Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition challenges the order dated September 7, 2000 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur Bench, in O.A. No. 177 of 2000. The petitioner is the son of late Naib Subedar D. Thomas Raj, who served in the Army Corps of EME and died in service on October 20, 1992, leaving behind dependents including the petitioner, his mother, and other family members. The petitioner applied for appointment on compassionate grounds to a Group-D post in 1992 after his father's death, submitting all necessary documents, but the respondents did not grant the appointment even after seven years. The respondents contended that the petitioner’s case was considered according to existing policy but did not qualify for appointment within the prescribed quota. The Tribunal held that the petitioner’s family could depend on terminal benefits and family pension and did not consider the compassionate appointment claim. Aggrieved by this, the petitioner filed the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner’s claim for appointment on compassionate grounds should be considered under the policy dated June 13, 1987 or the later policy dated October 9, 1998.
  2. Whether the delay of seven years in considering the petitioner’s claim for compassionate appointment was justified.
  3. Whether the petitioner is entitled to appointment on compassionate grounds despite the respondents’ contention of non-availability of posts.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner is qualified for appointment against a Group-D post under the policy existing at the time of application (June 13, 1987 policy), which allowed 20% Group-D posts to be filled on compassionate grounds.
  • The petitioner submitted all required documents promptly after his father’s death in 1992, but the respondents delayed consideration unjustifiably for seven years.
  • Relied on the Supreme Court decision in Smt. Sushma Gosain and others v. Union of India and others (AIR 1989 SC 1976), which mandates prompt appointment on compassionate grounds to mitigate family hardship and prohibits undue delay.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • The petitioner’s case was considered according to the policy dated October 9, 1998, which allowed only 5% vacancies for compassionate appointments to Group-D posts.
  • Due to non-availability of posts within the prescribed quota, the petitioner could not be appointed.
  • Referenced several Supreme Court decisions including State of Haryana v. Rani Devi (AIR 1996 SC 2445), Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. v. A. Radhika Thirumalai (AIR 1997 SC 123), Life Insurance Corporation v. Asha Ramchandra Ambekar (AIR 1994 SC 2148), and Himachal Road Transport Corporation v. Dinesh Kumar (AIR 1996 SC 2226) to support their stance.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Sushma Gosain and others v. Union of India and others (AIR 1989 SC 1976) Mandates prompt appointment on compassionate grounds to alleviate hardship; prohibits undue delay; allows creation of supernumerary posts if needed. The court relied on this precedent to emphasize that the petitioner’s claim should have been considered promptly under the earlier policy and that delay was unjustified.
State of Haryana v. Rani Devi (AIR 1996 SC 2445) Relevant to compassionate appointment policies. The court noted that this decision did not contradict the petitioner’s claim.
Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. v. A. Radhika Thirumalai (Smt) (AIR 1997 SC 123) Relevant to compassionate appointment policies. The court found no conflict with the petitioner’s submissions.
Life Insurance Corporation v. Asha Ramchandra Ambekar (AIR 1994 SC 2148) Relevant to compassionate appointment policies. The court observed this precedent did not oppose the petitioner’s claim.
Himachal Road Transport Corporation v. Dinesh Kumar (AIR 1996 SC 2226) Relevant to compassionate appointment policies. The court noted this decision was not contrary to the petitioner’s arguments.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the timing and eligibility of the petitioner’s claim, noting that the petitioner’s father died in 1992 and the petitioner applied for compassionate appointment the same year. The court found no dispute regarding the petitioner’s eligibility under the policy dated June 13, 1987, which allowed 20% of Group-D posts to be filled on compassionate grounds. It criticized the respondents for the seven-year delay in considering the claim and held that the petitioner’s case should have been considered under the earlier policy rather than the later 1998 policy, which reduced the quota to 5%. The court relied heavily on the Supreme Court’s mandate in Smt. Sushma Gosain’s case emphasizing prompt appointments on compassionate grounds to mitigate hardship. The court further noted that the respondents’ reliance on later policies and case law was not sufficient to deny the petitioner’s claim and that the delay was attributable to the respondents, not the petitioner. Therefore, the Tribunal’s order was set aside, and the respondents were directed to consider the petitioner’s appointment within two months.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is allowed and the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal dated September 7, 2000 is set aside.

The respondents are directed to consider the petitioner’s case for appointment on compassionate grounds against a Group-D post within two months, applying the policy dated June 13, 1987. There is no order as to costs. This decision directly affects the parties by mandating reconsideration of the petitioner’s claim under the earlier policy, but it does not establish any new legal precedent beyond reaffirming the importance of timely consideration of compassionate appointment claims.

    T. Swamy Dass v. Union Of India And Others

    ORDER Bhawani Singh, C.J.

    1. This writ petition is directed against order of Central Administrative Tribunal, Jabalpur Bench, dated September 7, 2000 passed in O.A. No. 177 of 2000.

    2. Petitioner is son of late Naib Subedar D. Thomas Raj who was with respondent Army Corps of EME and died on 20-10-1992 in Command Hospital, Southern Command, Pune due to chronic renal failure with severe anaemia at the age of 41, completing service of 22 years. The deceased left behind wife, applicant and parents dependent on him.

    3. The petitioner alleges that he is qualified to be appointed against Group-D post with the respondents. As such, he applied for appointment on compassionate ground in 1992, his father having died while in service. All necessary requirements in support of the claim were furnished to the competent authority. Surprisingly, after lapse of seven years, respondents did not allow the claim, expressing inability to give him appointment.

    4. Case of respondents is that case of petitioner was considered by the authorities at all levels on the basis of existing policy on the subject. However, his case could not find place in the merit list within the prescribed quota.

    5. The Tribunal did not consider the claim of petitioner for compassionate appointment, rather it proceeded to hold that deceased left only the applicant, his mother and the parents. They could depend on the terminal benefits to the tune of Rs. 17,984.00, Army Group Insurance Fund of Rs. 22,846.00 and mother of applicant was receiving family pension with dearness allowance. Petitioner feels aggrieved by this order, therefore, it has been challenged through this writ petition.

    6. Shri K.S. Thakur, learned counsel for petitioner and Shri R.S. Patel, learned Senior Standing Counsel for Central Government were heard. Record perused. Shri K.S. Thakur submitted that the petitioner is qualified to be appointed against Group-D post under the respondents as per policy which existed at the time when he became entitled to apply for appointment on compassionate ground. Learned counsel refers to policy of June 13, 1987 and contends that under this policy, 20% Group-D posts can be filled on compassionate ground. Learned counsel seeks assistance from Supreme Court decision reported in Smt. Sushma Gosain and others v. Union of India and others (AIR 1989 SC 1976), Paragraph 9 of which holds that :-

    "9. We consider that it must be stated unequivocally that in all claims for appointment on compassionate grounds, there should not be any delay in appointment. The purpose of providing appointment on compassionate ground is to mitigate the hardship due to death of the bread earner in the family. Such appointment should, therefore, be provided immediately to redeem the family in distress. It is improper to keep such case pending for years. If there is no suitable post for appointment supernumerary post should be created to accommodate the applicant."

    In this case, the petitioner had given application for appointment on the post of L.D.C. on compassionate ground in November, 1982. She had then a right to have her case considered for appointment on compassionate ground under the existing Government memorandum. In January, 1983, she passed trade test conducted by DGBR, though there was no reason to make her wait till 1985 when ban on appointment of ladies was imposed. The plea so raised was rejected and Apex Court issued mandatory direction to the respondents to appoint the petitioner in the post to which she had already qualified. The Apex Court further directed to appoint her in an appropriate place in Delhi itself within a period of three weeks from the date of order.

    7. Shri R.S. Patel, learned counsel for respondents contends that the case of petitioner was considered in the light of policy dated October 9,1998 under which only 5% vacancies are available for compassionate appointment to Group-D posts. Since posts were not available, the petitioner could not be appointed. The question which falls for consideration is whether the case of petitioner should be considered on the basis of policy dated June 13, 1987 or policy issued on October 9,1998.

    8. Giving consideration to the matter, we are of considered opinion that case of the petitioner should have been considered under the policy of June 13, 1987. Father of petitioner died on October 29,1992. Same year, the petitioner applied for appointment on compassionate ground against Class IV post. There is not dispute that he was eligible at that time. He and his mother ' furnished material sought by the respondents in support of the claim. Therefore, the respondents should not have delayed consideration of the claim for seven years. The fault was on the part of respondents and not of the petitioner. The case of petitioner should have been considered on the basis of requirements under policy dated June 13, 1987 and not on the basis of later policy of October 9, 1998 and the decision so arrived is liable to be set aside.

    9. Learned counsel for respondents brought decisions in the case of State of Haryana v. Rani Devi (AIR 1996 SC 2445), Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. v. A. Radhika Thirumalai (Smt). (AIR 1997 SC 123), Life Insurance Corporation v. Asha Ramchandra Ambekar (AIR 1994 SC 2148) and Himachal Road Transport Corporation v. Dinesh Kumar. (AIR 1996 SC 2226) to our notice. Perusal of these decisions shows that none of them run contrary to the submissions advanced by the petitioner. The Apex Court has in some cases issued mandatory directions for appointment, one such case is Smt. Sushma Gosain (supra). We hold that the petitioner is entitled to be considered and appointed on compassionate ground for reasons stated in the preceding part of this judgment. Having said so, the respondents have to consider the case of the petitioner for appointment against Group-D post to which he was eligible on the basis of policy dated June 13, 1987.

    10. Consequently, the writ petition is allowed and order of Central Administrative Tribunal dated September 7, 2000 is set aside. The respondents are directed to consider the case of petitioner for appointment on compassionate ground against Group-D post within a period of two months. There shall be no order as to cost.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    T. Swamy Dass v. Union Of India And Others
    (Jan 10, 2002)