AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Acts
  • sections 248 and 249 and 250 of Kerala Panchayat Raj Act 1994.
  • Section 248 and Section 250 of Kerala Panchayat Raj Act,
  • sections 167, 463, 464, 465, 468, 471 r/w 34 of IPC
  • PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • section 250 of Kerala Panchayat Raj Act)
  • sections 167, 465, 468, 471 r/w 34 of IPC
  • section 463 or section 471 of IPC
  • section 450 of Cr.P.C.
  • section 482 of Cr.P.C.
  • section 156(3) Cr.P.C.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Judges
Acts
  • sections 248 and 249 and 250 of Kerala Panchayat Raj Act 1994.
  • Section 248 and Section 250 of Kerala Panchayat Raj Act,
  • sections 167, 463, 464, 465, 468, 471 r/w 34 of IPC
  • PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • section 250 of Kerala Panchayat Raj Act)
  • sections 167, 465, 468, 471 r/w 34 of IPC
  • section 463 or section 471 of IPC
  • section 450 of Cr.P.C.
  • section 482 of Cr.P.C.
  • section 156(3) Cr.P.C.
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are accused in C.C.No.93/10 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Ettumanoor. The 1st respondent is the de facto complainant who filed Annexure A private complaint alleging offences punishable under sections 167, 463, 464, 465, 468, 471 r/w 34 of the Indian Penal Code. That complaint was forwarded to the Ettumanoor police station under section 156(3) Cr.P.C. and registered as Crime No.105/09. Following police investigation the police submitted Annexure C report; the Magistrate below took cognizance and instituted C.C.No.93/10. The petitioners (1st petitioner then Secretary of Athirampuzha Grama Panchayat; petitioners 2 and 3 employees of the same panchayat; 4th petitioner the then President) challenged the proceedings by filing the present petition under section 482 of Cr.P.C.

The substantive allegation is that the petitioners created a document recording that a Karmasamithi meeting was convened on 15.7.2008 (Annexure F) and used that purported document as genuine; the Panchayat committee minutes dated 22.7.2008 (Annexure G) recorded decisions purportedly based on that Karmasamithi meeting and those decisions were forwarded to higher authorities. On that basis the de facto complainant and the police alleged offences under various provisions of the IPC and initiated proceedings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the materials on record disclose that the petitioners falsely made or fabricated a document (Annexure F) such that offences under sections 167, 463, 465, 468, 471 r/w 34 of IPC (and section 463 or section 471 specifically) are attracted.
  2. Whether the Magistrate below lacked jurisdiction to proceed in the absence of sanction under the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act (specifically sections 248 and 250 as relied upon by the petitioners) or whether proceedings ought to have been initiated under the Prevention of Corruption Act.
  3. Whether the disputed facts are predominantly mixed questions of fact that require trial evidence rather than determination at the stage of the present petition under section 482 Cr.P.C.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • There is no material on record to show that the petitioners have falsely made or created any document as alleged in the complaint or the police report.
  • Annexure G minutes dated 22.7.2008 contain no reference to Annexure F minutes dated 15.7.2008 (the alleged fabricated Karmasamithi minutes), undermining the prosecution's theory.
  • Given the nature of the allegations and the materials in Annexure C and Annexure A, proceedings, if any, ought to have been initiated under the Prevention of Corruption Act rather than the IPC provisions relied upon in Annexure C.
  • In view of sections 248 and 250 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, in the absence of sanction from the competent authority the learned Magistrate was wrong in taking cognizance; sanction is necessary before trial can proceed.
  • The petitioners relied on the decisions in Parminder Kaur v. State of Uttar Pradesh [(2010) 1 SCC 322] and Hydru Haji v. State of Kerala (2011 (1) KLT 63) in support of their contentions.

1st Respondent's Arguments

  • Under the Peoples Planning Programme scheme, proposals must originate from a properly constituted Karmasamithi and be considered by the Panchayat; the Panchayat committee then finalises schemes to present to higher authorities.
  • Although Annexure F (15.7.2008 Karmasamithi minutes) may not represent a properly constituted body, the Panchayat nevertheless acted on the basis of Annexure F as evidenced by Annexure G (22.7.2008 minutes), and specific item numbers correspond: item nos.7 and 31 in Annexure F correspond to item nos.50 and 73 in Annexure G respectively.
  • Relied upon OM KR Dhankar v. State of Haryana [2012 (2) KLT 106 (SC)] to support the contention that the scheme of decision-making and the connected documents show a link between Annexures F and G.

Public Prosecutor / State

  • The Public Prosecutor adopted the petitioners' contention insofar as the material on record does not reveal an overt act of forgery by the petitioners.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Parminder Kaur v. State of Uttar Pradesh [(2010) 1 Supreme Court Cases 322] Cited by the petitioners in support of their contention regarding the requirement of sanction / procedural protections before proceeding against public functionaries (as relied upon by petitioners). The court found the decision cited by the petitioners to be not applicable or relevant in view of the facts of the present case; the circumstances in Parminder Kaur were held not to be identical to those here.
Hydru Haji v. State of Kerala (2011 (1) KLT 63) Cited by the petitioners (paragraphs 10, 14 to 18 were relied upon) in support of their submission on sanction / procedural requirements. The court held that Hydru Haji was not applicable or relevant on the facts and circumstances of the present case.
OM KR Dhankar v. State of Haryana [2012 (2) KLT 106 (SC)] Relied upon by the 1st respondent to support the proposition that offences under certain forgery-related provisions cannot be regarded as having been committed by officials while acting in discharge of official duty. The court observed that, on the strength of this authority, offences referred to under sections 467, 468, 471 cannot be regarded as having been committed while the petitioners were acting in discharge of official duty; this undercut the petitioners' submission that sanction under the Panchayat Act was necessarily required at the threshold.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court heard the parties and examined Annexures A, C, F and G. It analyzed the competing contentions and proceeded as follows:

  1. The court observed that the record raises mixed questions of fact — notably whether Annexure G decisions were based on Annexure F and whether Annexure F was a genuine or fabricated document. These are factual disputes that require evidence to be tested at trial.
  2. On review of Annexure G, the court acknowledged there is no explicit reference to Annexure F; however it noted substantive similarity in the wording of particular items (item nos.7 and 31 in Annexure F and item nos.50 and 73 in Annexure G), suggesting some connection which the evidence at trial must explore.
  3. The court considered the allegation in Annexure C that the petitioners created fake records of a Karmasamithi meeting of 15.7.2008 and misrepresented those records in the Panchayat minutes of 22.7.2008 to obtain higher authority approval. The court found that if Annexure F were presented as genuine (i.e., relied on as original), section 471 IPC (using as genuine a forged document) could be attracted, subject to proof at trial.
  4. The court concluded that whether section 463 or section 471 IPC is attracted is a matter to be decided on the evidence at trial; it was premature at the stage of a petition under section 482 Cr.P.C. to hold those sections inapplicable.
  5. With respect to the contention that sanction under the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act was required before the Magistrate could take cognizance, the court noted the Magistrate's order (Annexure E) which found that the necessity or otherwise of sanction could be determined only after evidence is led. The court also referred to OM KR Dhankar and observed that offences under sections 467, 468, 471 could not necessarily be regarded as having been committed while acting in discharge of official duty; consequently, the petitioners' reliance on sanction provisions and on the other decisions (Parminder Kaur and Hydru Haji) did not persuade the court to quash the proceedings at this stage.
  6. Having assessed the mixed factual matrix and the lack of conclusive material to show that the offences were not made out as a matter of law at the threshold, the court concluded that interference with the proceedings would be inappropriate and premature.
  7. Procedural direction: the court made clear that the materials referred to in disposing of the petition were limited to that purpose and directed the Magistrate to dispose of C.C.No.93/10 without being influenced by the observations and findings contained in this opinion. The petitioners were permitted to raise all their contentions before the trial court.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Subject to the observations and directions recorded in the opinion, the Criminal Miscellaneous Petition is dismissed.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The criminal proceedings in C.C.No.93/10 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Ettumanoor will continue; the trial court is to proceed uninfluenced by the appellate observations in this petition and the petitioners remain free to raise all their contentions at trial.
  • The court found that mixed questions of fact remain to be adjudicated and therefore declined to quash the proceedings at the threshold; the question whether sections 463 or 471 (and other IPC provisions alleged) are attracted must be determined on trial evidence.
  • The court rejected the petitioners' argument that precedent relied upon by them (Parminder Kaur and Hydru Haji) compelled a quashing of proceedings; it treated OM KR Dhankar as supporting the view that certain forgery-related offences may not necessarily be committed in the discharge of official duty and thus did not require pre-trial sanction in the present factual matrix.
  • The petitioners 1 to 3 were informed that they may apply to the trial court for exemption from personal attendance during the trial; the trial court will decide such applications on merit and will not insist on physical presence unless indispensable.
  • No novel legal principle or binding precedent was laid down by this opinion; the decision primarily addresses the propriety of interfering at the section 482 Cr.P.C. stage given the mixed questions of fact and the necessity of evidence to resolve them.

Disposition: The petition is dismissed. The judgment is signed by V.K. Mohanan, Judge.

    State Of Uttar Pradesh And Another ... v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Another

    The petitioners are accused in C.C.No.93/10 on the file of the court of Judicial First Class Magistrate-Ettumanoor. The 1st respondent is the de facto complainant. Initially, the 1st respondent herein approached the court below by filing Annexure A complaint alleging offences punishable under sections 167, 463, 464, 465, 468, 471 r/w 34 of IPC against the petitioners, which was forwarded to the Ettumanoor police station under section 156(3) Cr.P.C. and consequently, Crime No.105/09 was registered in the Ettumanoor police station. The police after investigation, have preferred Annexure C report, upon which, the court below took cognizance and instituted C.C.No.93/10. It is against the above proceedings, the petitioners, who are accused, preferred the present petition under section 482 of Cr.P.C.

    2. The 1st petitioner herein is then working as Secretary Crl.M.C.No.722 of 2013 of Athirampuzha Grama panchayat and petitioner nos.2 and 3 are respectively working as the Junior Superintendent and Upper Division Clerk of the said panchayat. The 4th petitioner was the then President of Athirampuzha Grama panchayat. As per the allegation, the petitioners had created a document stating that a meeting of a Karmasamithi was convened on 15.7.2008 and the said document was used as a genuine document and the factum of convening of meeting of the Karmasamithi on 15.7.2008 was recorded in the minutes of the Panchayat committee held on 22.7.2008 and thus, according to the de facto complainant as well as the police, the petitioners/accused have committed the offences punishable under sections 167, 465, 468, 471 r/w 34 of IPC.

    3. I have heard Adv.Sri.George Sebastian, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners and Adv.Sri.P.A.Salim, the learned counsel appearing for the 1st respondent and Adv.Sri.Rajesh Vijayan, the learned Public Prosecutor for Crl.M.C.No.722 of 2013 the State.

    4. The learned counsel for the petitioners, after taking me through Annexure A private complaint and the police report, specifically submitted that there is no material to show that the petitioners have falsely made or created any document as alleged in the complaint or in the report. After inviting my attention to Annexure G minutes dated 22.7.2008 of the Panchayat committee, it is submitted that there is no reference about Annexure F minutes dated 15.7.2008 of the Karmasamithi, which was allegedly fabricated by the petitioners. It is also the contention of the learned counsel that, in the light of Annexure C report and particularly in view of the averments in Annexure A complaint, the proceedings under the provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act ought to have been initiated and therefore the proceedings, as per Annexure C, in the court of Judicial First Class Magistrate-Ettumanur, would not lie against the petitioners. It is also contended that in Crl.M.C.No.722 of 2013 view of Section 248 and Section 250 of Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, in the absence of sanction from the competent authority, the learned Magistrate is wrong in taking cognizance for the said offences against the petitioners and on that ground also, the proceedings pending before the court below are liable to be quashed. In support of the contentions, the learned counsel for the petitioners has placed reliance upon the decisions reported in Parminder Kaur Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and another [(2010) 1 Supreme Court Cases 322] paragraph 29 and in Hydru Haji Vs. State of Kerala (2011(1) KLT 63) paragraphs 10, 14 to 18.

    5. Contrary to the above contention of the learned counsel for the petitioners, the learned counsel for the 1st respondent, has strenuously submitted that as per the scheme of the Peoples Planning Programme, proposal from a properly constituted Karmasamithi has to be considered by the panchayat and on the basis of such proposal, it is for Crl.M.C.No.722 of 2013 the panchayat committee to finalise the scheme to be presented before the higher authorities. But in the present case, no such step was taken. But based on Annexure F minutes of the Karmasamithi meeting held on 15.7.2008, which is not a properly constituted Karmasamithi, the panchayat has taken decision, as per the meeting held on 22.7.2008 as evidenced by Annexure G minutes and submitted the proposals before the District Planning Committee. After inviting my attention, particularly, to item nos.7 and 31 in Annexure F and item nos.50 and 73 in Annexure G minutes dated 22.7.2008, the learned counsel for the 1st respondent submitted that item nos.7 and 31 in Annexure F are one and the same scheme programme and item nos.50 and 73 in Annexure G minutes, are also of the same proposal and project. To fortify the contention of the learned counsel for the 1st respondent, he placed reliance upon the decision reported in OM KR. Dhankar v. State of Haryana [2012(2) KLT 106(SC)].

    Crl.M.C.No.722 of 2013

    6. The learned Public Prosecutor also submitted by adopting the contentions advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioners that, though the averment in Annexure A complaint is to the effect that the petitioners have forged the document, the available materials does not reveal any such overtact against the petitioners.

    7. In the light of the contentions advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioners as well as the 1st respondent, which I referred above, it can be seen that mixed questions of facts are involved and the said disputed facts can be settled only on the basis of the evidence yet to be adduced during the trial of the case. It is true that on going through Annexure G minutes, there is no reference of Annexure F minutes, but at the very same time, it can be seen that item nos.7 and 31 in Annexure F and item nos.50 and 73 in Annexure G are more or less the same. The learned counsel for the petitioners does not fully agree with the submission of the learned counsel for the 1st respondent Crl.M.C.No.722 of 2013 that, in order to formulate a proposal to be submitted before the higher authorities, for taking a decision, such proposal has to be originated from the Karmasamithi. So, the question as to how the Panchayat committee has to take decision and formulate a proposal to be submitted before the higher authorities, has to be enquired into on the basis of the evidence yet to be adduced. At this juncture, it is relevant to note that as pointed out by the learned counsel for the 1st respondent, item nos.7 and 31 in Annexure F and item nos.50 and 73 in Annexure G minutes are similarly worded, which shows that the decision of the Panchayat committee as per Annexure G minutes, has some connection with Annexure F minutes of the Karmasamithi committee held on 15.7.2008, which is not a properly constituted one, since as per the version of the 1st respondent, the presence of Sri.Joseph Paraveli, alone can be treated as official, since he was the Chairman of the said Karmasamithi, but the other members are not properly elected or constituted. Crl.M.C.No.722 of 2013 Thus, according to me, if Annexure F was presented as genuine, Section 471 of IPC would be attracted, provided, there are sufficient evidence to prove that the decisions in Annexure G were taken on the basis of Annexure F. So, the question whether section 463 or section 471 of IPC is attracted, is a matter to be decided on the basis of the evidence yet to be adduced. At this juncture it is also relevant to note that, in Annexure C report, it is specifically alleged that towards the formation of the 2nd stage of the programme/plan for the year 2008-09, the petitioners had created fake records of convening of Karmasamithi meeting on 15.7.2008, and misinterpreted that fake records to be an original one in the minutes of the Panchayat meeting that was held on 22.7.2008 and thereby, by way of cheating, the accused obtained an approval from the higher authorities and thereby committed the offences charged against them. So, according to me, it cannot be said that section 471 of IPC is not attracted as per Annexure C report and whether Crl.M.C.No.722 of 2013 the same can be substantiated or not, has to be decided on the basis of the evidence yet to be adduced during the trial of the case. Therefore, at this stage, it is premature for this Court to say that sections 167, 465, 468, 471 r/w 34 of IPC are not attracted in this case.

    8. Another contention raised by the learned counsel for the petitioners is about the jurisdiction of the court below to proceed with the trial of the case in the absence of proper sanction from competent authority, in view of sections 248 and 249 and 250 of Kerala Panchayat Raj Act 1994. As per Annexure E order, the learned Magistrate has held that whether the act committed by the petitioners/accused are in good faith or not, can be considered only after considering the evidence in this case and only at that stage, the sanction under section 450 of Cr.P.C. (purportedly under section 250 of Kerala Panchayat Raj Act) is necessary or not, can be determined and also found that there is no material to consider the charge Crl.M.C.No.722 of 2013 levelled against the petitioners are groundless. In the present case, the offences alleged against the petitioners are punishable under sections 167, 465, 468, 471 r/w 34 of IPC and that is on the basis of Annexure F document, which I have already referred above. As rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for the 1st respondent, on the strength of the decision in OM KR. Dhankar v. State of Haryana [2012 (2) KLT 106(SC)], the offences referred under sections 467, 468, 471, cannot be regarded as having been committed by the petitioners at the time of acting or purporting to act in discharge of any official duty. The decisions relied on by the learned counsel for the petitioners reported in Parminder Kaur Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and another [(2010) 1 Supreme Court Cases 322] paragraph 29 and in Hydru Haji Vs. State of Kerala (2011(1) KLT 63) paragraphs 10, 14 to 18, according to me, are not applicable and relevant in view of the facts of this case and particularly, the facts and circumstances involved in those cases are not identical to Crl.M.C.No.722 of 2013 the present one. So, according to me, this Court will not be justified in interfering with the proceedings pending against the petitioners at this stage, particularly in view of the mixed questions of facts involved in the case. Therefore, I find no merit in this petition and accordingly the same is liable to be dismissed.

    9. The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the petitioners 1 to 3 are now working in different offices/stations on their various capacities and therefore the court below may be directed to exempt them from their personal appearance during the trial of the case. The above submission, according to me, deserves positive consideration. It is for the petitioners 1 to 3 to seek exemption by filing proper petitions before the court below at appropriate stage and it is for that court to consider the same on merit. I am sure that in case such petitions are filed, the court will consider the same on merit and the court will not insist for the physical presence of the Crl.M.C.No.722 of 2013 petitioners 1 to 3, unless their presence are indispensable during the time of trial of the case.

    10. It is made clear that the datas and materials referred above are only for the purpose of disposing this petition and the learned Magistrate of the court below is directed to dispose of C.C.No.93/10 pending in that court, untrammelled by any of the discussions and observations and also the findings contained herein before. The petitioners are permitted to raise all the contentions raised in this Crl.M.C., before the court below also.

    Subject to the above observations and directions, the above Crl.M.C. is dismissed.

    Sd/-

    V.K.MOHANAN, Judge.

    ami/ //True copy// P.A. to Judge

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Uttar Pradesh And Another ... v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Another
    (Oct 16, 2012)