledge, intention and meaning of "counterfeit"/"forged" for made-up notes) were decisive and that the convictions should be set aside on that legal basis.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bur Singh v. The Crown (1930) ILR 11 Lah 555; (1931) 32 Cri LJ 351 Principle that mere possession of a forged note is not by itself an offence under the IPC; to convict under Section 489C it must be proved that (a) at the time of possession the accused knew or had reason to believe the notes to be forged/counterfeit, and (b) the accused intended to use the notes as genuine. Intention may be proved by collateral circumstances (e.g., palming off notes before, or possession in such numbers that alternative explanations are implausible). The court applied this authority to conclude that both appellants were not proved to have the requisite knowledge and intent. For Joginder, a single note and her illiteracy and lack of other incriminating circumstances meant intent was not proved. For Bachan, although he had 13 notes, the prosecution failed to exclude other plausible explanations (including conversion to the Reserve Bank of India) and did not establish knowledge/intent beyond reasonable doubt; accordingly both were acquitted.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a series of analytic steps rooted in the evidence and statutory definitions contained in the IPC:

  1. Nature of the notes: The court accepted the evidence of the State Bank deputy manager (P.W.2, Exhibit P.D.) that the exhibits were "made-up" notes — each composed of two portions of two different genuine notes joined together. P.W.2 explained that such made-up notes can resemble genuine notes, may deceive an average or illiterate person, are not produced by mechanical printing (and thus differ from classical "forgery"), and are ordinarily rejected by banks though they may be sent to the Reserve Bank of India for processing.
  2. Statutory meaning of "counterfeit" and "forgery": The court referred to Section 28 IPC (definition of "counterfeit") and to Sections 463–464 IPC (definitions pertaining to forgery). It rejected the view that "counterfeit" is confined to coins and concluded that the statutory definition of counterfeiting is not so limited.
  3. Application to made-up notes: The court analysed whether joining two original portions creates a new thing that "resembles" the genuine note for the purposes of counterfeiting. It held that making a made-up note that is intended to be or likely to be used to resemble a genuine note falls within the mischief of Sections 489A–489D (i.e., counterfeiting for currency offences). However, because no mechanical or printing process was involved in making the made-up notes, they are not "forged" in the technical sense under Sections 463–464.
  4. Requirements for conviction under Sections 489B/489C: Relying on Bur Singh, the court reiterated that to sustain convictions under these sections the prosecution must prove (a) possession together with knowledge or reason to believe the notes to be forged/counterfeit, and (b) the intention to use them as genuine. Mere possession, by itself, is insufficient.
  5. Application to Joginder Kaur: The court found that Joginder had only one made-up note, was illiterate, and there was no evidence she had palmed off such notes previously or that she attempted to pass the note after being warned it was not genuine. The prosecution did not prove dishonest intention to cause wrongful loss or to gain. There was also no allegation of common intention with her husband under Section 34 IPC. On these bases the prosecution failed to prove the essential mental elements; the court extended the benefit of doubt to her.
  6. Application to Bachan Singh: Although Bachan was found with thirteen made-up notes, the court held that the prosecution still had to prove knowledge/reason to believe and an intention to use them as genuine. The court noted P.W.2's evidence of an open trade in such notes and the possibility of conversion via the Reserve Bank of India (albeit at a loss). That possibility made possession explainable other than an intention to pass them as genuine. No collateral circumstances were produced (e.g., prior palming-off, such large-scale possession as to render any other purpose inexplicable). Therefore the requisite mental elements were not proved beyond reasonable doubt and Bachan too was entitled to the benefit of doubt.
  7. Conclusion on analysis: In light of the statutory definitions, expert evidence as to the nature and market for made-up notes, and the lack of proof of knowledge and intent in the individual cases, the court found the convictions could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal was allowed and the appellants were acquitted. The court ordered that the appellants be extended the benefit of doubt and be acquitted of the charges as recorded at trial.

Core Ruling: The appeal is ALLOWED and the appellants are ACQUITTED.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The convictions and sentences entered by the trial court (as set out in the opinion) were set aside for both appellants; they were acquitted.
  • Legal clarification in the opinion: The court distinguished "made-up" notes from technical forgery (Sections 463–464) while concluding that "made-up" notes can fall within the statutory notion of "counterfeit" for the purposes of Sections 489A–489D, but convictions under those sections still require proof of knowledge/reason to believe and intention to use as genuine. The opinion emphasises the necessity of proving the accused's mental state — mere possession is not per se sufficient.
  • Broader precedent-setting: The opinion applies established principles (including Bur Singh) to the facts; it does not assert the creation of a novel legal rule beyond its interpretation that made-up notes are not "forged" by mechanical printing but may amount to "counterfeit" for currency offences, subject to proof of mental elements. The decision's direct consequence is the acquittal of these appellants on the record before the court.

This summary is prepared exclusively from the provided opinion text and does not add information beyond that text.

    Bachan Singh And Anr. v. The State Of Punjab

    1. This is an appeal by Bachan Singh, an iron-smith and his wife Joginder Kaur, an illiterate lady, both residents of Ludhiana.

    2. The facts as found by the trial Judge and which are not seriously disputed in the present appeal are thus:

    On 17-6-1978, Kundan Lai, P.W. 1, was approached, by Jogisder Kaur appellant with a ten rupee currency note, Exhibit P. 1, asking for its change. He checked the note in the light and observed that the note had one side darker than the other. He suspected it not to be genuine. His suspicion was confirmed by his son Vishwa Nath and his neighbouring shop-keeper Dalip Singh P.W. 3. 1982 Cri, L. J./3 I In the meantime the police party headed by Assistant Sub-Inspector Jagjit Singh, P.W. 4, reached there, Kundan Lai, P.W. 1, made statement Exhibit P. C. to the Assistant Sub-Inspector which became the basis of the first information report. At that time Bachan Singh appellant was with his wife. The Assistant Sub-Inspector arrested both the accused and on personal search of Bachan Singh thirteen counterfeit currency notes, Exhibits P. 2 to P. 14 and other 21 ten rupee notes were recovered. These facts stood supported on the evidence of Kundan Lai, P.W. 1, Dalip Singh, P.W. 3 and Assistant Sub-Inspector Jagjit Singh, P.W. 4, whose statements have been relied upon by the trial Judge in recording the order of conviction.

    3. The defence is at variance. According to Joginder Kaur, she alone was in the bazaar and had approached Kundan Lai, P. W, 1 offering him the note, Exhibit P. 1, for change since she had to pay rickshaw fare. Kundan Lai, P.W. 1, told her that the note was not genuine and then she offered another note. On this there was an altercation and she was taken to the police station and falsely implicated. Bachan Singh appellant claimed that when his wife was in the police station he was present in his house when Assistant Sub-Inspector Jagjit Singh, P.W. 4 and some constables came there, demanded of him Rs, 200/- to secure release of his wife and on his disinclination beat him, took away Rs. 1400/- from his box lying in his house and then he was falsely involved in the case. He got himself medically examined. He even filed a complaint against Assistant Sub-Inspector Jagjit Singh in which the latter was summoned. Exhibit D. A. was a copy of the complaint. The defence was rejected by the trial Judge.

    4. Joginder Kaur was convicted:

    (i) Under Section 420/511, Indian Penal Code for attempting to cheat Kundan Lai, P.W. 1. She was sentenced to two years rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs, 500/-; in default six months rigorous imprisonment;

    (ii) Under Section 489B, Indian Penal Code, for trafficking in or using as genuine a forged or a counterfeit currency note knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit. For such offence she was sentenced to four years rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 500/-; in default six months rigorous imprisonment; and

    (iii) Under Section 489C, Indian Penal Code for having in her possession a forged or counterfeit currency note knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit and intended to use the same as genuine. For such offence she was sentenced to two years rigorous imprisonment. All the sentences were ordered to run concurrently.

    5. Bachan Singh was convicted and sentenced:

    (i) Under Section 489C, Indian Penal Code for having in his possession forged or counterfeit currency notes knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit and intended to use the same as genuine. For such offence he was sentenced to four years rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 500/-; in default six months rigorous imprisonment.

    6. Shri R. S. Palta, learned Counsel for the appellants rightly considered that it would be an uphill task to dislodge the prosecution version as far as the recoveries of the notes from the respective two appellants are concerned. Though Assistant Sub-Inspector Jagjit Singh, P.W. 4, has been attributed false implication of Bachan Singh appellant, there is nothing to point out against the truthfulness and credibility of the evidence of Kundan Lai, P.W. 1 and Dalip Singh, P.W. 3, who are shop-keepers by profession at Ludhiana having no truck with the police. His contentions are predominately legal on the strength of which he has argued for the acquittal of the appellants.

    7. At the outset it would be essential to pictorially describe the notes in question. Concededly all the notes in question, Exhibits P. 1 and P. 2 to P. 14 look like currency notes, for each of them is nothing but two portions of two different currency notes joined together. That is why they have been termed as "made up notes" by P.W. 2 Shri Dar-shan Kumar Ahluwalia, Deputy Manager of the State Bank of India, Ludhiana, to whom the matter was referred for Information and he gave his report Ex- hibit P. D. The following extracts of his statement may be taken note of:

    Forged currency notes can also be prepared with certain dye, with a mechanical process. There are other made up notes which are also forged. The made up notes can also resemble the true notes. I have seen ten rupee note Ex. P. 1. If this note is given to an average man along with other currency notes, it can pass as a genuine note. An illiterate person can also be misled when such a note is given to him. If note Ex. P. 1, is presented to the bank only with portion A to A or B to B, the bank will not change it. The bank cannot accept torn currency notes or in pieces. I have seen currency notes Exs. P. 1, P. 25 to P. 33, these notes bear different nos. These are not genuine notes. These are made-up notes. Ex. P. 34 and Ex. p. 35 also bears two different nos. and these notes are also made-up notes. All the note(s) can be passed off as genuine notes if these notes are given separately in packets.

    * * * * * There is difference between counterfeit and made-up notes. Volunteered, counterfeiting is only in coins. I have seen all the printed notes in this case. These notes are joined of the originally printed notes from the Government press. If the entire note is joined and have same no., the bank can take it. If one of the numbers of the note is torn or missing, the bank does not accept it.

    * * * * * I have seen currency notes Exs. P. 3 to P. 24. The bank will not accept these notes, because they are made up notes from different pieces of the notes. But if such notes are given to the bank to be sent to the R. B. I. on the payment of the current notes, these may be sent to the Reserve Bank of India. By payment I mean that all the expenses for collection. Volunteered in my opinion these notes will be rejected even by the Reserve Bank of India. m a * * * * * * * It is correct that few persons sit near clock tower Ludhiana and deal in the business of sale and purchase of torn-notes, while some others do such business while coming in the street. Such persons do not bring the torn notes to the State Bank, a3 we do not accept those notes, they directly send the same to the Reserve Bank of India. The torn Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab and also worn-out notes are dealt with only by the Reserve Bank of India.

    * * * * * The word forged regarding the exhibited notes in this case used by me in my above statement have been wrongly stated, because forging of currency notes pertains to printing. By 'made up' currency notes. I mean joining of different pieces of legal and genuine notes."

    8. Having known the nature of the notes in question it requires to be determined whether such 'made up' notes can be called counterfeit or forged notes. Section 28, Indian Penal Code, defines the word 'counterfeit'. It is to the following effect:

    28. A person is said to "counterfeit" who causes one thing to resemble another thing, intending by means of that resemblance to practise deception or knowing it to be likely that deception will thereby be practised. Explanation****

    9. Sections 489A to 489D were originally not in the Indian Penal Code but were introduced later by the Currency Notes Forgery Act (XII of 1899). Since in the aforesaid sections the word 'counterfeit' has been employed it is futile to confine the definition of the word 'counterfeit' given in Section 28 of the Indian Penal Code to coins alone. P.W. 2 Sh. Darshan Kumar Ahluwalia too wishes to confine counterfeiting to coins but that impression of his is plainly wrong. But can 'made-up notes' be termed as 'counterfeit notes' is one question and the other one is can 'made-up notes' be 'forged notes'. Now counterfeiting is a process by which one thing is caused to resemble another thing. It presupposes that there is an original. The act of counterfeiting is the effect of producing another so as to resemble the original, and the object of which is to practise deception, or knowing it likely that the deception will thereby be practised. In a 'made-up note' both parts thereof are original portions of the genuine notes. Could two different portions of two genuine currency notes by putting them together amount to counterfeiting is a subtle question which poses to be answered. If it is taken that by joining two different pieces of two genuine currency notes, the end-product in the shape of a made-up note would still be a genuine currency note then it would not be counterfeiting. But if it is taken that by joining two different portions of two different currency notes would turn out the end-product to be a note which is made to resemble the genuine currency note (represented by one part or the other part) then obviously a new thing has come into being so as to resemble another. The object of placing together two different pieces of two genuine currency notes as a made-up note presupposea to create a new legal tender which it otherwise is not. The mere fact thaj; such notes are changeable at face value from the Reserve Bank of India it being its issuing authority as the promissor thereof, and giving the bearer the sum represented in the note torn is of no consequence. But in order to retain the character of a currency note it has to maintain its original character and any act practised to make it resemble like if retaining its original character, would to my mind be counterfeiting so as to come within the mischief of Sections 489-A to 489-D, Indian Penal Code. There can be no quarrel with the opinion expressed by Sh. Darshan Kumar Ahluwalia, P.W. 2, that a made-up note is not a forged note since no mechanical process is involved. Since no process as is known to Sections 463 and 464, Indian Penal Code, is involved in making a made-up note, the allegation of forgery to my mind is completely out in the process.

    10. In order to sustain the conviction of Joginder Kaur appellant, the prosecution has not only to prove that she had the possession of counterfeit note, Exhibit P. 1, ensuring it or having reason to believe it as such, but further to prove circumstances which lead clearly indubitably and irresistibly to her in-, tention to use the notes on the public as has been held in Bur Singh v. The Crown (1930) ILR 11 Lah 555 : 1931) 32 Cri LJ 351. It has further been held that such intention could be proved by a collateral circumstance that she had palmed off such notes before, or that she was in possession of such notes in such large numbers, that her possession for any other purpose was inexplicable. The facts as found are that she had on her person only one made-up note, that she was an illiterate lady and that anybody as Sh. Darshan Kumar Ahluwalia, P, W, 2, would have us believe could be misled to treat it as a genuine note. She gave the note to Kundan Lai, P.W. 2 and he told her that it was not a genuine note and his belief was confirmed when he showed it to others as well. It has nowhere been asserted that the note was ever returned to her and having known fully well or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit she yet made another attempt to palm it off. Thus tendering alone such note to Kundan Lai, P.W., unless the prosecution could prove that it was with dishonest intention so as to cause wrongful loss to him and wrong- ful gain to herself would not make her act to fall squarely within Section 420/511, Indian Panal Code, or to have come within the mischief of Section 489B or 489C, Indian Penal Code. The inference sought to be drawn that she must have known or reason to believe the note, Exhibit P 1, to be counterfeit because her husband accompanying her was found to be in possession of similar notes is entirely misplaced for no common intention has been attributed to them and they have not been charged with the aid of Section 34, Indian Penal Code. For the individual act of Jogin- der kaur she cannot be convicted for the above named offences and must be extended the benefit of doubt.

    11. With regard to the case of Bachan Singh it is to be noted that he was found in possession of 13 counterfeit ten rupee notes. He is an iron-smith by profession and barely literate. How could he have the knowledge or reason to believe the same to be counterfeit is one part but the other important part is whether he intended to use the same as genuine or that they may be used as genuine has further to be proved by the prosecution. It was held in Bur Singh v. The Crown, {(1931) 32 Cri LJ 351) (Lah) (supra), that mere possession of a forged note is not an offence under the Indian Penal Code and in order to bring a case within the purview of Section 489C, Indian Penal Code, it was not only necessary to prove that the accused was in possession of forged notes but it should forther be established that

    (a) at the time of his possession he knew the notes to be forged or had the reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit; and

    (b) he intended to use the same as genuine. No further collateral circum- stances in the case have been brought forth such as the accused had palmed off such notes before, or that he was in possession of such and similar notes in such large numbers, that his possession for any other purpose was inexplicable,

    12. It has been Emitted by Darshan Kumar Ahluwalia, P.W. 2, that there is an open trade going about these notes for they ultimately can be cashed with the Reserve Bank of India and in some cases subject to charges being paid by local banks also_ In other Word though they are not legal tender but these notes have some apparent but depreciated value The possibility cannot be ruled out that the possession of such notes with the appellant was for the purpose of such conversion from the Reserve Bank of India Thus it cannot be inferred that he intended to use them as genuine in the made up form as legal currency or intended that they may be so use Thus to him as well benefit of doubt must be extended. No presumption can be raised against him merely because his wife accompanying him had offered a similar kind of note for use as genuine

    13. For the foregoing reasons this appeal merits acceptance. It is hereby allowed, the appellants are extended the benefit of doubt and are acquitted of the charges.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bachan Singh And Anr. v. The State Of Punjab
    (Feb 24, 1981)