Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Section 35 of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976 (Bihar Act XXIII of 1976) (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • clauses (a) and (b) of sub-section (1),
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Section 35 of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976 (Bihar Act XXIII of 1976) (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • clauses (a) and (b) of sub-section (1),
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Radha Mohan Prasad, J. (with Nagendra Rai, J. concurring)

Factual and Procedural Background

Three writ applications were heard together because the questions involved and the facts were substantially similar. The petitioners challenged withholding of their salaries from August/October 1991 by the respondents. In C.W.J.C. No. 873 of 1992(R) petitioners sought quashing of an order dated 18-10-1991 by the Registrar of Ranchi University directing the Principal of Markham Commerce College not to pay staff whose names did not appear in the list approved by the State Government, and the consequential order of the Principal (Annexure 6) stopping payment. In C.W.J.C. No. 837 of 1992(R) petitioners sought quashing of orders dated 3-1-1992, 18-1-1992 and 20-1-1992 (Annexures 6, 5 and 8) withholding salary from October 1991. An amendment sought quashing of a University order dated 23-7-1992 (Annexure 9) directing termination of services of persons whose names did not appear in the State-approved list.

Petitioners in the first two matters alleged appointments as Class III and IV employees (clerks, laboratory staff, peons, etc.) between 1983 and 1985 by the Governing Body of Markham Commerce College, with their services confirmed by the Governing Body. Petitioners in C.W.J.C. No. 837 of 1992(R) said posts had been sanctioned earlier (meeting dated 26-7-1976), appointments were made after advertisement and interview by a selection committee, and the selection panel was approved by the University.

The colleges became constituent colleges of Ranchi University on 31-10-1986. The University sent employee names to the State Government for approval. The State Government issued a circular on 12-2-1990 (Annexure 3) sending provisional approved lists and inviting objections, stating that omitted names receiving salary would continue to receive it until a final decision. Petitioners asserted their names were sent but omitted from the approved list due to a typographical error.

The University and State filed counter-affidavits denying that the petitioners' names were in the approved lists prepared after scrutiny, asserting prior University directions (including a direction dated 2-2-1987, Annexure A) that no payment be made to such unapproved staff, and stating the Vice-Chancellor did not approve the appointments. The University also asserted financial constraints and that funds are available only for employees on State-approved posts; if any Principal paid such employees, that payment was unauthorized and recoverable.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners, whose appointments were made without prior approval of the State Government after the colleges became constituent colleges, are entitled to have their withheld salaries paid by the University or State.
  2. Whether appointments and continuance of the petitioners beyond six months (without prior State approval) are lawful under Section 35 of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976.
  3. Whether payments made to employees appointed in contravention of Section 35 can create enforceable rights in favour of those employees or whether such payments are recoverable and at the risk of those who authorised them.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (learned Counsel Mr. A.K. Sinha)

  • The petitioners had been working for a long period (over eight years in some cases), and stopping their salaries or terminating their services was wholly unjustified.
  • Stopping payment/termination was contrary to the State Government's circular (Annexure 3), which indicated that omitted names receiving salary would continue until a final decision.
  • The University acted arbitrarily and mala fide by withholding salary and seeking termination despite long service.
  • In any case, petitioners claimed entitlement to payment by the University for the period they actually worked.

Respondents' Arguments (Ranchi University and State; learned Counsel Mr. M.S. Anwar)

  • The petitioners' names did not appear in the list prepared on the basis of the University's scrutiny committee recommendation; the University did not accept them as duly appointed employees and did not direct payment.
  • The University had earlier directed (2-2-1987, Annexure A) that no payment be made to such unauthorised teachers and non-teaching staff.
  • The State Government had not approved their names; the Vice-Chancellor did not approve appointments made by the Principal.
  • Under Section 35 of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976, no college (except those in clauses (a) and (b) of sub-section (1)) could appoint any person on any post without prior approval of the State Government, except to fill a sanctioned teacher's post for up to six months by a qualified candidate.
  • Appointments made without prior State approval are nullities and cannot impose liability on the University or State for payment of salary; any payment authorised by Principals or other authorities in contravention of the statute is at the risk of those who authorised it and recoverable.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Manoj Prasad & Ors. v. Ranchi University & Ors., C.W.J.C. No. 868 of 1992(R), reported in (1993) 2 BLJR (DB) (RB) 893 (Division Bench) The Division Bench held that in cases of illegal appointments made by Principals at the local level, any authority (Principal, Vice-Chancellor, Registrar or other) authorising payment to such appointees does so at its own risk; the University may seek to realise amounts disbursed from persons authorising such illegal payment and take other lawful action against them. The court relied on this decision to conclude that even if University authorities or college bodies acted to appoint or pay the petitioners in contravention of Section 35, those actions were at the risk of the appointing/authorising authorities and could not confer enforceable rights on the petitioners to claim salary from the University or State.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded from undisputed material facts: the relevant colleges were formerly affiliated but were not established, maintained or governed by the State Government and were not minority institutions (thus they did not fall within clauses (a) or (b) of Section 35(1) of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976). It was also not disputed that the petitioners' appointments were made without prior approval of the State Government and that petitioners claimed to have continued in service beyond six months.

The court considered Section 35 of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976, which (as quoted in the opinion) prohibits creation of posts involving financial liabilities and requires prior State approval for appointment to posts in colleges other than those covered by clauses (a) and (b), and provides a limited exception for filling a sanctioned teacher's post for a period not exceeding six months by a qualified candidate.

Applying the statutory mandate, the court concluded that the petitioners' appointments and continuance beyond six months were in breach of the mandatory provisions of Section 35. The court then applied the Division Bench precedent (Manoj Prasad & Ors.) which establishes that where appointments are illegal under the statute, any payments made pursuant to such appointments by college authorities or university officers are at the risk of those who authorised them and cannot generate a legal right in favour of the appointee to claim payment from the University or State.

On this combined basis of statutory violation and binding precedent, the court found that the petitioners could not obtain the reliefs sought in these writ applications. The court nevertheless acknowledged the factual circumstance that some petitioners had worked continuously for long periods (about eight years) and observed that the University could re-examine their claims and refer the matter afresh to the State Government; if the State Government then approved the appointments in terms of Section 35, petitioners would be free to pursue appropriate redressal mechanisms thereafter.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ applications are DISMISSED. The court held that the petitioners' appointments and continuance beyond six months without prior State approval were in breach of Section 35 of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976, and that any actions by Principals or University officers to appoint or pay such persons do not confer enforceable rights on the petitioners.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The petitioners are not entitled to the reliefs prayed for and their writ petitions are dismissed.
  • Practical consequence for petitioners: The court invited the University to re-examine the petitioners' claims and to refer the matter to the State Government. If the State Government subsequently accords approval under Section 35, the petitioners will have liberty to pursue remedies before the appropriate authority.
  • Legal consequence: The decision applies the existing Division Bench precedent and statutory rule; the court treated payments made contrary to Section 35 as incapable of conferring rights on the employees. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond applying the statute and the cited Division Bench authority.
Order: Petition dismissed. (Nagendra Rai, J. agreed.)

    Gopi Krishna Pathak & Ors. v. Ranchi University & Ors.

    Radha Mohan Prasad, J.:— All the three writ applications have been heard together and are being disposed of by this common judgment/order as the questions involved are identical as also the facts are, more or less, similar.

    2. In the said writ applications the grievance of the petitioners is that their salary with effect from August, 1991.October, 1991 has been withheld by the respondents without any valid reason and thus, the action at the respondents in this regard is wholly unjustified. C.W.J.C No. 873 of 1992 (R), a further prayer has been made for quashing of the order dated 18-10-1991 issued by the Registrar, Ranchi University (respondent No. 3) whereby he has issued direction to the Principal of Markham Commerce College, Hazaribagh not to make payment to such teaching and non-teaching staff whose names do not figure in the list approved by the Government and the consequential order of the Principal, as contained in Anaexure 6, stopping the payment of salary of the petitioners of the said case. In C.W.J.C No. 837 of 1992(R), the petitioners have also prayed for quashing of the orders dated 3-1-1992, 18-1-1992 and 20-1-1992, as contained in Anaexures 6, 5 and 8, respectively, issued by the University whereby the salary of the petitioners has been withheld from the month of October, 1991.

    3. Later an amendment petition has been filed on behalf of the petitioners of the first two writ applications for quashing of the order of the University dated 23rd July, 1992, annexed as Annexure 9 to both the writ applications, whereby the Principals of all the newly converted constituent Colleges under the University have been directed by the University to terminate the services of all such persons (both teaching and non-teaching) whose names do not appear in the approved list sent by the State Government in the HRD Department.

    4. In short, the case of the petitioners in the first two cases is that they were appointed as Class III and Class IV employees in different posts, such as, Clerk, Laboratory Incharge Laboratory Assistant, Peons etc. on different dates between 1983 and 1985 in the aforesaid Markham Commerce College by the Governing Body and, accordingly, the petitioners joined their respective posts in the aforesaid Colleges. It is also stated by the petitioners of the first two writ applications that their appointments were made by the Governing body of aforesaid Markham Commerce College and their services were confirmed by the Governing Body.

    5. The case os the petitioners of C.W.J.C No. 837 of 1992 (R) is that prior to 1976 the Governing Body of B.S.K College sanctioned the posts for the College in its meeting dated 26-7-1976 and created 21 posts in class III and 20 posts in Class IV and sought the approval of the University. It is also stated that their appointments were made after due advertisement and interview by a selection committee which prepared a panel of selected candidates in which the names of the petitioners were included and the same was also approved by the University, whereafter they were appointed.

    6. The said Colleges were taken over as constituent Colleges of the Ranchi University with effect from 31-10-1986. The petitioners claimed that after the take over of the College, the University sent the names of the employees, both teaching and non-teaching, of the said Colleges to the State Government for approval. The State Government (respondent No. 5 in C.W.J.C No. 873 of 1992(R) on 12th February, 1990 had issued circular which has been annexed as Anneure 3 in C.W.J.C No. 873 of 1992(R) to all the Universities in the State of Bihar, including the Ranchi University, in which the names of the approved employees of different newly constituent Colleges duly recommended by the University were also sent inviting objections. In the said circular, however, it was mentioned that if certain names are omitted to be included in the provisional list and they are getting their salary from the concerned College, then they would continue to get the same until some final decision is not taken in their matter. It is further stated by the petitioners of the first two writ applications that their names were also sent for approval by the University but due to some typopraphical error their names were not included in the approved list.

    7. Counter-affidavits have been filed in all the writ applications on behalf of the University and also on behalf of the State. Their case, in short, is that the names of the petitioners did not find place in the list prepared on the basis of the recommendation of the scrutiny committee of the University and, thus, neither the University accepted them to be duly appointed employees of the College nor a direction was made for payment of their salary at that time. The University had issued specific direction to the Principal of the College as far back as on 2nd February, 1987 itself, as contained in Annexure A to the counter-affidavit, while releasing the fund to the newly converted constituent College up to January, 1987 that no payment is to be made to such teachers and non-teaching staff. According to them, the State Government also have not approved their names. Further, it is stated that the Vice-Chancellor also deeded not to approve the appoinment made by the Principal. It has been denied that the University ever made any payment to those employees who were not appointed on a sanctioned post and whose names had not been approved by the University and/or by the State Government. It is also state that the University is facing financial crises and unable to pay salary to its regular employees regularly as it is fully dependent on the State Government. The University is receiving fund only for such employees who are working on approved posts and as such is unable to pay the salary of the petitioner. However if any payment has been made by the Principle, then the same is an unauthorised payment and the University shall take necessary action in this regard against the Principals.

    8. Mr. A.K Sinha, learned Counsel for the petitioners, submitted that those petitioners have been working for a long time and stopping of the payment of their salary and/or termination of their services is wholly unjustified and contrary to the decision of the State Government, as contained in Annexure 3. He further submitted that the respondent-University in their case have acted arbitarily and mala fide inasmuch as though they have been working in the College for now over eight years or more, their services are being sought to be terminated without there being any valid reason. According to the learned Counsel, in any case, the petitioners are entitled to the payment of their salary by the University for the period they have actuality worked.

    9. On the other hand, Mr. M.S Anwar, learned Counsel appearing for the University, submitted that, in view of the provisions contained in Section 35 of the Bihar State Universities Act, 1976 (Bihar Act XXIII of 1976) (hereinafter referred to as the Act’) no College other than those mentioned in clauses (a) and (b) of sub-section (1) of Section 35 of the Act was entitled to appoint any person on any post without the prior approval of the State Government except for filling up a sanctioned post of a teacher and that too for a period not exceeding six months, by a candidate possessing the prescribed qualification. Section 35 of the Act is as follows:—

    “35. No post for appointment shall be created without the prior sanction of the State Government.—Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, no University or any College affiliated to such a University, except such College—

    (a) as is established, maintained or governed by the State Government; or

    (b) as is established by religious or linguistic minority;

    (i) After the commencement of this Act no teaching or non-teaching post involving financial liabilities shall be created without the prior approval of the State Government;

    (ii) shall either increase the pay or allowance attached to any post, or sanction any new allowance:

    Provided that the State Government may, by an order, revise the pay-scale attached to such post or sanction any new allowance;

    (iii) shall sanction any special pay or allowance or other remuneration of any kind including ex-gratia payment or any other benefit having financial implication to any person holding a teaching or non-teaching post;

    (iv) shall incur expenditure of any kind on any development scheme without the prior approval of the State Government.

    (2) Notwithstanding anything containsd in this Act, no college other than one mentioned in clauses (a) and (b) of sub-section (1), shall, after the commencement of this Act, appoint any person on any post without the prior approval of the State Government:

    Provided that the approval of the State Government shall not be necessary for filing up a sanctioned post of a teacher for a period not exceeding six months, by a candidate possessing the prescribed qualification.”

    10. According to him, as the very appointment of the petitioners having been made without the prior approval of the State Government makes the same nullity in the eye of law and the University or the State Government cannot be added with the liability for payment of their salary. In support of this submission Mr. Anwar placed reliance to a Division Bench judgment of this Court passed in C.W.J.C No. 868 of 1992(R) in the case of Manoj Prasad & Ors. v. Ranchi University & Ors., reported in (1993) 2 BLJR (DB) (RB), 893 wherein, more or less, in similar facts, the Division Bench of this Court held as follows:—

    “In the case of illegal appointments made by the Principals at the local level, if any one authorises payment of wages to them, be it the Principal, the Vice-Chancellor, Registrar or any other authority, they do so at their own risk. It is open to the University in such cases to realise the amount so disbursed from the concerned persons authorising such illegal payment, apart from any other action that may be taken against them in accordance with law.”

    11. From the facts of these Cases it is not in dispute that both the Colleges before they became constituent were affiliated Colleges of the University and are not covered by clauses (a) and (b) of Section 35 of the Act as it is neither established, maintained or governed by the State Government nor by a religious or linguistic minority. Further, it is not in dispute that the appointments of the petitioners were not made after faking prior approval of the State Government on the contrary the State Government have not approved their appointment still it is claimed that they have continued to work for a period exceeding six months.

    12. In that, view of the matter, the appointments of the petitioners and even continuance of the teachers amongst them beyond six months are in the breach of the mandatory pro visions of Section 35 of the Act. Thus, in view of the aforesaid Division Bench Judgment of this Court that even if the Principal, Governing Body, Vice-Chancellor, Registrar of any other authority acted in the matter of their appointment/continuance or even in relation to payment of wages contrary to the aforementioned provisions contained in Section 35 of the Act, then they have done so at their own risk and that cannot confer any right in the petitioners to claim the reliefs prayed for in these writ applications.

    13. Accordingly, I find that the petitioners are not entitled for any relief prayed for in these writ applications and the same are dismissed. However, in the special facts and circumstances. I would like to observe that as the petitioners are said to have worked continuously for eight years in the College, it will be open for the University to re-examine their claims and refer the matter to the State Government again and if the State Government accords its approval in terms of Section 35 of the Act, then the petitioners will be at liberty to move the appropriate authority for redressal of their grievances made in these writ applications.

    14. Nagendra Rai, J.:— I agree.

    Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gopi Krishna Pathak & Ors. v. Ranchi University & Ors.
    (Apr 16, 1993)