AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an application under Articles 220 and 227 of the Constitution of India seeking to quash an industrial tribunal award dated 19 February 1966 (Reference Case No. 21 of 1864). The award, made in favour of the workmen, held them entitled to payment of bonus for the period July–December 1963 equivalent to one month's pay as an implied condition of service.

The petitioner is a public limited company incorporated in England with operations in India; its Calcutta factory was shifted to Ranchi in 1960, and the dispute concerns the Ranchi factory. The Government of Bihar, by notification dated 24 September 1964, referred disputes between the petitioner and its workmen (represented by the Minimax Workmen's Union, opposite party 1) to the industrial tribunal under Section 10(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act.

The reference contained two items: (1) whether the management was justified in not making payment of the customary bonus for July–December 1963 (payable in January 1964) and, if not, what relief the workmen were entitled to; and (2) standards of production for introducing a bonus scheme and linkage of bonus to production. Item (2) was the subject of an interim award and is not part of this petition; item (1) was decided by the impugned award now challenged.

By the impugned award the tribunal held the workmen entitled to a half-yearly bonus equal to one month's pay for July–December 1963 (payable January 1964) as an implied term of employment; it also held that 122 workers who were not paid because they took part in a general strike on 15 January 1964 were nevertheless entitled to the bonus. The tribunal rejected the management's preliminary objection that the reference could not be construed as raising the question of bonus as an implied term of contract.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the management was justified in not making payment of the "customary bonus" for July–December 1963, which was due in January 1964.
  2. Whether the bonus in question was an ex gratia/profit-sharing/production-linked payment or an implied condition of service (i.e., contractual in effect) payable half-yearly.
  3. Whether the industrial tribunal had jurisdiction to construe the order of reference and decide whether the bonus was an implied term of service despite the reference describing it as "customary bonus".

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (Sri Lal Narayan Sinha)

  • The tribunal erred in going beyond the specific term of reference (which used the phrase "customary bonus" for the six-month period July–December 1963) by treating the issue as whether the bonus was an implied term of contract of service.
  • The tribunal lacked jurisdiction to vary or construe the order of reference so as to treat "customary bonus" as "bonus as implied term of service".
  • Submission that "customary bonus" is a term of definite connotation and is different from "contractual bonus"; argued that customary bonus is normally linked with festivals (a festival bonus), and here the bonus as claimed by workmen was not linked to any festival.

Union / Workmen's Arguments

  • The union's written statement asserted that the company did not pay living wages to all its workmen and, to fill the gap between real wages and minimum wages, the company used to pay one month's basic pay as a half-yearly bonus every six months irrespective of production or profit.
  • The union pleaded that this payment had been made since inception of the Ranchi factory and had, by long and uniform practice, become a condition of employment (an implied contractual term), i.e., not an ex gratia payment.

Management's Pleadings (as recorded)

  • The management maintained that the payment described as "customary bonus" was linked with festivals and thus contended that the bonus claimed was a festival/customary bonus; also suggested that the payment was ex gratia or a profit-sharing/production bonus at the management's discretion.
  • As per the management's case, production in July–December 1963 was low due to worker slow-down tactics and therefore no bonus was declared for that period.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Madras v. G.P. Sarathy and Anr., 1953 I L.L.J. 174 Support for the proposition that a tribunal has power and duty to find out the real dispute referred and not to be defeated by mere formalities in the reference. The court relied on this authority to affirm that the tribunal could look beyond the cryptic language of a reference to determine the actual dispute between parties.
Western India Automobile Association v. Industrial Tribunal, Bombay, 1949 L.L.J. 245 That the scope of adjudication under the Industrial Disputes Act is wide and references may be in wider terms; the tribunal may call for statements to crystallize the dispute. Used to support the view that wider phrasing in a reference does not bar the tribunal from deciding the substantive dispute so long as it falls within Section 2(k) and parties are identifiable.
Delhi Cloth and General Mills Co. Ltd. v. Their Workmen and Ors., 1967 I L.L.J. 423 (at 431) The tribunal must look to the pleadings of the parties to find out the exact nature of the dispute because orders of reference are often cryptic. The court applied this to hold that the tribunal was entitled — indeed required — to examine pleadings to ascertain the true dispute and therefore to construe the reference accordingly.
Tulsidas Khimji v. Their Workmen, 1962 I L.L.J. 435 Observations that cases arising out of "customary bonus" have often concerned festival bonuses (e.g., pujas, Diwali). Cited to note that while customary bonuses are often festival-related, "festival bonus" and "customary bonus" are not necessarily synonymous in law.
Ispahani Ltd., Calcutta v. Ispahani Employees' Union, 1959 II L.L.J. 4 Explains that a claim for puja bonus may be founded either on an implied agreement creating a term of employment or, alternatively, as a customary bonus. The court relied on this to show that customary bonus and implied contractual bonus can be distinct, but one can support the other; here the tribunal's treatment of the bonus as implied term was consistent with Ispahani principles.
Grahams Trading Company (India) Ltd. v. Their Workmen, 1959 II L.L.J. 393 Set out the tests for establishing a customary/traditional bonus: (i) unbroken series of years; (ii) paid for a sufficiently long time; (iii) payment made under circumstances excluding ex gratia; (iv) payment at a uniform rate. The court applied these tests to the tribunal's factual findings and observed that, on those findings (which were not challenged), the tests for customary or implied bonus were satisfied.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded along the following lines, based strictly on material in the record:

  1. Examination of pleadings and administrative records: The tribunal examined the pleadings and the written statement filed by the union, which asserted payment of one month's basic pay as a half-yearly bonus since inception of the factory (January 1961), paid irrespective of production or profit and even during periods of loss. The management's written statement, by contrast, claimed the payment was ex gratia or profit-sharing/production-linked and that customary bonus implied festival linkage.
  2. Inquiry into Assistant Labour Commissioner's report: The court considered the Assistant Labour Commissioner's joint inquiry report (dated 13 June 1964), which recorded that the bonus had been paid bi-annually equal to one month's pay since the factory's start in January 1961, was neither profit-sharing nor production-linked, and therefore the management was not justified in withholding payment from workers who took part in the strike. The Assistant Labour Commissioner recommended a reference couched in terms that mirrored the order of reference.
  3. Proper construction of the reference: The court accepted the tribunal's view that the word "customary" in the order of reference had been "loosely used" and that the true dispute — as crystallized by pleadings and the Labour Department's records — was whether the bonus was an implied term of service. The court held that it was within the tribunal's power and duty to construe the reference by reference to the pleadings and the facts, citing authorities that support such an approach.
  4. Relationship between "customary" and "contractual": The court noted there is no strict legal definition of "customary bonus" and observed the dictionary meaning of "customary" allows overlap with contractual rights; it accepted that a customary practice can evolve into a contractual term. The court rejected the petitioner's contention that treating customary and contractual as overlapping obliterated a necessary distinction in this case.
  5. Application of established tests: The court set out the Grahams Trading test for customary bonus (unbroken series; sufficiently long time; circumstances excluding ex gratia; uniform rate) and observed that, on the facts found by the tribunal (and not challenged before the court), these criteria — and the tests for implied-term festival bonus as in Ispahani — were satisfied.
  6. Conclusion on jurisdiction and merits: Because the tribunal's finding as to the true nature of the dispute was supported by the pleadings and the Labour Department records, and because relevant authorities authorize the tribunal to look into pleadings and not be trapped by formalistic wording of a reference, the court found no error in the tribunal's approach or conclusion.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The application is DISMISSED.

Direct consequences for the parties:

  • The impugned award of the industrial tribunal (holding the workmen entitled to a half-yearly bonus equal to one month's pay for July–December 1963 and that the 122 workmen who participated in the 15 January 1964 strike were nevertheless entitled to the bonus) stands.
  • The petitioner was ordered to pay costs: hearing fee of Rs. 200 payable to opposite party 1.

The opinion does not purport to set out or announce any new legal principle beyond applying established authorities; it confines itself to upholding the tribunal's jurisdiction to determine the true dispute and to the factual conclusion that the tests for a customary/contractual bonus were met on the record.

Decision delivered by R.L. Narasimham, C.J.; the other judge recorded agreement.

    Minimax, Ltd. v. Its Workmen Represented By The Minimax Workmen'S Union And Anr

    1. This application under Articles 220 and 227 of the Constitution of India has been filed for quashing the award of the industrial tribunal, Bihar, Patna, dated 19 February 1966, in Reference Case No. 21 of 1864 (annexure A). The a ward, which was in favour of the workmen, held them entitled to payment of bonus for the period July to December 1063, equivalent to one, month's pay as implied condition of service.'

    2. The petitioner is a public limited company, incorporated in England with branches all over the world, including Calcutta, Delhi and Bombay. Since long the petitioner bas been carrying on the business of manufacturing and selling various types of machines and machineries in this country in the year 1960, the company shirted its Calcutta factory to Ranchi, and it is with this factory at Ranchi that we are concerned in the present application.

    3. The Government of Bihar, in the Department of Labour and Employment, by Notification No. 111/DI-1006/64-L&E-8953, dated 24 September 1964, referred the dispute between the petitioner and its workmen represented by the Minimax Workmen's Union, opposite party 1 (hereinafter referred to as the union), under Section 10(1) of the industrial Disputes Act (hereinafter referred to as the Act). The disputes referred by the said notification were as follows:

    (1) Whether the management was justified in not making payment of the customary bonus for the period July-December 1963, in January 1964 to the workers ? If not, to what relief, if any, the workmen are entitled?

    (2) What should be standards of production for the introduction bonus scheme, and in what way should the bonus be linked to production?

    4. Item (2) of the reference was decided by the tribunal by an interim award dated 4 September 1965 and we are not concerned with that interim award in this application. Item (1) of the reference has been decided by the award (annexure A) which is under challenge in this application,

    5. By the impugned award the tribunal held that the workmen were entitled to half-yearly bonus equivalent to one month's pay for the period July to December 1963, payable in January 1964, as implied term of employment and that the 122 workers (mentioned in the written statement of the union), who were not paid the bonus for having taken part in general strike on 15 January 1964, were entitled to the payment of this bonus. It also rejected the preliminary objection of the management and held that what was really in dispute was the question whether bonus was payable an implied term of contract of service or not, and it was loosely described as "customary bonus" in the order of reference. It further held that payment of such kind of bonus was not hit by the Payment of Bonus Act, 1965, although is was adjustible against bonus under the said Act.

    6. The main contention of Sri Lal Narayan Sinha, appearing for the petitioner, was that the reference to the tribunal was with regard to payment of "customary bonus" for the period July to December 1963, payable in January 1964, i.e., for a period of six. months, and the tribunal was in error in going beyond the term of reference in awarding bonus "as implied term of contract of service." He further submitted that the tribunal had no jurisdiction to vary the term of reference, so as to construe it as being one for bonus as implied term of service.

    7. It is no doubt true that in the order of reference the bonus to be paid for six months from July to December 1963 has been described as "customary" bonus. Before the tribunal, the petitioner urged that customary bonus is always linked with festivals and it was not the case of the workman that this bonus was linked with any festival, and. according to the case made out by the petitioner as well, there was nothing like featival for a period of six months in respect of which the bonus in question was being claimed. That being the position, the tribunal locked into the written statement filed by the union to find out as to what WPS the real dispute between the parties with regard to bonus, the existence of an industrial dispute within the meaning of Section 2(k) of the Act, with regard to payment of bonus between the parties not being disputed. The tribunal, in Paras. 2 and 3 of its award, on a consideration of the pleadings of the parties, held that it was nobody's case that the bonus which the union was claiming was linked with any festival and the word "customary" in the order of reference has been loosely used. The tribunal also, on a consideration of the written statement of the union, found that what the workmen were really claiming was bonus as implied condition of service and proceeded to dispose of the reference on that footing. To satisfy ourselves, with regard to the aforesaid finding arrived at by the tribunal, we called for the records of the tribunal with the connected files of the Labour Department of the State Government as to what was really the dispute between the parties.

    8. In the written statement filed by the union (Para 8) it is stated that the company does not payliving wages to all its workman and to filt up the gap between the real wages and the minimum wages, the company used to pay one month's basic pay as half-yearly bonus for their services for every six months, irrespective of produotion or profit. in Paras. 34 to 40, while dealing with this question specifically, it is stated that the pay-meat of one month's basic pay as customary bonus for every six months from January to June and July to December. as a condition of service of the workmen under the company including its Ranchi factory since its inception, irrespective of its profit and production, and the payment which has been made for an unbroken series of years, has become a condition of employment under the company and the bonus in question is being paid of a sufficiently long time at uniform rate even during a period of loss, and that by not paying the bonus in question, the management has changed the condition of the service of the workmen in this regard. It would thus be apparent that finding of the tribunal that the workmen in their written statement were really claiming bonus as implied condition of service is quite correct. The management, no the other hand, in Paras. 6 and 8 of its written statement alleged that the payment of customary bonus has to be licked with some festival and there is nothing like festival for a period of six months, and claimed that this payment was ex graiia, paid out of bounty, as an incentive to the labourers.

    9. We also looked into the files of the Labour Department and it appears that on an application filed by the union for referring the dispute with regard to tonus as well as other matters, a report was called for from the Assistant Labour Commissioner of Jamshedpur, as to which of the pending disputes between the management and its workmen were fit for reference. The Assistant Labour Commissioner held a joint enquiry with the representatives of the petitioner and the workmen and submitted a report on 13 June 1964. Point 2 of the report starts with the caption "bonus" and from the said report, it is apparent that the demand of the workmen's union that one month's basic pay was paid to all its workmen since it as very inception till the period July 1963, irrespective of profit or loss and claimed that it was not a profit-sharing bonus, but a part of the workers' wages. On the other hard, it was claimed by the management that it was not a customary bonus, but actually a profit-sharing bonus, which was paid to the work-men every six months and it was entirely the management's prerogative to declare this bonus. According to the management, production in July to December 1963 was very low due to the slow-down tactics of the workers and hence the management did not declare any bonus during this period. The Assistant Labour Commissioner, on this point, reported that the bonus was paid bi-annually to all workers equivalent to one month's pay in July and January, since the start of the factory in January 1961 and it was neither a profit sharing nor a production bonus, and the management was not justified is withholding the payment to the workers concerned who took part in the strike. On the relevant question, he recommended for reference in the following terms:

    Are the management justified in not making payment of the customary bonus for the period July-December 1963, which was due in January 1964? If not, what compensation or relief, if any, should be granted to the workers?

    10. It is significant to note that the point in issue, with which we are concerned in this case, has been referred in more or less identical terms, as recommended by the Assistant Labour Commissioner, Jamshed-pur. Therefore, the finding of the tribunal as to what was really the dispute and the demand of tee workmen is not only support-ed by the pleadings before the tribunal, but also by the report on which basis the reference in question baa been made, Sri Lal Narayan Sinha also baa not challenged the correctness of the finding of the tribunal as to what was really in dispute between the parties. What be has challenged is the jurisdiction of the tribunal to construe the reference so as to bring out the real dispute for its decision. That the tribunal not only has such power but a duty is cast on it to find out what was the real dispute which was referred to it and to decide it and not to throw It out on mere technicality, finds ample support from the following observations of their lordships of the Supreme Court in the case of State of Madras v. G.P. Sarathy and Anr. 1953--I L.L.J. 174;

    The scope of adjudication by a tribunal under the Act is much wider, as pointed out in Western India Automobile Association v. Industrial Tribunal, Bombay 1949 L.L.J. 245, and it would involve no hardship if the reference also is made in wider terms provided, of course, the dispute is one of the kind described in Section 2(k) and the parties between whom such dispute has actually arisen or is apprehended in the view of the Government are indicated either individually or collectively with reasonable clearness. The rules framed under the Act provide for the tribunal calling for statements of their respective cases from the parties and the disputes would thus get crystallized before the tribunal proceeds to make its award. On the other hand, it is significant that there is no procedure provided in the Act or in the rules for the Government ascertaining the particulars of the disputes from the parties before referring them to a tribunal under Section 10(1).

    11. Their lordships further observed that the settlement of an industrial dispute being an alternative method of settlement of disputes on fair and just basis, it was in public interest that such disputes were settled peacefully and quickly within the framework of the Act, rather than by resort to methods of direct action which would disturb the public peace and order and diminish production, and Courts should not be astute to discover formal defects and technical flaws to overthrow such settlements.

    The power of the tribunal to look into the pleadings for the purpose of finding out the exact nature of a dispute which was referred to it is beyond dispute, in view of the recent pronouncement of their lordships of the Supreme Court in the case of Delhi Cloth and General Mills Company, Ltd. v. their workmen and Ors. 1967--I L.L.J. 423 at 431 quoted below:

    ...in our opinion, the tribunal must, in any event, look to the pleadings of the parties to find out the exact nature of the dispute, because in most cases the order of reference is so cryptic that it is Impossible to cull out therefrom the various points about which the parties were at variance leading to the trouble....

    Thus there does not appear to be any substance in the submission of the learned Counsel that the tribunal has no power to construe the reference and to look into the pleadings of the parties for the purpose.

    12. Sri Lal Narayan Sinha next urged that "customary bonus" is not an expression of indefinite meaning and is a term of definite connotation and is different from "contractual bonus" and that it is only the customary aspect of the bonus which was referred to the tribunal and substitution of one for the other was not possible. Learned Counsel, however, conceded that a customary bonus may be recognized or grow into a right or become contractual but submitted that overlapping, however, does not obliterate the distinction between the two. There does not seem to be any substance is this contention of the learned Counsel also. What was in dispute was whether bonus in question was an ex gratia payment made in case of profit or it was an implied condition of service and that was what was referred to the tribunal, as has been rightly held by the tribunal, as discussed above, and not the customary aspect of the bonus. As already pointed out, the stand of the petitioner before the tribunal was different that customary bonus was synonymous with puja or festival bonus and the bonus which was referred to, according to both parties, was not linked with any festival. The tribunal overruled the petitioner's objection and held that the word "customary" was loosely used in the reference and what was referred was bonus as implied condition of service, payable every six months. The parties proceeded on that basis and led evidence and on a consideration of the evidence, the tribunal found that the bonus in question was being paid continuously without any break for a sufficiently long time having been paid since the inception of the Ranchi factory, even in the year of loss, at uniform rates, which has been admitted by the management witness 2 as mentioned in Para, 10 of the award.

    13. The expression "customary bonus" has not been defined in law. It is surely not a profit-sharing or a production bonus. The dictionary meaning of the word "customary" as found in the Oxford English Dictionary (Vol. II, 1961 reprint) is "usual, habitual, accustomed," etc., as also "commonly used or practised." It has been conceded by Sri Sinha that what is "customary" can become "contractual" also. Therefore, the two expressions are not absolutely exclusive. It is no doubt true that cases arising out of customary bonus have often been regarding festival bonus. As observed by their lordships of the Supreme Court in the case of Tulsidas Khimji v. their workmen 1962--I L.L.J. 435.

    such a bonus has a reference to a special occasion like a festival, for example, the pujas in Bengal and the dewali in Western India--occasions which are generally utilized by employers to reward the services of their employees.

    "Festival bonus" or "puja bonus" is not synonymous with "customary bonus" finds support from the following observations of their lordships of the Supreme Court in the well-known case of Ispahani, Ltd., Calcutta v. Ispahani Employees' Union 1959--II L.L.J. 4 where the question was of the payment of puja bonus as implied term of employment:

    The claim for puja bonus in Bengal is based on either of two grounds. It may either be a matter of Implied agreement between employers and employees creating a term of employment for payment of puja bonus, or (secondly) even though no implied agreement can be inferred, it may be payable as a customary bonus.

    14. Be that as it may, in the instant case, as already pointed out, the festival aspect of the bonus was never in dispute between the parties, nor it was referred to the tribunal. Sri Sinha rightly conceded that the customary bonus can become contractual. Customary bonus divorced from festival bonus is not alien to contractual bonus and the tribunal cannot be said to have travelled beyond the term of reference, in construing the reference with regard to customary bonus as contractual in the facts and the circumstances of thia case.

    15. The test to be applied in support of a claim of customary or traditional bonus has been laid down by their lordships of the Supreme Court in the case of Grahams Trading Company (India), Ltd. v. their workmen 1959--II. L.L.J. 393, namely--

    (i) payment should be over an unbroken aeries of years,

    (ii) it should be paid for a suffioiently long time, though the length of the period might depend on the circumstances of each case,

    (iii) it should be under circumstances so as to exclude the possibility of ex gratia payment, and

    (iv) payment at uniform rate throughout.

    Their lordships also pointed out these tests are more stringent than those in the case of puja bonus as Implied term of service, which need not be uniform as pointed out in Ispahani case 1969--II L.L.J. 4 (vide supra). It is important to note that on the facts found by the tribunal, as referred to in Para. 10 above (which have not been challenged before us), not only the tests laid down for payment of bonus as implied condition of service as in Ispahani case 1959--II. L.L.J. 4 (vide supra) have been satisfied, but even the tests applicable for "customary bonus" (other than "festival bonus") enumerated above seem to have been satisfied.

    16. In the result, there is no merit in this application and it is accordingly dismissed with costs, hearing fee Rs. 200 payable to opposite party 1.

    R.L. Narasimham, C.J.

    17. I agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Minimax, Ltd. v. Its Workmen Represented By The Minimax Workmen'S Union And Anr
    (Nov 9, 1967)