AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Central Government.6. Section 25(1)(h) of the Orissa Grama Panchayat Act, 1964 (hereinafter
  • Sarpanch.12. Section 39(1)(c)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Central Government.6. Section 25(1)(h) of the Orissa Grama Panchayat Act, 1964 (hereinafter
  • Sarpanch.12. Section 39(1)(c)

    Nabaghan Sahu v. Election Officer, Mukundapur Grama Panchayat And Others Opp. Parties.

    G.K Misra, C.J:— The only point urged by Mr. Mohanty in this writ application is that opposite party No. 4 held an office of Profit under the Central Government and as such was disquli-fied for being elected or nominated as Sarpanch. Facts material to this contention may only be narrated.

    2. Nominations were invited from candidates intending to contest election to the office of sarpanch for Mukundapur Grama Panchayat in the district of Cuttack. 13th of May, 1970 was fixed as the last date for filing nominations.

    3. The petitioner and opposite party Nos. 4 to 6 filed nominations. The same were scrutinised on 13th of May, 1970. The petitioner opposed the nomination of opposite party No. 4 alleging that he was holding an office of Profit under the Central Government as a Sub-Post Master in Mukandapur village Post office. The objection was over-ruled and the nomination of opposite party No. 4 was accepted. Polling was done on 10th of June, 1970. On 13th of June, 1970 the Election Officer declared opposite Party No. 4 to have been elected as Sarpanch. The writ application has been filed to set aside the election after declaring it to be void.

    4. Opposite party No. 4 in his counter affidavit states that at the time of filing the nomination and election he was working as an extra-departmental agent in the branch post office in Mukundapur village and was getting an allowance of Rs. 53/- per month to work as an agent and that he had never been appointed to hold any office of Profit as Sub-Postmaster.

    5. The sole question for determination is whether a person working as an extra-departmental agent in a branch post office on a monthly allowance holds an office of Profit under the Central Government.

    6. Section 25(1)(h) of the Orissa Grama Panchayat Act, 1964 (hereinafter to be referred to as the Act) runs thus:—

    “25.(1) A person shall be disqualified for being elected or nominated as a Sarpanch or any other member of the Grama Panchayat constituted under this Act, if he—

    xxxxxx

    (h) bolds any office of Profit under the State or Central Government or any local authority;”

    7. There is no controversy that an extra-departmental agent in a branch post office works under the Central Government. The only question is whether he holds any office of Profit. The word ‘Profit’ conveys the idea of pecuniary gain. If there is a gain, ordinarily its quantum or amount is immaterial.

    8. To determine whether an office is one held under the Government, various tests have been laid down. They are (i) whether the Government makes the appointment; (ii) whether it has the rigth to remove or dismiss the servant; (iii) whether it pays the remuneration; and (iv) whether it exercises control over the work of the incumbent. In certain oases some of the indicia may be absent. The main test is whether the work is controlled by the Government and it has a voice in the removal or dismissal of the employee.

    9. Judged by these tests, there is no ecoape from the conclusion that an extra-departmental agent in a branch post office holds an office of Profit under the Central Government. Central Government appoints these agents. Their services are liable to be removed by the Government and their work is controlled by it.

    10. In Ch. Venkata Swamy v. Superintendent, Post Offices, Ganjam Division . 1957 XXIII C.L.T 2., a Bench of this Court held that an extradepartmental branch post master cannot be held to be a Government Servant. This decision was held as laying down bad law in The State of Assam v. Kanak Chandra Dutta See para 13 . 1967 S.C.D 521.. The view that we have taken is fully supported by Cheddu Singh v. Monohar Singh . A.I.R 1964 All. 179..

    11. Opposite party No. 4 was holding an office of Profit under the Centra] Government at the material time and was therefore disqualified for being elected or nominated as a Sarpanch.

    12. Section 39(1)(c) lays down that the Munsif shall declare the election of a returned candidate void, if he is of the opinion that any nomination paper has been improperly rejected or accepted. As has already been stated, the nomination paper of opposite party No. 4 was improperly accepted by the Election Officer as the formar was holding an office of Profit under the Central Government. If an election petition had been filed before the Munsif the election of opposite party No. 4, the returned candidate, would have been declared void.

    13. The only other question is whether this Court would exercise its jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the constitution to declare the election void when the petitioner has not resorted to the alternative remedy of filing an election petition before the Munsif having jurisdiction under section 30 of the Act.

    14. Law is now well settled that existence of an alternative remedy does not bar the jurisdiction of this Court to interfere in exercise of its power under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution. It merely touches the field of exercise of discretion. In this case the question involved is one of pure law and it is not necessary to send the petitioner to go through the long process of canvassing the matter through an election petition.

    15. In the result, the writ application is allowed. Election of oppositeparty no. 4 as Sarpanch of Mukundapur Grama Panchayat is declared void. In the circumstances, parties to bear their own costs.

    B.C Das, J.:— I agree.

    16. Writ application allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nabaghan Sahu v. Election Officer, Mukundapur Grama Panchayat And Others Opp. Parties.
    (Dec 1, 1970)