Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Rule 3
  • submissions.7. Rule 3
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Rule 3
  • submissions.7. Rule 3
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion delivered by Balakrishnan Nair, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter arises from W.A. No. 2065/08 (with connected appeals W.A. Nos. 1137/09 and 1923/08). The first respondent in the writ petition (now respondent in the appeal) had been appointed as Librarian Grade III in the Higher Secondary wing of the second respondent's school on 16.8.2001. The appointment was not approved by the Director of Higher Secondary Education. Chapter XXXII was added to the Kerala Education Rules (K.E.R.) on 12.11.2001, setting out categories of posts and the manner of appointment in aided Higher Secondary schools.

The Government, after directions of this Court, issued Ext. P12 (order dated 27-1-2006) rejecting the first respondent's claim. The first respondent challenged Ext. P12 by filing a writ petition. The learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition and directed the Director to sanction the post of Librarian Grade III so that the first respondent could be accommodated. The appellants (who were respondents in the writ petition) challenged that direction by way of this writ appeal.

Issues about the library's existence and size were disputed: appellants relied on an inspection finding of 720 books, while respondents claimed more than 11,000 books. The Government also took a policy/financial stance that it would not sanction librarian posts generally and proposed an alternative arrangement (assigning an H.S.S.T. (Junior) to run the library with Rs. 250 per month incentive), reflected in Annexure A1 dated 20.4.2006.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the directions issued by the learned Single Judge to sanction the post of Librarian Grade III in the second respondent's school, so as to approve the appointment of the first respondent in that post, are justified.
  2. Whether, under Rule 3 of Chapter XXXII of the Kerala Education Rules, sanctioning of posts (specifically the post of Librarian) is automatic or is a matter for the Director's discretion and, in certain circumstances, a power coupled with a duty that must be exercised.

Arguments of the Parties

First Respondent / Writ Petitioner — Main Contentions

  • Chapter XXXII of the K.E.R. creates the posts of Librarian Grade III and Grade IV; since the school has a library, a post of Librarian must exist and the appointment should be approved.
  • Relied on decisions of the Division Bench in Shaji v. Ramachandran (2003 (2) KLT 814) and the Full Bench in Aided Higher Secondary School Teachers Association v. State of Kerala (2005 (1) KLT 94 (FB)).
  • Relied on Ext. P4 (decision of the learned Single Judge directing creation of posts of Lab Assistants) in support of the submission that the post ought to be sanctioned or recognized.

Appellants (Respondents in the Writ Petition) — Main Contentions

  • Although various posts are enumerated under the K.E.R., appointment can be made only if the Director of Higher Secondary Education sanctions the post, in view of the express wording of Rule 3 of Chapter XXXII.
  • In the second respondent's school the Director had not sanctioned the post of Librarian; therefore the appointment of the first respondent was illegal and unauthorised.
  • The second respondent's school does not have a full‑fledged library; an inspection at admission stage found only 720 books.
  • The Government has studied financial implications and decided not to sanction librarian posts generally, proposing instead an arrangement where an H.S.S.T. (Junior) would run the library after some training and receive Rs. 250/month as incentive (Annexure A1 dated 20.4.2006); given the state's financial position, it is not possible to sanction librarian posts.

Contesting Respondents / Supporting Counsel — Main Contentions

  • Rule 3 creates the post of Librarian; the Manager is the appointing authority; a full‑fledged library is a condition for sanctioning a Higher Secondary course and therefore the Director is bound to sanction the post of Librarian.
  • Relied on the same Division Bench and Full Bench authorities (Shaji v. Ramachandran and Aided Higher Secondary School Teachers Association v. State of Kerala) to support the contention that sanction should follow where a library exists and is required for the course.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shaji v. Ramachandran (2003 (2) KLT 814) Authority relied upon by the parties regarding sanctioning/creation of posts in Higher Secondary schools under K.E.R. The Court noted that the learned Single Judge relied on this decision; it was one of the authorities considered in addressing whether posts must be sanctioned.
Aided Higher Secondary School Teachers Association v. State of Kerala (2005 (1) KLT 94 (Full Bench)) Full Bench authority on aided Higher Secondary school posts and related matters cited by parties. The Court noted the Single Judge's reliance on this full bench decision in reaching his direction; it was considered but did not lead the appellate court to affirm the direction to compulsorily sanction the post.
Commissioner of Police v. Gordhandas Banji, AIR 1952 SC 16 Explains the concept of a "power coupled with duty" — when a statutory power can generate a duty to act. The Court relied on this authority (along with others) to explain that a power vested in the Director may, in certain circumstances, be a power coupled with duty and thus call for exercise of the power.
Income Tax Officer v. Hirday Narain, (1970) 2 SCC 355 : AIR 1971 SC 33 Further explanation of the doctrine of power coupled with duty. Used by the Court together with Gordhandas Banji to explain when a discretionary power becomes one that must be exercised.
Julius v. Lord Bishop of Oxford [1880 (5) AC 214] Historical/source authority (speech of Earl Cairns, L.C.) relied upon in the above Supreme Court decisions defining "power coupled with duty." Mentioned as part of the chain of authority underpinning the concept of power coupled with duty relied upon by the Court.
The Comptroller and Auditor General v. K.S. Jagannathan (1986) 2 SCC 679 : AIR 1987 SC 537 Principle that a High Court under Article 226 can, in extreme cases, pass an order which the statutory authority could have passed had it exercised its discretion properly. The Court observed this authority but concluded that the present case lacked materials to justify the High Court itself directing sanction of the post; rather the matter should be remitted to the Director for fresh consideration.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by examining Rule 3 of Chapter XXXII of the Kerala Education Rules, which provides:

“3. The Kerala Aided Higher Secondary Education Service.— The service of every Aided Higher Secondary School shall consist of all or any of the following categories of posts as Director may sanction”. (emphasis supplied)

From the wording of Rule 3, the Court concluded that the Director has authority to sanction particular posts for each school, taking into account the school's requirements. Therefore, creation or sanctioning of posts under Rule 3 is not automatic; it is a decision for the Director.

The Court agreed with the Single Judge that sanctioning is not automatic, but disagreed with the Single Judge's practical outcome. Relying on established authorities explaining the doctrine of "power coupled with duty" (Commissioner of Police v. Gordhandas Banji and Income Tax Officer v. Hirday Narain, themselves tracing to Julius v. Lord Bishop of Oxford), the Court acknowledged that in some circumstances a statutory power may become a duty to be exercised. The Court illustrated with the example of the post of Principal — without which a school cannot function — where the Director's power is effectively coupled with duty.

However, the Court found that the record in this case did not provide sufficient material to conclude that the Director had no option but to sanction the Librarian post. The factual question whether a full‑fledged library exists in the second respondent's school was sharply disputed (appellants relying on 720 books from inspection, respondents claiming over 11,000 books). Given this factual dispute and the absence of material demonstrating that the Director had no discretion, the Court held it was improper for the Single Judge to direct that the post be sanctioned outright.

The Court explained the ordinary practice: it would quash a wrongful order and remit to the competent authority to act in accordance with law. It recognized the exceptional power of a High Court under Article 226 to itself pass an order that a statutory authority could have passed (citing The Comptroller and Auditor General v. K.S. Jagannathan) but concluded the present case was not such an extreme case warranting exercise of that power by the High Court.

Accordingly, the Court set aside the Single Judge's direction to sanction the Librarian Grade III post and remitted the matter to the Director (the second appellant) to consider the claim afresh and take a decision in accordance with law. The Court specified factors the Director should consider (students' strength, number of books, facilities in the library, etc.), directed that the Director be uninfluenced by any view expressed by the first appellant (Government) and that the Director may cause inspection by a responsible officer rather than personally inspect. The Director was to give the respondents an opportunity of being heard and complete the exercise within three months from production of the copy of the judgment.

Holding and Implications

Primary Holding: Writ Appeal allowed; the direction of the Single Judge to sanction the post of Librarian Grade III in the second respondent's school is set aside.

Direct consequences and orders:

  • The direction in the judgment under appeal to sanction the Librarian Grade III post is set aside.
  • The second appellant (Director of Higher Secondary Education) is directed to consider the respondents' claim for sanctioning the post of Librarian Grade III and take a decision in accordance with law, having regard to students' strength, number of books, library facilities, etc.
  • While taking the decision, the Director shall act independently and uninfluenced by any view expressed by the first appellant; the Director may delegate inspection to a responsible officer; the respondents must be given an opportunity of being heard.
  • The Director shall complete the exercise within three months from the date of production of a copy of this judgment.
  • The directions issued to the Director in W.A. No. 2065/08 are to govern W.A. Nos. 1137/09 and 1923/08 as well; the Director shall take a fresh decision in those cases within three months from production of a copy of this judgment.

Implications beyond the parties:

The opinion does not purport to create a new rule of law beyond its application to the present disputes. The immediate legal effect is procedural and remedial: the appellate court remitted the matter for fresh consideration by the Director rather than directing an immediate sanction. No new precedent-distinguishing doctrine was declared beyond application of established principles (including the doctrine of power coupled with duty and the limited circumstances under which a High Court may itself pass a decision the authority could have passed).

    State Of Kerala & Another v. Saji T.M & Another

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    Balakrishnan Nair, J.:—

    W.A Nos. 2065/08:

    2. The respondents 1 and 2 in the writ petition are the appellants. The first respondent herein was the writ petitioner. The point that arises for decision in this appeal is, whether the directions issued by the learned Single Judge to sanction the post of Librarian Gr. III in the second respondents school, so as to approve the appointment of the first respondent in that post, is justified dr not.

    3. The brief facts of the case are the following: Higher Secondary course was sanctioned in the second respondent's school during the academic year 2000-01, The first respondent/petitioner pointed out that the Higher Secondary Course was sanctioned as provided in Ext. P1 Government Order dated 1.10.1991, Ext. P2 Circular issued by the Director of Higher Secondary Education dated 2.2.1999 would reveal that it is mandatory to have infrastructural facilities like laboratories, libraries etc, for sanctioning Higher Secondary course. The second respondent appointed the first respondent as Librarian Gr. III in the Higher Secondary wing of the second respondent's school on 16.8.2001 Though motion for approval of the said appointment was made before the Director of Higher Secondary Education, no order was passed on it. In the meantime, the Government framed rules governing the qualifications and methods of appointment to various posts in the Higher Secondary wing, On 12.11.2001, Chapter XXXII, a new chapter was added to the Kerala Education Rules (for short, “K.E.R”), enumerating the posts and laying down the qualifications and methods of appointment to them in the aided Higher Secondary sector. When the appointment of the writ petitioner was not approved by the Director of Higher Secondary Education, he moved the Government and as per the directions of this Court, the Government rejected his claim by Ext. P12 order dated 27-1-2006. Challenging Ext. P12 and seeking consequential reliefs, the writ petition was filed. According to the first respondent/writ petitioner. Chapter XXXII K.E.R, creates the posts of Librarian Gr. III and Librarian Gr. IV, The second respondent's school has got a library. Therefore, there must be a post of Librarian. Reliance was placed on the decision of the Division Bench of this Court in Shaii v. Ramachandran. 2003 (2) KLT 814 and also the Full Bench decision in Aided Aided Higher Secondary School Teachers Association v. State Of Kerala. 2005 (1) KLT 94 (FB), in support of his submissions, He also relied on Ext. P4 decision of the learned Single Judge, directing creation of posts of Lab Assistants, in supp ort of his submissions.

    4. The appellants, who were respondents 1 and 2 in the writ petition, resisted the prayers pointing out that though various posts are created under the K.E.R, appointment can be made if only sanction is given for the same by the Director of Higher Secondary Education, in view of the express provisions contained in Rule 3 of Chapter XXXII, K.E.R In the case of the second respondent's school, the Director has not sanctioned the post of Librarian and therefore, the appointment of the first respondent in that post was illegal and unauthorised, it is submitted. The learned Single Judge after hearing both sides, accepted the contentions made by the first respondent relying on Shaji v. Ramachandran. (supra) and Aided Aided Higher Secondary School Teachers Association v. State Of Kerala, (supra). It was held that even if the post of Librarian is available as per Chapter XXXII, the appointment cannot be automatic. Sanction of the Director is necessary for making the appointment. The learned Judge noted that since it is mandatory to have a Library in a Higher Secondary School, the same cannot be manned without a Librarian and therefore, the Director was bound to sanction the post of Librarian and accordingly directed the Director to sanction the post of Librarian Gr. III, in which the first respondent could be accommodated. Feeling aggrieved by the above direction, the appellants have preferred this writ appeal.

    5. According to the appellants, the second respondent's school does not have a full-fledged library. When the appeal came up for admission, an inspection was conducted by the Deputy Director and it was found that there were only 720 books in the library. The Government have conducted a detailed study regarding the schools, their libraries and the financial commitment that may arise, if the post of Librarian is sanctioned in all the Higher Secondary schools in the State. Annexure 5 would show that the total financial commitment towards salary alone would come to Rs. 6,25,62,702/-% So, the Government have decided not to sanction any post of Librarian, but directed to put one of the H.S.S.T (Junior) having the minimum number of teaching periods to be in charge of the library. Such incumbent would be given some training on the running of the library in consultation with the Library Council. As incentive, such teacher will be given Rs. 250/- per month. The directions in this regard have been aiven as oer Annexure A1 order dated 20.4.2006 In view of the above position, it is not possible for the Government or the Director of Higher Secondary Education to sanction any post of Librarian, The financial position of the State does not permit the sanctioning of the post of Librarian, it is submitted. Therefore, the appellants prayed for setting aside the direction issued by this Court.

    6. We heard Smt Bindu learned Government Pleader for the appellants, Sri. M.V Bose for the first respondent and also the learned counsel, for the second respondent. We also had the benefit of hearing Sri. T.H Abdul Azeez and Sri Jacob Abraham, who appeared for the contesting respondents in the connected appeals. The learned Government Pleader reiterated the aforementioned contentions raised in the appeal memorandum, The learned counsel for the contesting respondents pointed out that, the post of Librarian is created by the K.E.R The Manager is the appointing authority. Moreover, it is obligatory to have a full-fledged Library for sanction of Higher Secondary course. If that be so, the Director is bound to sanction the post of Librarian. So, the learned Single Judge has rightly allowed the writ petition, it is submitted. They also relied on the aforementioned decisions of the Division Bench and Full Bench in [Shaji v. Ramachandran (supra) and Aided Aided Higher Secondary School Teachers Association v. State Of Kerala. (supra)]. in support of their submissions.

    7. Rule 3 of Chapter XXXII.K.E.R reads as follows:

    “3. The Kerala Aided Higher Secondary Education Service.— The service of every Aided Higher Secondary School shall consist of all or any of the following categories of posts as Director may sanction”.

    (emphasis supplied)

    8. After the above statement, the rule, enumerates various categories of posts, starting from Principal - Category I and ending with Category VIII - Part time Menial. So, from among the aforementioned categories of posts, the Director has been authorised by the Rules to sanction particular post/s, having regard to the requirements of the school concerned. The learned Single Judge after considering the aforementioned two decisions, held that creation of posts enumerated in Rule 3 is not automatic. Only the Director can sanction those posts. But, having regard to the existence of the Library and the same being one of the requirements for running a Higher Secondary Course, the learned Judge said that the Director cannot say that he will not sanction the post of Librarian, He has got a duty in this regard and therefore, the learned Single Judge directed to grant sanction for the post of Librarian. We agree with the finding of the learned Judge that sanctioning of the post is not automatic. Among the posts mentioned in Rule 3 of Chapter XXXII of the K.E.R in relation to each Higher Secondary School, the Director has got a discretion to sanction the posts having regard to its requirement, The power vested in the Director to sanction posts in the school is a power coupled with duty and it has to be exercised when circumstances warranting the exercise of that power are shown to exist and a person interested makes a motion. See, the concept of power coupled with duty explained by the Apex Court in Commissioner of Police v. Gordhandas Banji AIR 1952 SC 16 and Income Tax Officer v. Hirday Narain (1970) 2 SCC 355 : AIR 1971 SC 33, In both the decisions, the Apex Court, relying on the speech of Earl Cairns, L.C in the House of Lords in Julius v. Lord Bishop of Oxford. [1880 (5) AC 214], explained the concept of power coupled with duty.

    9. The power is the capacity vested in a public” authority to affect the rights of others, whereas, duty is an obligation to act in a particular manner. The duty vested in a public authority, will create a corresponding right on some other. In certain circumstances, having regard to the facts of the case, a power may become a power coupled with duty. As per the Rules, the Director of Higher Secondary Education has got the power to sanction the post of Principal in a Higher Secondary School, But, without the post of Principal, the school cannot function. So, it can be safely concluded that in regard to the post of Principal, the power of the Director is one coupled with duty, which has to be exercised, Likewise, in the case of Librarian also, it is for the Director to decide whether a post should be sanctioned or not. Going by the statutory scheme, we find no role for the Government in sanctioning of posts in Higher Secondary wing. There is no rule in Chapter XXXII. similar to Rule 14 of Chapter XXIII of the K.E.R, which enables the Government to extend the prohibition introduced by it for creation of posts in Government Schools to aided schools also. If, owing to financial constraints, the Government issue some directions to the Director, and the Director acts upon it, such decision of the Director would be ultra vires and unauthorised, because he will be acting under dictation and will be surrendering his power to act in his discretion, to the Government, which have no say in the matter as per the Rules. So, in this case, we are of the view that, whether sanction of the post of Librarian in the second respondent's school is justified or not, is a matter which the Director may decide independently. The contention of the appellants that the school is having only 720 books, is seriously disputed by the respondents. According to them there are more than 11,000 books and a full-fledged Library is functioning, justifying the creation of the post of Librarian in the school. The same is a seriously disputed point. In view of such, circumstances, we feel that it was not proper for the learned Single Judge to hold that the post of Librarian is liable to be created and direct the Director to do that. Normally, this Court will quash a wrong order and leave it to the authority to act in accordance with law. It is for the designated authority to take the decision. It is true, in extreme cases, as was held by the Apex Court in The Comptroller and Auditor General v. K.S Jagannathan (1986) 2 SCC 679 : AIR 1987 SC 537, the High Court under Article 226 can pass an order which the statutory authority could have passed, had it exercised the discretion vested in it properly. But, in this case, we find that there are no materials before this Court to come to the conclusion that, there was no other option for the Director but to sanction the post in the school. Though the learned Single Judge technically left the matter for the decision of the Director, practically, the Director has no other option but to sanction the post of Librarian, in view of the clear finding in favour of sanction of the post of Librarian Gr. III. In view of the above position, we set aside the direction in the judgment under appeal, to sanction the post of Librarian Grade ID in the second respondent's school. The second appellant is directed to consider the claim of the respondents herein for sanction of the post of Librarian Gr. III and take a decision in accordance with law, having regard to the students' strength, the number of books in the Library, the facilities in the Library etc. While taking the decision, the second appellant shall be uninfluenced by any view expressed by the first appellant. The second appellant need not personally inspect the school, but can cause the same to be done by some responsible officer under him. After giving an opportunity of being heard to the respondents herein, the 2nd appellant may take a finsl decision on sanctioning the post of Librarian, The second appellant shall complete this exercise within three months from the date of production of a copy of this judgment.

    10. The Writ Appeal is allowed as above.

    11. W.A Nos. 1137/09 and 1923/08:

    The first respondent in W.A No. 1137/09 is a Grade III Librarian, whereas the first respondent in WA No. 1923/08 is a Grade IV Librarian, It is ordered that the directions issued to the Director of Higher Secondary Education in W.A No. 2065/08 will govern these cases also. The Director shall take a fresh decision in these cases also within three months from the date of production of a copy of this judgment. The Writ Appeals are allowed as above.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Kerala & Another v. Saji T.M & Another
    (Jul 16, 2009)