AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • POST OFFICE ACT
  • Sec. 6 of the Indian Post Office Act,
  • Sec. 6 of the Post Office Act, 1898
  • Sec. 6 of the Post Office Act
  • S. 6, Post Office Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • POST OFFICE ACT
  • Sec. 6 of the Indian Post Office Act,
  • Sec. 6 of the Post Office Act, 1898
  • Sec. 6 of the Post Office Act
  • S. 6, Post Office Act
Smart Summary

Official Summary of the Division Bench Opinion (as authored by Rajendra Babu, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

A registered letter containing a demand draft for Rs. 4,000 (sent by the plaintiff's husband Sreedharan on 11-4-75) reached the Railway Mail Service Office at Trivandrum on 15-4-75 but was not delivered to the addressee. An RMS sorter, the 2nd defendant Sukumaran Nair, fraudulently removed the registered letter and handed the demand draft to Mrs. Saroja P. Nair, who presented it for encashment; the draft was encashed on 21-4-75. The plaintiff lodged police and postal complaints; the 2nd defendant was subsequently convicted in the criminal proceedings arising out of the misappropriation.

The plaintiff sued for recovery of Rs. 4,000 (value of the draft) with interest and Rs. 2,000 by way of damages. The suit was originally against the Post and Telegraphs Department (represented by the Postmaster General) and the 2nd defendant; the Union of India was later impleaded as a defendant in 1983. The trial Court decreed the suit against all defendants. The Postal Department and the Union of India (defendants 1 and 3) appealed to the District Court, Trivandrum (A.S. 96/86), which dismissed their appeal and affirmed the decree. The defendants then filed the present second appeal to the Division Bench. The learned single Judge had referred the matter to the Division Bench because of importance and lack of uniformity in earlier decisions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Section 6 of the Post Office Act (1898) confers total immunity on the Central Government and the postal authorities for loss, misdelivery, delay or damage to any postal article in the course of transmission by post such that the Government cannot be held liable to compensate an owner for loss caused by a postal employee's fraudulent act.
  2. Whether the loss caused by a postal employee's fraudulent removal and disposition of a postal article constitutes "loss" by the Government (protected by Sec. 6) or a loss to the owner for which the Government remains liable.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendants / Union of India (1st defendant and standing counsel)

  • Argued that Sec. 6 of the Post Office Act grants absolute immunity to the Central Government for loss, misdelivery, delay or damage to postal articles in the course of transmission by post, and that this immunity extends to losses suffered by owners.
  • Contended that the suit was barred by limitation because the Union of India was not made a party before the expiry of the limitation period, and that no notice under Order 39/Section 80 (sic: Section 80, C.P.C.) was issued to the Union of India, rendering the suit not maintainable.
  • Asserted that because the loss was due to fraud by the 2nd defendant (an employee), liability lay solely with that employee.
  • Also argued that the amount was still available with the Syndicate Bank (which had withheld payment) and that the plaintiff could recover from the bank.

Amicus Curiae / Respondent-side submissions (as presented by Adv. O. Ramachandran Nambiar)

  • Argued that the word "loss" in Sec. 6 refers to loss by the postal department or Government and not to the pecuniary loss suffered by the owner by being wrongfully deprived of the article.
  • Relied on the Division Bench decision in Union of India v. Sri Narayan Agarwalla (AIR 1955 Cal 371) and earlier Calcutta authority (East Indian Railway Co. v. Jagpal Singh) to support the interpretation that "loss" means loss to the department/government.
  • Further argued that the legislature did not intend to exempt the Government from tortious liability for deliberate fraudulent acts of employees; fraud or wilful default by an officer is an exception to any departmental immunity and the employer (State) cannot avoid liability for a willful wrong by its employee.
  • Contended that if "loss" were to be read as loss to the owner, other language in Sec. 6 concerning misdelivery, delay and damage would be redundant; the statutory text indicates a narrower meaning (loss to the Government).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. Sri Narayan Agarwalla, AIR 1955 Cal 371 Held that the word "loss" in Sec. 6 of the Post Office Act means loss to the postal department/Government and not pecuniary loss to the owner. Relied upon as supporting the view that "loss" contemplates loss by the Government; the Division Bench adopted this interpretation for the present case.
East Indian Railway Co. v. Jagpal Singh, AIR 1924 Cal 725 Interpreted "loss" under S.72 of the Railways Act as not meaning pecuniary loss to the owner of the goods. Used as antecedent support (by the Calcutta Court) for reading "loss" as loss to the department; mentioned in the reasoning to support the Calcutta view.
Union of India v. New Vijay Weaving Works, (1974) 15 Guj LR 322 Held that the "loss" in Sec. 6 is loss by the State; fraud or wilful act of an officer does not absolve the State from liability for tortious acts committed by its officials in the course of duty. Recognized as a supporting High Court view; the Division Bench expressly adopted the Gujarat High Court's analysis that Sec.6 immunity is confined to loss by the Government, and not loss to owners caused by wilful acts of employees.
Union of India v. Firm Ram Gopal Hukam Chand, AIR 1960 All 672 Held Sec.6 is a shield to protect post office/officials in legitimate discharge of functions but cannot be converted into a licence to commit wrongful acts; post office may be liable to sender for value of entrusted article where exemption cannot be claimed. Cited to show that Sec.6 is not intended for inequitable exoneration of the Department; the Division Bench noted this authority in support of limiting Sec.6 protection.
Union of India v. Ramji Lal, AIR 1965 All 184 Represents a contrary view (to the Allahabad single-judge line) on the scope of Sec.6. Noted by the Division Bench as an example of conflicting views in the High Court; the existence of conflicting authorities supported referring to the larger question.
Commr. of Income-tax, Delhi v. P.M. Rathod & Co., AIR 1959 SC 1394 Described the department's relation in VPP system as that of agent of the sender for recovery of price; indicated statutory-carrier character of the Department. Mentioned to show prior Supreme Court recognition of the Department's carrier-like responsibilities; the Bench observed the point but stated it was not directly engaged in the present decision.
Union of India v. Amar Singh, (1960) 2 SCR 75 : AIR 1960 SC 233 Discussed aspects of the postal department's responsibilities (similar approach to the Rathod case). Referenced for context about the Department's jural relationship with senders; noted but not central to the present ruling.
Union of India v. Mohd. Nazim, AIR 1980 SC 431 Supreme Court decision taking a different view on issues related to the Department's liability (identified as different from earlier Supreme Court approaches). Noted by the Division Bench but expressly stated to be outside the core question decided in this case; the Bench did not base its ruling on this authority.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Division Bench proceeded by examining the text of Section 6 of the Post Office Act (reproduced in the opinion) and the competing interpretations of the term "loss" appearing therein. Two principal interpretive lines emerged from earlier authority:

  • One line (exemplified by the Calcutta and Gujarat High Courts) reads "loss" in Sec. 6 as referring to loss to the postal department or Government (i.e., the Department's own loss of possession), so that Sec. 6 protects the Government only against liabilities arising from loss to the Department itself; and
  • The other line reads "loss" more broadly as including pecuniary loss to the owner, which would yield broader immunity for the Government against claims by owners.

The Court reviewed these authorities (Calcutta, Gujarat and several Allahabad decisions) and the textual structure of Sec. 6. It accepted key points argued by counsel and amicus:

  • Sec. 6 must be read as a statutory protection that saves the Government from the liabilities of a common carrier, but it does not confer upon the postal authorities or their officers a licence to commit wrongful acts with impunity.
  • Where a postal official wilfully or fraudulently does something that results in the loss or misdelivery of an article entrusted to the office, the official has committed a breach of statutory duty in the discharge of his functions on behalf of the State; the employer-State cannot avoid responsibility for such wilful wrongs by invoking Sec. 6.
  • In the facts of the case the letter and demand draft were not lost "in the course of transmission" by the Department in the sense of being involuntarily lost by the state; instead, the article remained with an employee who deliberately removed and diverted it for personal benefit. Thus, there was no loss to the Government's possession even though there was a loss to the owner.

On this basis, the Court expressly adopted the views of the Calcutta and Gujarat High Courts that the "loss" contemplated by Sec. 6 is loss to the Government (department) and not the owner. Applying that construction to the facts, the Court concluded that Sec. 6 did not protect the Government from liability for the owner's loss where the loss arose from a postal employee's wilful and fraudulent act and where the Department had not itself lost possession in the sense intended by Sec. 6.

The Court therefore found the reasoning and outcomes of the Courts below — which had decreed recovery against the postal authorities and the Union of India — to be correct and without reason for interference.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Division Bench held that Section 6 of the Post Office Act does not confer total immunity on the Central Government for losses sustained by owners when those losses are caused by the fraudulent or wilful acts of postal employees; accordingly, the Government is liable to compensate the plaintiff for the loss resulting from its employee's wilful and fraudulent removal and encashment of the demand draft.

Immediate consequences:

  • The decree and judgment of the trial Court and the District Court (which had decreed recovery against the Government and postal department) are justified and the Division Bench found no reason to interfere with them.
  • The Government and the postal department are liable to compensate the plaintiff for the loss she suffered due to the wilful fraudulent act of their employee (the 2nd defendant) in the circumstances set out in the opinion.

Broader implications: The opinion adopts and applies existing High Court interpretations (Calcutta and Gujarat) reading "loss" in Sec. 6 as loss to the Government rather than loss to the owner, and limits Sec. 6 protection where an employee's wilful or fraudulent act causes owner-loss. The opinion itself does not elaborate additional broader policy consequences beyond these direct effects.

Order: "Order accordingly." (the Court answered the referred question as described above.)

    Post And Telegraph Department, Trivandrum And Another v. A. Sarada .

    Rajendra Babu, J.:— A demand draft was sent in a letter by registered post. An employee of the postal department, Instead of delivering the letter to the addressee, fraudulently removed the letter and the demand draft and encashed the draft. The question for consideration is whether the Union of India and the postal department are liable to compensate the loss sustained by the owner due to the non-delivery of the demand draft by the fraudulent act of their employee. When the matter came up before the learned single Judge, considering the importance of the question and as there was no uniformity in the decisions of the Courts, the matter was referred to the Division Bench.

    2. The Posts and Telegraphs Department and the Union of India (defendants 1 and 3 in O.S 473/81 before the Sub-Court, Trivandrum) filed the second appeal challenging the decree passed in the above suit which was confirmed in appeal — A.S 96/86 — by the District Court, Trivandrum. The plaintiff's husband one Sreedharan sent a registered letter dt. 11-4-75 containing a demand draft for Rs. 4000/- drawn on the Indian Overseas Bank, Varkala Branch. The letter was received in the Railway Mail Service Office at Trivandrum on 15-4-1975, but it was not delivered to the addressee, the plaintiff. The 2nd defendant one Sukumaran Nair, who was employed as a sorter in the R.M.S Office, fraudulently removed the registered letter and handed over the demand draft to one Mrs. Saroja P. Nair, a financier and advocate, for encashment and got the draft encashed on 21-4-75. The plaintiff lodged a complaint to the police and the postal authorities regarding the mischief committed by the 2nd defendant. Later, the 2nd defendant was convicted in the criminal case that was registered against him and others. As the plaintiff filed as objection before the Syndicate Bank through which Mrs. Saroja P. Nair presented the draft for collection; the bank withheld the amount and kept it with them without making payment to Mrs. Saroja P. Nair. The postal authorities disclaimed the liability for the value of the draft and damages and accordingly the plaintiff filed the suit for recovery of Rs. 4000/- being the amount of the draft and the interest thereon and also Rs. 2000/- by way of damages for the loss and injury sustained by her. The suit was originally instituted against the Post and Telegraphs Department, represented by the Postmaster General at Trivandrum, and the 2nd defendant who removed the draft. Due to the objection that the suit was not properly instituted, the Union of India was impleaded in 1983 as the 3rd defendant.

    3. The main contentions put forward by the 1st defendant in the written statement was that the suit was barred by limitation as the Union of India was not made a party before the expiry of the period of limitation and as no notice u/S. 80, C.P.C was issued on the Union of India, the suit was not maintainable too. It was further contended that in view of Sec. 6 of the Post Office Act, there was total immunity to the postal authorities and to the Union of India from all the liabilities for the loss of any postal article in the course of transmission by post. As fraud had been committed by the 2nd defendant, he alone was responsible for the loss. It was further contended that as the amount was still available with the Syndicate Bank, the plaintiff could get the same from the bank.

    4. The 3rd defendant did not file any separate written statement. The trial Court, after considering the evidence, repelled all the contentions put forward by the defendant and decreed the suit as against all the defendants. Defendants 1 and 3 viz. the Postal Department and the Union of India challenged the decree and judgment in appeal by preferring A.S 96/86 before the District Court, Trivandrum. The appeal was dismissed upholding the decree and judgment of the trial Court. Aggrieved by the above judgment and decree, the defendants 1 and 3 have filed this second appeal.

    5. Heard the learned standing counsel for the Union of India and the learned counsel for the respondent. Adv. Sri O. Ramachandran Nambiar was appointed as amicus curiae for assisting the Court and he also was heard. For the sake of convenience, parties are referred to as plaintiff and defendants as arrayed in the plaint.

    6. The only question for consideration before the Division Bench was whether Sec. 6 of the Post Office Act conferred total immunity on the Government for the loss sustained by the owner as a result of the fraudulent action on the part of the employee and whether the Union of India could not be made liable for the plaint claim. The evidence in the case was that the 2nd defendant, who was an employee of the postal department, committed fraud by removing the registered letter and the demand draft and encashing the draft through one Mrs. Saroja P. Nair, a financier and advocate. The moot question was whether the Union of India was not liable to compensate for the fraudulent act of the employee by which the addressee, the plaintiff, lost the postal article and whether the employee who committed the mischief alone was liable to compensate. Sec. 6 of the Post Office Act, 1898 reads:

    “Exemption from liability for loss, misdelivery, delay or damage.— The Government shall not incur any liability by reason of the loss, misdelivery or delay of, or damage to, any postal article in course of transmission by post, except insofar as such liability may in express terms be undertaken by the Central Government as hereinafter provided; and no officer of the Post Office shall incur any liability by reason of any such loss, misdelivery, delay or damage, unless he has caused the same fraudulently or by his wilful act or default.”

    The learned Standing Counsel for the Union of India submitted that the Central Government has got absolute immunity in respect of the loss, misdelivery or delay of, or damage to any postal article in the course of the transmission by post in view of Sec. 6 of the Post Office Act and as such the Government is not at all liable to compensate the loss sustained by the plaintiff. It was further submitted that the loss contemplated under Sec. 6 of the above Act would include loss to the Government as well as loss to the owner and as the postal article was lost so far as the plaintiff was concerned, there was total immunity in view of Sec. 6 of the Act and thereby the Government was not liable to compensate. Advocate Sri O.A Ramachandran Nambiar argued that the loss contemplated under Sec. 6 was only loss by the Government or to the Department and it did not take in the loss sustained to the owner. He placed reliance on the decision of the Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court in Union of India v. Sri Narayan Agarwalla, AIR 1955 Cal 371. The question came up for consideration in the above case was whether the Government of India can escape from the liability to pay compensation for the loss caused by the non-delivery of an article it received for carriage and delivery when the article had not been lost by the Government. The Government set up a defence that the particular parcel was taken away by thieves along with other things from the post office. But the State could not establish that the articles were stolen by thieves and that story or contention was not accepted by the Court and it was held that the Government of India cannot escape from the liability to pay compensation for the loss caused by non-delivery of the article it received for carriage and delivery where the article has not been proved to be lost by the Government. There it was held (Para 8):

    “In my judgment a similar interpretation should be put on the word “loss” in S. 6, Post Office Act and it should be held that “loss” in their section does not mean pecuniary or other loss by the owner of the goods through being wrongfully deprived of the possession or enjoyment thereof, but means loss by the postal department of the Government and such loss occurs whenever the department involuntarily or through inadvertence loses possession of the goods and for the time being is unable to trace them.”

    In holding such a view the learned Judge was placing reliance on an earlier decision of the same High Court in East Indian Railway Co. v. Jagpal Singh, AIR 1924 Cal 725, wherein the Court considered the word “loss” u/S. 72 of the Railways Act. There it was held that the ‘loss’ contemplated u/S. 72 of the Railways Act did not mean pecuniary or other loss to the owner of the goods. Sri O. Ramachandran Nambiar had further argued that the legislature intended to grant exemption only in respect of loss to the Government and it did not contemplate any loss to the owner and the intention of the legislature is explicit, from the very language of the statute. It was further submitted that the deliberate fraudulent acts resulting in the loss, misdelivery or delay or damage due to the fraudulent or wilful acts of default from the employees was not at all intended to be exempted from the purview of the tortious liability of the Government. Sri O. Ramacandran Nambiar further submitted that if the legislature wanted to exonerate the liability of the State in respect of loss sustained by the owner of the article, there was no necessity for making specific provision regarding exemption in respect of misdelivery, delay or damage in addition to loss as the misdelivery, delay or damage to the article would be, in fact, a loss to the owner of the article. Cases of misdelivery or delay or damage will necessarily cause loss to the owner. Therefore, if loss meant “loss to the owner”, whether it had been loss to the Government or not, the words “misdelivery or delay of or damage to the article” in Sec. 6 was redundant.

    7. The High Court of Gujarat also has taken the view that ‘loss’ contemplated u/S. 6 was loss by the State and it did not take in loss to the owner in Union of India v. New Vijay Weaving Works, (1974) 15 Guj LR 322. There the learned single Judge of to Gujarat High Court held that by the provisions of the Indian Post Office Act, the department assumes the liability of a carrier and can be described as a statutory carrier and even as per Sec. 6 of the Indian Post Office Act, fraud and wilful act of an officer of the post office does not earn exception contemplated by the section. It was further observed that if fraud and wilful act or default cannot save an officer from liability arising from loss etc., it is difficult to comprehend how such fraud or wilful act or default can save the Government from a similar liability and Sec. 6 was intended to save the Government from the liability of a common carrier and nothing more can be read in the provisions of that section. A postal article is entrusted to the postal authorities for its safe carriage and delivery to the addressee, and not for its wilful damage or destruction or removal. When a postal official wilfully does anything which results in its loss or damage, he commits breach of statutory duty in discharge of his functions on behalf of the State and the State, being his employer, cannot avoid its responsibility for the wilful wrong done by him to the members of the public. The loss, misdelivery, delay or damage cannot therefore be considered as those resulting from fraud or wilful act or default of the postal officials dealing with a postal article. The immunity as per Sec. 6 of the Act is subject to the exception that it is not applicable in cases where such liability is undertaken in express terms by the Central Government as provided in the Act. So also no officers of the post office shall incur any liability by reason of the loss, misdelivery, delay or damage unless it was a case involving the result caused by the fraud or wilful act or default. That means the liability of the Central Government is confined to statutory liability expressly undertaken under the provisions of the liability of the postal employees so confined to cases where the loss, delay, misdelivery or damage was the result caused fraudulently or by wilful act or default. The postal department in fact is liable for the tortious acts of its officials committed during the course of their duty with regard to the postal articles entrusted to their care.

    8. In Union of India v. Firm Ram Gopal Hukam Chand, AIR 1960 All 672 the learned single Judge of the Allahabad High Court had considered the scope of Sec. 6 of the Post Office Act and held that Sec. 6 of the Post Office Act providing that Government shall not be liable for the loss, damage, non-delivery or misdelivery of postal articles entrusted to its charge was intended by the legislature to serve as shield for the protection of the post office and its officials in the legitimate discharge of their functions, but the shield cannot be converted into a weapon of inequity in the hands of a Government Department enjoying a monopoly of an essential service Sec. 6 does not empower the post office or its officials to do what they like with the articles entrusted to their care or commit wrongful acts against the owners of those articles. There it was held that the post office was liable to the sender for the value of the article which was entrusted to its care and in respect of which it cannot claim exemption under Sec. 6. In a subsequent decision another learned Judge of the Allahabad High Court took a contrary view in Union of India v. Ramji Lal, AIR 1965 All 184.

    9. By virtue of the provisions of the Indian Post Office Act the Department has the liability of a statutory carrier and it was not exercising any sovereign functions as it was enjoined in England. The jural relationship between the sender and the post office in respect of the carriage of goods sent by the sender under VPP system was held by the Supreme Court to be that of an agent of the sender for the recovery of the price and if it fails to recover the price and deliver the goods, it is liable for damages to the sender. Commr. of Income-tax, Delhi v. P.M Rathod and Co., AIR 1959 SC 1394. A similar approach was taken by the Supreme Court in Union Of India v. Amar Singh, (1960) 2 SCR 75: (AIR 1960 SC 233). But a different view was taken by the Supreme Court in Union Of India v. Mohd. Nazim., AIR 1980 SC 431. Anyway we are not concerned with the above question in the present case. By Sec. 6 of the Act the Government is saved of the liability of a common carrier and it did not confer or empower the postal authorities to deal with the article entrusted in any manner they like. When a postal official wilfully or fraudulently does anything which results in the loss or damage, he commits breach of a statutory duty in the discharge of his function on behalf of the State. The State, being the employer, cannot avoid its responsibility for the wilful wrong done by the employee to the members of the public. Hence it cannot be said that the legislature intended an outright exoneration of the liability of the State when loss is occasioned to the owner of the vehicle and the loss contemplated under Sec. 6 can only be in respect of the loss by the Government. In the present case the employee of the postal department had fraudulently and wilfully removed the postal article and took away the demand draft and utilised for his own benefit. So far as the department is concerned, it cannot be said that the postal article was lost in the course of transmission. In fact, the postal article was with its employee and he utilised it for his own benefit and as such there is no loss by the Government, though there is a loss suffered by the owner. We respectfully adopt the view taken by the High Courts of Calcutta and Gujarat that the loss contemplated under Sec. 6 is loss to the Government and not loss to the owner of the postal articles. The approach taken by the Courts below in decreeing the suit as against the Government and the department has to be justified and we find no reasons to interfere with the above decree. The Government is liable to compensate for the loss sustained to the plaintiff as a result of the wilful act committed by its employee, the 2nd defendant. The question of law referred to us is answered accordingly. We place on record our appreciation for the co-operation and the laborious work done by Sri O. Ramachandran Nambiar.

    Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Post And Telegraph Department, Trivandrum And Another v. A. Sarada .
    (Oct 19, 2001)