Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • 6 of Kerala Abkari Shops (Disposal in Auction) Rules (hereinafter referred to as the Rules). Sub-r. (7) of R. 6 of the Rules
  • S. 8 or S. 15C or S. 55 or S. 55B or S. 56A or S. 57 or S. 58 or S. 58A or S. 58B of this Act
  • S. 320 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Central Act 45 of 1860).(2)
  • Code of Criminal procedure, 1973 (Central Act 2 of 1974),
  • Abkari Act by Amendment Act No. 21 of 1984
  • EVIDENCE ACT 1872
  • S. 32 of the Kerala Abkari Act (Act
  • case.3. S. 57A of the Abkari Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • 6 of Kerala Abkari Shops (Disposal in Auction) Rules (hereinafter referred to as the Rules). Sub-r. (7) of R. 6 of the Rules
  • S. 8 or S. 15C or S. 55 or S. 55B or S. 56A or S. 57 or S. 58 or S. 58A or S. 58B of this Act
  • S. 320 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Central Act 45 of 1860).(2)
  • Code of Criminal procedure, 1973 (Central Act 2 of 1974),
  • Abkari Act by Amendment Act No. 21 of 1984
  • EVIDENCE ACT 1872
  • S. 32 of the Kerala Abkari Act (Act
  • case.3. S. 57A of the Abkari Act
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (J.B. Koshy, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are accused in Crime No. 2/96 of the Alathur Excise Range (Judicial First Class Magistrate's Court, Alathur). They worked at toddy shop No. 78/96-97 as a salesman, power of attorney holder and licensee. During an inspection samples of toddy taken from the shop were analysed and found to contain Chloral Hydrate (a hypnotic drug) and were declared unfit for human consumption. The Excise Officers concluded an offence under Section 57A of the Kerala Abkari Act and filed Annexure I report before the Magistrate. The petitioners challenged those proceedings on the ground that, prior to amendments effected in 1997, Abkari Officers lacked procedural power to conduct the searches and file reports for offences under S.57A.

The opinion considers the legal question whether Abkari Officers could, prior to the 1997 amendment, lawfully file complaints when samples taken during inspections under Section 32 (rather than searches under Section 31) were found adulterated. The High Court reviewed relevant statutory provisions, earlier High Court decisions (including Crl. M.C No. 1381/96 and connected matters), and the Supreme Court decision in Suraj v. Excise Inspector (reported in 2001 (1) KLT 169 SC). The petition seeking quashing of the Annexure I report was dismissed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, before amendment of the Abkari Act by Act No. 16 of 1997, Abkari Officers had power to file complaints based on samples taken during inspections conducted under Section 32 when such samples were found to be adulterated (i.e., whether procedural defects prior to 1997 made prosecutions under S.57A unavailable).
  2. Whether entry, inspection, sample collection and seizure carried out under Section 32 (as distinct from Section 31) required the inspecting officer to have prior reason to believe that a specified offence listed in Section 31 had been committed.
  3. Whether the Annexure I report filed by the Excise Inspector should be set aside at an initial stage (by quashing proceedings) where the third petitioner (the licensee) was not present during the inspection and where presumptions or absolute liabilities against licensees were introduced only after the inspection.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • Before the amendment of Section 31 (effective 3.6.1997), Abkari Officers could lawfully conduct searches without warrant only when they had reason to believe that one of the specific offences enumerated in Section 31 had been committed; S.57A was not among those listed and therefore procedural authority to investigate or file reports under S.57A did not exist.
  • Sections 31 and 34 (and S.50 as then worded) did not enable investigation or filing of complaints for S.57A prior to their amendment in 1997; consequently, prosecutions under S.57A arising from the period between its insertion in 1984 and the 1997 amendments were said to be impermissible.
  • Insofar as sample collection and searches were said to be undertaken under S.32 in this case, the petitioners contended the first limb (reason to believe a specified offence) was not satisfied and therefore the entry/search and consequent proceedings were illegal.
  • As to the third petitioner (the licensee) who was not present, the petitioners argued that presumptions and absolute liability against licensees were incorporated after the inspection; hence, at least the case against the absent licensee should be dropped at this stage.

Respondent / State's Arguments (as presented by the Additional Director General of Prosecutions)

  • The Supreme Court in Suraj v. Excise Inspector addressed the power of entry and search under Section 31 (unamended), and held that if an Excise Inspector had reason to believe an offence under the Act was committed, entry and search could be conducted and, upon valid entry and search, material suggesting commission of other offences (including S.57A) could form the basis of a report under Section 50.
  • The present case involved inspection under Section 32 (not Section 31). Section 32 authorises routine entry and inspection of licensed manufacturing or selling premises (when open) and permits testing, measurement and weighing of materials and liquor; it is not conditioned on the officer having reason to believe that a specified offence from the list in S.31 has occurred.
  • Rules (Kerala Abkari Shops (Disposal in Auction) Rules — R.6(7)) also empower authorised officers to take possession of toddy/foreign liquor found unfit for consumption or suspected to have been tampered with, and to seize and destroy such liquor. Section 27 requires licensed persons to submit to testing as required by the Abkari Officer.
  • Where an inspection is lawfully conducted under Section 32 and samples reveal an offence, the authorised Abkari Officer can file a report under Section 50 and the Magistrate will proceed under the Code of Criminal Procedure. Questions of the licensee's personal culpability (whether he mixed, permitted mixing, or omitted precautions) are matters to be determined at trial on evidence, not at the initial stage of quashing the complaint.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Suraj v. Excise Inspector, 2001 (1) KLT 169 SC The Supreme Court held that (a) prior to the 1997 amendments the position was largely the same save for specific aspects, (b) amendments to Ss.31 & 50 and insertion of S.50A placed the matter beyond controversy, and (c) if an Excise Inspector validly entered and searched under unamended S.31 and found material suggestive of other offences, he could file a report for those offences; if the first limb (reason to believe specified offences) was not established, the entry/search and subsequent prosecution would be illegal. The High Court relied on Suraj to reject the petitioners' contention that prosecutions under S.57A were impossible before the 1997 amendments, and to explain that a valid inspection/search (whether under S.31 or, as here, under S.32) can give rise to a report under S.50 if material of offence is found; the Court emphasised that factual questions about the officer's belief must be determined at trial.
State of Kerala v. Balakrishnan, 1991 (2) KLT 323 Authority on procedure to be followed before committing accused to Sessions — specifically, that the proviso to S.200(2) Cr.P.C. should be complied with (as applied in the context of excise matters). The High Court noted it had followed this decision in an earlier High Court judgment to require compliance with the relevant Cr.P.C. proviso when committing accused to Sessions. The Court observed that where the offence is exclusively triable by the Sessions Court, the Magistrate must call and examine witnesses as contemplated by the proviso to S.200(2) Cr.P.C.
Crl. M.C No. 1381/96 and connected cases (High Court judgment dated 19.5.1998) Held that a report by an Abkari Inspector can be treated as a complaint; upon receipt the Magistrate shall inquire into the offence as if a complaint had been made under the Code of Criminal Procedure; the report by a public servant acting in discharge of duty may dispense with oral examination of complainant/witnesses in certain circumstances. The Court relied on this High Court decision to reject the petitioners' argument that S.50 could not be invoked prior to its substitution in 1997 and to explain the procedural route by which an Abkari Inspector's report triggers Magistrate proceedings.
State of Kerala, 2002 (1) KLT 10 (Division Bench) Held that after amendment of S.50 and introduction of S.50A it is not necessary, in cases to be committed to Sessions, for a Magistrate to hold an enquiry as contemplated by the proviso to S.202(2) Cr.P.C., and that such course is possible even if proceedings were initiated before the introduction of S.50A. The High Court noted this Division Bench decision to support the view that procedural amendments do not preclude continuing proceedings initiated earlier and that the amendment clarified procedural powers without retrospectively invalidating earlier initiated proceedings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded in these principal steps, based strictly on the material and reasoning set out in the opinion:

  1. Statutory differentiation between S.31 and S.32: The Court emphasised that Section 31 (unamended, pre-3.6.1997) conferred powers of entry and search in relation to places where the officer had reason to believe that certain specified offences (a listed group of sections) had been committed. By contrast, Section 32 authorises entry and inspection of licensed premises (manufacturing or selling premises) while they are open and permits examination, testing and measurement of materials and liquor found there. Section 32 is aimed at routine inspection of licensed premises and does not contain the same pre-condition (reason to believe a specified offence) that is in the first limb of S.31.
  2. Effect of earlier and later amendments: Although Section 57A was inserted in 1984 (and created substantive offences), the petitioners argued that lack of procedural provisions in Ss.31/34/50 (until amended in 1997) made prosecutions for S.57A impossible. The Court reviewed prior High Court rulings and the Supreme Court's decision in Suraj, and concluded that the position prior to 1997 was not such as to render prosecutions under S.57A impossible. The 1997 amendments clarified and placed beyond controversy the procedural powers, but did not mean that prosecutions before that date were necessarily invalid.
  3. Validity of inspections under Section 32: Because the present inspection was conducted under S.32 (licensed premises while open) and not under S.31, the Court held that there was no statutory precondition requiring the authorised officer to have formed an opinion that a specified offence in S.31 had already been committed. In routine inspections authorised by S.32 the officer may take samples and, if tests reveal offences (such as under S.57A), the officer is authorised to file a report under S.50 to the competent Magistrate.
  4. Secondary statutory and rules support: The Court relied on Rule 6(7) of the Kerala Abkari Shops (Disposal in Auction) Rules which authorises inspection officers to take possession of toddy or foreign liquor found unfit for consumption or suspected of being tampered with, and to seize/destroy such liquor. Section 27 of the Act requires the licensee to submit to testing as required by the Abkari Officer. These provisions support the view that sampling and seizure in licensed premises during inspection are within the statutory scheme.
  5. Role of S.50 and Magistrate procedure: Once an Abkari Officer files a report under S.50, the Magistrate is to inquire into the offence as if a complaint had been made under the Code of Criminal Procedure; certain procedural steps (for offences triable exclusively by Sessions) are governed by provisos to Cr.P.C. and were previously considered in High Court and Supreme Court authorities. The Court observed that procedural questions about the competence of a Magistrate or compliance with Cr.P.C. provisions are matters for appropriate handling by the Magistrate and, where necessary, for commitment to Sessions.
  6. Concerning the third petitioner (licensee not present): The Court observed that the culpability elements in S.57A (e.g., "whoever mixes or permits to be mixed..." and "whoever omits to take reasonable precautions...") require factual determination on evidence. Whether the licensee permitted mixing or omitted precautions must be decided at trial; it is not proper to dispose of those issues at the initial stage by quashing the report.
  7. Conclusion on illegality/contention: Given the above, the Court concluded that where an inspection under S.32 is lawfully conducted and samples are found to reveal offences, filing a report under S.50 is within the statutory scheme and there was no ground to interfere with the Annexure I report at this stage.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The Criminal Miscellaneous Petition is dismissed; the Annexure I report sent by the Excise Inspector to the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Alathur is not set aside.

Immediate implications for the parties:

  • The proceedings initiated by the Annexure I report will continue; the Magistrate is to deal with the matter according to the Code of Criminal Procedure and, if necessary, commit the case for trial or take other procedural steps required by law.
  • Questions of individual culpability — for example whether the licensee permitted the mixing or omitted reasonable precautions — are factual matters to be determined at trial; they are not resolved by the High Court at the preliminary stage of a petition to quash.

Broader legal implications (as stated or relied upon in the opinion):

  • The decision aligns with prior High Court and Supreme Court pronouncements (notably Suraj v. Excise Inspector) that procedural amendments effected in 1997 clarified and confirmed powers already existing in practice, and that a valid entry/inspection can give rise to a report under S.50 if material of an offence is found.
  • The Court reiterated the general interpretive principle that statutes should, where possible, be construed so as to be effective and workable rather than rendered futile; in this context, the Court rejected a construction that would nullify the substantive effect of S.57A pending procedural amendments.

The opinion does not set aside the Annexure I report or grant the petitioners' request to quash the proceedings; it applies existing precedents and statutory provisions to uphold the legality of inspection under S.32 and the filing of the report under S.50.

    Prabhakaran v. Excise Inspector

    J.B Koshy, J.:— Power of Abkari Officers to file complaints when samples taken during inspection conducted under S. 32 of the Kerala Abkari Act (Act No. 1 of 1077) are found to be adulterated with noxious substances before amendment of the Act by Act No. 16 of 1997 is the question to be considered in this case. A contention was raised by the petitioners that in view of the observations made by the Apex Court in Suraj v. Excise Inspector (2001 (1) KLT 169 SC), entire proceedings are illegal since power of the Abkari Officers under S. 32 was not considered by the Supreme Court in the above decision and one of us (K. Padmanabhan Nair, J.) sitting in single referred the matter to the Division Bench. For understanding the question, we may now refer the facts of the case first.

    2. Petitioners are the accused in Crime No. 2/96 of Alathur Excise Range on the file of the Judicial First Class Magistrate's Court, Alathur. They are Salesman, Power of Attorney Holder and licensee respectively of toddy shop No. 78/96-97 of Alathur range. Samples of toddy was taken from their shop and on analysis it was found that it contained Chloral Hydrate, a hypnotic drug, and it was unfit for human consumption. Excise Officers came to the conclusion that offence under S. 57A of the Abkari Act (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) was attracted and hence Annexure I report was filed before the Magistrate's Court and the above is challenged in this case.

    3. S. 57A of the Abkari Act is as follows:

    “57A. For adulteration of liquor or intoxicating drug with noxious substances, etc.:

    (i) Whoever mixes or permits to be mixed any noxious substance or any substance which is likely to endanger human life or to cause grievous hurt to human beings, with any liquof or intoxicating drug shall, on conviction, be punishable—

    (ii) if, as a result of such act, grievous hurt is caused to any person, with imprisonment fora term which shall not be less than two years but which may extend to imprisonment for life and with fine which may extend to fifty thousand rupees; (ii) if, as a result of such act, death is caused to any person, with death or imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than two years but which may extend to imprisonment for life and with fine which may extend to fifty thousand rupees;

    (iii) in any other case, with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than one year, but which may extend to ten years, and with fine which may extend to twenty five thousand rupees.

    Explanation: For the purpose of this Section and S. 57B, the expression ‘grievous hurt’ shall have the same meaning as in S. 320 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Central Act 45 of 1860).

    (2) Whoever omits to take reasonable precautions to prevent the mixing of any noxious substance or any substance which is likely to endanger human life or to cause grievous hurt to human beings, with any liquor or intoxicating drug shall, on conviction, be punishable,—

    (i) if as a result of such omission, grievous hurt is caused to any person, with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than two years but which may extend to imprisonment for life, and with fine which may extend to fifty thousand rupees;

    (ii) if as a result of such omission, death is caused to any person, with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than three years but which may extend to imprisonment for life, and with fine which may extend to fifty thousand rupees;

    (iii) in any other case, with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than one year, but which may extend to ten years, and with fine which may extend to twenty five thousand rupees.

    (3) Whoever possesses any liquor or intoxicating drug in which any substance referred to in sub-s. (1) is mixed, knowing that such substance is mixed with such liquor or intoxicating drug shall, on conviction, be punishable with imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than one year but which may extend to ten years, and with fine which may extend to twenty-five thousand rupees.

    (4) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of Criminal procedure, 1973 (Central Act 2 of 1974), no person accused or convicted of an offence under sub-s. (1) or sub-s. (3) shall, if in custody, be released on bail or on his own bond, unless—

    (a) the prosecution has been given an opportunity to oppose the application for such release, and

    (b) where the prosecution opposes the application, the court is satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for believing that he is not guilty of such offence.

    (5) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (1 of 1872)

    (a) where a person is prosecuted for an offence under sub-s. (1) or sub-s. (2), the burden of proving that he has not mixed or permitted to be mixed or, as the case may be, omitted to take reasonable predictions to prevent the mixing of, any substance referred to in that sub-section with any liquor or intoxicating drug shall be on him;

    (b) Where a person is prosecuted for an offence under sub-s. (3) for being in possession of any liquor or intoxicating drug in which any substance referred to in sub-s. (1) is mixed, the burden of proving that he did not know that such substance was mixed with such liquor or intoxicating drug shall be on him.”

    4. The above section was inserted in the Abkari Act by Amendment Act No. 21 of 1984 with effect from 3.12.1984

    5. Main contention of the petitioners is that during the relevant time, officers of Excise Department had power only to conduct search if offence specified in S. 31 of the Act are committed or alleged to be committed and S. 57A was not mentioned during the relevant time till S. 31 of the Act was amended with effect from 3.6.1997 During the relevant time (before 3.6.1997), S. 31 of the Act was as follows:

    “31. Power to certain Abkari and police officers to search houses etc without warrant: Whenever the Commissioner of Excise or any Abkari Officer not below such ranks may be specified by the Government in this behalf or any Police Officer not below the rank of Sub Inspector or a Police Station Officer, has reason to believe that an offence under S. 8 or S. 15C or S. 55 or S. 55B or S. 56A or S. 57 or S. 58 or S. 58A or S. 58B of this Act has been committed and that the delay occasioned by obtaining a search warrant under the preceding section will prevent the execution thereof, he may, after recording his reasons and the grounds of his belief at any time by day or night, enter and search any place and may seize anything found therein which he has reason to believe to be liable to confiscation under this Act and may detain and search and, if he thinks proper, arrest any person found in such place whom he has reason to believe to be guilty of any offence under this Act.

    Provided that every person arrested under this section shall be admitted to bail by such officer as aforesaid if sufficient bail be tendered for his appearance either before a Magistrate or before an Abkari Inspector as the case may be”.

    6. S. 34 of the Act also specifically gives power to the Abkari Officer for arrest and seizure only for the offences committed under Ss. 8, 15C, 55, 55B, 56A, 57, 58, 58A and 58B of the Act. S. 57A was not mentioned. The above section was also amended only with effect from 3.6.1997 It is the contention of the petitioners that search and seizure made under Ss. 31 and 34 are illegal when the offence alleged is S. 57A. In effect, even though S. 57 was enacted in 1984, no action was possible for convicting a person under the above Section till 3.6.1997 for want of procedural formalities.

    7. Similar contentions were repelled by this Court in Crl. M.C No. 1381 of 1986 and connected cases. This Court held as follows:

    “The latter part of S. 31 empowers the Abkari Officers to search any place and seize anything found therein which he has reason to believe to be liable to confiscation under the Act and may detain and search and, if he thinks proper, arrest any person found in such place whom he has reason to believe to be guilty of any offence under the Act.”

    8. Thereafter, the Court held that when Abkari Inspector has reason to believe that an offence under the Act is committed, he shall forward a report to the Magistrate and thereupon the Magistrate shall inquire into the offence as if the complaint had been made before him as prescribed in the Code of Criminal Procedure. The Magistrate of the first class is empowered to take cognizane of the offence upon receiving the complaint. When the complaint is received, the Magistrate taking cognizance of the offence shall examine upon oath the complainant and his witnesses present. But, if the complaint is made in writing, the Magistrate need not examine the complainant and his witnesses if he is a public servant acting or purporting to act in the discharge of his official duties or the court has made the complaint. The report filed by the Excise Inspector can be treated as a complaint in which case the Excise Inspector being a public servant acting in the discharge of his official duties, the Court is not obliged to examine the complainant and his witnesses. But, if the offence is exclusively triable by the Court of Sessions, he shall call upon the complainant to produce witnesses and examine them on oath as provided in the proviso to S. 200(2) Cr. P.C This is in terms of S. 50 of the Act. S. 50 of the Act during the relevant time was as follows:

    “50. Report of Abkari Inspector gives jurisdiction to a competent Magistrate:— When an Abkari Inspector forwards in custody any person accused of an offence under this Act to the Magistrate having jurisdiction to try the case or admits any such person to bail to appear before such Magistrate such officer shall also forward to such Magistrate a report setting forth the name of the accused person and the nature of the offence with which he is charged and the names of the persons who appear to be acquainted with the circumstances of the case, and shall send to such Magistrate any article which it may be necessary to produce before him. Upon receipt of such report the Magistrate shall inquire into such offence and try the person accused thereof in like manner as if complaint had been made before him as prescribed in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898.”

    9. It is contended by the counsel for the petitioners that only under S. 50, a report can be filed only when the Magistrate has jurisdiction to try the case and for offence under S. 57A, the Magistrate can only commit and cannot try and, therefore, S. 50 is also not applicable before S. 50 was substituted by Act No. 16/97 with effect from 3.6.1997 Therefore, prosecution for offences under S. 57A is not possible on the basis of a report of the Abkari Officer under S. 50 of the Act. In other words, contention of the petitioners was that even though S. 57A of the Act was introduced in the Abkari Act from 1984, no action was possible under S. 57A and in the absence of enabling procedural provisions till Ss. 31, 34 and 50 were amended by Amendment Act No. 16/97. In other words, according to the petitioners, no person could be convicted under S. 57A of the Act notwithstanding its insertion by Amendment Act No. 21/84 with effect from 3.12.1984 till procedural sections were amended in 1997 and cases booked during that period cannot be tried at all. This contention was also not accepted by this Court in the judgment dated 19.5.1998 in Crl. M.C 1381/96 and connected cases. With regard to the argument based on S. 50 of the Act and competence of the Magistrate to try the offence, this Court observed as follows:

    “6. When an Abkari Inspector has reason to believe that an offence under the Act is committed, he shall forward a report to the Magistrate setting forth the name of the accused person and the nature of the offence with which he is charged and the names of the persons who appear to be acquainted with the circumstances of the case, and shall send to such Magistrate any article which may be necessary to produce before him. In such event, the Magistrate shall inquire into the offence as if the complaint had been made before him as prescribed in the Code of Criminal Procedure. The Magistrate of the first class is empowered to take cognizance of the offence upon receiving the complaint which constitute an offence. When the complaint is received, the Magistrate taking cognizance of the offence shall examine upon oath the complainant and his witnesses present. But, if the complaint is made in writing, the Magistrate need not examine the complainant and his witnesses if he is a public servant acting or purporting to act in the discharge of his official duties or the court has made the complaint. The report filed by the Excise Inspector can be treated as a complaint in which case the Excise Inspector being a public servant acting in the discharge of his official duties, the court is not obliged to examine the complainant and his witnesses. But, as the offence is exclusively triable by the Court of Sessions, he shall call upon the complainant to produce witnesses and examine them on oath as provided in the proviso to S. 200(2) Cr. P.C”

    10. In the above decision, this Court also followed the decision reported in State of Kerala v. Balakrishnan (1991 (2) KLT 323) and held that, in such cases, before committing the accused to the Sessions, proviso to S. 200(2) Cr. P.C should be complied with. Appeals filed from the decision of the learned Single Judge in Crl. M.C No. 1381/96 and connected cases were dismissed by the Supreme Court in Suraj v. Excise Inspector (2001 (1) KLT 169 SC). It is not disputed that after the amendment in 1997, specific provisions enabling Abkari officers to investigate and file complaint for offences under S. 57A was incorporated. After considering the various provisions, the Supreme Court held as follows:

    “The above examination of the relevant provisions demonstrates that before amendment of the aforesaid provision in 1997, the position was much the same except to the extent indicated above. The amendment of Ss. 31 and 50 and insertion of S. 50A has not changed the law but has placed the matter beyond controversy. In this view of the matter, the contentions that the offence under S. 57A could not have been tried before June, 1997 for want of machinery under Act and allowing the trial to proceed after the said date would amount to giving retrospective effect to S. 50A in the absence of specific provision to that effect, have to fail as being untenable.”

    11. We also note that a Division Bench of this Court in State of Kerala (2002 (1) KLT 10) held that in view of the amendment of S. 50 and introduction of S. 50A, it is not necessary in a case to be committed to a Court of Sessions, for a Magistrate to hold an enquiry as contemplated by the proviso to S. 202(2) Cr. P.C and that will be possible even if the proceedings were initiated before the introduction of S. 50A.

    12. If the interpretation suggested by the petitioners is accepted, implementation of S. 57 A will not be possible meaning thereby legislature achieved nothing by insertion of S. 57A in the Act Of course, by subsequent amendment, legislature has clearly made out procedural guidelines to avoid any possible hindrance in implementing S. 57A. The Courts strongly lean against the construction which reduces the Statute to a futility. As far as possible, statutory provision will be construed by Courts so as to make it effective, operative and workable. An interpretation which will defeat the intention of the legislature cannot be favoured by the Court. Purpose of legislation, object of enacting a provision etc. cannot be lost sight of. General presumption in favour of validity of a Statute also indicate that legislature will enact a provision for the purpose of getting at result and not in vain. Court has to avoid a construction which will make it unworkable. In the absence of substantial constitutional or legal hurdles and procedural obstacles, as far as possible, Courts will only try to give meaningful life to legislative enactments.

    13. A contention was taken in this case by the learned counsel for the petitioners that even in the above Supreme Court decision it was held that power of the Abkari Officers to conduct search under S. 31 (unamended) at any place at any time was confined to cases where Abkari Officers had reason that One of the specified offences in S. 50 is committed and S. 57A was not specified. The Supreme Court held that in any given case, if the Excise Inspector had reason to believe that offence specified in the Act was committed, the Abkari officers can enter the premises and search and if the entry and search is legal and if any offence is detected during search whether specified or not including an offence under S. 57A, then, report can be filed before the Magistrate under S. 50. The Supreme Court in Suraj's case (supra) held as follows:

    “In any given case, whether the Excise Inspector had reason to believe that an offence was committed and that offence was one of the specified offences are questions of facts which must be established in each case on evidence. Should be prosecution fail to prove these facts, the entry and search of any place per se would be illegal and so also the collection of samples by him and consequently the prosecution of the alleged offender will equally be illegal. But under the amended provision such a power extends to every case where the Excise Inspector has reason to believe that an offence under the Act has been committed. Even so on a valid entry and search of any place in exercise of power under unamended S. 31 of the Act, should an Excise Inspector find material suggestive of commission of an offence under the Act in addition to or instead of the specified offences, he can, on the basis of such material file a complaint a report regarding commission of such an offence also in addition to or in lieu of the offences in respect of which search was made.”

    14. A similar contention was raised in Crl. Appeal No. 1071/2000 considered in the above case. There also, the Supreme Court held that the complaint cannot be quashed. However, it was held as follows:

    “the prosecution has to make out a case under the first limb of S. 31, which can be determined only on examination of the Excise Inspector and decided on trial. In such a case, if the proceedings are not quashed under S. 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure by the High Court, it cannot be said that the High Court has committed any error in law.”

    15. Based upon these observations, it is contended that even the first limb is not satisfied and search under S. 32 itself is illegal.

    16. Additional Director General of Prosecutions submitted that the Supreme Court in the above case was considering the power of entry and search of any place by the Excise Inspector under S. 31 of the unamended Act. Abkari officers can conduct search under S. 31 only if he had reason to believe that specified offences in that section have been committed. If the first part is satisfied and during entry if any offence is committed, whether specified or unspecified, report can be filed. That is the sum and substance of the Supreme Court decision. However, that observation is applicable only if entry and search is conducted under S. 31 of the Act. It is submitted that here in this case search was conducted under S. 32 of the Act and not under S. 31 of the Act. S. 32 of the Abkari Act reads as follows:

    “32. Power to enter and inspect place of manufacture and sale:— The Commissioner of Excise or any Abkari Officer not below the rank of preventive Officer or any Police Officer duly empowered in that behalf, may enter and inspect, at any time by day or by night, any place in which any licensed manufacturer carries on the manufacture of any liquor or intoxicating drug, or draws toddy, or stores any liquor on intoxicating drug or toddy, and may enter and inspect, at any time during which the same may be open, and place in which any liquor or intoxicating drug is kept for sale by any licensed person; and may examine, test, measure or weigh any materials, stills, utensils, implements, apparatus, liquor or intoxicating drugs found in such place.”

    17. Unlike S. 31, where Abkari Officers had right of entry and search, at any place, under S. 32, the Abkari Officers can enter and inspect only the premises where liquor and intoxicating drug is kept for sale by any licensed person and only places where any licensed manufacturer carries on any manufacture of liquor or intoxicating drug etc. at any time whether day or night during which the same may be open and may test, measure or weigh any materials, utensils etc. This speaks about the routine inspection in the licensed premises or places of licensed persons. Here, only the licensed premises was searched under S. 32. Under S. 32 of the Act, power of entry and inspection is not limited to specified offences during the relevant time when inspection was conducted. The power under S. 32 is kept in tact and entry and inspection of the licensed premises under S. 32, when the premises is open, can be done and after test and examination, if any offences were suspected to have conducted, he can file a report under S. 50. Earlier High Court judgment as well as the Supreme Court judgment only deal with the power of search and inspection under S. 31 of the Act. Here, specific contention is that they have conducted inspection of only licensed premises under S. 32 of the Act. For conducting inspection and search, there is no condition precedent that before such inspection, the officer has reason to believe that a specified offence has been committed. Regular inspection in the licensed premises and seizure of liquor can be done under R. 6 of Kerala Abkari Shops (Disposal in Auction) Rules (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules’). Sub-r. (7) of R. 6 of the Rules reads as follows:—

    “Every officer authorised to inspect shops shall have authority to take possession of any toddy, foreign liquor found unfit for consumption or suspected to have been tampered with. The officers not below the ranks of Excise Inspectors are empowered to seize and destroy any liquor kept in shops and found to be unfit for consumption or which has been tampered with”.

    18. Under S. 27 of the Act, person in possession of the liquor as per licence is bound to test the liquor as required by the Abkari Officer. Therefore, if sample is taken during inspection as authorised under S. 32 and if the Abkari Officer finds out any offences, it is for the authorised Abkari Officer to file report under S. 50 of the Act to the competent Magistrate and, thereafter, it is for the Magistrate to deal with the same as prescribed in the Code of Criminal Procedure. Since inspection was conducted here as authorised under S. 32 and sample was taken and report was filed on the basis of the result of the test, it is for the Magistrate to deal with the matter and, if necessary, commit the matter as contemplated under the provisions of the Act and we see no ground to interfere in the matter at the initial stage. Hence we are of the opinion that for conducting an inspection of the premises of a licensed person under S. 32, it is not obligatory that the authorised officer has to form an opinion that a specified offence in S. 31 is committed. In such routine inspection, if an offence is detected, he is perfectly authorised to file a report under S. 50.

    19. Another contention raised was that third petitioner was only a licensee. Admittedly, he was not present at the place of incident. Presumptions and absolute liability against a licensee was incorporated after the inspection and hence at least case against him shall be dropped. Sub-s. (1) of S. 57A opens with the sentence “whoever mixes or permits to be mixed………”. Sub-s. (2) also says “whoever omits to take reasonable precautions…………”. So whether licensee permitted mixing of any noxious substances or whether he has taken care to prevent the same etc. are to be decided on evidence and whether ingredients of the section are substantiated as against him on the applicable rules of evidence is a matter to be considered by the criminal court and it is not a case whether charges should be thrashed at the initial stage even before adducing any evidence. It is for him to make out his defence before the trial court.

    20. We see no case to set aside Annexure I report sent by the Excise Inspector to the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Alathur.

    21. The Crl. M.C is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Prabhakaran v. Excise Inspector
    (Jan 30, 2002)