AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section (2) of Section 514 of the Cr PC.15. The Rule is made absolute.AD/H.G.P16. Rule
  • sub-section (3) of Section 117
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section (2) of Section 514 of the Cr PC.15. The Rule is made absolute.AD/H.G.P16. Rule
  • sub-section (3) of Section 117
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition was filed by the second party challenging an order of the Additional District Magistrate, Cuttack, which had confirmed an earlier order of a Magistrate 1st Class dated January 27, 1959. The Magistrate's order forfeited interim bonds executed by members of the second party, issued distress warrants against them and directed the police to take them into custody to prevent a breach of the peace.

Procedural chronology (as stated in the opinion):

  • Magistrate took cognizance under Section 107, CrPC and issued notice under Section 112 on 8 August 1958, requiring bonds of Rs.100 each with sureties for one year.
  • The petitioners appeared and showed cause on 23 August 1958. On 26 September 1958 the Sub-divisional Magistrate required execution of interim bonds of Rs.100 each with one surety under s.117(3), CrPC, for the pendency of the inquiry.
  • The petitioners had shown cause against execution of the interim bonds on 19 September 1958 and furnished interim bonds on 29 September 1958.
  • The police submitted a report alleging six overt acts between 26-7-58 and 4-8-58 and requested forfeiture of the interim bonds.
  • The Magistrate examined two witnesses (in January 1959) and refused to examine the Sub-Inspector when requested. The petitioners alleged the prosecution witnesses were biased and sought to call rebuttal witnesses, which the Magistrate disallowed.
  • Despite pending applications and the petitioners' intention to file an application under section 526(8) of the CrPC, the Magistrate proceeded and on 27 January 1959 forfeited the bonds, issued distress warrants and directed police custody.
  • The petitioners appealed; the Additional District Magistrate, Cuttack, by order dated 6 March 1959, confirmed the Magistrate's order. The present petition challenges that confirmation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Magistrate complied with the procedure laid down in Section 514 of the Code of Criminal Procedure before forfeiting the interim bonds (in particular, whether proof to the satisfaction of the Court was recorded before issuing a notice to show cause).
  2. Whether Section 514 permits the Court to take accused persons into custody or to issue distress warrants and direct police to take them into custody as part of bond forfeiture proceedings.
  3. Whether failure to give notice to show cause under Section 514 is merely an irregularity curable under Section 537 of the CrPC or an illegality warranting setting aside of the forfeiture.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' (Appellants') Arguments — represented by Mr. Ranjit Mohanty

  • Contended the Magistrate violated Section 514, CrPC, which prescribes a two-step procedure: (1) proof to the satisfaction of the Court that the bond has been forfeited and recording of grounds of such proof; and (2) calling upon the person bound to pay the penalty or to show cause why it should not be paid.
  • Argued that Section 514 contains no provision for taking accused persons into custody; subsection (2) permits only issuing a warrant for attachment and sale of movable property if penalty is unpaid.
  • Relied on precedent (Kishan Narayan Singh v. Emperor, AIR 1922 Pat. 242) interpreting Section 514 as requiring recordal of proof before issuing notice to show cause.

Respondent / Government's Arguments — including the Government Advocate and Mr. Chatterjee for the complainant

  • The Government Advocate argued the failure to give notice to the petitioners was an irregularity curable under Section 537, CrPC, and relied on Harbilas v. The State (AIR 1952 Madh-B 2) which held that Section 514(1) does not mandatorily require notice and that issuing notice is discretionary.
  • Mr. Chatterjee (for the complainant) conceded that the Magistrate's order directing immediate issue of distress warrants (and thereby custody) was clearly wrong and that Section 514 provides only for attachment and sale of movable property where penalty is unpaid.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kishan Narayan Singh v. Emperor, AIR 1922 Pat. 242 Held that Section 514 requires that proof be given to the satisfaction of the Court and the grounds of such proof be recorded before a notice to show cause is issued. Cited as supporting the proposition that the Magistrate must record proof before calling upon the surety to show cause; the Court relied on this view to conclude non-compliance was illegality.
Zulmi Kahar… v. Emperor, AIR 1929 Pat. 643 Affirmed that the proper course under Section 514(1) is for the Magistrate to reach a finding on evidence that the bail-bond has been forfeited and then issue notice to show cause. Noted with approval; the Court relied on this authority (Fazl Ali, J.'s view) to support the requirement of a prior finding based on evidence.
Ram Bilas Sharma v. Emperor, AIR 1940 Pat. 375 Stated it is wrong to forfeit bonds and hold bailors to their bonds without calling upon them to show cause. Applied as part of a line of Patna decisions reinforcing that compliance with Section 514 is mandatory and non-compliance is an illegality.
Manmohan Chakravarti v. Emperor, AIR 1928 Cal 261 Explained that Section 514 prescribes two steps: proof and recordal, then calling upon the person to show cause or to pay the penalty. Followed as supportive authority for the two-step interpretation of Section 514; Court relied on this to hold the Magistrate erred.
Mt. Taro v. Emperor, AIR 1949 EP 221 Followed the principle that Section 514 requires proof and notice before realisation of penalty. Identified as a following authority for the two-step approach; used to reinforce the conclusion that omission is more than irregularity.
Harbilas v. The State, AIR 1952 Madh-B 2 Held Section 514(1) does not mandatorily require issuance of notice to show cause; the issue of notice is discretionary; failure to give notice is an irregularity curable under Section 537. Relied upon by the Government Advocate but explicitly distinguished and rejected by the Court as not persuasive; the Court declined to follow this view.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded primarily from a textual reading of Section 514, CrPC and from precedents. The reasoning steps set out in the opinion are:

  1. Interpretation of Section 514: The Court identified two mandatory steps in the statute — (a) the bond must be proved to have been forfeited to the satisfaction of the Court and the grounds of such proof must be recorded; and (b) the Court, on being satisfied, may call on the person bound by the bond to pay the penalty or to show cause why it should not be paid. This is drawn directly from the language of s.514 as quoted in the opinion.
  2. On the permissible remedies under s.514(2): The Court noted that subsection (2) authorises recovery by warrant for attachment and sale of movable property if penalty is not paid. The Court emphasised there is no provision in s.514 for taking accused persons into custody as part of forfeiture proceedings.
  3. Application of precedent: The Court relied on earlier decisions from the Patna and Calcutta High Courts (Kishan Narayan Singh; Zulmi Kahar; Ram Bilas Sharma; Manmohan Chakravarti; Mt. Taro) that interpret s.514 consistently with the two-step requirement and hold that failing to follow those provisions amounts to an illegality rather than a mere curable irregularity.
  4. Distinguishing adverse authority: The Court considered Harbilas v. The State (Madhya Bharat) relied on by the Government Advocate but found it distinguishable and declined to follow its view that notice is discretionary and that omission is merely an irregularity curable under s.537.
  5. Conclusion from facts to law: Finding that the Magistrate did not issue notice to the petitioners to show cause and proceeded to forfeit the bonds and order distress warrants and custody, the Court concluded that the Magistrate had violated the mandatory procedure under s.514. That violation amounted to an illegality entitling the petitioners to have the proceedings set aside.
  6. Remedial guidance: The Court explained that if the Magistrate reopens the matter (on a finding of imminence of breach of the peace), he must strictly follow Section 514: allow both parties to adduce evidence, be satisfied on evidence before forfeiting a bond, record the order in writing, give notice to show cause before forfeiture, and if penalty remains unpaid, proceed under s.514(2) for attachment and sale of movable property.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The Court set aside the Magistrate's order dated 27 January 1959 and allowed the petition. The Court declared the petitioner entitled to that relief because the Magistrate failed to comply with Section 514, CrPC.

The core ruling is therefore emphasized as follows:

ORDER: The order of the Magistrate forfeiting the interim bonds, issuing distress warrants and directing police custody (dated 27 January 1959) is set aside; the petition is allowed and the Rule is made absolute.

Direct Implications for the Parties

  • The specific forfeiture order and the distress warrants issued on 27 January 1959 were quashed.
  • The petitioners were relieved of the consequences of that order.
  • The Magistrate is permitted to re-inquire if he finds imminence of breach of the peace, but must strictly follow the procedure in Section 514 (record proof, give notice to show cause, allow evidence, and only on failure to pay proceed under s.514(2)).

Broader Implications / Precedential Effect

The Court grounded its decision on established high-court authorities interpreting Section 514 and expressly declined to follow a conflicting Madhya Bharat decision. The opinion enforces the mandatory procedural steps in Section 514 as interpreted by the cited precedents; it does not state that it is announcing a new principle of law beyond applying those existing authorities.

Disposition: Rule made absolute.

    Bishnu Dalai And Others v. The State And Another Opposite Parties.

    1. This is a petition by the second party against an order of the Additional District Magistrate, Cuttack, confirming the order of a Magistrate 1st Class, dated January 27, 1959. The Magistrate by his order forfeited the interim bond executed by the members of the 2nd party and issued distress warrants against them and directed the police to take them into custody for avoiding any breach of the peace.

    2. The facts are rather short and simple. The Magistrate took coenizance of a case under Section 107 of the Cr PC against the present petitioners and issued notice under section 112 on August 8, 1958. By that order the Magistrate required the petitioners to show cause why they should not be ordered to execute bonds of Rs. 100/- each with sureties for the like amount for a period of one year for keeping the peace. The petitioners appeared and showed cause on August 23, 1958. Subsequently on September 26, 1958 the Sub-divisional Magistrate of Cuttack called upon the petitioners to execute interim bonds for Rs. 100/- each with one surety of the like amount to keep peace during the pendency of the enquiry under sub-section (3) of Section 117 of the Cr PC.

    3. The petitioners on September 19, 1958 had already shown cause against the order for execution of the interim bond and on September 29 they furnished the interim bonds to the satisfaction of the Magistrate. The Police submitted another report against the petitioners before the Sub-divisional Magistrate, Cuttack and requested him to forfeit the interim bonds since the petitioners had violated the terms of the said interim bond. The allegations were that between 26-7-58 and 4-8-58 the petitioner had committed six overt acts. The petitioners also filed an application that the 1st party should also be bound down. It appears that no orders have yet been passed on that petition. I am not, however, concerned with that application in the present proceedings. The Magistrate it appears examined two witnesses on January of 12, 1959 and they were cross-examined by the petitioners. In another application the petitioners wanted the Sub-Inspector of Police, Lalbag Police Station to be examined which the Magistrate refused. Thereafter it is stated that the petitioner wanted to adduce rebutting evidence to displace the evidence given on behalf of the first party on the ground that of the two witnesses examined Sankarsan Mohanty had categorically admitted that he was a professional witness for the Lalbag Police and the other witness Sudam Behera also admitted that he was an interested person under the influence of the first party. In spite of these allegations, the Magistrate did not allow the petitioners to examine any witness on their behalf. Furthermore, the Magistrate was informed that the petitioners intend to file an application under section 526(8) of the Cr PC.

    4. But in spite of this information, the Magistrate, & it appears, proceeded with the case and eventually passed the order on January 27, 1959, forfeiting the bonds and issued distress warrants against them and directed the Police to take them into the custody. Against this order of the Magistrate the petitioners carried an appeal which was heard by the Additional District Magistrate, Cuttack, who by his order dated March 6, 1959, confirmed the order passed by the Magistrate on the ground that the order was lawful and that there was no illegality committed by the Magistrate. Against this order the present application has been filed in tris Court.

    5. Mr. Ranjit Mohanty, learned counsel on behalf of the petitioners, contended that the order of the Magistrate is clearly wrong in law since he has violated the provisions of Section 514 of the Cr PC. Sec. 514 lays down the procedure for forfeiture of the bond and it states:

    “(1) Whenever it is proved to the satisfaction of the Court by which a bond under this Code has been taken, or of the court of a Presidency Magistrate or Magistrate of the first class, or when the bond is for appearance before a Court, to the satisfaction of such court, that such bond has been forfeited, the Court shall record the grounds of such proof, and may call upon any person bound by such bond to pay the penalty thereof, or to show cause why it should not be paid.

    (2) If sufficient cause is not shown and the penalty is not paid, the Court may proceed to recover the same by issuing warrant for the attachment and sale of the movable property belonging to such person or his estate if he be dead.”

    6. A plain reading of S. 514 indicates that two steps must be taken by the Magistrate: (1) It must be proved to the satisfaction of the Court that the bond has been forfeited whereupon the Court has to record the grounds of such proof; and (2) the Court on being satisfied as aforesaid may call upon the person bound by such bond to pay the penalty thereof or to show cause why it should not be paid.

    7. There is no provision in Sec. 514 to take the accused persons to custody. All that sub-sec. (2) of S. 514 requires is that if sufficient cause is not shown and the penalty is not paid then the Court may issue a warrant for the attachment and sale of the movable property belonging to such person or Ins estate if he is dead. In support of his contention Mr. Mohanti relied upon a decision in Kishan Narayan Singh v. Emperor, AIR 1922 Pat. 242. In that case Adami, J. held that Section 514 lays down that it must be proved to the satisfaction of the court that the bond has been forfeited and that the Court shall record the grounds of such proof, and it is after such grounds have been recorded that the person bound by the bond may be called on to show cause why the amount should not be paid.

    8. Where there has been a failure to carry out the express provisions of the law and the Deputy Magistrate acted without jurisdiction in failing to record the proof before he issued notice to show cause, the petitioners are entitled to have the proceedings set aside. This decision met with the approval of Fazl Ali, J. (as he then was) in the case of Zulmi Kahar…Accused Petitions; v. Emperor…Opposite Party., AIR 1929 Pat. 643 where he took the view that the proper course for a Magistrate proceeding to pass order under Sec. 514(1) is to come to a finding based on some evidence that the bail-bond executed by the surety has been duly forfeited and then only to issue a notice to show cause why the penalty should not be realised from him.

    9. There is another decision of the Patna High Court in Ram Bilas Sharma v. Emperor, AIR 1940 Pat 375 where Dhavle, J. took the view that it is wrong to pass an order of forfeiture and to hold bailors to their bonds without calling upon them to show cause why the penalty should not be paid. The same view was taken by the Calcutta High Court in the case of Manmohan Chakravarti v. Emperor, AIR 1928 Cal 261. Sanderson, C.J in that case held that the provisions of Sec. 514 indicate that two steps are to be taken first, it must be proved to the satisfaction of the Court that the bond has been forfeited, whereupon the Court is to record the grounds of such proof, secondly, the Court: on being satisfied as aforesaid, may call upon the person bound by such bond to pay the penalty thereof, or to show cause why it should not be paid. The decision has been followed by the East Punjab High Court in the case of Mt. Taro v. Emperor AIR 1949 EP 221.

    10. The Government Advocate contended that the failure to give notice to the petitioners is an irregularity which is curable under section 537 of the Cr PC. In support of his contention, he sought to rely upon a decision of the Madhya Bharat High Court reported in Harbilas v. The State, AIR 1952 Madh-B 2. In that case Dixit, J. held that Sec. 514(1) does not require the Court to issue notice to show cause why the bond should not be forfeited. Again, the issue of notice to show cause why the penalty of the bond should not be realised is discretionary and not mandatory. It cannot, therefore, be maintained that an order of forfeiture of the bond or the recovery of the penalty of the bond passed without giving notice to the surety is illegal.

    11. The facts in that case are already distinguishable and with great respect to the learned Judge, I cannot persuade myself to follow the view taken by that Court. In the Patna decisions referred to above, their Lordships of the Patna High Court have taken the view that if the provisions of Section 514 of the Cr PC are not followed, it would amount to an illegality and not merely an irregularity. In my opinion, the Magistrate not having issued notice to the petitioners to show cause as to why the penalty should not be paid, has clearly violated the provisions of Sec. 514 which amounts to an illegality. Accordingly, the order passed by the Magistrate is bound to be set aside.

    12. Mr. Chatterjee, learned counsel for the complainant, frankly conceded that the order directing issue of distress warrants straightaway is clearly wrong. As I have stated above, there is no provision in the Code of Criminal Procedure for taking the petitioners into custody. All that section 514(2) requires is that in case the petitioners fail to pay the penalty, the Court may proceed to recover the same by issuing a warrant for the attachment and sale of the movable property of the petitioners. Accordingly, I would set aside the order of the Magistrate dated January 27, 1959, and allow this petition.

    13. It is, however, still open to the Magistrate, if he finds that there is imminence of the breach of the peace, to enquire again into the matter keeping strictly in view the procedure as laid down in Section 514 of the Cr PC and allow opportunities to both parties to adduce evidence and pass his orders on hearing both parties. The Magistrate must be satisfied on the evidence on record that there are reasons for forfeiting the bond. After the order in writing is recorded by the Magistrate he must give notice to the petitioners if the bond is to be forfeited to show cause as to why it should not be forfeited.

    14. In case of failure to pay the penalty, he should proceed under sub-section (2) of Section 514 of the Cr PC.

    15. The Rule is made absolute.

    AD/H.G.P

    16. Rule made absolute.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bishnu Dalai And Others v. The State And Another Opposite Parties.
    (Nov 23, 1959)