Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent was tried for cheating the informant, Dr. Pravat Chandra Chowdhury, on 21-12-1982 by falsely impersonating Manoranjan Mohapatra, an I.A.S Officer on probation. The informant, a Medical Officer, was approached by the respondent who claimed to be the said officer and showed a purported letter from the Ministry of Home Affairs. The respondent alleged an investigation into C.I.A agents related to nurses and health visitors. Suspicious of the respondent's claims, the informant filed an FIR. The police investigated and charged the respondent under Sections 419 and 420 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The trial Magistrate convicted the respondent under Section 419 IPC but acquitted him of Section 420 IPC and sentenced him to three years rigorous imprisonment. On appeal, the Additional Sessions Judge set aside the conviction and remanded the case for fresh disposal with directions to summon defence witnesses. After the defence declined to examine witnesses, the trial court again convicted under Section 419 IPC and acquitted under Section 420 IPC. The respondent appealed, and the Additional Sessions Judge acquitted him, finding contradictions in the prosecution case and holding that the prosecution failed to prove the charge beyond reasonable doubt. The State filed the present appeal challenging this order of acquittal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution proved the charge of cheating by personation under Section 419 IPC beyond reasonable doubt?
  2. Whether the essential ingredient of "cheating" as defined under Section 415 IPC was established in the case?
  3. Whether the Additional Sessions Judge erred in acquitting the respondent by discarding the prosecution evidence?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The learned Public Prosecutor contended that the evidence of prosecution witnesses (P.Ws 1 to 5) should have been accepted and that the Additional Sessions Judge erred in discarding their evidence.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the evidence and found that the Additional Sessions Judge had thoroughly reappraised the prosecution's oral evidence and identified glaring contradictions, rendering the evidence unreliable and full of surmises. The court emphasized the legal requirement under Section 419 IPC that "cheating by personation" necessitates the presence of the essential ingredient of "cheating" as defined in Section 415 IPC. This requires that the accused fraudulently or dishonestly induce the deceived person to deliver any property. The court found this crucial ingredient absent in the present case, as there was no evidence that the informant delivered any property or money to the accused induced by deception. Consequently, the offence under Section 419 IPC was not established in law. The court upheld the acquittal, finding no error in the Additional Sessions Judge's appreciation of evidence and reasoning.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the appeal filed by the State, thereby upholding the acquittal of the respondent. The direct effect of this decision is that the respondent remains acquitted of cheating by personation under Section 419 IPC. The opinion does not set any new precedent or discuss broader legal implications beyond the facts of the case.

    State Of Orissa v. Krushna Chandra Sahu .

    1. This appeal by the State is against an order of acquittal of the respondent who stood his trial for having cheated the informant, Dr. Pravat Chandra Chowdhury, on 21-12-1982 by falsely impersonating himself to be Manoranjan Mohapatra, an I.A.S Officer on probation. It was alleged in the F.I.R (Ext. I) that Pravat Chandra Chowdhury was a Medical Officer of Remuna Primary Health Centre and on 21-12-1982 at 12 Noon, the respondent-accused met him and identified himself as Manoranjan Mohapatra, I.A.S on probation. He showed him a letter purported to have been issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India, New Delhi, and told him that he had come to investigate into the activity of C.I.A Agents who have got relationship with the Nurses and Lady Health Visitors of the Primary Health Centre. As those nurses and Health Visitors were not present, the accused told Dr. Chowdhury that he was going to the market and would come after some time. While leaving the place, however, the accused told Dr. Chowdhury that if he would receive an appreciable amount of money then he would not proceed with the enquiry. Dr. Chowdhury thereafter doubted the credentials of the accused and lodged the F.I.R at Remuna Police Station. The Officer-in-charge took up investigation and ultimately filed the charge-sheet on completion of the investigation against the accused-respondent under Ss. 419, 420/75, Indian Penal Code. The accused, however, was charged for having committed the offences under Ss. 419 and 420, Indian Penal Code.

    2. The learned trying Magistrate held the accused guilty under S. 419, Indian Penal Code, but acquitted him of the charge under S. 420, Indian Penal Code, and sentenced him to undergo rigorous imprisonment for three years. The accused, therefore, preferred an appeal. The learned Additional Sessions Judge set aside the conviction against the accused and remanded the case to the trial Court for fresh disposal according to law with a further direction that the trial Court should issue summons to defence witnesses as per the address given by the accused. After remand, the learned trial Magistrate took steps for production of defence witnesses, but ultimately the defence declined to examine them and accordingly on the existing materials the case was heard and disposed of. Five witnesses were examined on behalf of the prosecution and none on behalf of the defence. Relying on the evidence of P.Ws 1 to 5, the learned trial Court came to the conclusion that the prosecution case against the accused under S. 419, Indian Penal Code, had been proved beyond reasonable doubt and accordingly convicted him thereunder and sentenced him to undergo rigorous imprisonment for three years. But so far as the charge under S. 420, Indian Penal Code, is concerned, the learned Magistrate came to the conclusion that there were no materials that by any inducement, the informant delivered any cash to the accused and accordingly the offence under S. 420, Indian Penal Code, had not been established. The accused was accordingly acquitted of the said charge.

    3. The accused preferred an appeal from the jail to the learned Sessions Judge. The learned Additional Sessions Judge has reappraised the evidence on record and has come to the conclusion that the Magistrate overlooked the glaring contradictions in the prosecution case. After sifting the evidence and on a thorough discussion of the same, the learned Additional Sessions Judge came to the conclusion that the oral evidence as put forth by the prosecution was full of surmises and as such could not be believed. In this view of the matter, the learned Additional Sessions Judge ultimately held that the prosecution had failed to establish the charge under S. 419, Indian Penal Code beyond reasonable doubt and, therefore, the accused was entitled to benefit of doubt. Accordingly, the criminal appeal was allowed, the conviction and sentence passed against the accused were set aside and the accused was set at liberty forthwith. It is this order of acquittal which is being challenged in this Government Appeal.

    4. The learned Public Prosecutor mainly contends that the evidence of P.Ws 1 to 5 should have been accepted by the learned Additional Sessions Judge and the learned Judge committed an error in discarding their evidence. He took me through the depositions of these witnesses. After perusing their evidence and on going through the judgment of the learned Additional Sessions Judge, I am of the opinion Chat the learned Additional Sessions Judge has not committed any error in appreciating the oral evidence on record. The appreciation of evidence made by the learned Additional Sessions Judge cannot be said to be perverse. I do not find any infirmity in the impugned judgment of acquittal passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge so as to interfere with the same. Then again, S. 419 provides:—

    “Whoever cheats by personation shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three years, or with fine, or with both.”

    5. Section 416 defines “cheating by personation” to mean,

    “A person is said to “cheat by personation” if he cheats by pretending to be some other person, or by knowingly substituting one person for another, or representing that he or any other person is a person other than he or such other person really is.”

    6. Therefore, one of the essential ingredients is “cheating”. There cannot be any manner of doubt that to constitute an offence under the section, all ingredients must be present. Therefore, the ingredients of S. 415, Indian Penal Code, which defines “cheating” must be established. To attract the provisions of S. 415, Indian Penal Code, it must be established that the accused fraudulently or dishonestly induced a person so deceived to deliver any property.

    7. This ingredient is totally lacking in the present case. In that view of the matter, in law also, the offence is not at all established.

    8. In the result, therefore, I do not find any merits in this appeal which is accordingly dismissed.

    9. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Orissa v. Krushna Chandra Sahu .
    (Jan 15, 1987)