AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 48 of the Bihar and Orissa Co-operative Societies Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act).
  • Section 114 and under Order XLVII, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908
  • Section 151 of the said Code. Then Sub-section (8)
  • Clause (b) of Sub-section (2) of Section 48
  • section in Sub-section (9) of Section 48
  • Clauses (b) or (c) of Sub-section (2)
  • Clause (b) or (c) of Sub-section (2)
  • Sub-section (2) of Section 48
  • Sub-section (9) of Section 48
  • Clause (b) of Sub-section (2)
  • Section 44 in Section 56
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 48 of the Bihar and Orissa Co-operative Societies Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act).
  • Section 114 and under Order XLVII, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908
  • Section 151 of the said Code. Then Sub-section (8)
  • Clause (b) of Sub-section (2) of Section 48
  • section in Sub-section (9) of Section 48
  • Clauses (b) or (c) of Sub-section (2)
  • Clause (b) or (c) of Sub-section (2)
  • Sub-section (2) of Section 48
  • Sub-section (9) of Section 48
  • Clause (b) of Sub-section (2)
  • Section 44 in Section 56
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a decree-holder's appeal against concurrent orders of the courts below holding his execution petition not maintainable and dismissing it. The appellant was a shareholder-member of the Bihar State Co-operative Marketing Union (the respondent) and had taken contracts to carry out certain works for the respondent. A dispute arose under Section 48 of the Bihar and Orissa Co-operative Societies Act concerning the amount payable for that work. The District Co-operative Officer rejected the appellant's claim. The appellant appealed to the Deputy Registrar (Co-operative Society (Judicial)), who allowed the appeal and passed a decree for Rs. 28,143.68 in the appellant's favour.

The appellant presented an execution petition before the Execution Munsif, Patna. The respondent filed a revision before the Registrar of Co-operative Societies against the Deputy Registrar's order. The Registrar modified the Deputy Registrar's order, significantly reducing the decree in the appellant's favour. The appellant did not amend his execution petition to reflect the Registrar's order, nor did he file a copy of the Registrar's order. The respondent objected in the execution proceedings that the Deputy Registrar's decree had merged into the Registrar's modified decree and that only the Registrar's decree could be executed. The Execution Munsif upheld the respondent's objection. The appellant appealed to the District Judge (heard by Additional Subordinate Judge 6th Court, Patna), which confirmed the Execution Munsif's order and dismissed the appeal. The present appeal to this Court followed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellate order of the Deputy Registrar passed under Section 48(6) of the Bihar and Orissa Co-operative Societies Act could be revised by the Registrar under Section 56 of the Act.
  2. Whether the Execution Munsif, Patna had pecuniary jurisdiction to entertain the execution petition arising from the Deputy Registrar's decree (noted in the opinion, although no objection on pecuniary jurisdiction was pressed before the courts below or this Court).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appeal-order passed by the Deputy Registrar under Section 48 of the Act was final and not subject to revision by the Registrar under Section 56.
  • Section 56, it was submitted, permits revision only of orders under Section 44; accordingly the Registrar had no jurisdiction to revise orders arising under Section 48.
  • If Section 56 were read more broadly, it still did not permit revision of orders passed under Section 48.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The revisionary power conferred on the Registrar by Section 56 is wide enough to apply to orders passed under all sections of the Act, including Section 48.
  • Reliance was placed on the Bench decision in Shahebgunj Motor Transport Co-operative Society Ltd. v. Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Bihar (1972 B.L.J.R. 455), where the Registrar revised an order under Section 11 and it was held that he had power to do so under Section 56.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shahebgunj Motor Transport Co-operative Society Ltd. v. Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Bihar (1972 B.L.J.R. 455) The Registrar has power under Section 56 of the Act to revise an order passed under another section of the Act (in that case, Section 11). The Court treated this Bench decision as binding (unless referred to a larger Bench) and accepted for present purposes that Section 56 is not confined to orders under Section 44 only. Nevertheless, the Court concluded that, despite this precedent, Section 56 does not apply to orders under Section 48 in the circumstances of the present case because of the finality provision in Section 48(9).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by identifying the precise question: whether an appellate order of the Deputy Registrar passed under Section 48(6) could be the subject of revision by the Registrar under Section 56. The Court reviewed the relevant statutory provisions in the Act:

  • Section 48(1), (2), (6), (7), (8) and (9) were examined. Notably, Section 48(2) permits the Registrar either (a) to decide the dispute himself, (b) to transfer it to any person exercising the powers of a Registrar, or (c) to refer it to arbitrators. Section 48(6) permits appeal to the Registrar against decisions transferred or referred under clauses (b) or (c). Section 48(7) confers review and inherent jurisdiction on the Registrar similar to specified Civil Procedure Code provisions. Section 48(8) permits the Registrar to state a case to the District Judge whose decision shall be final. Section 48(9) provides that "save as expressly provided in this section" a decision of the Registrar under this section and, subject to orders of the Registrar on appeal or review, a decision given in a dispute transferred or referred under clauses (b) or (c) shall be final.
  • Section 56 provides that "The Registrar may on application or of his own motion revise any order passed by a person exercising the powers of a Registrar or by a liquidator under Section 44." The Court noted that Section 44 itself refers to Registrar's revisional power in certain subsections.

The Court considered competing textual interpretations. The appellant argued that the phrase "under Section 44" in Section 56 limits the Registrar's revisional power to orders under Section 44 and that the grammatical structure of Section 56 supported that restrictive reading. The respondent argued that the existence of a separate section (Section 56) conferring revisional power indicates a broad power applicable to orders under various sections of the Act.

Because of the binding Bench decision in Shahebgunj Motor Transport (which held Registrar could revise an order under another section pursuant to Section 56), the Court proceeded on the assumption that Section 56 is not limited to orders under Section 44 only. However, the Court nevertheless concluded that Section 56 had no application to orders passed by persons exercising the powers of a Registrar under Section 48 for the following reasons:

  • Section 48 itself creates its own comprehensive scheme for reference, disposal, appeal, review and finality. The phrase "save as expressly provided in this section" in Section 48(9) indicates the legislature intended the finality provisions in Section 48 to be insulated from other provisions of the Act unless Section 48 itself provided otherwise.
  • Section 48(9) gives finality to decisions given in disputes transferred or referred under clauses (b) or (c) of Section 48(2) and makes the Registrar's decisions under Section 48 subject only to the internal appeal, review and district-judge reference mechanisms provided within Section 48.
  • An order under clause (a) of Section 48(2) must be by the Registrar "himself" (and not by a person exercising the powers of the Registrar). Such an order, being by the Registrar, would not be subject to revision under Section 56 in the manner contemplated; more importantly, the statutory language shows the scheme of internal finality within Section 48.
  • The appellate order before the Court was an order of the Deputy Registrar under Section 48(6) in relation to a dispute transferred under clause (b) of Section 48(2). The Court concluded that, in view of Section 48(9)'s finality language, that appellate order could not be revised by the Registrar under Section 56.

Accordingly, the Court held that no revision lay to the Registrar against the Deputy Registrar's order in this case and that the Registrar's order modifying the Deputy Registrar's order and decree was without jurisdiction.

The Court also considered (briefly) the question of pecuniary jurisdiction of the Execution Munsif. It noted Section 51, which provides that orders passed under Sections 44, 48 and 50 may be enforced by Civil Courts having local (territorial) jurisdiction "in the same manner as a decree of such Court." The Court interpreted this provision as referring to territorial jurisdiction, not pecuniary jurisdiction. Because no objection on pecuniary jurisdiction was taken before the courts below or before this Court, the Court declined to decide this point further.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; the orders of the courts below dismissing the appellant's execution petition are set aside.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The Registrar's revision that modified the Deputy Registrar's order and decree was held to be without jurisdiction in respect of the appellate order under Section 48(6).
  • The Execution Munsif, Patna is directed to dispose of the execution case in accordance with law (i.e., the execution proceedings may proceed consistent with the Deputy Registrar's decree as held to be not subject to revision by the Registrar in these circumstances).
  • The appellant was allowed the appeal with costs; hearing fee for this Court was assessed at Rs. 150/-.

Broader implications:

The opinion reasons from the statutory scheme of Section 48 and Section 56 and relies on a binding Bench decision (Shahebgunj Motor Transport) to frame its analysis. The Court did not purport to lay down a new general precedent overriding Section 48's internal finality; rather it applied statutory construction to conclude that Section 56 did not authorize revision of the Deputy Registrar's appellate order in this case. The opinion does not discuss broader doctrinal consequences beyond the direct disposition in this case.

    Din Dayal Singh v. The Bihar State Co-Operative Marketing Union Ltd.

    Shambhu Prasad Singh, J.:— This is a decree-holder's appeal against concurrent orders of the courts below holding his execution petition as not maintainable and dismissing it. The appellant was a share-holder member of the Bihar State Co-operative Marketing Union, the respondent. He also took contracts for doing certain works for the respondent. As there were differences as to the amount payable to him for the said work a dispute arose under Section 48 of the Bihar and Orissa Co-operative Societies Act (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’). The claim of the appellant was, however, rejected by the District Co-operative Officer Against that order the appellant preferred an appeal which was heard by the Deputy Registrar, Co-operative Society (Judicial). The Deputy Registrar allowed the appeal and passed a decree for Rs. 28,143.68 P. against the respondent. The appellant levied execution before the Execution Munsif, Patna. The respondent went in revision to the Registrar, Co-operative Societies, against the order of the Deputy Registrar. The Registrar modified the order of the Deputy Registrar reducing considerably the amount decreed in favour of the appellant. The appellant, however did not amend his execution petition in the light of the order passed by the Registrar nor did he file a copy of the order of the Registrar.

    2. An objection was raised on behalf of the respondent that the execution case was not maintainable for, the decree of the Deputy Registrar had merged in the decree of the Registrar and that decree alone could be executed. The contention of the appellant was that no revision lay to the Registrar against the order of the Deputy Registrar and the order and decree of the Registrar modifying the order and decree of the Deputy Registrar were without jurisdiction. The execution Munsif upheld the contention of the respondent. Thereafter there was an appeal by the appellant to the District Judge which was heard by additional Subordinate Judge 6th Court, Patna, who confirmed the order of the Execution Munsif and dismissed the appeal.

    3. Mr. Janardan Sinha appearing for the appellant in this Court has contended that an order passed on appeal by the Deputy Registrar (Judicial) under Section 48 of the Act was final and could not be revised by the Registrar in exercise of revisional powers conferred upon him under Section 56 of the Act. According to Mr. Sinha, under Section 56 of the Act the Registrar can revise orders passed under Section 44 of the Act and not other sections of the Act and even if it is held that the Registrar of exercise of the powers conferred upon him under Section 56 of the Act can revise orders passed under sections, other than Section 44, he cannot revise orders passed under Section 48 of the Act. On the other hand, on behalf of the respondent it has been contended that power of revision conferred upon the Registrar under Section 56 of the Act is wide enough to apply to orders passed under all sections of the Act including Section 48. In support of this contention reliance has been placed on a Bench decision of this Court in (1) Shahebgunj Motor Transport Co-operative Society Ltd. v. Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Bihar (1972 B.L.J.R 455). In that case the Registrar had revised an order passed under Section 11 of the Act and it was held that he had power to do so under Section 56 of the Act.

    4. In order to appreciate the contentions raised before us it may be necessary to refer to certain sections of the Act. Section 48(1) provides for reference of certain disputes to the Registrar. Sub-section (2) of Section 48 lays down that on receipt of such reference the Registrar (a) may decide the dispute himself, or (b) transfer it for disposal to any person exercising the powers of a Registrar in this behalf, or (c) subject to any rule, refer it for disposal to an arbitrator or arbitrators. Sub-section (6) says that any person aggrieved by any decision given in dispute transferred or referred under Clause (b) or (c) of Sub-section (2) may, within three months from the date of such decision, appeal to the Registrar. Sub-section (7) provides that the Registrar, in the case of disputes under this section, shall have the power of review vested in a Civil Court under Section 114 and under Order XLVII, Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 and shall also have the inherent jurisdiction specified in Section 151 of the said Code. Then Sub-section (8) lays down that the Registrar may where it appear to him advisable, either on application or of his own motion, state a case and refer it to the District Judge for decision, and the decision of the District Judge shall be final, Sub-section (9) reads as follows:—

    “Save as expressly provided in this section, a decision of the Registrar under this section, and subject to the orders of the Registrar on appeal or review, a decision given in a dispute transferred or referred under Clause (b) or (c) of Sub-section (2) shall be final.”

    5. Section 6 of the Act provides that the State Government may appoint a person to be Registrar of Co-operative Societies for the State or any portion of it, and may appoint persons to asisst such Registrar and that the State Government may by general or special order published in the official gazette confer on any person appointed to assist the Registrar, all or any of the powers of the Registrar under the Act except the powers under Section 26.

    6. It is not in dispute that both the District Co-operative Officer and the Deputy Registrar (Judicial) were appointed to assist the Registrar under Section 6(1) of the Act and were conferred powers under Section 6(2) of the Act to exercise the powers of the Registrar. The District Co-operative Officer, therefore, decided the dispute under Clause (b) of Sub-section (2) of Section 48 and the Deputy Registrar beard the appeal which was filed under Sub-section (6) of that Section. The exact question which arises for decision in this appeal is whether the appellate order of the Deputy Registrar passed under Section 48(6) could be revised by the Registrar under Section 56 of the Act.

    7. Section 56 of the Act reads as follows: “The Registrar may on application or of his own motion revise any order passed by a person exercising the powers of a Registrar or by a liquidator under Section 44”.

    8. Sub-sections (3) and (6) of Section 44 of the Act themselves refer to the power of the Registrar to revise an order passed under that section. It has been contended on behalf of the appellant that the fact that other Section of the Act do not refer to the powers of revision by the Registrar and Section 44 refers to it shows that the power of revision conferred on the Registrar under Section 56 is confined to order passed under Section 44 only and the words “under Section 44” in Section 56 qualify both (1) “any order passed by a person exercising the powers of a Registrar” and (2) “by a liquidator”. It has also been emphasised that the use of the expression ‘any order passed by’ only once and not again before the expression “by a liquidator” supports this contention. On the other hand, it has been contended on behalf of the respondent that if the intention of the legislature would have been that the Registrar could revise only such orders which were passed under Section 44, then provision for that would have been made in that section and the power of revision would not have been conferred by the legislature on the Registrar by a separate section, namely, Section 56. It has been urged that the very fact that power of revision has been conferred on the Registrar by an independent section shows that the power can be exercised by the Registrar in respect of any order passed by a person exercising the powers of a Registrar under any of the Section of the Act. The decision of the question is not free from difficulty and much can be said in support of the contention of the appellant. However, in view of the Bench decision of the Court in Shahebgunj Motor Transport Co-operative Societies' case (supra) which is binding on us, unless the matter is referred to a larger Bench, I proceed on the assumption that the power of revision conferred on the Registrar under Section 56 of the Act is not limited to orders passed by a person exercising the powers of a Registrar under Section 44 only. However, I am of the opinion that inspite of the view that Section 56 is not limited in its application to orders passed under Section 44 only, it has got no application to orders passed by a person exercising the powers of a Registrar under Section 48 of the Act.

    9. Relevant provisions of Section 48 of the Act have already been referred to and it has been noted that the section itself provides for appeal as well as review and then lays down that save as expressly provided in that section, a decision of the Registrar under that section and subject to the orders of the Registrar on appeal or review, a decision given in a dispute transferred or referred under Clause (b) or (c) shall be final. Tie expression “save as expressly provided in this section” in Sub-section (9) of Section 48 is of special significance. By use of that expression the legislature appears to have clearly laid down that provisions of other sections of the Act do not affect the finality of the order passed under Section 48. It is true that Sub-section (9) of Section 48 gives finality to decisions given in a dispute transferred or referred under Clauses (b) or (c) of Sub-section (2) only and not to a decision under Clause (a) of Sub-section (2), but reading Section 48 as a whole it is manifest that the decision contemplated under Clause (a) of Sub-section (2) must be by the Registrar “himself” [used in clause (a)] “and not by any person exercising the powers of a Registrar in this behalf” [used in clause (b)]. An order under Clause (a) which can be passed by the Registrar himself, and not by any person exercising the powers of a Registrar, obviously cannot be revised under Section 56 of the Act. In this case however, we are concerned with an order passed in an appeal against the decision given in a dispute transferred under Clause (b) of Sub-section (2) and I am of the opinion that on account of the language of Sub-section (9) of Section 48, the appellate order of the Deputy Registrar in this case passed under Section 48(6) of the Act could not be revised by the Registrar under Section 56 of the Act. It has rightly been contended on behalf of the appellant that no revision lay to the Registrar against the order of the Deputy Registrar and the order and decree of the Registrar modifying the order and decree of the Deputy Registrar were without jurisdiction. In the circumstances, the courts below have erred in rejecting the application for execution of the order and decree passed by the Deputy Registrar.

    10. It appears that the amount claimed in the dispute and awarded in the decree passed by the Deputy Registrar was beyond the pecuniary jurisdiction of the Execution Munsif of Patna before whom the execution petition was filed. Perhaps, it was filed there on account of the language of Section 51 which reads as follows:

    “Orders passed under Sections 44, 48 and 50 shall, in addition to any other method of enforcement provided under this Act, on application be enforced as follows:—

    (a) When passed by the Registrar, a liquidator or by an arbitrator or arbitrators, by any Civil Court having local jurisdiction in the same manner as a decree of such Court, (b) When passed by the District Judge in the same manner as a decree of the District Judge made in any suit pending before him”

    11. The section refers only to “local jurisdiction,” i.e territorial jurisdiction of the court before which the execution petition is to be filed and not of its pecuniary jurisdiction. In the circumstances the Execution Munsif appears to have jurisdiction to entertain the petition for execution. Really no objection was taken before that court or before the lower appellate court that the execution petition could not be filed before the Execution Munsif for lack of pecuniary jurisdiction. This point was also not raised before this Court. I do not, therefore, propose to discuss this point any further.

    12. In the result, the appeal is allowed with costs. The orders of the courts below dismissing the execution case of the appellant are set aside and the Execution munsif, Patna, is directed to dispose of the execution case in accordance with law. Hearing fee for this Court is assessed at Rs. 150/- only.

    13. Uday Sinha, J.:— I agree.

    Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Din Dayal Singh v. The Bihar State Co-Operative Marketing Union Ltd.
    (Nov 13, 1975)