Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 20(b)(i) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (Act for short)
  • section 162(1) of the Code.
  • section 161 of the Code.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 20(b)(i) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (Act for short)
  • section 162(1) of the Code.
  • section 161 of the Code.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant was the accused in Sessions Case No. 80 of 1991 before the Second Additional Assistant Sessions Judge, Ernakulam. He was convicted under section 20(b)(i) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for 1½ years. The prosecution case, as recorded in the opinion, is that on 7-5-1991 at about 5 p.m., near the Naval base Ernakulam Gate, police found the accused possessing seven small packets of ganja. The Sub-Inspector (PW-8) recovered the packets, which were taken to the police station and crime registered under section 20(b)(i) of the Act. After trial the Assistant Sessions Judge convicted the accused and imposed the sentence noted above. The accused appealed; the appeal was heard with counsel for the appellant and the Public Prosecutor.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the evidence of witnesses (PW-1 and PW-3) became inadmissible because police read over to them their statements recorded under section 161 of the Code before they entered the witness-box, in view of section 162 of the Code.
  2. Whether non-compliance with section 50 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (production before a gazetted officer or magistrate and informing accused of right to be searched in their presence) vitiated the seizure and conviction.
  3. Whether the discrepancy in weights recorded at the place of seizure and by the analyst affected the identity of the seized article and thereby raised reasonable doubt about prosecution's case.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • That inadmissible evidence was permitted because PW-1 and PW-3 stated in cross-examination that police had read over to them the statements recorded under section 161 of the Code before they were examined; reliance was placed on Ramvilas v. State of M.P. (Madhya Pradesh High Court) and the Privy Council decision in Zahiruddin v. Emperor to support the contention that such reading rendered evidence inadmissible under section 162.
  • That mandatory provisions of the NDPS Act, particularly section 50, were not complied with: the accused was not produced before a gazetted officer or magistrate and was not informed of his right to be searched in the presence of a magistrate or gazetted officer; reliance was placed on the Supreme Court decision in Balbir Singh v. State of Punjab.
  • That there was a discrepancy between the weight of the article ascertained at the place of seizure and the weight shown in the analyst's receipt (Ext. P4), arguing that the article analyzed might be different from the article seized (the opinion records the seized weight and analyst's weight and identifies this contention being raised).

Prosecution / State (as reflected in the opinion)

  • PW-8 (Sub-Inspector) testified to having detected the offence, apprehended the accused, searched him, found seven small packets, arrested him and produced him along with the contraband to the police station; PW-4 (goldsmith) brought a balance and weighed the recovered packets at the scene.
  • PW-8 stated that he asked the accused whether he wanted the search to be conducted in the presence of a gazetted officer or a magistrate and that the accused answered in the negative (this was relied on to counter the appellant's section 50 contention).
  • The prosecution relied on corroboration between the police officers and the independent witnesses (PW-1, PW-3 and PW-4) and on the analyst's report that the recovered article was ganja to establish possession and intent for sale.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramvilas v. State of M.P. (1985 Crl. L.J. 1773) (Madhya Pradesh High Court) Held that where a police statement made to a witness was narrated to him shortly before he entered the witness-box, such evidence would be inadmissible under section 162 because the narration was for the purpose of giving evidence at trial. The court noted the decision but did not follow it; it distinguished the present facts and relied instead on the Gujarat Full Bench decision which took a different view.
Zahiruddin v. Emperor, AIR 1947 PC 75 (Privy Council) Privy Council held the evidence inadmissible where the witness had previously given a signed statement to police and the statement was made use of by the witness while giving evidence to prompt his memory. The court observed the Privy Council decision but held that its ratio could not be extended to the present case because the Privy Council's decision turned on two facts (prior signed statement and prompting of memory while giving evidence) which were not present here.
Nathu v. State, AIR 1978 Gujarat 49 (Full Bench) Full Bench considered whether reading over a police statement to a witness before he entered the box renders evidence inadmissible under section 162(1); answered that such evidence is not automatically inadmissible, that reading over does not amount to contravention of S.162(1), but may affect probative value judged in context. The court expressly agreed with the Full Bench answers, adopted its reasoning and applied its conclusions to hold that reading over the statements to PWs.1 and 3 did not render their testimony inadmissible, though probative value must be judged in context.
Balbir Singh v. State of Punjab ((1994) 3 SCC 299 : AIR 1994 SC 1872) Authority concerning compliance with section 50 of the NDPS Act (rights regarding search in presence of gazetted officer or magistrate). The appellant relied on this decision to argue non-compliance. The court addressed this contention with reference to PW-8's testimony and held that because the seizure was under section 43 (public place) and there was no request by the accused to be produced before a gazetted officer, section 50 was not violated in the manner alleged.
Muhammed v. State of Kerala, 1995 (1) K.L.T 24 Stated that in cases of seizure under section 43 of the NDPS Act, the empowered officer has no obligation to inform the accused of his right under section 50 and that production before a gazetted officer or magistrate is required only if such a request comes from the accused. The court relied on this Kerala decision to hold that a seizure from a public place under section 43 does not attract the obligations under section 50 unless the accused requests production before a gazetted officer or magistrate; since no such request was made, there was no violation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a stepwise manner addressing each principal contention advanced by the appellant and applying the legal principles and authorities cited in the opinion.

1. Admissibility of Evidence (section 161/162 Code):

  • The court reviewed the divergent authorities, notably the Privy Council decision in Zahiruddin, the Madhya Pradesh High Court decision in Ramvilas, and the Full Bench of the Gujarat High Court in Nathu v. State.
  • The court accepted the Gujarat Full Bench's analysis and answers to the referred questions, summarized in the opinion: (a) evidence of a witness whose police statement is read over to him before he enters the box does not become inadmissible per se; its probative value must be assessed in the facts of each case; (b) reading over the statement before the witness enters the box does not amount to contravention of section 162(1); and (c) such reading does not amount to 'use' of the statement contrary to S.162(1).
  • The court distinguished Zahiruddin on its facts (which involved a signed statement and prompting of memory in-court) and concluded that the ratio of that case could not be extended to the present circumstances.
  • Applying this principle, the court held that the testimonies of PW-1 and PW-3 were not rendered inadmissible simply because the police had read over their section 161 statements to them before they entered the box; however, the court noted that such circumstances may affect probative value and must be judged in context.

2. Evaluation of Witness Evidence and Corroboration:

  • Both PW-1 (a nearby tea shop owner) and PW-3 were declared hostile but each gave some evidence that corroborated aspects of the prosecution case: both saw the accused being restrained by police and saw a bundle in his hand (though PW-3 could not say it contained ganja).
  • The court found that the testimony of PW-8 (Sub-Inspector) and PW-4 (goldsmith who weighed the recovered packets at the scene) supplied direct evidence of recovery and weighing; the analyst's report established the article was ganja.
  • On the whole, the court concluded that the prosecution had proved that the accused was found possessing ganja and that it was intended for sale, relying on the combined testimony and documentary evidence.

3. Compliance with Section 50 of the NDPS Act:

  • The appellant argued non-compliance with section 50 (production before gazetted officer or magistrate and informing of right to search in their presence) relying on Balbir Singh.
  • The court accepted PW-8's testimony that he asked the accused whether he should be searched in the presence of a gazetted officer or magistrate and that the accused declined; although this was not recorded in the mahazar, the court found no reason to disbelieve PW-8.
  • Moreover, because the seizure occurred in a public place and was thus under section 43 of the Act, the court followed the reasoning in Muhammed v. State of Kerala that section 50 obligations do not arise unless the accused requests production before a gazetted officer or magistrate. There was no case that the accused made such a request. Therefore the court found no violation of the Act in this respect.

4. Discrepancy in Weights / Identity of Exhibit:

  • The appellant pointed to a discrepancy in weights as recorded at the place of seizure and in the analyst's receipt (the opinion records a weight ascertained at the place of seizure and a different weight shown in Ext. P4). The opinion records these figures as 7,600 grams (place of seizure) and 9,500 grams (received by analyst) and notes that counsel argued this raised doubt as to identity.
  • The court observed that the weighing at the place of seizure was done by PW-4 who brought a balance and that minor differences in weighing between the scene and analysis are likely; the court characterized the difference as not substantial for the purpose of undermining identity (the opinion also contains the statement "The difference being only 2 grams" when assessing significance, though the numerical figures earlier recorded differ).
  • Accordingly, the court held that the discrepancy did not create a reasonable doubt about the identity of the seized article and did not prevent proof of possession and intent for sale.

5. Conclusion of Analysis:

  • Applying the foregoing analysis, the court found the trial court was correct to rely on the relevant portions of the witness testimonies and police evidence, to accept the analyst's report, and to convict the accused under section 20(b)(i) of the NDPS Act.
  • The sentence imposed by the trial court was also held to be reasonable; the court noted the appellant had by then already suffered the sentence.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court upheld the conviction and sentence of the appellant; the appeal was dismissed.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The appellant's conviction under section 20(b)(i) of the NDPS Act and the sentence of rigorous imprisonment for 1½ years were sustained; the appeal was dismissed and no interference was called for (the opinion notes the appellant had already suffered the sentence).
  • On legal principles: The court expressly adopted the Full Bench view in Nathu v. State that reading over a police statement to a witness before he enters the witness-box does not automatically render the witness's evidence inadmissible under section 162(1) of the Code, though it may affect probative value. The court distinguished the Privy Council decision in Zahiruddin and did not extend its ratio to the facts here.
  • The opinion did not purport to lay down a novel general rule beyond applying existing authorities; it resolved the instant appeal by applying established precedents and fact-specific analysis. No broader new precedent was announced in the text of the opinion beyond the court's application of cited authorities to the facts before it.

    Ali v. State Of Kerala

    1. The accused in Sessions Case 80 of 1991 before Second Additional Assistant Sessions Judge, Ernakulam is the appellant. He was convicted under section 20(b)(i) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (Act for short) and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of 1½ years. The prosecution case is that the accused was found possessing 7.6 grams of ganja for purpose of sale near Naval base Ernakulam Gate at about 5 p.m on 7-5-1991. The Sub-Inspector of Police, Harbour Police Station found 7 small packets of ganja. The accused had no valid permit or licence to possess the article. The article was recovered and the contraband article were taken to the police Station and crime was registered under section 20(b)(i) of the Act. After trial the Assistant Sessions Judge found the accused guilty of the offence charged against him convicted him and awarded the sentence referred above. Hence the appeal. Heard counsel for the appellant and Public Prosecutor.

    2. The main contention advanced by learned counsel for the appellant is that inadmissible evidence was permitted to be adduced by the Assistant Sessions Judge. This plea is presumably raised in view of the statement of PW-1 in cross-examination that before he was examined the policemen had read over to him the statement recorded under section 161 of the Code. It was so stated by PW-3 also, According to counsel, the statement can be used only for the purposes mentioned in section 162 of the Code and not for any other purpose. Narration of the facts in the statement to the witnesses amounts to making use of the statement at the time of trial, according to counsel and that is prohibited by section 162 of the Code. Reliance is placed on the decision of the Madhya pradesh High Court in Ramvilas v. State of M.P (1985 Crl. L.J 1773). A Division bench of the Madhya Pradesh High court held that where statement made by the witness to the police was narrated to him not when he was in the witness-box but shortly before entering the witness-box, the evidence of such witness would be inadmissible in view of section 162 because the fact remains that it was narrated to him for the purpose of giving evidence at the trial. The Madhya pradesh High Court has followed the privy Council decision reported in AIR 1947 PC 75 Zahiruddin v. Emperor. But the matter is seen to have been considered at length by a Full bench of the Gujarat High Court in Nathu v. State (AIR 1978 Gujarat 49). The following questions were referred to the Full bench for decision.

    1. Is the evidence of a witness whose statement recorded in the course of investigation under Chapter XII of the Criminal P.C if read over to him before the witness steps into witness box becomes inadmissible or such as would be of no value whatsoever?

    2. Does such contravention of Section 162(1) affect admissibility or probative value of the evidence of such a witness?

    3. Does reading over of such statement to a witness before he enters witness box amount to use of such statement contrary to Section 162(1)?

    3. Since the questions referred are of general importance and needed a final and authoritative answer based on the correct interpretation of the prohibition against the use of police statements enacted in-section 162(1) of the Code the Full bench had surveyed all the decisions on that topic including the Privy Council decision in AIR 1947 PC 75. The Full Bench answered the questions in paragraph 27 of the Judgement at page 60 thus:

    “(1) The evidence of such witness does not become inadmissible; its probative value has to be judged in the circumstances of each case. No hard and fast rule can be laid down that in all such cases the evidence of such witness will be of no value whatsoever.

    (2) Reading over of the police statement to the witness(before he enters the box does not amount to contravention of the prohibition contained in S. 162(1). But the fact of reading over of the statement may affect the probative value of the evidence of the witness.

    (3) Reading over of such a statement to the witness before he enters the box does not amount to use of such statement contrary to S. 162(1).”

    4. I am in respectful agreement with the views expressed by the Gujarat High Court in the Full bench decision aforementioned. As observed therein the user contemplated in section 162 of the Code is actual user in court proceedings and not user de hors the court proceedings. The court proceedings begin when the court starts hearing a case and end when the court stops the proceedings and adjourns them to some other day. The section does not prevent user of a police statement outside the court proceedings. That is manifested from the words “be used for any purpose, save as hereinafter provided, at any inquiry or trial in respect of any offence under investigation.” The prohibition is only for using such statements in proceedings before court. It was for that reason that the Privy Council in Zahiruddin's case (supra) held that evidence of the witness is inadmissible. In that case the evidence was rendered inadmissible for two reasons (1) he had previously given a signed statement to the police and (2) the statement was made use of by the witness while giving evidence to prompt his memory. The ratio of the decision of the privy Council cannot therefore be extended to the present case. The result is that the testimonies of PWs. 1 and 3 do not become inadmissible for the reason that the police had read out the statement to them before they entered the witness box. There is thus no contravention of the prohibition contained in section 162(1) of the Code. The reading of the statement to the witnesses does not therefore amount to use of such a statement, contrary to the provision contained in section 162(1) of the Code. Still the reading over of the statement may affect the probative value of the evidence of the witness which the court had to judge in the circumstances of each case.

    5. In the light of the principles enunciated in the foregoing paragraphs the reading over of the statement to PWs. 1 and 3 does not make their evidence inadmissible. But the court has to consider the evidence given by these witnesses carefully for deciding the probative value of such evidence in the light of the facts and circumstances of the case.

    6. Both PWs. 1 and 3 were declared hostile by the Public Prosecutor and cross-examined. The Assistant Sessions Judge has relied on the testimony of these two witnesses only on some of the facts spoken to by them to find corroboration in the evidence of the police officers. The offence was detected by the Sub-Inspector, PW-8. On getting information that ganja was being sold at the Ernakulam gate of the Naval Base while PW-8 along with PWs. 5 and 6 were in the course of investigation of other crimes, he along with the policemen went to that place, apprehended the accused, searched his body, found the contraband article, arrested him and produced him along with the contraband article to the police station. Before that, one of the police constables and brought PW-4, a goldsmith to that place with a balance. The seven small packets recovered from the person of the accused were weighed and the weight ascertained. PW-1 is a nearby tea shop owner. Though he had not supported the prosecution in full he had seen the accused being restrained by the police. He also has seen a bundle in the hand of the accused. PW-3 also has seen the accused being restrained by the police. He also has seen a bundle in the hand of the accused. This according to him happened near the Ernakulam Gate of the Naval Base. He was not in a position to say whether the bundle possessed by the accused contained ganja. The testimony of these two witnesses regarding the apprehension of the accused and the seizure of an article from him can therefore be relied upon. The recovery of the article has been spoken to by PW-8, the Sub Inspector and PW-4, the goldsmith who weighed the ganja recovered from the accused. The article on analysis was found to be ganja. The prosecution has therefore succeeded in proving that the accused was found possessing ganja and that it was intended for sale.

    7. The conviction is assailed by the appellant on the ground that the mandatory provisions contained in the Act had not been complied with. In particular it is pointed out that the accused was not produced before gazetted officer or a Magistrate as required under section 50 of the Act. The accused was also not informed of his right to be searched in the presence of a magistrate or Gazetted Officer under that section. Reliance was placed on the decision on of the Supreme Court in Balbir Singh v. State of Punjab ((1994) 3 SCC 299 : AIR 1994 SC 1872). But it is spoken to by PW-8 that the accused was asked whether he should be searched in the presence of a gazetted officer or a legistrate to which he answered in the negative. This according to the appellant was not recorded in the mahazar prepared and was subsequently introduced by the witness at the time of examination. There is no reason to disbelieve PW-8 on this aspect. Even if it be that PW-8 has not informed the accused of his right under section 50 of the Act there is no violation of that section. The seizure took place from a public place and has therefore been made under section 43 of the Act. This Court in the decision in Muhammed v. State of Kerala (1995 (1) K.L.T 24) held that in the case of a seizure under section 43 of the Act the empowered officer or the authorised officer has no obligation to inform the accused of his right under section 50, of the Act Whereas he shall be produced before a gazetted officer or a magistrate only if a request comes from the accused. Appellant has no case that such a request was made by him to PW-8. There has thus been no violation of section ??? of the Act.

    8. It is then contended that the article analysed by the analyst and the article seizued from the accused are different. This contention is raised for the reason that the weight of the article seized was ascertained to be 7,600 grams whereas the weight of the article received by the analyst as per. Ext. p4 is shown is 9,500 grams. According to counsel, that raises a doubt regarding the prosecution version and the identity of the article seized. The article was weighed from the place of seizure. PW-4 has brought a balance for that purpose. There is every likelihood of some difference when the article is weighed by the analyst. The difference being only 2 grams and in view of the evidence tendered in the side of the prosecution, much cannot be made out from this difference in order to hold that the article analysed by the analyst is different from the article seized. The observation of the court below that the difference does not assume much importance is therefore justified. The prosecution has thus succeeded in establishing the guilt of the accused. The court below was therefore right in finding him guilty and in convicting him. The sentence awarded is also reasonable. By this time appellant has already suffered the sentence. No interference is therefore called for.

    9. For the aforesaid reasons the conviction and sentence against the appellant are sustained and the appeal is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ali v. State Of Kerala
    (Jan 13, 1995)