AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 23, Rule 1(3) read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order 23, Civil Procedure Code
  • Order 23, Rule 1, sub-rule 3(kh), Civil Procedure Code
  • Order 23, Rule 1(3) Civil Procedure Code
  • section 18, Rule 4, Civil Procedure Code.
  • ORDER 23 RULE 1 A CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • ORDER 18 RULE 4 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order 23
  • provisions of Order 23, Rule 1(3)
  • provisions of Order 23, Rule 1
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 1,
  • Rule 1 of Order 23
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 23, Rule 1(3) read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order 23, Civil Procedure Code
  • Order 23, Rule 1, sub-rule 3(kh), Civil Procedure Code
  • Order 23, Rule 1(3) Civil Procedure Code
  • section 18, Rule 4, Civil Procedure Code.
  • ORDER 23 RULE 1 A CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • ORDER 18 RULE 4 CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order 23
  • provisions of Order 23, Rule 1(3)
  • provisions of Order 23, Rule 1
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 1,
  • Rule 1 of Order 23
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiffs/respondents filed a suit for declaration and permanent injunction against the defendant/petitioner concerning certain open land, claiming ownership based on adverse possession. The defendant denied the allegations and contended that one Anil Kumar Shivhare, brother of the plaintiff, was a tenant of the disputed property. The defendant alleged that the suit was filed malafidely to frustrate his eviction suit against Anil Kumar Shivhare. After framing issues and recording the plaintiff's evidence, the defendant submitted evidence by affidavit under Order 18, Rule 4, Civil Procedure Code. Subsequently, the plaintiffs filed an application under Order 23, Rule 1(3) read with Section 151, Civil Procedure Code, seeking permission to withdraw the suit on the ground of non-joinder of necessary parties (other sons of plaintiff No. 1) and sought liberty to file a fresh suit. The trial court allowed the withdrawal with liberty to file a fresh suit. The petitioner challenged this order on the ground that non-joinder of parties is not a formal defect permitting withdrawal under Order 23, Rule 1(3).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether non-joinder of parties in a suit constitutes a formal defect entitling the plaintiff to withdraw the suit and seek liberty to file a fresh suit under Order 23, Rule 1(3) of the Civil Procedure Code?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Non-joinder of necessary parties is not a formal defect but a defect striking at the root of the suit.
  • Order 23, Rule 1(3) of the Civil Procedure Code is not attracted by non-joinder of parties.
  • Permission to withdraw a suit under Order 23, Rule 1(3) is not a matter of right and requires sufficient and good grounds.
  • The suit was permitted to be withdrawn on an impermissible ground of formal defect, warranting interference.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Non-joinder of party amounts to a formal defect in the suit.
  • Plaintiffs have the right to withdraw the suit on this ground under Order 23, Rule 1(3).
  • The order of the trial court allowing withdrawal was proper and no interference is warranted under Article 227 of the Constitution.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Khatuna v. Ramsewak Kashinath, AIR 1986 Orissa 1 Non-joinder of necessary party is not a formal defect; defect strikes at root of suit; Order 23, Rule 1(3) not attracted. Relied upon to hold that non-joinder is not a formal defect and cannot justify withdrawal under Order 23, Rule 1(3).
Smt. Savitri Devi v. Hiralal, AIR 1977 HP 91 Similar principle that non-joinder of necessary party is not a formal defect. Supported the view that non-joinder is substantive defect, not formal.
Uma Devi v. Nagarpalika Begamgunj, 1999 (2) MPJR 487 Withdrawal of suit under Order 23, Rule 1(3) is not a matter of right; requires good grounds. Applied to emphasize that permission to withdraw must be justified by sufficient grounds.
Haridas Sadhu Khan v. Giridhari Sadhu Khan, AIR 1934 Cal 59 Non-joinder of necessary party is not a formal defect. Supported the principle that non-joinder is substantive defect.
Ram Padarth Misir v. Data Din Misir, AIR 1941 Oudh 417 Non-joinder of necessary party is not a formal defect. Followed to confirm the nature of non-joinder as substantive defect.
Muktanath Tiwari v. Vidyashanker Dube, AIR 1943 Allahabad 67 Non-joinder of necessary party is not a formal defect. Reinforced the principle on non-joinder.
Asian Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Madholal Sindhu, AIR 1950 Bombay 378 Non-joinder of parties is not a formal defect under Order 23, Rule 1. Relied upon to reject non-joinder as formal defect.
Tarachand Bapuchand v. Gaibihaji Ahamed Bagwan, AIR 1956 Bombay 632 Non-joinder is not a formal defect. Followed to uphold the substantive nature of non-joinder defect.
Trinath Parida v. Sobha Bholaini, AIR 1973 Orissa 387 Non-joinder of necessary party is not a formal defect. Confirmed the principle as followed by Orissa High Court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the scope of Order 23, Rule 1(3) of the Civil Procedure Code, which permits withdrawal of suit if the suit must fail due to a formal defect or if sufficient grounds exist to allow filing a fresh suit. The Court analyzed whether non-joinder of necessary parties constitutes a formal defect. Relying on consistent judicial precedents from various High Courts including Orissa, Himachal Pradesh, Calcutta, Bombay, Allahabad, and Oudh, the Court held that non-joinder of necessary parties is not a formal defect but a substantive defect striking at the root of the suit. Consequently, the provision for withdrawal under Order 23, Rule 1(3) is not attracted by non-joinder of parties. The Court also noted that permission to withdraw a suit is not a matter of right and requires good grounds. In the present case, since the suit had advanced to the stage where defendant's evidence was filed, and the only ground for withdrawal was non-joinder, the Court found the trial court erred in permitting withdrawal. Therefore, the Court quashed the order allowing withdrawal and directed the trial court to proceed with the suit in accordance with law.

Holding and Implications

The Court's final decision is as follows:

The petition is allowed.

The order dated 13-8-2005 permitting the plaintiffs to withdraw the suit and file a fresh suit is quashed. The trial court is directed to continue the suit on merits. The decision clarifies that non-joinder of necessary parties is not a formal defect permitting withdrawal under Order 23, Rule 1(3), and that permission to withdraw a suit is discretionary and requires sufficient grounds. No new precedent beyond the application of established principles was set. The direct effect is restoration of the suit for trial without permitting withdrawal on the ground of non-joinder.

    Vinod Kumar Gupta v. Ramadevi Shivhare And Another

    1. Challenging the order Annexure P/1 dated 13-8-2005 passed by 1st Additional District Judge, Dabra, district Gwalior in Civil Suit No. 10-A/04 allowing application under Order 23, Rule 1, sub-rule 3(kh), Civil Procedure Code permitting the plaintiffs/respondents to withdraw the suit and granting liberty to file a fresh suit, petitioner has filed this petition.

    2. According to Shri V.K Bhardwaj, learned counsel representing the petitioner, the legal question involved in this petition is as to whether the non-joinder of parties in a suit can be a formal defect entitling the plaintiff to withdraw the suit and seeking liberty to file a fresh suit under Order 23, Rule 1, sub-rule (3), Civil Procedure Code?

    3. Facts in brief necessary for disposal of this petition are that plaintiffs/respondents filed the suit in question for declaration and permanent injunction against the defendant/the present petitioner with regard to certain open land as detailed in the suit. The injunction and declaration was sought on the ground of adverse possession and prayer made was that respondents be restrained from interfering with the plaintiffs possession and on the basis of adverse possession to be declared owner of the said land. Petitioner who is defendant in the suit appeared and denied the allegations made in the plaint. It was case of the defendant that one Anil Kumar Shivhare brother of the plaintiff is a tenant of the disputed property. Defendant No. 1 Shri Vinod Kumar Gupta has testified in Civil Suit No. 236A/01, Vinod Kumar Gupta v. Gote Ram to the effect had admitted that his brother Anil Kumar Shivhare is a tenant of the suit property and petitioner/defendant is the landlord. It was stated that thereafter when the petitioner filed suit for eviction against Anil Kumar Shivhare, the present suit which has been filed malafidely so that the suit filed against Anil Kumar Shivhare is frustrated. On the basis of submission made in the written statement, various issues were framed, evidence of plaintiff were recorded and after plaintiff closed his evidence, petitioner submitted his evidence by way of affidavit under section 18, Rule 4, Civil Procedure Code. After the evidence of the defendant/petitioner under Order 18, Rule 4, Civil Procedure Code was submitted, the application Annexure P/6 under Order 23, Rule 1(3) read with section 151, Civil Procedure Code was filed and in the said application Annexure P/6 it was stated that the suit is filed only by plaintiff No. 1 but his other sons are also necessary parties, because of non-joinder of proper party, the suit may fail, therefore, contending that there is some formal defect in the suit, application is Filed for withdrawal of the suit with liberty of filing a fresh suit. Accordingly, permission is granted to the plaintiffs to withdraw the suit with liberty to file a fresh suit. Inter alia contending that non-joinder of party is not a formal defect as contemplated under sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order 23 and on this ground suit cannot be permitted to be withdrawn, petitioner seeks interference in the matter.

    4. In support of aforesaid contentions, Shri V.K Bhardwaj invites my attention to the principles laid down by the Orissa High Court in the of Khatuna v. Ramsewak Kashinath, AIR 1986 Orissa 1 to emphasise that non-joinder of necessary party in a suit is not a formal defect, the defect strikes at the root of the suit in any stage and the provisions of Order 23, Rule 1(3) is not attracted. He placed further reliance in this regard to another judgment of Himachal Pradesh High Court in the case of Smt. Savitri Devi v. Hiralal, AIR 1977 HP 91 wherein also similar principles are laid down. That apart, inviting my attention to judgment of this in the case of Uma Devi v. Nagarpalika Begamgunj, 1999 (2) MPJR 487, Shri Bhardwaj argued that permission to withdraw the suit cannot be granted as a matter of right, it can be granted only if sufficient and good ground for withdrawal of suit is made out. Accordingly, he submits that in the facts and circumstances of the case as the suit is permitted to be withdrawn on the ground of formal defect which is impermissible, he seeks interference in the matter.

    5. Shri R.P Gupta, learned counsel representing the respondents refuted the aforesaid and argued that as there is formal defect in the suit due to non-joinder of party, plaintiffs has a right to withdraw the suit and therefore, order passed by the Court below exercising jurisdiction under Order 23, Rule 1(3), Civil Procedure Code being proper, no case is made out for interference in these Proceedings under Article 227 of the Constitution.

    6. I have heard learned counsel for parties at length and perused the record. Order 23 of Civil Procedure Code deals with withdrawal and abandonment of the suit. Rule 1 of Order 23 pertains withdrawal of a suit or abandonment of part of claim. Under sub-rule (3) of Rule 1, the plaintiff can be granted permission at any time after institution of suit either to withdraw the suit or to abandon any or part of the claim and the said permission under sub-rule (3) can be granted when the Court is satisfied that the suit must fail by reason of some formal defect or there are sufficient grounds for allowing the plaintiff to institute a fresh suit for the subject-matter of the suit or part of a claim.

    7. The question as to whether non-joinder of party in a suit is a formal defect as contemplated under sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order 23, Civil Procedure Code has been considered in the case of Khatuna (supra) by the Orissa High Court. It has been held by the Orissa High Court in the aforesaid case that non-joinder of necessary party in a suit is not a formal defect. It is held that such a defect strikes at the root of the suit and in such case provisions of Order 23, Rule 1 is not attracted. For arriving at such a conclusion and before lying down the aforesaid principle, the Orissa High Court has placed reliance on a Division Bench's judgment of the Calcutta High Court in the case of Haridas Sadhu Khan v. Giridhari Sadhu Khan, AIR 1934 Cal 59 wherein it has been held by the Calcutta High Court that the defect to the effect in a suit that certain necessary party was not impleaded is not a formal defect. It is seen that similar view was expressed in the case of Ram Padarth Misir v. Data Din Misir, AIR 1941 Oudh 417 and by the Allahabad High Court in the case of Muktanath Tiwari v. Vidyashanker Dube, AIR 1943 Allahabad 67. In the case of Asian Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Madholal Sindhu, AIR 1950 Bombay 378, Chief Justice Chagla who wrote the judgment on behalf of Division Bench has also held that non-joinder of some of the parties in the suit is not a formal defect as contemplated under Order 23, Rule 1, Civil Procedure Code thereafter again Bombay High Court in the case of Tarachand Bapuchand v. Gaibihaji Ahamed Bagwan, AIR 1956 Bombay 632 has taken similar view and judgment in this case was rendered by Shri Gajendragadkar, J. as he then there was. It is seen that the judgments of the Bombay High Court were followed by the Orissa High Court in the case of Trinath Parida v. Sobha Bholaini, AIR 1973 Orissa 387 and it was held that non-joinder of necessary party is not a formal defect. The principle laid by the Himachal Pradesh High Court in the case of Savitri Devi (supra) was also taken note of in this case and it was held that principle laid down by the Bombay High Court in the case of Tarachand Bapuchand (supra) and the Oudh High Court in the case of Ram Padarath Misir (supra) are relied to the Himachal Pradesh High Court and the principles laid in all these judgments are that non-joinder of necessary party is not a formal defect but the defect which strikes at the root of the suit.

    8. It is seen from the judgments of Orissa High Court and Himachal Pradesh High Court that various judgments have been relied upon and it has been the consistent view of most of the Courts that non-joinder of the party is not a formal defect. In the case of Uma Devi (supra), a Bench of this Court has held that right granted to the plaintiff under Order 23, Rule 1(3) Civil Procedure Code cannot be claimed as a matter of right. It has been held that plaintiff is required to satisfy the Court and should show good ground for seeking permission to withdraw the suit and grant of liberty. It has been held by this Court in the case of Uma Devi (supra) that a trial de novo is not to be lightly granted to plaintiff to enable to come prepared to fight a fresh legal battle.

    9. Keeping in view the totality of the facts and circumstances of the case and the principle that emerges from a complete reading of the judgments as indicated hereinabove, it has to be held that in the present case the suit has proceeded to a stage where defendant's evidence under Order 18, Rule 4, Civil Procedure Code has been filed and plaintiffs now wants to withdraw the suit and proceed with a trial de novo. As the only reason given for invoking the jurisdiction under sub-rule (3) of Rule 1 of Order 23 is non-joinder of party and as non-joinder of necessary party is held not to be a formal defect by various High Courts in the judgments as indicated hereinabove, the application cannot be allowed. Nothing contrary is brought to notice of this Court and this Court also does not see any reason to held that defect of non-joinder of party is not a formal defect. Accordingly, in the facts and circumstances of the case, it has to be held that the grounds contemplated for withdrawal of a suit under Order 23, Rule 1(3), Civil Procedure Code is not made out by the plaintiffs in the present case and in allowing the application for withdrawal of the suit under Order 23, Rule 1(3), Civil Procedure Code without ingredient of the same being satisfied, learned Court has committed grave error which warrants interference now in these proceedings under Article 227 of the Constitution.

    10. Accordingly, finding much force in the contentions advanced by Shri V.K Bhardwaj, learned counsel for petitioner and finding the order passed by the Court below to be erroneous and contrary to the principles of law it has to be held that learned Court has exercised jurisdiction in a incorrect manner which is impermissible under law. Accordingly, this petition is allowed. The order impugned Annexure P/1 dated 13-8-2005 granting permission to the plaintiffs to withdraws the suit in question is quashed. Learned Court is directed to proceed with the suit in accordance with law.

    11. Petition stands allowed and disposed of with the aforesaid without any order so as to costs.

    Petition allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Vinod Kumar Gupta v. Ramadevi Shivhare And Another
    (Sep 22, 2007)