BEFORE:
The Hon'ble JUSTICE PINAKI CHANDRA GHOSE
The Hon'ble JUSTICE ASIM KUMAR RAY
Date : 6th August, 2010.
The Court :- Learned Counsel appearing on
behalf of the parties drew our attention to the following
portion of the judgment and the observations made in the
judgment and order dated May 14, 2010 passed by the Hon'ble
First Court. In particular our attention has been drawn to the
following portion of the impugned order :
1. Internal Page 9, Paper Book page no 118.
Implicit of such statement is the admission of the arbitrator's connection with
the finance company. Taking a cue from the apparent admission on pleadings
that the arbitrator acts regularly as arbitrator for various financial companies
including this finance company, the hirer has called attention to what appears to
be a reference number in several of the arbitrator's documents pertaining to the
reference. The hirer suggests that the reference number AC - 555A which is
either scribbled in pencil in some documents or appears in the acknowledgement
due cards and at top the minutes of the meetings that form part of the arbitrator's
records, may imply that it was the five hundred and fifty-fifth reference taken up
by the arbitrator, whether of not it also implies that it was the five hundred and
fifty-fifth reference pertaining to this finance company or its present advocate-
on-record.
2. Internal Page 13, Paper Book page no 122.
(a) To boot, the minutes recorded that no further or other noticed for the
next meeting would be issued and that the arbitrator would proceed ex parte and
close the reference. The recording that the arbitrator would proceed ex parte
clearly apprehended that the respondents may not attend the meeting convened
next sand betrayed the state of the mind of the arbitrator since there was no
corresponding warning to the claimant that the reference would stand dismissed
upon the claimant's absence on the next date. The question that naturally arises
is as to whether the respondents to the reference were given any chance to attend
the next meeting or the recording of the minutes foretold something sinister."
3. Internal Page 14, Paper Book page no 123.
(a) The minutes of the meetings said to have been held on
September 20, 2007 and April 21, 2008 did not give any reason for such unusual
hiatus in either case. There is nothing in the records of the arbitrator to show any
attempt at service of any notice relating to the reference on the respondents to
the reference prior to November 1, 2008.
(b)Again, the original copy of the minutes, in the arbitrator's records, of the
meeting shown to have been held on April 21, 2008 contains an endorsement at
the top thereof that it had been received on behalf of advocate representing the
claimant on October 31, 2008. It is only subsequent to October 31, 2008 that the
postal records, whether of despatch or of service, are almost meticulously
maintained"
4. Internal Page 15, Paper Book page no 124.
(a)
There is substance in the challenging insinuation that the documents
relating to the reference produced by the arbitrator and the financier company
may have been fabricated or brought into existence or ante-dated or present a
show of the reference having commenced long prior to it actually did.
(b)
Such time tested and salutary practice was abandoned in this case
may be assumed for the moment, that the arbitrator's jurisdiction is evoked ex
parte by a party to the agreement and the arbitrator may thereafter inform such
fact to the other party or parties to the agreement. Based on such assumption,
the arbitral proceedings would commence only upon the other party or parties to
the reference being made aware of the reference by the arbitrator.
5. Internal Page 16, Paper Book page no 125.
It is thus obvious that the financier's ruse of having failed to forward
copies of the minutes relating to the previous alleged meeting as recorded in the
minutes of the meeting shown to have been held on April 21, 2008, was a
recording of convenience to set up a charade of the reference having commenced
prior to November 1, 2008 with the obvious motive of seeking to preclude a
stand that by November, 2008 there was no live claim to go to arbitration.
6. Internal Page 18, Paper Book page no 127.
The third paragraph was the rubber-stamp recording that no further or
separate notice would be served and if the respondents were not represented on
the next date the reference would be conducted ex parte and closed.
7. Internal Page 19, Paper Book page no 128.
(a)
It is a matter of absurd coincidence that the next two meetings in the
reference after November 21, 2008 were shown to have been held on December
19, 2008 and February 12, 2009.
(b) It is also possible to deduct that a sudden direction by the court on the
finance company to immediately produce the records relating to the reference
that were in its possession, precluded the sifting of the records or the discarding
of the unnecessary set of minutes
8. Internal Page 20, Paper Book page no 129.
"Though the arbitrator's records were sought and produced on a
subsequent day, the "mistake" had already taken place in the finance company's
bunch of papers having already been handed over to court with two rival acts of
minutes for the meeting said to have been held on November 21, 2008."
9. Internal Page 24, Paper Book page no 133.
"There are other statements in the financier's affidavit to the hirer's
petition that cannot be missed. At paragraph 12 of its affidavit (page 17) in one
of the rare positive assertions in such affidavit, the financier alleges that the
financier "made enquiries with the Learned Arbitrator and was informed that the
said award was duly sent to the petitioner (hirer) by registered post." Nothing in
the arbitrator's records reveal that such an enquiry was made other than in
writing, it would lead to the inescapable reference that the hirer had private
access to the arbitrator and the arbitrator engaged in ex parte oral
communication with the financier."
10. Internal Page 25, Paper Book page no 134.
(a)
In the classical view, no party may engage in ex parte communication
with the arbitrator. Even if such hallowed test is not applied, it is evident that
the notice of arbitration was neither sent nor intended to be sent by the financier
to the hirer or the guarantor that is if the arbitral proceedings commenced at all
when the finance company wants everyony to believe that it did. Despite
repeated queries put to the finance company at the hearing, such aspect of the
matter was completely glossed over.
(b) The relevant sentence in the financier's affidavit is a demonstrably
false allegation made on oath with scant regard for the seriousness that has to be
attached to the proceedings of the present nature."
11. Internal Page 26, Paper Book page no 135.
(a)
This is of particular significance in the context of the charge of bias
levelled against the arbitrator and it being the admitted position on pleadings
that this arbitrator has conducted several reference sent by this finance
company.
(b)
The two petitioners say that misconduct and bias on the arbitrator's
part is writ large on every page of the award. It must also be remembered that
there is a serious charger that the arbitrator routinely and mechanically makes
awards in favour of their finance company.
(c)
There is, thus, the first indication of a routine recording in the award
that has apparently been made mechanically.
12. Internal Page 28, Paper Book page no 137.
It makes one wonder how the other documents referred to in the twelfth
paragraph mysteriously opened up for the arbitrator to gaze into them and
subsequently evaporated just as furtively as they had come in.
13. Internal Page 30, Paper Book page no 139.
(a)
It is not without sufficient cause that the challengers say that the level
of informality that is generally associated with arbitration proceedings was
carried such an absurd limit by this arbitrator that would suggest that the
arbitrator and the claimant were, possibly extensions of each other.
(b) But there was even more ghastly mischief afoot in the reference."
(c) "........................ the records were concocted to give them an
appearance of authenticity. To sustain this award by any quirk of law or the
strained application of any legal principal would do violence to the rudimentary
concept of justice, be opposed to public policy and a slur on the process of
adjudication that an arbitral reference connotes.:
14. Internal Page 31, Paper Book page no 140.
(a) The circumstances here reveal a fundamental abuse of his position by
the arbitrator."
(b) The misconduct on the part of this arbitrator involves personal
turpitude on the part of the arbitrator amounting to subversion of the process of
adjudication that has resulted in complete miscarriage of justice.
(b) The records of the arbitrator unmistakably points to the sabotage of the
process of adjudication. The award is not only abhorrently bad and liable to be
set aside, but it appears to be a vicious merchandise of criminal conduct reeking
of collusion."
(c) The manner in which the finance company and the arbitrator went
about the business of this reference, as it evident from the arbitrator's records,
was calculated to cause prejudice to the hirer and the guarantor and left them no
room to defend themselves as the finance company procured its award from a
pliant merchant who reduced the process of adjudication to a farce."
15. Internal Page 35, Paper Book page no 144.
"The finance company will pay costs of Rs.2 lakh each of the hirer and
the guarantor. It will be open to the hirer and the guarantor to institute
appropriate proceedings against the finance company, the arbitrator and others
concerned, both civil and criminal.
In these circumstances the learned Counsel submitted that the
said observations would create difficulty in respect of the practicing
Advocates of this Court and further submitted that by consent of the
parties that the above observation made by His Lordship may be
expunged from the judgment and order dated May 14, 2010.
In view of that we only state that since the parties have
jointly submitted before us that the said observations should be
expunged from the order and/or judgment, we only keep it on record
that on the undertaking of the learned Advocate for the parties
against whom the said observations were made that they will not
further act in such a manner when such an order could be passed by the
Court. Accordingly, we record a caution to the said learned Advocates
and expunge the said observations from the said order/judgment. But we
keep it on record that in future if occasion arises we will deal
sternly against them.
By consent we make it clear that the claimant being the
appellant herein shall not take any further steps as regards to the
order so passed including the arbitration proceeding and also in any
proceeding before any other appropriate forum including the National
Commission. Steps to be taken for withdrawal of all the proceedings by
and between the parties or for dismissal of the proceeding pending
before any forum by them against each other.
The cheques will be issued in favour of Rasal Dilip Damodar
to be forwarded to M/s. Fox & Mondal attention Mr. Anil Dhar,
Advocate.
With the above observations, and by consent of the
parties both the appeal and the applications are disposed of.
All parties concerned are to act on a xerox signed copy of
this order on the usual undertakings.
Urgent xerox certified copy of this order, if applied for,
be supplied to the parties subject to compliance with all
requisite formalities.
(PINAKI CHANDRA GHOSE, J.)
(ASIM KUMAR RAY, J.)
dg/