Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Pasayat, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This Court took suo motu cognisance upon receiving a report from the Registrar (Inspection & Enquiry) that large quantities of antiquities, allegedly stolen from places of worship, were lying in various malkhanas of the State. Concerned that these priceless articles were being held in court custody with a risk of being sold to unscrupulous dealers or smuggled abroad, the Court examined whether measures should be taken for their preservation and public accessibility. The matter prompted consideration of existing statutory regimes governing antiquities, treasure and monuments and consultation with the State Museum and relevant State departments. The Court formulated and directed specific modalities for transferring the articles from the Puri Malkhana (and, by extension, other district malkhanas) to the Orissa State Museum for custody, identification, security and display. The writ application arising from the suo motu proceedings was disposed of in accordance with the Court's directions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether priceless antiquities and art objects stored in Court malkhanas should continue to remain in such custody or be transferred to an appropriate public institution (the State Museum) for proper preservation, identification, security and public study.
  2. What modalities and safeguards should govern the transfer, documentation, custody and exhibition of antiquities taken into judicial possession so as to protect them from loss, smuggling or deterioration while respecting legal processes and trial completion.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Joseph Fathen v. The State of Kerala, AIR 1965 SC 1514 Whether the definition of 'ancient monuments' in the concerned State Act and the Central Act was comprehensive enough to include archaeological sites or remains and whether the Acts applied both to ancient monuments strictly so-called and to archaeological sites/remains. The Court cited this Apex Court decision to explain the legislative background and the distribution of legislative competence (Union/State/Concurrent Lists) and to illustrate the legislative intent to demarcate the Central and State fields regarding ancient monuments and archaeological sites. The precedent was used to contextualize why statutory schemes exist and to support the Court's approach to preservation and custody of antiquities.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's reasoning proceeds in the following steps, derived from the opinion:

  1. Identification of the problem: The Court recorded historical and contemporary concerns that stone idols and other antiquities are often removed from places of worship and trafficked to dealers or smuggled abroad to become private show-pieces; this prompted the suo motu action on the Registrar's report.
  2. Survey of legal framework: The Court reviewed the relevant statutory enactments and definitions — notably the Antiquities and Art Treasures Act, 1972 (definitions of ‘antiquity’ and ‘art treasure’, licensing, record-keeping, compulsory acquisition and export prohibitions), the Antiquities (Export Control) Act, 1947 (earlier regime), the Indian Treasure-Trove Act, 1878 (procedure and penalties for treasure finds), and the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958 (preservation, regulation of excavations and protection of objects). It also traced the historical evolution of preservation statutes (Ancient Monuments Preservation Act, 1904; Ancient and Historical Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains (Declaration of National Importance) Act, 1951; State legislation such as the Orissa Ancient Monuments Preservation Act, 1956).
  3. Legislative intent and jurisdictional demarcation: Citing Joseph Fathen and other material, the Court explained the legislative intent to preserve antiquities and art treasures, to prevent smuggling and fraudulent commerce, and to demarcate Central and State fields to avoid jurisdictional overlap.
  4. Factual assessment: The Court recorded expert input from the Superintendent of the Orissa State Museum about the nature and antiquity of items in the Puri Malkhana — listing stone and metal sculptures with estimated centuries (ranging from 9th to 19th century A.D.). The report underscored the historical, religious and cultural value of the articles and their suitability for academic study.
  5. Policy and practical considerations: The Court reasoned that courts' malkhanas are not appropriate repositories for such objects because museums better serve the public and scholarly purposes: identification, study, preservation, display and security. The opinion invoked the role and functions of museums (quoting a museum practitioner's description) to justify transfer for public benefit.
  6. Formulation of safeguards and modalities: To balance preservation with judicial requirements, the Court specified detailed procedural safeguards for transfer, documentation, photographic records, undertakings by the State Museum, police protection during transfer, separate recording in malkhana registers, and the requirement that the Museum produce items before the Court when necessary. These modalities were to apply to Puri and other district malkhanas.

The Court concluded that, on the facts and law presented, transfer to the State Museum under the prescribed modalities was the appropriate course to protect the antiquities and make them available for study and public viewing while preserving the ability of courts to require production.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The writ application was disposed of and the Court ordered that antiquities and material objects of antiquity lying in the Puri Malkhana (and by analogous application in other district malkhanas) be transferred to the Orissa State Museum for proper custody, identification, security and exhibition, subject to the detailed modalities set out in the opinion.

The modalities ordered include (summarised from the opinion): preparation of proper documentation referencing court records; colour photography of each item with district identification and submission of copies to the High Court and malkhana; an undertaking by the State Museum for safe custody; a requirement that the Museum produce items to Court when necessary; execution of a bimanama and formal receipt by authorised Museum officers in presence of the District Judge; separate malkhana records for items handed over; police protection for transfers; and separate display space within the Museum titled "Antiquities involved in judicial proceedings" (Courts property).

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties and objects: The specified antiquities are to be physically transferred from court custody to the Orissa State Museum where they will be catalogued, secured, identifiable and placed on dedicated display for study and public inspection; the Museum must provide undertakings and be prepared to produce items to courts when required.
  • Administrative and procedural consequence: All District Judges and judicial officers in the State are to follow the prescribed procedure upon completion of trial in cases where material objects are of antiquity value; copies of the order are to be sent to the relevant State departments and the State Museum for implementation.
  • On precedent and law: The opinion applies existing statutes and precedents to implement protective measures; it does not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond directing implementation of existing legislative objectives and practical safeguards. The Court's directions operationalise the statutory protections and policy goals already evident in the Antiquities Act, Ancient Monuments Act and related statutes.

Miscellaneous

The opinion records appreciation for contributions from the State Department officials and the Superintendent of the Orissa State Museum who supplied suggestions and materials. The Chief Justice S. N. Phukan agreed with the order.

    In The Matter Of Preservation Of Antiquities

    Pasayat, J.:— Antiquities are, as Becon had written history defaced, or some remounts of history which have casually escaped the shipwreck of time. Faith and belief transform a piece of stone to be an idol or statue of God or Goddess. Conversely it becomes a show or decorative piece. It has become a matter of great concern that stone idols are being smuggled out of the country to become show-pieces in the drawing-rooms. This is not a new phenomenon, and even a century back such activities had caused concern as discussions infre would go to show. To regulate the export trade in antiquities and art treasures, to provide for prevention of smuggling of, fraudulent dealings in-antiquities, and to provide for the compulsory acquisition of antiquities and art treasures for preservation in public places. The Antiquities and Art Treasures Act, 1972 (in short, the ‘Antiquities Act’) has been enacted by Parliament in the Twenty-third Year of the Republic of India.

    2. It came to the notice of this Court that large quantities of antiquities which were stolen out of the places of worship are lying in different malkhanas of the State. Anxious considerations were given to work out modalities for preservation of these priceless articles which were taken out of the places of worship with the obvious object of selling them to unscrupulous dealers and in all likelihood they would have been smuggled out of the country. That is how suo motu action was taken on the basis of a report submitted by the Registrar (I & E) of this Court.

    3. At this juncture it is necessary to take note of various statutory enactments which have relevance. As referred to supra, the Antiquities Act is one such legislation. ‘Antiquity’ and ‘art treasure’ have been defined as follows in Section 2 of the said Act.

    “‘antiquity’ includes—

    (a)(1)(i) any coin, sculpture, painting, epigraph or other work of art of craftsmanship;

    (ii) any article, object or thing detached from a building or cave;

    (iii) any article, object or thing illustrative of science art, crafts, literature, religion, customs, morals or politics in bygone ages;

    (iv) any article, object or thing of historical interest;

    (v) any article, object or thing declared by the Central Government, by notification in the Official Gazette, to be antiquity for the purpose of the Act, which has been in existence for not less than one hundred year; and

    (2) any manuscript record or other document which is of scientific, historical, literary or aesthetic value and which has been in existence for not less than seventy-five years;

    (b) ‘art treasure’ means any human work of art, not being an antiquity, declared by the Central Government by notification in the Official Gazette, to be an art treasure for the purposes of the Act having regard to its artistic or aesthetic value:

    Provided that no declaration under this clause shall be made in respect of any such work of art so long as the author thereof is alive;”

    Antiquities can be sold only under a licence as provided under Section 5. The licensee is required to maintain records, photographs and registers. Powers have been given to the Central Government for compulsorily acquiring the antiquities and art treasures under Section 19, and payment of compensation for such acquisition is provided for. The penal consequences which flow from breach of statutory prescription for making export of any antiquity or art treasure in contravention of Section 3 have been provided for, thereby regulating export trade in antiquities and art treasures.

    4. Before enactment of the Antiquities Act, the Antiquities (Export Control) Act, 1947 held the field. The said Act provided for controlling the export of objects of antiquarian or historical interest or significance. Experience in the working of the Act shows that in the modern set up the provisions contained therein are not sufficient with a view to preserving object of antiquity and art treasures in India. It was therefore felt desirable to make a comprehensive law to regulate the export trade in antiquities and art treasures and to provide for the prevention of smuggling of, and fraudulent dealings in antiquities. It was also considered necessary to make provision in such law for the compulsory acquisition of antiquities and art treasures for preserving in public places. It is to be noted that Antiquities Act was brought into force with effect from 5th April, 1976. The Indian Treasure-Trove Act, 1878 deals with treasure-trove. ‘Treasure’ for the purpose of the said Act which shall be hereinafter referred to as the ‘Treasure Act’ means anything of any value hidden in the soil, or in anything affixed thereto. The procedure on finding treasure is laid down in Section 4 of the Treasure Act. The power to acquire the treasure on behalf of Government has been given under Section 16. The penal consequences which flow if the finder of any treasure fails to give the notice, or does not either make the deposit or give the security as required to be done under Section 4, or alters or attempts to alter such treasure so as to conceal its identity, the share of such treasure, or the money in lieu thereof as prescribed in Section 20. The abettors are also made offenders under Section 21 of the Treasure Act.

    The Central Government has also enacted the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958 to provide for the preservation of ancient and historical monuments and archaeological sites and remains of national importance for the regulation of archaeological excavations and for the protection of sculptures, carvings and other like objects. The said Act is hereinafter referred to as the ‘Ancient Monuments Act’. In Section 2(b) of the said Act ‘antiquity’ has been defined to read as follows:

    “(b) ‘antiquity’ includes—

    (i) any coin, sculpture, manuscript, epigraph, or other work of art or craftsmanship,

    (ii) any article, object or thing detached from a building or cave,

    (iii) any article, object or thing illustrative of science, art, craft, literature, religion, customs, morals or politics in by gone ages,

    (iv) any article, object or thing of historical interest, and

    (v) any article, object or thing declared by the Central Government, by notification in the Official Gazette, to be an antiquity for the purposes of this Act,

    which has been in existence for not less than one hundred years?”

    5. The Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958 repealed the Ancient and Historical Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains (Declaration of National Importance) Act, 1951 and Section 126 of the States Reorganisation Act, 1956. The Ancient Monuments Preservation Act, 1904 also ceased to have effect in relation to ancient and historical monuments and archaeological sites and remains declared by or under the Act to be of national importance, except as respects things done or omitted to be done before the commencement of the new Act. The object of enacting the Ancient Monuments Preservation Act, 1904, as appears from the Statement of Objects and Reasons was to preserve to India its ancient monuments in antiquarian and to prevent the excavation by unauthorised persons of sites of historic interest and value. In 1898 the question of antiquities exploration and research arrested attention and the necessity of taking steps for the protection of monuments and relics of antiquity was impressed upon the Government of India. It was then apparent that legislation was required to enable the Government to discharge their responsibilities in the matter and a Bill was drafted on the lines of the existing Acts of Parliament modified so as to embody certain provisions which have found a place in recent legislation regarding the antiquities of Greece and Italy. A greater number of more famous buildings in India are already in possession or under the control of the Government; but there are others worthy of preservation which are in the hands of private owners. Some of these have already been insured or are fast falling into decay. The provisions were stated to be in general accordance with the policy enunciated in Section 23 of the Religious Endowments Act, 1863, which recognised and saved the rights of the Government to prevent injury to and preserve buildings remarkable in their antiquity and for their historical or architectural value or required for the convenience of the public. It also dealt with the movable object of historical or artistic interest and these may be divided into two classes; the first consists of ornaments, enamels, silver and copper vessels, Persian and Arabian Manuscripts, and curios general. These are for the most part portable and consequently difficult to trade, they are as a rule artistic; are of historic interest and it would be impracticable even were it desirable to prevent a dealer from selling and a traveller from buying them. The sculptural carvings, images, has-reliefs, inscriptions and the like form a distinct class by themselves, in that their value depends upon their local connection, Such antiquities may, as in the case of those of Swet, be found outside India or in Native States and thus the Legislature cannot reach directly; while as regards the British territory and under the existing law, it is impossible to go beyond the provisions of the Indian Treasure Trove Act, 1878 (6 of 1878).

    6. The question before the Apex Court in Joseph Fathen v. The State of Kerala, AIR 1965 SC 1514 was the whether ‘ancient monuments’ as defined in concerned State Act and in Central Act is definition comprehensive enough to take in an archaeological site or remains, and whether the Acts apply to both ancient monuments strictly so-called and to archaeological sites or remains. While enacting the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1959, the legislature took note of the Entry 67 of the Union List, Entry 12 of the State List and Entry 40 of the Concurrent List. The purpose of enacting such statute was to clearly demarcate the area of operation of the field and to avoid confusion existing and overlapping of jurisdiction arising from the corresponding Act of 1904. It was noted as follows:

    “Under the Government of India Act, 1935, the subject ‘Ancient and historical monuments; archaeological monuments; archaeological sites and remains’ fell within Entry 15 of the Federal List. Under the Constitution, this subject has been distributed under three different heads, namely,—

    Entry 67, Union List — Ancient and historical monuments and records, and archaeological sites and remains, declared by or under law made by Parliament to be of national importance.

    Entry 12, State List — Ancient and historical monuments and records other than those declared by or under law made by Parliament to be of national importance, and

    Entry 40, Concurrent List — Archeological sites and remains other than those declared by or under law made by Parliament to be of national importance.

    There are at present two Acts in force relating to ancient monuments — the Ancient Monuments Preservation Act, 1904, and the Ancient and Historical Monuments and Archeological Sites and Remains (Declaration of National Importance) Act, 1951. The Act of 1951 merely declares certain monuments, etc. to be of national importance and the Act of 1904 applies also to such monuments.

    While the Constitution has distributed the subject-matter under three different heads, the Act of 1904 governs all ancient monument whether falling in the Central field or the State field, and vests all executive power in the Central Government. The position of the existing law relating to ancient monuments is far from satisfactory. The present Bill purports to be a self-contained law at the Centre which will apply exclusively to ancient monument, etc. of national importance falling under Entry 67 of List I and to archaeological sites and remains falling under Entry 40 in the Concurrent List. Simultaneously, the State Governments would be advised to enact a similar law in respect of ancient monuments, etc. falling under Entry 12 in the State List. In this manner, the Central and State fields will be clearly demarcated and the existing confusion and overlaping of jurisdiction arising from the Act of 1904 will be limited,”

    The State of Orissa has also enacted the Orissa Ancient Monuments Preservation Act, 1956. Definition of ‘ancient monuments’ in the aforesaid Act which is hereinafter referred to as the ‘Orissa Ancient Monuments Act’ is more or less in similar lines as that of the Ancient Monuments Act enacted by the Central Government.

    7. Enactment of these legislations and the prescription for penal consequences amply demonstrate the legislative intent to preserve ancient and historical monuments and archaeological sites and remains of national importance, for the regulation of archeological excavations and for the protection of sculptures, carvings and other like objects. Antiquities and art treasures are treasures which provide an insight to the social systems prevalent in ancient India, and their protection to trace the history of civilisation and the progress made are immense. These are not intended to be show pieces in the drawing-rooms of people. To protect smuggling of these priceless articles laws have been enacted. The question is whether these priceless articles would be kept lying in the malkhanas of the State. In most of the cases the trial is over long before, and nobody is coming forward to claim ownership thereof obviously because of stringent conditions prescribed for any person who claims to be the owner of these articles.

    8. As an illustrative case the officials of the Department of Tourism and Culture, Youth Service. Government of Orissa and the State Museum were asked to indicate their views about the period to which some of the antiquities stored in Puri Malkhana related to. The Superintendent of the State Museum has given the following details about the stone-sculptures and metal-sculptures.

    Stone Sculptures.

    The stone sculptures form part of temple decorations and others are cult deities of Buddhist and Hindu pantheons and probably being worshipped in Buddhist and Hindu shrines. These can be from 9th to 13th C.A.D

    1. Male figure (secular sculpture) - 13th C.A.D 2. Mother and child - 13th C.A.D 3. Padmapani-Avalokitesvara - 9th C.A.D 4. Garuda - 18th C.A.D 5. Gaje-Vidala - 13th C.A.D 6. Nayika - 12th-13th C.A.D 7. Nayika - 12th-13th C.A.D 8. Nayika - 12th-13th C.A.D 9. Nayika - 12th-13th C.A.D 10. Standing Padmapani Avalokitesvara - 10th-11th C.A.D 11. Mithuna - 12th-13th C.A.D 12. Mithuna - 12th-13th C.A.D 13. Seated Avalokitesvara - 9th-10th C.A.D 14. Seated Vajrapani Avalokitesvara - 9th-10th C.A.D 15. Male deity - 13th C.A.D

    Metal Sculptures

    The metal sculptures (Brass, Bronze am Astadhatu) are obviously from temples am Mathas where these are being worshipped. Some of the metal sculptures are rare ones like the sadabhuja-Gouranga. These are of 18th-19th C.A.D

    1. Sadabhuja Gouranga (combination of Ramakrishna and Gouranga) - 18th Century A.D 2. Krishna (Gopal) - 18th Century A.D 3. Male deity (Right hand brokent) - 18th Century A.D 4. Krishna - 18th Century A.D 5. Krishna - 19th C.A.D 6. Krishna - 19th C.A.D 7. Radha - 19th C.A.D 8. Radha - 18th C.A.D 9. Radha - 18th C.A.D 10. Radha - 18th C.A.D 11. Vishna-Narayan - 17th-18th C.A.D 12. Radha - 18th C.A.D 13. Gouranga - 18th C.A.D 14. Sakhi - 18th C.A.D 15. Krishna (Ohokra) - 18th-19th C.A.D

    The report is quite revealing and shows price lessness of the objects. They can provide immense material for study of the Hindu and Buddhist culture in the State of Orissa. Courts Malkhanas are certainly not the places of storage of such articles. They should be in public gaze for the academicians and historians to make further study and provide valuable information, and materials which would be of immense help to the present and future generations.

    In the circumstances, we feel that proper and safe custody of these priceless articles, and with a view to provide interested persons — materials for their study and research, they can be handed over to the State Museum. A suggestion was given that each Court may have a Museum where these articles can be exhibited. Attractive though the suggestion is, it has some practical difficulties and administrative problems. It would be appropriate if they are kept at the State Museum. If the concerned Department so feels convenient, it may make arrangement for its custody, storage and exhibition at such places as may be deemed proper.

    9. As has been observed by Duglas A. Allan in the Book ‘the Organisation of Museums Practical Advice’ (published by UNSSCO), a museum in its simplest form consists of a building to house collections of objects for inspection study and enjoyment. A museum thus gathers for convenience under the one roof material which originally was widely distributed through both time and space. Secondly, it provides the identification and connotation of the objects as a first step towards understanding them. It makes the on — looker's thoughts travel far from things commonly known and from his immediate surroundings. Thirdly, a museum displays its collections under conditions conducive to enjoyment and study so that the visitor will be happy to enter the institution, to scrutinise the exhibits, to ponder over them and to return to see more. It is only when his curiosity and wonder have been aroused that the spectator is encouraged to step and consider the specimens before him — to think deeply about them and to embark upon a course of study. No other institution collects and displays examples of our three dimensional world as an aid to general understanding; museums are unique. The primary function to collect is a public duty, for it is way of saving things which might otherwise disappear for ever. Objects are of intrinsic value or artistic in nature. Quality, condition, importance in illustrating art development, in representing a major artist or school, are other considerations of importance for museums to weight carefully when they collect. The concept of museum as the repository of ‘cureos’ or ‘muses’ is as old as the civilisation. The museum can be stated to be ‘any permanent establishment setup for the purpose of preserving, studying, enhancing by various means, and in particular of exhibiting it to the public for its delectalian and instruction……..artistic, historical, scientific and technological collections’. It is borne out to be a centre of culture, and effective instrument of education.

    10. The following modalities be observed for transfer of the articles from the Puri Malkhana to the State Museum.

    (1) Proper documentation of the objects will be prepared by the Museum with reference to the record available in the Court of the District Judge, Puri. As far as practicable, details like height, weight, peculiar features and special marks of identification if any shall be recorded.

    (2) Each of the items will be photographed in colour by the Museum along with the name of the District, i.e, Puri. A set of photographs will be submitted to the High Court and another set of copies of those photographs would be submitted to the Judge-in-charge, Malkhana, Puri for official records.

    (3) Orissa State Museum will be fully responsible for their safe custody, and an undertaking to the effect shall be given to the Judge-in-charge, Malkhana. Form of undertaking and manner of its execution shall be finalised by the Secretary, Department of Tourism and Culture, Sports and Youth Services, Registrar (Inspection and Enquiry, Orissa High Court, and the Superintendent, Orissa State Museum.

    (4) The Superintendent of the Orissa State Museum, Bhubaneswar shall produce any of the items or all the items as and when necessary by the Court. He shall ensure proper identification, security and retrieval, as and when necessary.

    (5) The Superintendent of the Orissa State Museum or any other officer authorised by him will receive the articles from the Judge-in-charge, Malkhana, Puri after executing the bimanama and undertaking in presence of the District Judge, Puri, on behalf of the Orissa State Museum.

    (6) Malkhana shall keep separate record of articles handed over to Orissa State Museum.

    (7) The articles shall be brought under proper police protection to State Museum and for the said purpose District Administration and police personnel shall render necessary assistance. So far as Malkhanas in other District Courts are concerned, the modalities indicated above shall also be applicable.

    (8) After transfer, State Museum shall appropriately identify and separately display the items. Separate space shall be provided for display in a separate section styled “Antiquities involved in judicial proceedings” (Courts property).

    11. On completion of trial in cases where the material objects appear to be of antiquity value, the Judicial Officer dealing with the matter shall pass orders that those antiquities shall be handed oyer to the State Museum subject to observance of formalities indicated above. Copies of our order be sent to the Commissioner-cum-Secretary, Department of Tourism, Culture, Sports and Youth Services, Bhubaneswar, the Superintendent, Orissa State Museum, Bhubaneswar and all the District Judges of the State for necessary follow up action. The District Judge shall inform the other Judicial Officers in their respective districts, about the procedure to be followed as detailed above.

    We put up on record our appreciation for Shri D.N Padhi, Commissioner-cum-Secretary, Department of Tourism, and Culture, sports and Youth Services, Government of Orissa, and Shri B. Samal, Superintendent of Orissa State Museum, Bhubaneswar, who have made valuable suggestions and supplied relevant materials for our consideration.

    The writ application is disposed of accordingly.

    S.N Phukan, C.J:— 12. I agree.

    Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    In The Matter Of Preservation Of Antiquities
    (Apr 10, 1998)