Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion: Letters Patent Appeal — Prasad, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This Letters Patent Appeal arises from the judgment dated 24-3-1998 passed in M.A. No. 520 of 1991 (R) (reported in 1999 AIHC 2440). The underlying claim (Claim Case No. 63 of 1987) was instituted by Lalmuni Devi (mother of the deceased) under Section 110-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 seeking compensation of Rs. 6,48,000 for the death of her son, Surendra Kumar Gupta.

On 12-5-1987, Surendra Kumar Gupta, aged about 24, was travelling in Amit Bus No. BPQ 9900 from Ramgarh to Gaya. Around 5:15 p.m. near village Masipiri on the National Highway (within Hazaribagh Sadar Police Station), the bus met with an accident allegedly caused by rash and negligent driving. The deceased sustained head injuries and died on the spot. Hazaribagh Sadar P.S. Case No. 5 of 1987 was registered regarding the incident.

Jay Singh admitted ownership of the bus. The bus was insured with Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Gaya Branch. The Tribunal found that the bus driver drove rashly and negligently, assessed compensation at Rs. 95,000 and held the insurance company liable to pay the entire award. The insurance company filed Misc. Appeal No. 520 of 1991 (R) challenging, inter alia, involvement of the Amit Bus in the accident and contending that its liability was limited to Rs. 15,000 per passenger under Section 95(2)(b)(ii) of the Motor Vehicles Act. The claimant filed a cross-appeal (Order 41, Rule 22 CPC) for enhancement of compensation.

The learned single Judge of this Court (in the appeal by the insurance company) affirmed the Tribunal's finding of driver negligence, held that the premium paid corresponded to statutory passenger cover (limiting insurer liability to Rs. 15,000 per passenger), and enhanced compensation to Rs. 1,25,000. The present Letters Patent Appeal concerns that judgment and the appropriate allocation of liability and quantum.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the liability of the insurer under the insurance policy was limited to Rs. 15,000 per passenger under Section 95(2)(b)(ii) of the Motor Vehicles Act, despite the policy being described as a "comprehensive" policy.
  2. Whether a claimant's cross-objection / cross-appeal under Order 41, Rule 22 CPC seeking enhancement of compensation is maintainable in an appeal filed by the insurance company.
  3. What is the correct quantum of compensation payable to the claimant (i.e., appropriate deductions, annual dependency and choice of multiplier) in the facts of this case.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant — Vehicle Owner (Mr. Badri Narain Prasad)

  • Contended that the claimant's cross-appeal in the miscellaneous appeal filed by the insurance company was not maintainable.
  • Argued that the learned single Judge erred in enhancing the quantum of compensation.
  • Maintained that because the vehicle was comprehensively insured, the insurer's liability was not limited and the insurer was liable to pay the entire awarded compensation; the finding that liability was limited to Rs. 15,000 was bad in law.
  • Also advanced (but did not ultimately press) that the driver of BPQ 9900 was not at fault.

Appellant — Insurance Company (Mr. G.C. Jha)

  • Submitted there was a concurrent finding of negligence against the bus driver and that the insurer's liability was limited to Rs. 15,000 per passenger under Section 95(2)(b)(ii) because no additional premium had been paid to cover liability beyond the statutory limit.
  • Contended that a "comprehensive" policy does not automatically render passenger liability unlimited; separate/express agreement and payment of additional premium is required to extend liability beyond statutory limits.

Claimant (Lalmuni Devi)

  • Filed the claim petition under Section 110-A M.V. Act claiming Rs. 6,48,000 as compensation for death of her son.
  • Prosecuted a cross-appeal under Order 41, Rule 22 CPC seeking enhancement of compensation (details of specific submissions on quantum beyond claiming enhancement are not extensively set out in the opinion).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
National Insurance Company v. Jugal Kishore, (1988) 1 SCC 626 : AIR 1988 SC 719 That a comprehensive insurance policy does not automatically render insurer's liability unlimited towards passenger/3rd party risks; specific additional premium/payment is required to extend liability beyond statutory limits. The court relied on this authority to support the conclusion that in absence of payment for higher passenger liability the insurer's liability was limited to the statutory limit (Rs. 15,000 per passenger).
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Shanti Bai, AIR 1995 SC 1113 Same principle as above — comprehensive policy does not by itself enlarge statutory limits of insurer's liability unless additional premium for higher cover is paid. The court treated this decision as supporting the proposition that the insurer's liability in the present case was limited to Rs. 15,000 per passenger given the premium actually paid and absence of any special contract.
Road Transport Company v. Bham Singh, 1998 Acc CJ 1101 : AIR 1998 SC 2487 Reinforces the proposition that a comprehensive policy does not automatically cover passenger liability beyond statutory limits without specific agreement and premium. Referenced as further support for the principle that absence of specific premium/payment for higher limits confines insurer liability to statutory limits.
Manjit Singh v. Rattan Singh, 1987 ACJ 1204 Permissibility of cross-objections / cross-appeals (Order 41, Rule 22 CPC) and appellate Court's power under Order 41, Rule 33 CPC to make appropriate orders to do complete justice between parties. Used by the court to justify entertaining the claimant's cross-appeal for enhancement in the appeal pending between other parties.
Nirmal Singh v. C.M. Jaya, 1997 Acc CJ 44 (Delhi) Similar proposition regarding appellate powers to decide matters so as to render complete justice and entertain cross-objections / cross-appeals. Relied upon to support the view that the claimant's cross-appeal for enhancement could be entertained in the appeal filed by the insurer.
New India Assurance Company v. Maimun Nisha, (1996) 2 Pat LJR 848 Authority relied upon by the vehicle owner to argue that a cross-objection by claimant under Order 41, Rule 22 CPC could not be entertained in an appeal filed by the insurance company where the insurer had not challenged the quantum. The court distinguished this case on facts — noting that in Maimun Nisha the insurer had not challenged quantum, whereas in the instant case the insurer had challenged both liability and quantum — and held Maimun Nisha inapplicable to the present facts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by addressing (a) the factual finding of negligence and death in the accident, (b) the insurer's liability under the policy, (c) the maintainability of the claimant's cross-appeal for enhancement, and (d) the correct quantum of compensation.

Factual findings

The Claims Tribunal had found, based on documentary and oral evidence including testimony of a co-traveller (A.W.2 Manoj Kumar), that Surendra Kumar Gupta died in the accident caused by rash and negligent driving of Amit Bus No. BPQ 9900. The learned single Judge affirmed that finding. The court accepted the concurrent findings of the two courts below that the deceased died while travelling in the Amit Bus and that its driver was at fault. The vehicle owner had not produced the driver as a witness to counter this case.

Liability of the Insurer — analysis of the policy

The court examined the insurance policy's schedules and premium breakdown. The policy showed seating capacity "52 + 3" and a total premium of Rs. 3,446. Schedule B showed Rs. 624 charged "for LL to passengers as per End. IMT 13(52)" (i.e., Rs. 12 per passenger). The column "Limit per passenger" in Schedule B was blank. The court reasoned that the Rs. 12 per passenger rate corresponded to the tariff for statutory passenger cover of Rs. 15,000 per passenger under Section 95(2)(b)(ii) of the Act; higher limits or unlimited liability would demand a higher per-passenger premium (the opinion cites Rs. 23 for Rs. 20,000 limit and Rs. 50 for unlimited liability as tariff examples).

On this basis, and applying binding Supreme Court authority, the court held that the comprehensive policy in itself did not make passenger liability unlimited. In absence of an express agreement and payment of additional premium to cover liability beyond statutory limits, the policy covered only the statutory limit. Relying on the cited precedents (National Insurance, New India Assurance, Road Transport Co. v. Bham Singh), the court concluded the insurer's liability was limited to Rs. 15,000 in respect of the death of the passenger.

Maintainability of claimant's cross-appeal

The court considered whether the claimant's cross-appeal under Order 41, Rule 22 CPC could be entertained in the appeal filed by the insurer. It observed no statutory prohibition against entertaining such a cross-objection/cross-appeal and relied on the power under Order 41, Rule 33 CPC to make appropriate orders to do complete justice. The court cited Manjit Singh and Nirmal Singh as supporting authorities. The court distinguished New India Assurance v. Maimun Nisha (1996), noting that in that case the insurer had not challenged quantum (only liability) whereas in the present case the insurer had challenged both liability and quantum; therefore Maimun Nisha did not apply.

Quantum of compensation — multiplier and computation

Both the Tribunal and the learned single Judge had assessed deceased's monthly income at Rs. 1,000 and deducted one-third for personal expenses, yielding monthly dependency of Rs. 667 (annual approx. Rs. 8,000). The lower courts applied a multiplier of 16 to arrive at a compensation figure. The present court evaluated the appropriate multiplier in light of the claimant's age: the mother was fifty years old in May 1989. The court concluded that the suitable multiplier in these circumstances should be 12, not 16. Applying the multiplier of 12 to the annual dependency figure produced a compensation amount of Rs. 96,000, which the court held to be just and reasonable.

Final allocation and incidental directions

Based on the above reasoning, the court modified the compensation award previously enhanced by the learned single Judge. It held the insurer's liability limited to Rs. 15,000 and directed the vehicle owner to pay the balance of the compensation. It also directed payment of interest at 12% per annum from the date of institution of the claim petition (1-8-1987) until payment and made no order as to costs.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Appeal partly allowed.

The court's operative directions and immediate consequences were:

  • Insurer's liability: The Oriental Insurance Company is liable only up to Rs. 15,000 in respect of the death of the passenger (statutory limit under Section 95(2)(b)(ii) of the Motor Vehicles Act) because no additional premium was paid to cover higher passenger liability.
  • Owner's liability: The vehicle owner (appellant) is directed to pay the balance of the compensation amounting to Rs. 81,000.
  • Quantum: The total compensation payable to the claimant is fixed at Rs. 96,000 (based on monthly dependency Rs. 667 and multiplier 12).
  • Interest: The compensation shall carry interest at 12% per annum from the date of institution of the claim petition (1-8-1987) till payment.
  • Costs: No order as to costs was made.

The opinion applies and follows established Supreme Court authorities on the principle that a comprehensive policy does not automatically extend insurer liability beyond statutory limits unless an express contract and additional premium exist. The court modified the quantum of compensation but did not purport to lay down a new legal principle; it applied existing precedents to the facts before it.

    Jay Singh v. Lal Muni Devi And Another

    Prasad, J.:— This Letters Patent Appeal arises out of the judgment dated 24-3-1998 passed in M.A No. 520 of 1991 (R): (reported in 1999 AIHC 2440), whereby and whereunder the learned single Judge of this Court alleged the appeal of the Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. to the effect that its liability was limited to the extent of Rs. 15,000/- for payment of compensation and the cross-appeal by the claimant was allowed in part enhancing the amount of compensation from Rs. 95,000/- to Rs. 1,25,000/- with interest @ 12% from the date of filing of the claim petition and there is direction that the appellant-owner (respondent No. 2 therein) of the offending vehicle shall pay the balance sum of the awarded compensation of Rs. 1,10,000/- to the claimant.

    2. Briefly put, the facts giving rise to the instant appeal are as under:

    On 12-5-1987 Surendra Kumar Gupta (a contractor by profession), aged about 24 years, the son of the claimant (Lalmuni Devi), A.W 5, boarded Amit Bus No. BPQ 9900 at Ramgarh within the district of Hazaribagh for Gaya, but on the National High Way around 5.15 p.m near village Masipiri, within the Police Station, Sadar (Muffasil), District, Hazaribagh, the bus, which was being driven rashly and negligently by the bus driver, met with the accident in which Surendra Kumar Gupta sustained head injury and he died on the spot. Thereafter Hazaribagh Sadar (Muffasil) P.S Case No. 5 of 1987 came to be instituted regarding the incident.

    3. It is an admitted fact that Jay Singh (appellant herein) is the owner of Bus No. BPQ 9900. It is also an admitted fact that on the date of the incident, the bus was insured with the Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Gaya Branch. Lalmuni Devi (Respondent No. 1 herein) brought Compensation (Claim Case No. 63 of 1987) under Section 110-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, before the Tribunal for compensation on the ground of death of her son Surendra Prasad Gupta. She claimed compensation to the tune of Rs. 6,48,000/-.

    Jay Singh by filing written statement resisted the claim petition, contending, inter alia that the death of the deceased was due to an unknown Coach Bus, which was negligently driven and there was no liability on him to pay the compensation and that the income of the deceased, shown by the claimant was excessive.

    The Oriental Insurance Company too contested the claim and denied its responsibility in the written statement, mainly on the grounds that the vehicle in question was plying without permit and in the alternative its stand was that its liability was limited to the extent as laid down under Section 95(2)(b)(ii) of the said Motor Vehicles Act (hereinafter to be referred to as ‘the Act’).

    4. The Tribunal, on consideration of the evidence and materials on record, held that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the Bus No. BPQ 9900 by the bus driver. It assessed the compensation of Rs. 95,000/- only and held that under the Insurance Policy the Insurance Company was liable to pay the entire compensation amount, and accordingly award was made.

    Being aggrieved by it, the Insurance Company preferred Misc. Appeal No. 520 of 1991 (R) amongst other grounds that the Amit Bus was not involved in the accident in which the deceased was travelling; that the driver of Amit Bus was not at fault, and the accident was caused by an unidentified bus and that at best its liability was limited to the extent of Rs. 15,000/- only under Section 95(2)(b)(ii) of the said Act for the death of the deceased. The claimant preferred cross appeal under Order 41, Rule 22 of the C.P.C for enhancement of the compensation amount.

    It was urged by the Insurance Company Appellant in Misc. Appeal No. 520 of 1991 (R) before the learned single Judge that Amit Bus was not involved in the accident on 12-5-1987 and the deceased was not travelling in it. The learned single Judge affirmed the finding of the Tribunal that on 12-5-1987 Amit Bus met with the accident, in which the deceased was travelling and the contention of the appellant-Company therein was not accepted by him. Further, the learned single Judge taking into consideration the decisions of the Apex Court in National Insurance Company v. Jugal Kishore, (1988) 1 SCC 626 : (AIR 1988 SC 719) and in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Shanti Bai, AIR 1995 SC 1113 as well as on examination of the copy of the Insurance Policy (Exhibit C) found that the premium of Rs. 624/- was paid for covering the risk of 52 passengers for meeting the requirements of the Motor Vehicles Act and as no additional premium has been paid, the liability of the Insurance Company was restricted to Rs. 15,000/- per passenger and unlimited liability could not be fastened on the Company simply because the Insurance Policy was comprehensive policy and hence, gave a finding that the Insurance Company was liable to pay Rs. 15,000/- only, out of the total compensation amount. Further, the learned single Judge on the basis of the monthly income of Rs. 1000/- of the deceased, as assessed by the Tribunal, and after deducting one third out of it towards the personal expenses of the deceased, worked out the loss of dependency around Rs. 667/- per month, which comes to annual Rs. 8000/- approx and presumably applying the multiplier of 16, he was of the view that the compensation would be at least Rs. 1,27,000/- and, ultimately, he enhanced the compensation sum to Rs. 1,25,000/-, which in his opinion was just and reasonable compensation. Accordingly, he allowed the miscellaneous appeal and the cross-appeal in part, as stated above.

    5. Mr. Badri Narain Prasad, learned counsel for the appellant-vehicle owner has assailed the impugned judgment mainly on the ground that the cross-appeal by the claimant in the miscellaneous appeal brought by the Insurance Company was not maintainable and the learned single Judge erred in enhancing the quantum of compensation and that as the vehicle No. BPQ 9900 was comprehensively insured, the liability of the company was not limited and it was liable to pay the entire awarded compensation sum and the finding of the learned single Judge that its liability was limited to Rs. 15,000/- only is bad in law. He also feebly urged that the driver of BPQ 9900 was not at fault when the accident took place, but this was not pressed by him later in the argument.

    6. Mr. G.C Jha, learned counsel for the Insurance Company, on the other hand, contended that there is the concurrent finding of the Tribunal and the learned single Judge that the accident took place on 12-5-1987 due to rash and negligent act of the driver of Amit Bus No. BPQ 9900 and the liability, of the Company was limited to Rs. 15,000/- only in terms of the Insurance Policy and in absence of payment of additional premiums, the liability of the Company for the death of a passenger does not become unlimited, simply because the vehicle is covered by the comprehensive policy.

    7. The Claims Tribunal on consideration of the documents filed by the parties and on appraisal of the evidence by the claimant, including that of A.W 2 (Manoj Kumar) a co-traveller of the deceased in Amit Bus, and a victim of the incident, recorded a finding that the deceased (Surendra Kumar Gupta), died in the motor accident which was due to rash and negligent act of the driver of Amit Bus BPQ 9900. The learned single Judge affirmed this finding of the Claims Tribunal. The vehicle owner did not examine the driver of the bus to explain that the accident did not take place due to his fault. There is concurrent finding of the two Courts that the deceased died in the accident on 12-5-1987 while travelling in Amit Bus and its driver was at fault. There is no reason to disagree with the concurrent finding of the two Courts.

    7-A. One may now come to the question regarding the liability of the Insurance Company for payment of compensation in respect of the death of the deceased Surendra Kumar Gupta in the accident. It is the stand of the learned counsel for the appellant vehicle owner that as the bus was covered by comprehensive insurance policy, there was unlimited liability of the insurance company to pay the compensation amount to the claimant. The contention of the learned counsel for the insurance company, on the other hand, is that there was the statutory liability of the insurance company under Section 95(2)(b)(ii) of the Act to pay the sum of Rs. 15,000/- only as compensation because no additional premium to cover the liability beyond it, has been paid by the vehicle owner to the insurance company. It is not disputed that as the vehicle involved in this case was a passenger bus in which passengers were carried for hire or reward, the provision of Section 95(1)(b)(ii) of the Act is applicable. At the time of the accident, the express provision of sub-section (2)(b) of the Act stood as follows:

    “Section 95(1): xxxxxxx

    (2) Subject to the proviso to sub-section (1), a policy of insurance shall cover any liability incurred in respect of any one accident up to the following limits, namely:—

    (a) xxxxxx

    (b) Where the vehicle is a vehicle in which passengers are carried for hire reward or by reason of or in pursuance of a contract of employment.

    (i) in respect of persons other than passengers carried for hire or reward a limit of fifty thousand rupees in all;

    (ii) in respect of passengers, a limit of fifteen thousand rupees for each individual passenger;”

    8. Now, one may scrutinise the insurance policy, issued in the present case. The policy indicates the limits of the liability and the amount of premium paid. In the column ‘INSURED'S ESTIMATED VALUE’ including the accessories the amount of Rs. 2,75,000/- has been shown and on the top of it a sum of Rs. 3446/- is mentioned in the column ‘Premium’ and in seating capacity column, the figure— ‘52 + 3’ is mentioned. The policy is in two parts — Schedules A and B. Schedule A is ‘OWN DAMAGE BASIC’ and Absolute Net Premium in Schedule ‘A’, is mentioned as — Rs. 2598,75. Obviously, Schedule ‘A’ does not cover the liability to public risk or passengers. Schedule ‘B’ of the policy speaks about the ‘LIABILITY TO PUBLIC RISK’ and the premium. The amount, shown in Schedule ‘B’ is as under:

    “B. LIABILITY TO PUBLIC RISK — Rs. 240.00 Add: for LL to passengers as per End. IMT 13(52) (India Motor Tariffs) — Rs. 624.00 Add……………… — Rs. 24.00 888.00”

    Below it, Absolute Net Premium ‘A’ sum of Rs. 2598.00 has been added, and under it has been shown that Rs. 150.00 has been added as ‘Unlimited’ which is for the damage to property to third party, caused by use of the vehicle, and after giving discount the total Net Premium of Schedule A + B is shown as Rs. 3446.00 The column in Schedule ‘B’ against limit per passengers is blank. The comprehensive policy issued in the present case, on the basis of the estimated value of Rs. 2,75,000/- of the bus, cannot automatically cover the liability with regard to the passengers for the amount higher than the statutory limit. The bus in question was insured for 52 passengers and the insurance company had charged the premium of Rs. 624/- @ Rs. 12/- per passengers. The charging of the amount of Rs. 12/- per passengers cannot be said to be the premium, payable to cover unlimited liability as it has not been mentioned so in the policy. The column ‘Limit per passengers ‘in Schedule B’ to the premium is blank and it was left blank because no additional premium to cover liability beyond the statutory limit has been paid. It has been pointed out by the learned counsel for the insurance company with reference to tariff in respect of ‘LEGAL LIABILITY FOR ACCIDENTS TO PASSENGERS’, that if the limit of liability for any one passenger is fifteen thousand rupees, the rate of annual premium, per passenger, is Rs. 12/-. If the limit is Rs. 20,000/- the rate of premium, per passenger, is Rs. 23/- and so on, and in respect of unlimited liability, the premium payable per passenger is Rs. 50/-. It is well settled that the comprehensive policy only entitles the owner to claim reimbursement of the entire amount of loss or damage suffered up to the estimated value of the vehicle. It does not mean that liability with respect to 3rd party risk or in respect of a passenger in accident becomes unlimited or higher than the statutory liability fixed under sub-section (2) of Section 95 of the Act. For this purpose, specific agreement has to be arrived at between the owner and the insurance company and separate premium has to be paid on the amount of liability undertaken by the insurance company in this behalf, and in absence of such an express agreement, the policy covers only the statutory liability. This proposition of law has been laid down by the Apex Court in National Insurance Company (AIR 1988 SC 719) (supra), the three Hon'ble Judges decision in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (AIR 1995 SC 1113) (supra) and in Road Transport Company v. Bham Singh, 1998 Acc CJ 1101 : (AIR 1998 SC 2487). In the present case, the premium which has been paid is @ Rs. 12/- per passenger and is clearly referable to the statutory liability of Rs. 15,000/- per passenger under Section 95(2)(b)(ii) of the Act. Further, in the instant case, there is no special contract between the insurance company and the vehicle owner to cover unlimited liability in respect of accident to a passenger. In absence of such an express agreement, the policy covers only the statutory liability. Exactly in similar circumstances, the Apex Court in New India Insurance Co. Ltd. (supra) held that the liability of the insurance company was limited to Rs. 15,000/-. Hence, the learned single Judge was justified and rightly held that the liability of the insurance company was limited to Rs. 15,000/- only.

    9. The next point, which arises for consideration is: whether the cross-appeal by the claimant for enhancement of compensation was maintainable. It is the stand of the learned counsel for the vehicle owner that the Misc. Appeal No. 520 of 1991 (P) had been preferred by the insurance company and, therefore, no cross-objection/cross-appeal filed by the claimant for enhancement of compensation could have been entertained. This point was not pressed by the vehicle owner before the learned single Judge in the Misc. Appeal. It is suffice to say that there is no specific prohibition under the Act to entertain cross-objection/cross-appeal filed by the claimant under Order 41, Rule 22 of the Civil Procedure Code for enhancement of compensation and under the provision of Order 41, Rule 33 of the Code, the appellate Court can make appropriate order to do complete justice between the parties and to decide the matter in a way that a claimant is given just compensation (Ref:— Manjit Singh v. Rattan Singh, 1987 ACJ 1204 (sic); Nirmal Singh v. C.M Jaya, 1997 Acc CJ 44 (Delhi).)

    10. Learned counsel for the appellant-vehicle owner, on the other hand, has relied on a decision of a learned single Judge of this Court in New India Assurance Company v. Maimun Nisha, (1996) 2 Pat LJR 848 in support of the contention that the cross-objection by a claimant under Order 41, Rule 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure could not be entertained in an appeal filed by the insurance company. In that case, the quantum of compensation had not been challenged by the insurance company and it had only challenged its liability. But in the instant case, the insurance company has challenged its liability as well as the quantum of compensation. It has been held in that case that where only the liability of the Insurance Company has been challenged and quantum which has become final between the co-respondents, cannot by way of cross-objection, be challenged in the appeal. The aforesaid decision in Maimun Nisha (supra) has no application to the facts of the present case.

    11. Lastly, one may come to the quantum of the compensation assessed by the Tribunal and enhancement in the Miscellaneous Appeal by the learned single Judge. Both the Courts below assessed the monthly income of the deceased as Rs. 1000/-. It is well settled that 1/3rd of the income has to be deducted towards personal expenses of the deceased. After such deduction, the loss of monthly dependency would come to Rs. 667/- and its annual figure (Rs. 667 × 12) would be Rs. 8000/- approx. The mother is the claimant of the deceased. Her age in May, 1989, was fifty years. Both the learned Courts below applied the multiplier of 16 for ultimate assessment of the compensation amount. The choice of the multiplier is determined by the age of the deceased as well as that of the claimant. In the instant case, the suitable multiplier should have been 12 and not 16. On applying the multiplier of 12 the compensation amount comes to Rs. 96000/- only. This, in my view, is the just and reasonable compensation to which the claimant is entitled. Hence, the compensation sum of Rs. 1,25,000/-, awarded by the learned single Judge, is modified accordingly.

    12. In the result, this appeal is allowed in part. The liability of the insurance company (respondent No. 2 herein) is limited to Rs. 15,000/- only. The appellant-vehicle owner shall be liable to pay the balance compensation sum of Rs. 81,000/-. The amount of compensation shall carry interest @ 12% per annum from the date of institution of the claim petition, i.e 1-8-1987, till the date of its payment. In the circumstances of this appeal, no order as to cost is made.

    Appeal partly allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Jay Singh v. Lal Muni Devi And Another
    (Jun 21, 1999)