Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The accused petitioner filed a revision petition seeking to quash Complaint Case No. 175C of 1993 pending before the Judicial Magistrate, 2nd Court, Howrah, and to set aside an order dated 2nd February 1994 passed in the said case. The complaint was filed by the opposite party No. 1, proprietor of R.A Pipe Fitting Co., alleging that the accused petitioner requested supply of materials on credit terms, promising payment within ninety days. The complainant supplied pipe fittings starting from 11.11.1991 but was not paid by 11.2.1992. Subsequently, the accused issued three cheques to the complainant, which were dishonored due to insufficient funds or stop payment instructions. Despite repeated promises, payment was not made, leading to the complaint and initiation of proceedings under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) for cheating. The learned Magistrate framed charges under Section 420 IPC, rejecting the accused's prayer for discharge.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the complaint and evidence disclose the essential ingredient of initial inducement by the accused petitioner to constitute an offence under Section 420 IPC?
  2. Whether the proceedings under Section 420 IPC are maintainable in the absence of such initial inducement?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petition and witness depositions do not establish any initial inducement by the accused petitioner to the complainant.
  • Absence of initial inducement negates the essential ingredient of offence under Section 420 IPC.
  • Reliance on precedents emphasizing that without initial inducement, Section 420 IPC is not attracted.

Complainant's Arguments

  • Dishonest intention (mens rea) can be inferred from the accused petitioner's subsequent conduct.
  • Issuing cheques knowing they were not genuine constitutes initial inducement and dishonest intention.
  • Reliance on precedents allowing inference of initial inducement from subsequent conduct.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
1983 Cr. L.J 106 (V.V.L.N Chari v. N.A Martin, Kerala) Requirement of initial inducement to constitute offence under Section 420 IPC. Supported the petitioner's contention that absence of initial inducement negates offence.
1987 Cr. L.J 1446 (G.K Mahanty v. Pratap Kishore Das, Orissa) Initial inducement as essential ingredient for Section 420 IPC. Reinforced the petitioner's argument on absence of inducement.
AIR 1974 SC 301 (Hari Prasad Ckamarai v. Bishnu Kumar Surekha) Interpretation of mens rea and inducement under Section 420 IPC. Referenced to clarify legal principles regarding inducement.
1991 Cr. L.J 1603 (Radha Raman Sahu v. Trihchan Nanda, Orissa) Requirement of initial inducement for offence under Section 420 IPC. Used to support petitioner's submission on absence of inducement.
1989 Cr. L.J 443 (Radhakrishan Dalmia v. Narayan, M.P) Inference of mens rea and inducement from subsequent conduct. Relied upon by complainant to argue inducement can be inferred.
1978 Cr. L.J 1360 (M.M Maternity & Construction Committee v. K. Rajmalla, A.P) Mens rea inferred from subsequent conduct. Supported complainant's argument on dishonest intention.
1982 Cr. L.J 1482 (Bholanath v. State, Delhi) Inference of inducement and mens rea from subsequent actions. Used by complainant to establish dishonest intention.
AIR 1983 SC 1149 (Ramavatar Gupta v. Gopal Das) Subsequent conduct as evidence of initial inducement under Section 420 IPC. Complainant cited to support inference of inducement from later conduct.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the timeline and facts, noting that the cheques were issued after the supply of materials was completed and not during the initial transaction or order stage. The complainant's own deposition confirmed that he had verified the accused petitioner's conduct before commencing supply, indicating no inducement at the outset. The Court emphasized that an offence under Section 420 IPC requires inducement at the initial stage. Subsequent conduct or promises do not satisfy this essential element. Accordingly, the Court found that since no initial inducement was established, the charge under Section 420 IPC was not maintainable. The Court thus quashed the entire proceeding including the impugned order.

Holding and Implications

The revisional application is allowed and the proceedings in Case No. 175C of 1993, including the order dated 2.2.94, are quashed.

The decision directly results in the termination of the criminal proceedings against the accused petitioner under Section 420 IPC in this matter. No broader precedent was established beyond the application of the principle that initial inducement is a necessary ingredient of the offence under Section 420 IPC.

    M.S Natarajan v. Ramasis Shaw & Anr.

    Nripendra Kumar Bhattacharyya, J.:—By this revision the accused petitioner has come up before this Court praying for quashing the Complaint Case No. 175C of 1993 pending in the court of the learned Judicial Magistrate, 2nd Court, Howrah, and also for setting aside the order dated 2nd February, 1994 passed by the said learned Magistrate in the said case.

    2. The fact silhouetted behind this case is that the opposite party No. 1 herein filed a petition of complaint before the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Howrah, alleging, inter alia, that the complainant is the proprietor of R.A Pipe Fitting Co. of 12/5, Musalman Para Lane, P.S Bantra, District Howrah, and deals in the business of iron pipe and pipe fittings. The complainant opposite party No. 1 received a letter from the accused petitioner herein on 11.10.91 asking for delivery of certain materials on terms that payments should be deferred by ninety days from the date of the delivery of the material. The complainant opposite party met the accused petitioner on 27th July, 1991 at Madurai and talked about the letter for supply of the materials. On believing the representation of the accused petitioner, the complainant opposite party after coming back to Howrah started supplying pipe fittings on 11.11.91 and submitted his bills for payment. The complainant opposite party was not paid the price of the materials supplied till 11.2.92 and being apprehensive, the complainant opposite party made tagids for payment and after deferring such payments the accused petitioner made over three cheques bearing Nos. 093977 dated 15.7.92 for Rs. 50,000/-, 093978 dated 30.8.92 for Rs. 50,000/-, and 092979 dated 15.8.92 for Rs. 52,000/- only on Indian Bank, T.V.S Nagar Branch, Madurai, in favour of the complainant opposite party. The said three cheques were tendered to the Biank through the Federal Bank Limited, Howrah Branch at Bantra, Howrah, but the cheques amounting to Rs. 50,000/- were returned as the amount was not duly covered. The third cheques was returned with the endorsement that the accused asked for stopping payment. By a letter dated 14th October, 1992 the accused petitioner promised payment but as the payment was not made, again the complainant opposite party made tagid by a lawyer's letter dated 2nd November, 1992. From time to time the accused petitioner by different letters promised payment and on 18.1.93 the complainant opposite party demanded immediate payment of money from the accused petitioner. The accused petitioner denied all transactions. Hence the petition of complaint. Summons was issued after taking cognizance by the learned Magistrate. Evidence was gone into and the learned Magistrate framed a charge against the accused petitioner under s. 420 of the Indian Penal Code, though prayer was made before the learned Magistrate for discharge of the accused petitioner as there was no ingredient of cheating as contemplated under s. 420 of the Indian Penal Code.

    3. Appearing for the petitioner, Mr. Tapan Kumar Dutt, learned Advocate, contended by referring to the petition of complaint and the deposition of the witnesses that the petition of complaint and the deposition do not show any initial inducement by the accused petitioner to the complainant opposite party and as such the ingredient of s. 420, IPC being absent the proceeding should be quashed. He further contended that at the initial stage there was no inducement. According to him, as there was no case of initial inducement by the accused petitioner to the complainant opposite party, the proceeding for the offence under s. 420, IPC is not competent and liable to be quashed. In this connection, he referred to some decisions, to wit. 1983 Cr. L.J 106, [V.V.L.N Chari v. N.A Martin (Kerala)], 1987 Cr. L.J 1446, [G.K Mahanty v. Pratap Kishore Das (Orissa)], AIR 1974 SC 301, [Hari Prasad Ckamarai v. Bishnu Kumar Surekha], and 1991 Cr. L.J 1603, [Radha Raman Sahu v. Trihchan Nanda (Orissa)], Mr. Dutt contended that in view of the ratio that has been deduced in those cases that in order to constitute an offence under s. 420, IPC, if here is no initial inducement by the accused to the complainant, then no offence under s. 402, IPC is constituted.

    4. Mr. Tapan Kumar Banerjee, learned Advocate appearing for the complainant opposite party No. 1 herein, on the other hand, contended that from the subsequent conduct of the accused petitioner mens rea can be inferred and if the cheques were given during the time of transaction knowing fully well that those cheques were not genuine, that would constitute dishonest intention and inducement by the accused petitioner at the initial stage. In this connection, Mr. Banerjee referred to some decisions reported in 1989 Cr. L.J 443, [Radhakrishan Dalmia v. Narayan (M.P)], 1978 Cr. L.J 1360, [M.M Maternity & Construdtion Committee v. K. Rajmalla (A.P)], 1982 Cr. L.J 1482, [Bholanath v. State (Delhi)] and AIR 1983 SC 1149, [Ramavatar Gupta v. Gopal Das]. In all those decisions it has been held that from subsequent conduct it can be inferred that the accused petitioner induced the complainant opposite party at the initial stage.

    5. Heard the submissions of the learned Advocates for the parties and considered the materials on record.

    6. In order to constitute an offence under s. 420, IPC, there must be some inducement by the accused petitioner ta the complainant at the initial stage. In the instant case, the cheques were given to the complainant opposite party not during the time of transaction which took place subsequent to 27th October, 1991 and supply of the materials was complete on 30th January, 1992 and the cheques were given subsequent to that. So during the time of transaction no cheque was given to the complainant opposite party by the accused petitioner; only a promise was made that payment should be made within ninety days from the date of delivery of the materials. The deposition of the complainant on oath as P.W 1 is that on getting the order of supply from the accused petitioner the complainant opposite party had gone to Madurai, verified about the conduct of the accused and talked to the accused regarding his order. After being satisfied, he started supplying materials. So from his own deposition it will evince that during the time of the order and during the time of the talk the complainant opposite party satisfied himself about the conduct of the accused petitioner. So during the time of the transaction there was no inducement. If there was no inducement at the initial stage, subsequent inducement will not constitute the offence under s. 420 of the Indian Penal Code. As there was no initial inducement in this case, the case under s. 420, IPC is not maintainable.

    7. In that view of the matter, I hereby quash the entire proceeding being case No. 175C of 1993, including the order dated 2.2.94 as passed by the learned Judicial Magistrate, 2nd Court Howrah.

    8. The revisional application is thus allowed.

    Revisional application allowed. Proceeding quashed.
    T.D.N

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M.S Natarajan v. Ramasis Shaw & Anr.
    (Jan 4, 1995)