Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 10(17) of the Mahatma Gandhi University Act, 1985. R. 5 of the said Rules
  • University Students' Code of Conduct Rules 2005
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • S. 10(17) of the Mahatma Gandhi University Act, 1985. R. 5 of the said Rules
  • University Students' Code of Conduct Rules 2005
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — K.S. Radhakrishnan, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ petition was filed by the Manager and Principal of S.N.M. College, Maliankara and the Principal of S.N.M. Institute of Management and Technology, Maliankara. The petitioners sought directions to the police to provide adequate protection to the life and property of students and staff, to prevent outsiders from entering the college campus, and to prevent respondents 3 to 7 from setting up student units or performing political activities within the college campus (including disrupting classes, threatening students to join unions, and otherwise engaging in agitation). The petitioners alleged that, despite this Court's earlier rulings and University rules banning political activity inside campus, members and leaders of student organisations (notably SFI, and attempts by KSU and ABVP) and outsiders were forcing organisation activity, threatening and manhandling students, and that police intervention was inadequate.

The matter proceeded before this Court against the background of earlier Kerala case law and University rules (Mahatma Gandhi University Students' Code of Conduct Rules, 2005), and the petition records events including complaints dated 25.07.2006 and subsequent incidents in July–August 2006 (including meetings allegedly forcefully conducted on 7.8.2006). Respondents 3–5 filed a counter affidavit denying disruption and asserting that SFI units and meetings have historically functioned with permission from Management. The Government Pleader described police action taken and a subsequent crime registration based on written complaint.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether student political activities and the setting up or functioning of student-union units within a college campus may be prohibited by college managements and educational institutions consistent with prior decisions of this Court and University rules.
  2. Whether the police have a duty to act, on receipt of complaints from Management or Principals, to prevent outsiders and student organisations from entering college campuses and conducting political activities in violation of court directions and University rules.
  3. What remedial steps the Court should direct where prior judgments and University rules banning political activities on campus are not being followed and where complaints of threats, manhandling and forced activities are made.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The college(s) are private aided (S.N.M. College) and self-financing (S.N.M. Institute of Management and Technology) educational institutions where political activities are banned by University rules and this Court's precedent.
  • Certain students claiming to be members of SFI, aided by outsiders (respondents 3 and 4), attempted to set up SFI units inside SNM College campus, threatened students (including new entrants) to join their union, and physically manhandled complainants.
  • Specific incidents were alleged: a complaint by a first-year student Febin M.V. of being threatened and manhandled on 25.07.2006; on 3.8.2006 an alleged attempt to hold a meeting in the auditorium; on 7.8.2006 outsiders allegedly forcefully conducted an SFI meeting in the auditorium; and continued attempts by other unions (KSU and ABVP) to force membership and disrupt classes.
  • The police were alleged to have been inactive or ineffective in enforcing this Court's directions and the University Conduct Rules, and in protecting students and college property.
  • Petitioners sought police protection and directions to prevent outsiders and student organisations from setting up and functioning within campus, and consequential reliefs including protection of movable and immovable property.

Respondents (3–5) — Counter-Affidavit

  • Affidavit sworn by the Taluk Secretary of SFI states that an SFI unit has been functioning in the campus from the institution's inception and that there has been no change in that scenario.
  • It was asserted that union meetings are conducted on campus as usual after seeking permission from Management, and that active politics existed from establishment of the institutions.
  • The affidavit further stated that SFI used to conduct meetings in the college auditorium after getting permission from Management.

State / Government Pleader

  • The Government Pleader reported that on 7.8.2006 a telephone message from the college reported trespass by outsiders; police reached the site immediately and initially no untoward incident was noticed.
  • Subsequently, a case was registered as Crime No. 326/06 under Ss. 143, 147, 447 read with S.149 IPC based on a written complaint; accused were arrested except one named Shiny, and statements were recorded from named students regarding manhandling.
  • The Government Pleader also stated that initially no cognizable offence was registered and that at the time of affidavit there was no law-and-order situation calling for police intervention.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sojan Francis v. M.G. University (2003 (2) KLT 582) The guidelines banning political activities within college campus and forbidding students from organising or attending meetings other than official ones are not designed to prohibit fundamental rights under Art. 19(1)(a) or (c) of the Constitution. The Court relied on this declaration to support the proposition that college managements and universities may regulate and restrict political activities within campus without infringing fundamental rights, and as background authority for upholding the University's conduct rules in the present dispute.
Kerala Students Union v. Sojan Francis (2004 (2) KLT 378) Upheld the rights of private managements and educational agencies to prohibit functioning of students' organizations within campus (directly or through member-students) and to prohibit strike, gherao, dharna, bandh, hartal etc. within the campus; recorded an affidavit of the Principal Secretary to the Education Department endorsing measures to prevent such activities. The Court treated this decision as authoritative and binding: it observed that, despite that decision and the University rules, some colleges were not following the directions. The Court reiterated that student unions have no right to set up units within campus and directed police to enforce the 2004 decision and University Conduct Rules.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded from established precedent and the University rules to the facts of non-compliance and police response:

  1. The Court began by recalling its earlier decisions. It noted that in Sojan Francis (2003) the Court declared that guidelines banning political activities on campus do not aim to prohibit students' fundamental rights under Art. 19(1)(a) or (c). It also recalled that in Kerala Students Union v. Sojan Francis (2004) the Court had upheld the rights of private managements and educational agencies to prohibit the functioning of students' organizations on campus and to forbid strikes, gherao, dharna and similar agitation.
  2. The Court then set out the relevant University regulation: Mahatma Gandhi University Students' Code of Conduct Rules, 2005, framed under S.10(17) of the Mahatma Gandhi University Act, 1985, specifically focusing on Rule 5 which prohibits political activity inside the campus and prescribes disciplinary consequences for organising or participating in political gatherings, strikes, dharnas, gherao, shouting slogans and obstructing the ordinary functioning of institutions.
  3. Applying that legal framework to the factual record before it, the Court summarized the petitioners' allegations of repeated attempts by SFI members and outsiders to enter the college, coerce students, and hold meetings despite the ban; it recited specific incidents (complaint by Febin M.V., alleged meeting on 7.8.2006, and the claimed police inaction).
  4. The Court also considered the counter-affidavit of respondents 3–5 claiming historical functioning of SFI units and that meetings were conducted with Management permission, and the Government Pleader's account of police response and registration of Crime No. 326/06 under relevant provisions of the IPC.
  5. On the basis of these materials, the Court concluded that although its prior rulings and the University rules clearly entitle managements to prohibit political activities and have the police enforce that prohibition, those directions were not being followed in some colleges (including the present case). The Court emphasized the duty of the police to act on complaints from Management or Principals to ensure that student organisations are kept away from the campus when they act in violation of the judgments and the Conduct Rules.
  6. The Court made it explicit that Students Unions (including SFI and others) have no right to set up their units within the college campus in face of the binding judgment and the Rules. It directed that, on receiving complaints from managements or principals, police officials should avert such attempts and, in default, the management may initiate contempt of court proceedings.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Writ Petition is disposed of with directions to ensure compliance with this Court's earlier decision and the University's Conduct Rules.

Direct consequences ordered by the Court (as recorded in the opinion):

  • The Court directed the Director General of Police (DGP), Kerala State, to ensure that the judgment in Kerala Students Union v. Sojan Francis (2004 (2) KLT 378) and the Mahatma Gandhi University Conduct Rules are scrupulously followed.
  • Respondents 1 and 2 (police authorities at the relevant level) were directed to give adequate and effective protection to the petitioners as and when requested.
  • The Court warned that managements may approach police where unions attempt prohibited activity and, if police fail to avert such attempts, appropriate action (including contempt proceedings) would follow.

Broader implications: The opinion primarily enforces existing precedent and University rules; it does not purport to lay down a new rule of law beyond affirming that prior decisions and the Conduct Rules must be followed and that police have a duty to act on management complaints.

Disposition: Writ Petition disposed of with directions as above; copy of judgment to be communicated to the Director General of Police, Kerala State, Trivandrum for appropriate follow up action.

    S.N.M College v. S.I Of Police

    The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

    K.S Radhakrishnan, J.:— This court in Sojan Francis v. M.G University (2003 (2) KLT 582) declared that the guidelines banning political activities within the college campus and forbidding the students from organising or attending meetings other than the official ones within the campus is not designed to prohibit any of the fundamental rights of the students guaranteed under Art. 19(1)(a) or (c) of the Constitution of India. Later after hearing all the students organisations of the State like Students Federation of India (SFI), Kerala Students Union (KSU), Akhila Bharathiya Vidyarthi Parishat (ABVP) etc., this court in Kerala Students Union v. Sojan Francis (2004 (2) KLT 378) upheld the rights of the private managements and the educational agencies in prohibiting the functioning of students organizations like SFI, KSU, ABVT etc. within the campus either directly or through their member-students and also the prohibition of strike, gherao, dharna, bandh, hartal etc. within the campus either directly or through their member-students. This court had recorded the affidavit filed by the Principal Secretary to the Education Department and stated as follows:

    “Measures suggested by the State Government are to be welcomed while upholding the right of the Managements to stall organizational activities of students organizations like SFI, ABVP, KSU etc. directly or through their member students within the campus. Strike, dharna, gherao etc. indulged in by the students within the campus can also be prevented and State Government and the Universities have got a legal obligation to protect the rights of not only the Management, Principals and the teaching faculty of the affiliating colleges but also that of Government owned colleges and educational institutions and to take appropriate measures to enforce those rights.”

    2. This court later took judicial notice of the fact that some of the Universities and affiliated colleges are strictly following the directions of this court and few others are not. One of such cases is before us for determination. This Writ Petition has been preferred by the Manager of S.N.M College, Maliankara and its Principal so also the Principal of S.N.M Institute of Management and Technology, Maliankara for a direction to the police to give adequate protection to the life and property of the students and staff of the colleges and to render necessary assistance to prevent outsiders from entering the college campus and also to prevent the attempt of the respondents 3 to 7 to set up their respective units or perform any kind of political activity within the college campus including disrupting of classes by way of agitation and threatening the students to join their respective unions and also for a direction to give adequate protection to the movable and immovable properties of the colleges and also for other consequential reliefs.

    3. S.N.M College, Maliankara, a private aided college, is affiliated to M.G University and S.N.M Institute of Management and Technology, Maliankara is a self financing Engineering college owned by the above mentioned educational agency. Political activities by the students organizations are banned in the college campus. Following the decision of this court in Sojan Francis' case, supra (2003 (2) KLT 582), Mahatma Gandhi University has framed Mahatma Gandhi University Students' Code of Conduct Rules 2005 in exercise of the powers conferred under S. 10(17) of the Mahatma Gandhi University Act, 1985. R. 5 of the said Rules reads as follows:

    5. Prohibition on political activity inside the campus.

    (a) No student of a college shall get himself involved in any political activity by himself or abet the said activity to be carried on by fellow students inside the campus in any manner whatsoever and any such activity is hereby banned inside the campus.

    (b) Taking part in any political activity by organizing students or to cause gatherings inside the college campus for the purpose of doing any activities as defined in R. 4(6) shall constitute serious indiscipline. Every member of such a gathering shall be individually liable and responsible for the gross indiscipline in this regard and the Principal shall have the power to take disciplinary action against students who indulge in the aforesaid activities.

    (c) It shall constitute gross indiscipline to call for and appeal to strike based on policies and ideologies that may be preached by the political parties or their sister organizations or students wings. The participants in the strike as aforesaid shall be dealt with by the disciplinary authority and they shall be imposed appropriate punishment as provided in these rules.

    (d) No student of a college shall stage or indulge in any activity like Dharna, Gherao, obstructing entry to and from any class room, office, hall or other places inside the campus and such activities shall be traded as misconduct.

    (c) No student shall shout slogans inside the class rooms, office or any other place inside the campus and obstruct and interfere or to cause disturbance and nuisance to the ordinary functioning of the institution. These activities shall be treated as misconduct.

    4. Petitioners submit that in spite of the Bench decision of this court and in spite of the Conduct Rules framed by the University, certain students claiming to be members of the SFI attempted to start their unit within the SNM College campus with the aid of outsiders like respondents 3 and 4 during the current academic year. Petitioners allege that respondents 3 and 4 have come to the college and threatened various students including new comers to join their unit. Politics was banned in S.N.M College, Maliankara in the year 2004 and there was no political activities in S.N.M Institute of Management and Technology. But still the S.F.I is trying to set up their unit within the campus. Following the footsteps of SFI members of other Unions like KSU and ABVP have also started forceful inclusion of students into their fold. Petitioners allege that attempts are being made with the active connivance of outsiders who owe allegiance to their respective parent political parties.

    5. The lecturer in charge of Principal of S.N.M College on 26.7.2006 received a complaint from a first year B.A Economics student by name Febin M.V alleging that on 25.07.2006 he was threatened and manhandled by certain students claiming to be the members of SFI. Threat was made because of his reluctance to join their Union. Since complaint was brought to the knowledge of the Principal in-charge, the complainant and his friends were manhandled by certain outsiders under the leadership of the third respondent who claimed to be the Taluk Secretary of S.F.I Principal in-charge forwarded the complaint to the first respondent and police came to the scene, but instead of taking action against the intruders into the college as well as to stall the attempts made by the students organization they were trying to compromise the issue without enforcing the judgments of this court and the rules framed by the University. Police was totally inactive and took no steps to uphold the direction given by this court and the rules framed by the Mahatma Gandhi University.

    6. The third respondent on 2.8.2006 the third respondent claiming to be the Taluk Secretary of SFI met the second petitioner and informed that his Union would conduct a meeting in the college auditorium during lunch break on 3.8.2006 Second respondent did not accede to that request and immediately forwarded a complaint to the police intimating the threat from the third respondent. No effective action was taken by the police. The Principal again on 4.8.2006 preferred a written complaint to the first respondent requesting him to take action against outsiders who illegally entered the college. Due to the constant threat from respondents 3 to 5, the complainant Febin M.V obtained T.C from the college and left the college. Petitioners further submit that on 7.8.2006 certain outsiders under the leadership of respondents 3 and 4 came to the college during lunch break and forcefully conducted a meeting of SFI in the college auditorium after closing the doors of the auditorium from behind. The matter was immediately reported to the police by the second petitioner but the police came long after the meeting was over. Due to the forceful attempt of respondents 3 to 5 to set up their unit in the college, respondents 6 and 7 are also making similar attempts to set up their respective units in the college in gross violation of the judgment of this court and the rules framed by the University. Petitioners further submit that due to the high handedness and illegal activities of the members of SFI, outsiders claiming to be the leaders of KSU and AB VR, are illegally conducting demonstrations within the college campus and disrupting classes.

    7. Counter affidavit has been filed on behalf of respondents 3 to 5. Affidavit is sworn to by the Taluk Secretary of the SFI. It is stated in paragraph 3 that the unit of the SFI is functioning in the campus from the very beginning of the Institution itself and there has been no change in the scenario till now with regard to the functioning of the organization. It is also stated that the Union meetings are conducted in the campus as usual after seeking permission from the Management. Further it is stated that active politics have been there from the very establishment of both the institutions. Further it is stated that SFI used to conduct their meeting in the college auditorium and the meetings are conducted after getting permission from the Management. Though notice was received no counter affidavit has been filed by the respondents 6 and 7.

    8. Learned Government Pleader stated that on 7.8.2006 a telephone message was received from the college stating that outsiders had trespassed into the college and the police reached the place immediately but no untoward incident was noticed. Later a case was registered as crime No. 326/06 under Ss. 143, 147, 447 read with S. 149 I.P.C on the basis of the written complaint and the accused was arrested except one Shiny. Statement was also recorded from Jaison, final year B.A and Sujith, 2nd year B.Sc regarding manhandling. Since the offence was non-cognizable no crime was registered. It is also stated that now there is no law and order situation for police intervention.

    9. We find in spite of the declaration of law laid down by this court in Sojan Francis' case, supra that private managements and educational institutions have the right to prohibit political activities within the college campus and forbid students from organizing or attending meetings other than the official ones, those directions are not being followed in some of the colleges just like in the present case. Students organizations even after the guidelines laid down by this court in Sojan Francis's case, supra, are still creating disturbances in the college campus. We make it clear as and when complaint is received from the Management or Principal of an educational Institution in the State the police has got a duty to act and see that those students organization be kept away from the college campus. Students Unions have no right to set up their units within the college campus. Students Federation of India or other Students Unions have no right to start their Union activities within the college campus since they are bound by the judgment of this court. If the Union starts any such activities within the college campus in violation of the decision of this court reported in 2004 (2) KLT 378 and the rules framed by the University, the Management can approach the police officials who will see that such attempts are averted failing which appropriate action would be taken for contempt of court proceedings.

    10. This Writ Petition is disposed of with a direction to the Director General of Police to see that the judgment of this court in Kerala Students Union v. Sojan Francis (2004 (2) KLT 378) and the Conduct Rules framed by the M.G University are scrupulously followed.

    11. Respondents 1 and 2 would give adequate and effective protection to the petitioners as and when requested.

    12. Communicate a copy of this judgment to the Director General of Police, Kerala State, Trivandrum for appropriate follow up action.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S.N.M College v. S.I Of Police
    (Dec 15, 2006)