In the matter of an application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
****
Dr. Vikas Singh, S/O Sri Umesh Prasad Singh,
resident of RCA-30, near North Boundary Wall
of T.V. Tower, Bahadurpur Housing Colony,
Kankerbagh, P.S. Agamkuan, district Patna .. Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through it's Principal Secretary, Health, Medical
Education and Family Welfare Department, Government of Bihar, Vikas
Bhawan, Bailey Road, Patna
2. The Patna University through it's Registrar, Ashok Raj Path, Patna 4
3. The Vice Chancellor, Patna University, Ashok Raj Path, Patna 4
4. The Controller of Examination, Patna University, Ashok Raj Path, Patna 4
5. The Principal, Patna Medical College & Hospital, Ashok Raj Path, Patna 4
6. Prof. Dr. Vijay Prakash, Professor and Head of the Department of
Medicine, Patna Medical College & Hospital, Patna
7. The Registrar, Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research,
Chandigarh .. Respondents
****
For the petitioner .. Mr. Chandra Shekhar,
Sr. Adv. With
M/S Dr. A.K. Upadhyay &
L.B. Singh, Advs.
2. Petitioner had initially filed this application for a direction
to the respondent Patna University not to publish result of M.D. (General
Medicine) 2005-2008 and to conduct fresh examination of clinical/viva
voce and practical by constituting a team of externals, who are experts in
the field of medicine. Further, prayer was to set up enquiry into the
manipulation made by respondent no. 6 in the matter of examination and
result in M.D. (General Medicine) 2005-2008 and to take suitable action
against respondent no. 6 for abusing the high office.
3. During the pendency of the writ application, petitioner has
filed a number of interlocutory applications vide I.A. Nos. 6064, 6223
and 6224 of 2008 and also I.A. No. 7300 of 2008. I.A. No. 6064 of 2008
was filed with a prayer to call for entire records connected with M.D.
(General Medicine) 2005-2008 examination and evaluation and for a
direction not to destroy answer books of candidates of theory paper of the
concerned examination. This application was disposed off presuming
that during the pendency of the writ application the University will not
destroy the connected records till the final disposal of the main case. I.A.
No. 6223 of 2008 was filed for a direction to respondent University to
disassociate respondent no. 6 from conducting the examination. This
interlocutory application was disposed off as for similar direction
representation of the petitioner was pending before the Vice Chancellor.
I.A. No. 6224 of 2008 was for a direction to the Post Graduate Institute of
Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, to entertain petitioner's
application for entrance test for admission in session 2009 as on account
of failure in M.D. (General Medicine) 2005-2008 the petitioner was not
supposed to be eligible for appearing in entrance test. This application
was also disposed off treating it as premature, with an observation that
petitioner may apply for appearing in the entrance test at an appropriate
time in M.D. Course mentioning about the pendency of the present writ
application and the Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and
Research, Chandigarh, will have liberty to consider the same. I.A. No.
7300 of 2008 was filed by the petitioner for a direction to the Registrar,
Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh,
to allow him to appear in entrance test. By filing this interlocutory
application, petitioner brought this fact in the notice of the Court that
after his failure in M.D. (General Medicine) 2005-2008 (which is under
challenge), the petitioner appeared in the next M.D. examination held by
Patna University and has been declared successful. The petitioner
wanted to apply for D.M. Course in Cardiology at the P.G.I.M.E.R.,
Chandigarh, and the prayer was for a direction to the Registrar of the
institute concerned to allow him to appear in the entrance examination.
Publication of result and admission in the course being subject to final
judgment passed in the writ application. This interlocutory application
was allowed, the Registrar, Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education
and Research, Chandigarh, was added as respondent no. 7.
4. Petitioner, in the present writ application, has alleged
malice in law as well as malice in fact. Malice in law and malice in fact
has been alleged against respondent no. 6, who is the Head of the
Department of Medicine, Patna Medical College & Hospital. Allegation
has also been made against Patna University that M.D. (General
Medicine) 2005-2008 examination has been conducted in violation of
Patna University Act and Rules as well as the Medical Council of India
Regulation 2000.
5. The petitioner has claimed to have a most outstanding
academic record throughout his career. It has been stated that right from
his school days till passing his M.B.B.S. course, the petitioner has passed
all examination with high marks. He joined Patna Medical College &
Hospital for his M.B.B.S. Course on the basis of B.C.E.C.E. 1998
Examination. His place in the merit list was at serial no. 19. In the
M.B.B.S. examination he was awarded several gold medals for being best
student of his batch, highest marks in the final M.B.B.S. examination and
highest marks in paediatrics, surgery and medicine. He was selected for
M.D. (General Medicine) on the basis of competition and got admitted in
the course in Patna Medical College & Hospital for the session 2005-
2008. The petitioner and one Harsh Vardhan were enrolled in the unit of
Dr. Vijay Prakash for M.D. on 16.04.2005. Subsequently, on 27.04.2005,
third student Dr. Prakash joined the unit. As per the curriculum of M.D.
(General Medicine) petitioner took research work under the supervision
of respondent no. 6 on the subject
Estimation of Microalbuniunia in
Young Diabetic Patients and it's correlation of Clinical Profile of Patients
and Glycaemic Control
. Petitioner completed his research and prepared
his thesis. He presented the thesis with seal and signature of Dr. Vijay
Prakash as his supervisor on 13.10.2007. On submission of his thesis it
was to be forwarded by the supervisor/guide, but, the petitioner was
directed by respondent no. 6 to remove page no. 2 and 5 from his thesis
containing the foreword and acknowledgement drawn in the name of
respondent no. 6. At this juncture the petitioner was informed that his
guide has been changed and the foreword and acknowledgement is to be
replaced by inserting the foreword to Dr. Vibhu Priyadarshi. The
petitioner did not have any knowledge regarding change of supervisor as
he continued to work under respondent no. 6 all through his research
period. This is the instance which petitioner corelates to malafide alleged
against respondent no. 6. Petitioner's case is that after his enrolment in
the M.D. Course, respondent no. 6 approached his parents to negotiate
marriage of his daughter with the petitioner, but, the negotiation could
not materialize. In May 2006 petitioner got married as per the desire of
his parents and non-acceptance of proposal of marriage by petitioner's
parents prejudiced respondent no. 6 subsequent to petitioner's marriage.
Respondent no. 6 being Professor and Head of the Department of
Medicine, started acting prejudicial to the interest of petitioner. Out of
vengeance, he changed petitioner's supervisor in a most illegal and
arbitrary manner though synopsis of his thesis was signed by respondent
no. 6. Legally change of guide can be done only with the approval of the
Members of Post Graduate Research Council. Agenda of Post Graduate
Research Council meeting, dated 25.03.2006, was circulated among the
Members of the Council and the meeting was scheduled to be held on
29.03.2006. There was no agenda regarding change of guide with respect
to the petitioner. In the meeting, dated 29.03.2006, agenda relating to
change of guide of petitioner or any one was not discussed and no
resolution was taken in this regard. Only thesis of candidates were
approved. Resolution of the meeting indicates respondent no. 6 as guide
of petitioner. Subsequently, without any approval of the Post Graduate
Research Council a letter, dated 25.05.2006, was sent by the Assistant
Registrar, Patna University, to the Dean, Faculty of Medicine, Patna
University, whereby list of candidates whose thesis were approved in the
meeting of P.G.R.C., dated 29.03.2006, was communicated. In this letter
name of petitioner's guide was changed without any prior approval of
P.G.R.C. Counsel for the petitioner has submitted that whenever there is
change of guide a specific resolution is taken, in this regard, by the Post
Graduate Research Council. In support of his contention that in the
meeting, dated 29.03.2006, no resolution was taken regarding change of
guide. Annexure 14 has been annexed which is the proceeding of the
meeting of Post Graduate Research Council, dated 29.03.2006. Counsel
for the petitioner has submitted that Annexure 14 shows that no such
resolution was taken in the meeting. The petitioner has also annexed
Annexures 15 and 16 in support of this contention that for change of
guide specific resolution is required to be taken in the meeting of Post
Graduate Research Council. Annexures 15 and 16 are proceedings of
P.G.R.C. meeting held on earlier occasions wherein specific resolution
had been taken for change of guide of candidates. Petitioner has also
submitted that in case any resolution regarding change of guide would
have been taken in the meeting, dated 29.03.2006, information would
have been sent to petitioner and respondent no. 6 and in that case
respondent no. 6 would not have signed the foreword and
acknowledgement of petitioner's thesis on 13.10.2007. All these show
the manipulation done by respondent no. 6 in connivance of others to
vindicate his malice against the petitioner.
6. Respondent no. 6 and the University both have filed
counter affidavits. Respondent no. 6, in his counter affidavit, has
admitted that initially petitioner had submitted synopsis of his proposed
M.D. (General Medicine) Thesis under his guidance and inadvertently he
had put his signature in it's foreword. A change of guide was necessary
in terms of the requirements and guidelines of Medical Council of India
as in one academic session, one Professor/Associate Professor can not
have more than two graduate students registered in his unit. Since, in the
unit of respondent no. 6 there were three graduate students, as such, one
of them was transferred to another unit. Incidentally petitioner was
selected by P.G.R.C. for such change of unit. This was the reason that
even though proposal for acceptance of M.D. Thesis of the petitioner was
placed before the Post Graduate Research Council (Medicine) showing
respondent no. 6 to be the supervisor of petitioner in the meeting, dated
29.03.2006, but, subsequently, it was resolved to change the supervisor of
the petitioner. In place of respondent no. 6, Dr. Bibhu Priyadarshi was
designated as the supervisor in respect of the petitioner. Annexure A/6
has been annexed in support of this contention.
7. The University, in it's cryptic counter affidavit, has not
replied several paragraphs where the petitioner has alleged regarding
malafide in changing the guide of the petitioner in violation of Patna
University Act and Rules. However, on perusal of different Annexures
specially the agenda, dated 25.03.2006, of Post Graduate Research
Council and the proceedings of the meeting, dated 29.03.2006 of the Post
Graduate Research Council, it is apparent that though agenda regarding
change of guide was there, but, no resolution regarding change of guide
was taken. However, vide Annexure B/6, dated 25.05.2006, the Dean,
Faculty of Medicine, Patna University, was informed by the Assistant
Registrar, Patna University, regarding the approval of the synopsis of the
thesis of candidates in the meeting, dated 29.03.2006, by the Post
Graduate Research Council. In this letter name of petitioner's guide is
changed and in place of respondent no. 6, Dr. Bibhu Priyadarshi's name
has been substituted. How and when it happened, it has not been replied
either by the University or respondent no. 6. However, there is nothing to
show that such change was brought at the instance of respondent no. 6
due to his malice against the petitioner.
8. The petitioner has also alleged that he faired extremely
well in viva voce examination/oral examination. In the process of long
examination on the patient by respondent no. 6 he replied all questions
consistent with the reasoning of medical science, but, despite his
outstanding merit the result has been manipulated and the marks, based
on manipulation, were sent to Examination Controller for publication of
result.
9. On perusal of the pleadings, it transpires that in the M.D.
(General Medicine) total marks allotted is 600, which is distributed in
theory, clinical and viva voce examination. Each candidate has to appear
in four theory papers total 200 marks, each of50 marks. They are also
required to appear at clinical examination of 300 marks and viva voce
examination of 100 marks. A candidate is required to pass independently
both in theory and clinical/viva voce examination securing 50 per cent
marks in each. The petitioner has annexed Annexure "C", that is, the
result sheet, which shows that out of 200 marks in theory papers he got
103 marks. Theory papers are examined by external examiners, as such,
internal examiner has no role in allotment of the marks. There is no
allegation that respondent no. 6 has done any thing in evaluation of
theory papers. So far the clinical or viva voce examination is concerned,
as per Patna University Act and Rules it is conducted by two external and
two internal examiners. In M.D. (General Medicine) 2005-2008 two
external examiners were Dr. P. Kar, Professor of Medicine, Maulana
Azad Medical College, New Delhi, and Dr. A.K. Vaish, Professor of
Medicine, King George Medical College, Lucknow. The external
examiners are appointed by the Dean, Faculty of Medicine, from panel of
names and it is approve by the Vice Chancellor. So far as two internal
examiners are concerned, Head of the Department of Medicine is one of
the internal examiners and the second internal examiner is appointed on
rotational basis considering seniority. Dr. M.P. Singh, Professor of
Medicine, Patna Medical College & Hospital, was other internal
examiner. For clinical examination total marks are 300 which is
distributed 150 marks for a long case and 150 marks for two short cases,
for each case 75 marks. For the long case Dr. A.K. Vaish and respondent
no. 6 were examiners and for short cases Dr. P. Kar and Dr. M.P. Singh
were examining the candidates. Viva voce examination is conducted by
four examiners, two external and two internal for which 100 marks are
allotted, one candidate is examined at four tables by each examiners, who
have to award marks within 25 marks, as 100 marks is distributed among
the four examiners each one with 25 marks. Petitioner's case is that he
obtained 55 marks in viva voce out of 100 marks, but, he failed in clinical
examination as he could get only 46.3 per cent marks, out of 50 per cent
pass marks. Allegation is that less marks was allotted to him by
respondent no. 6 and Dr. A.K. Vaish in the clinical examination of one
long case at the instance of respondent no. 6. Dr. A.K. Vaish and
respondent no. 6 were the examiners for long case. It has been alleged by
the petitioner that respondent no. 6 is connected with the examination of
both the Medical Colleges, from where the externals were selected, as
such, he was in a position to influence the externals for allotting less
marks to the petitioner in the clinical examination. Out of 300 marks
allotted for clinical examination and vive voce petitioner managed to get
only 139 marks and failed.
10. Petitioner's counsel has also stated that the marks sheet
only shows aggregate marks allotted in the clinical and viva voce
examination, specific marks allotted for long case, short case and marks
allotted by four examiners in the viva voce have not been disclosed.
Neither the examination sheet has been produced by the University to
make it clear as to what marks were allotted to the petitioner under which
specific head. The aggregate marks is quite vague and evasive, which
strengthen this view of the petitioner that some manipulation have been
made at the instance of respondent no. 6 in allotment of final marks.
11. Respondent no. 6, in his counter affidavit, has stated that
allegations are incorrect and false. Externals are selected not by the Head
of the Department, but, by the University and the Dean, Faculty of
Medicine, from the panel. So far Dr. P. Kar and Dr. A.K. Vaish are
concerned, they are teachers of high repute. It is not a fact that
respondent no. 6 was the only one examiner in the examination process
relating to clinical and viva voce examination. All examiners connected
with clinical and viva voce examination play their role. Each examiner is
in control of equal number of marks. Examiners, external and internal,
have to sign on the marks sheet. In this circumstance, allegation made by
the petitioner that respondent no. 6 has played decisive role in evaluation
process, he influenced the externals as well as the second internal is a far
fetched imagination. By making such allegation, the petitioner has not
casted false aspersion against respondent no. 6 only, but, he has alleged
malafide against reputed external examiners, who are senior physicians,
such allegations have been made against the externals as well as the
second internal even without impleading them as party, as such, the
allegations is fit to be rejected. It is only an imagination of the petitioner
on account of over estimation of his own caliber. In case the petitioner
has done so well in the examination then at least in the theory paper the
petitioner should have fetched much higher marks, but, in theory paper
also he could manage only just pass marks as out of 200 he could obtain
103 marks only.
12. I find that the way entire examination is conducted it is
very difficult to accept this fact that respondent no. 6 could manage entire
examination process and only at his instance the externals have agreed to
give less mark to the petitioner, irrespective of best performance of the
petitioner. I also find that by making such allegation petitioner has not
only alleged malafide against respondent no. 6, but, has also alleged
malafide against other examiners who are not even impleaded as party in
the present case. On this count as well as the fact, discussed above, I do
not find that petitioner has been able to prove the alleged malafide against
respondent no. 6.
13. "Express malice" or "malice in fact" means an actual
malicious intention on the part of the person, who has done wrongful act.
In other words, "malice in fact" means an act committed due to personal
spite, corrupt motive or malicious intention. For proving such malicious
intention, it is necessary to furnish necessary and sufficient particulars for
those allegations. In the present case, allegation against respondent no. 6
is that he acted maliciously and succeeded in getting the petitioner failed
in M.D. (General Medicine) 2005-2008 examination. Reason behind this
malicious intention, as alleged in the writ petition is refusal of petitioner's
marriage negotiation by his parents with the daughter of respondent no. 6.
Petitioner's case is that he got enrolled for his M.D. examination in the
unit of respondent no. 6 on 16.04.2005. He has not mentioned in the writ
petition the date on which date Dr. Vijay Prakash has met his parents for
marriage negotiation of his daughter, at which place and in presence of
which persons this marriage negogiation failed. Simply, he has
mentioned that on 06.05.2006 petitioner got married as per his parents'
desire. It is not alleged in the petition that in between 16.04.2005 and
06.05.2006, that is the period when he was doing his M.D. course in the
unit of respondent no. 6, petitioner was misbehaved, discouraged or not
guided properly by respondent no. 6. In fact, the statement in the writ
application indicates that research and thesis work of the petitioner
properly progressed and finally finished under the guidance of respondent
no. 6. Petitioner completed his thesis successfully under the supervision
and guidance of respondent no. 6 even thesis of petitioner was produced
for final acceptance before respondent no. 6. All these circumstances do
not indicate any malice in the behaviour of respondent no. 6. If there
would have been any malice, in that case, thesis of the petitioner itself
would not have been accepted, which is the first step for appearing in the
M.D. examination. However, guide was subsequently changed and in
place of respondent no. 6, Dr. Bibhu Priyadarshi was made petitioner's
guide whereas other two candidates were retained in the unit of
respondent no. 6. Respondent no. 6 has controverted the allegation of
malice made by the petitioner. It has specifically been denied that any
marriage proposal of his daughter was initiated with the petitioner. It has
also been stated that the change of guide of the writ petitioner was done
in accordance with the Medical Council of India Guidelines, with the
approval of P.G.R.C. It has been stated that in the agenda of P.G.R.C.,
dated 25.03.2006, one of the agenda was change of guide to be taken in
the meeting scheduled on 29.03.2006, though in the proceedings of
P.G.R.C. it is not specifically mentioned, but, resolution was taken in that
very meeting, dated 29.03.2006, so far change of guide is concerned.
14. In the counter affidavit of Patna University, it has not
been contradicted.
15. From the facts, stated above, I find that in order to bring
malicious intention sufficient particulars have not been brought by the
petitioner. The incident which took place subsequently could have been
linked to the malicious intention of respondent no. 6. Only in case the
petitioner would have succeeded in proving the incident due to which
malafide has been alleged, that is, failure of marriage negotiation. Since,
this incident itself has not been proved, subsequent circumstance can not
be connected for proving alleged malafide against respondent no. 6 by the
petitioner. I do not find that petitioner has been able to prove alleged
malafide against respondent no. 6.
16. Petitioner has also alleged malice in law. It has been
stated by the petitioner that examination of M.D. (General Medicine)
2005-2008 has been conducted in breach of examination rules of Patna
University Act and Medical Council of India Rules. This has been done
at the instance of respondent no. 6 on account of abuse of power. It is not
in dispute that Patna University retains control over academic activities of
Patna Medical College & Hospital as examining body. Section 25 and 26
deal with the constitution and power of academic council, which is
academic body of the University. Section 27 of the Patna University Act
deals with different faculties of the University including faculty of
medicine. Section 29 deals with the constitution, power and function of
the Examination Board which provides for appointment of the question
setters and examiners from the panel of names submitted by the
Examination Board. The advisory power of Examination Board is
subject to Regulation. Section 39 of the Act provides for framing of
Regulation subject to the provisions of the Act and Ordinances in the
matters of (a) courses of studies, (b) condition of attempts and eligibility
for awarding degree and diploma, (c) creation of teaching, faculty,
constitution, power and functions of the examination board, (d) mode of
appointment and duties of the examiners and conduct of examination.
Clause (2) of Section 39 prescribes procedure for framing of Regulation
and its commencement.
17. Patna University has framed Regulation for M.D. and
M.S. examination in Faculty of Medicine in the year 1975 in terms of
Patna University Act, 1961, and in view of Section 75 of the 1976 Act.
Till date there is no other Regulation framed or adopted in terms of
Section 39 of the Act. In order to maintain uniform standard of post
graduation course in medical science, the Medical Council of India has
also framed Post Graduate Medical Education Regulation, 2000. Clause
(14) of the Medical Council of India Regulation provides for
examination, examiners, principal of colleges and the modalities of the
examination, such as, thesis, theory, clinical, practical and oral
examination. Appendix I of the Regulation prescribes guideline of
appointment of post graduate examiners. Petitioner has alleged that
contrary to the existing Regulation of Patna University and Medical
Council of India Regulation, 2000, the Head of the Department of the
Patna Medical College & Hospital had proposed modification in the
pattern of conduct of examination of post graduate courses. Even though
the proposal has not been made part of Regulation of Patna University
under Section 39 of the Patna University Act. The examination
procedure has been changed as per the proposed modalities. This
proposed modality has conferred unguided power in the hands of the
Head of the Department. The Head of the Department has become whole
and sole in the examination as Chairman of the Board of Examiners. He
has power of nomination of internal and external. In addition he is also
associated with the examination. He may be supervisor and examiner of
the thesis of any candidate who is under other supervisor. In this way, as
per the proposed modality, the M.D. examination has become one man
show. As per the existing Regulation of Patna University and the Post
Graduate Regulation, 2000, of the Medical Council of India, there should
have been three examiners for evaluation of thesis and four examiners for
clinical/practical and viva voce, but, in M.D. (General Medicine) 2005-
2008 examination there were only two external and two internal
examiners which was in breach of Regulations. Section 29 confers
powers to the Examination Board to refer names of question setters and
examiners from the panel. The Vice Chancellor and the Dean of the
Faculty have to appoint, on the basis of such recommendations, but, in
the M.D. course of 2005-2008 entire scheme has been bye passed and
everything has been done by respondent no. 6, being the Head of the
Department. It has also been stated by the petitioner's counsel that as per
the Medical Council of India Regulation, clinical and viva voce
examination of more than eight candidates can be conducted in one day,
but, in breach of Regulation more than eight candidates were examined,
which shows that the examination has been made a mockery. The
internal examiner was appointed ignoring seniority. As per Regulation,
Head of the Department can not be an examiner in the examination of
those medical colleges from where externals are selected, but, respondent
no. 6 is coneccted with examinations of those Universities from where
externals were selected for conducting examination of M.D. (General
Medicine) 2005-2008. Thus, the credibility of the examination is under
cloud.
18. Respondent no. 6, in his counter affidavit and
supplementary counter affidavit, has denied all allegations. It has been
stated that Heads of the Department of each speciality of Patna
University had resolved in a meeting to adopt the modalities as
prescribed by Medical Council of India for conducting post graduate
examinations and the same was sent to the Vice Chancellor of Patna
University by the Principal of Patna Medical College & Hospital and the
Dean, Faculty of Medicine, Patna University vide letter, dated
30.11.2004. Patna University by a communication, contained in letter no.
4123-25/examination, dated 05.05.2006, intimated that at least 50 per
cent of the examiners have to be external. The senior most examiner
shall be the Chairman of the Board and ordinarily the supervisor shall be
one of the internal examiners. This decision was in conflict with the
Medical Council of India recommendations. The said communiqué was
withdrawn when Controller of Examination realized it. The Examination
Board of Patna University in it's meeting held on 10.08.2004 had taken a
decision to follow Medical Council of India guidelines. The M.D./M.S.
Examination Regulation framed by Patna University, thus, have become
redundant and had been given a go bye by Patna University itself. So far
the appointment of external examination is concerned, it was done in
consultation with the Patna University in anticipation of the approval of
Vice Chancellor. Respondent no. 6 has denied the allegation that he is
connected with post graduate examination of Maulana Azad Medical
College, New Delhi. It has been stated that respondent no. 6 has never
been an examiner of the said institution. The internal examiner, Dr. M.P.
Singh, was unanimously chosen to act as second internal examiner in the
meeting of teachers of Department of Medicine, as such, it was not a
decision of respondent no. 6.
19. The Patna University, in it's counter affidavit, has stated
that the University is conducting the M.D, M.S., M.Ch., Medical
Diploma examination as per the provisions of existing Regulation.
However, the guidelines of Medical Council of India are also mandatory
and are being followed. Decision of Patna University to appoint external
and internal examiners and conducting P.G. examination of Medical
Colleges, following Medical Council of India Regulation, ignoring Patna
University Act and Rules was challenged earlier before the High Court.
In L.P.A. No. 458 of 2008 vide order, dated 27.06.2008, Hon'ble High
Court has decided that there is nothing wrong if the pattern of conduction
of post graduate examination approved by the University as suggested by
the Medical Council of India.
20. On consideration of entire materials, I find that the
allegation made by the petitioner regarding conduct of M.D. (General
Medicine) 2005-2008 examination in violation of Patna University Act,
Regulation and the Medical Council of India Regulation, 2000, is not
correct. Appointment of external and internal examiners, as per the
proposed guideline was challenged before this Court where it has been
held that there is no illegality in selection of external and internal
examiners, as per the Medical Council of India Guidelines, since, it is the
decision of the Patna University. This has also been followed in M.D.
(General Medicine) 2005-2008 examination, I do not find that
examination was conducted in violation of Section 39 of the Patna
University Act or Regulation as well as Medical Council of India
Regulation, 2000. The allegation made by the petitioner that entire
examination was one man show of respondent no. 6 has no substance.
Accordingly, the malice in law, alleged by the petitioner, has also not
been proved.
21. During the pendency of the writ application result of
M.D. (General Medicine) 2005-2008 examination, which is under
challenge in the present writ application, was published and as per
apprehension of the petitioner, he failed. Thereafter, petitioner appeared
in next examination conducted by the University. This examination was
held under the same provisions following same guidelines. Petitioner has
now been declared successful in the M.D. examination. On account of his
success petitioner has not challenged the same Rules, Regulations and
Procedures followed by the Department of Medicine for conducting M.D.
examination. Petitioner by filing interlocutory applications has tried to
bring this fact before the Court that on account of his failure in his first
attempt in the M.D. examination he will suffer so far his career
advancement is concerned. He will not be eligible for appearing in the
entrance examination of D.M. course specially, the examination
conducted by Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research,
Chandigarh, is concerned. On account of his failure in the M.D. course
he is disqualified from appearing in the examination. The petitioner has
not brought on record the prospectus of Post Graduate Institute of
Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh. However, prospectus of
Sanjay Gandhi Post Graduation Institute of Medical Science, Lucknow,
Christian Medical College, Vellore and AIIMS P.G/Post Doctoral
Courses, New Delhi, has been brought on record. No such ineligibility
conditions have been put in the prospectus these three institutions.
Simply because one institution has put some condition regarding
eligibility of candidate on account of failure, that will not give any cause
to the petitioner for directing the respondents to declare him pass even
though facts brought on record indicate that the result of M.D. (General
Medicine) 2005-2008 examination do not suffer from any malice or
malafide. During the pendency of the writ application petitioner has
already passed his M.D. course. He has also passed Part I of M.R.C.P., in
this view this writ application, itself, has become infructuous as no cause
of action survives.
22. Accordingly, I do not find any merit in this application.
It is dismissed.
(Mridula Mishra, J.)
The Patna High Court,
The 24th day of June, 2009,
A.F.R.,
Cp:3/S.A.