Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 7(1) read with Section 8 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 (for short the Act) the Sub Court
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 7(1) read with Section 8 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 (for short the Act) the Sub Court
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The first defendant in O.S 246 of 1984 filed an application (I.A 2143 of 1993) for transferring the suit for partition from the Sub Court, Thrissur to the Family Court, Ernakulam. The learned Sub Judge dismissed this petition. The first defendant, who is also the revision petitioner in this matter, challenges the dismissal in this revision petition.

The plaintiff/respondent is the wife of the first defendant and instituted the suit seeking partition and allotment of her one-third share in the plaint schedule property. The second defendant is their daughter. The respondent alleged that she, the revision petitioner, and the second defendant are each entitled to one-third share in the property. The revision petitioner contended that his sisters are also entitled to shares and that the tenants and his sisters are necessary parties to the suit. Accordingly, the sisters and tenants were impleaded as defendants 3 to 7.

After the suit was instituted, defendants 3 to 5 (the sisters of the first defendant) filed O.S 165 of 1985 for partition without including the respondent, and obtained a decree. The respondent then instituted O.S 246 of 1986 seeking declaration that the preliminary decree in O.S 165 of 1985 is invalid and not binding on her. Both O.S 246 of 1984 and O.S 246 of 1986 were allowed to be tried jointly. Following the recording of evidence, the petition for transfer to the Family Court was filed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Sub Court has jurisdiction to try the suit for partition or whether the suit falls within the jurisdiction of the Family Court under Section 7(1)(c) read with Section 8 of the Family Courts Act, 1984.
  2. Whether the suit is a suit or proceeding between the parties to a marriage with respect to the property of the parties or of either of them, thereby attracting the exclusion of jurisdiction of the Civil Court under the Family Courts Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Petitioner’s Arguments

  • Relying on Explanation (c) to Section 7(1) read with Section 8 of the Family Courts Act, 1984, the revision petitioner argued that the Sub Court lacked jurisdiction and the suit should be transferred to the Family Court.
  • It was contended that since the contest was only between the husband and wife (the parties to the marriage), clause (c) of Explanation to Section 7(1) applies and excludes jurisdiction of the Civil Court.
  • The petitioner relied on the decision in Shorab Modi v. Mansata Film Distributors to argue that “same parties” under Section 10 CPC does not require complete identity of parties or subject matter, implying that the Family Court should have jurisdiction.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The respondent maintained that the property in dispute belongs not only to the parties to the marriage but also to others, including the sisters of the revision petitioner.
  • The respondent argued that the suit does not fall under clause (c) of Explanation to Section 7(1) because the subject matter is not exclusively property of the parties to the marriage or either of them.
  • It was also pointed out that the sisters of the revision petitioner had instituted a separate partition suit and obtained a decree, which the respondent challenged.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Abdul v. Bhawani, AIR 1966 SC 1718 Statutes ousting civil court jurisdiction must be strictly construed; party seeking to oust jurisdiction must prove it. The court applied this principle to hold that jurisdiction exclusion under the Family Courts Act must be explicit and strict.
V.L.N.S Temple v. I. Pattabhirami, AIR 1967 SC 781 Reiteration of strict construction of jurisdiction ousting provisions; clarification on suits between parties to marriage concerning property. The court used this precedent to emphasize that the suit must be strictly between parties to the marriage regarding their property to attract Family Court jurisdiction.
Shorab Modi v. Mansata Film Distributors, AIR 1957 Calcutta 727 Interpretation of “same parties” under Section 10 CPC for stay of suit; “same parties” means parties between whom the matter substantially in issue has arisen. The court rejected the application of this precedent for interpreting jurisdiction under the Family Courts Act, noting the difference in statutory context and strictness required.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the jurisdictional provisions of the Family Courts Act, 1984, specifically Section 7(1)(c) and Section 8. Section 7(1)(c) grants Family Courts jurisdiction over suits between parties to a marriage concerning their property. Section 8 excludes the jurisdiction of District or Subordinate Civil Courts over such suits within the Family Court’s territorial jurisdiction.

The court noted the general principle that civil courts’ jurisdiction is presumed and exclusion must be explicit or clearly implied. Applying the Supreme Court’s rulings in Abdul v. Bhawani and V.L.N.S Temple v. I. Pattabhirami, the court emphasized strict construction of statutes ousting civil court jurisdiction.

In this case, the property subject to the suit did not belong exclusively to the parties to the marriage but also to the revision petitioner’s sisters, who were impleaded as necessary parties. The presence of these other interested parties meant the suit did not fall within the scope of Section 7(1)(c). Therefore, Section 8 did not operate to exclude the jurisdiction of the Sub Court.

The court rejected the revision petitioner’s reliance on the Shorab Modi decision, holding that the principles governing stay of suits under Section 10 CPC are not applicable to jurisdictional interpretation under the Family Courts Act.

Consequently, the court upheld the learned Sub Judge’s order dismissing the petition to transfer the suit to the Family Court.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is dismissed.

The court held that the Sub Court has jurisdiction to try the suit for partition as the suit involves property interests of persons other than the parties to the marriage, and thus does not fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Family Court under the Family Courts Act. The decision affirms the principle of strict construction of statutes ousting civil court jurisdiction and clarifies that the presence of additional parties with property interests excludes Family Court jurisdiction under Section 7(1)(c). No new precedent was set; the ruling directly affects the parties by maintaining the status quo regarding jurisdiction.

    Krishnan Nambudiri v. Thankamani

    1. First defendant in O.S 246 of 1984 of the Sub Court, Thrissur, a suit for partition, filed I.A 2143 of 1993 for transferring the suit to the Family Court, Ernakulam. The said petition was dismissed by the learned Sub Judge. The revision petitioner challenges the said order in this revision.

    2. Plaintiff/respondent is the wife of the first defendant-revision petitioner. She instituted the suit for partition and allotment of her ⅓rd share in the plaint schedule property. Second defendant is the daughter of plaintiff and first defendant. The respondent alleged that herself, the revision petitioner and the second defendant are entitled to ⅓rd each in the plaint schedule property. But the first defendant maintained that his sisters are also entitled to share and that, the tenants of the rooms and his sisters are also necessary parties.

    3. Accordingly they were also impleaded, the sisters of the revision petitioner are defendants 3 to 5, and defendants 6 and 7 are the tenants. In the counter affidavit to C.M.P 3657 of 1993 filed by the revision petitioner for interim stay the respondent mentions the circumstance which necessitated the impleadment of defendants 3 to 7. In that counter affidavit, the respondent would maintain that after the institution of the suit defendants 3 to 5 the sisters of the first defendant instituted O.S 165 of 1985 for partition without impleading the respondent and obtained a decree. Therefore, the respondent instituted O.S 246 of 1986 for declaration that preliminary decree in O.S 165 of 1985 is invalid and not binding on her. It is further averred in the counter affidavit that O.S 246 of 1984, from the order in which this revision arises, and O.S 246 of 1986 were allowed to be jointly triad and that after recording the evidence in the case, the said petition for transfer of the case to the Family Court was filed.

    4. According to the learned counsel for the revision petitioner as per Explanation (c) to Section 7(1) read with Section 8 of the Family Courts Act, 1984 (for short ‘the Act’) the Sub Court has no jurisdiction to try the suit and therefore the suit has to be transferred to the Family Court. Section 7(1) of the Act so far as the same is relevant reads;

    ‘7. Jurisdiction. (1) subject to the other provisions of this Act, A Family Court shall-

    (a) have and exercise all the jurisdiction exercisable by any district Court or any subordinate Civil Court under any law for the time being in force in respect of suits and proceedings of the nature referred to in the Explanation; and

    (b) be deemed, for the purposes of exercising such jurisdiction under such law, to be a district court or, as the case may be such subordinate civil court for the area to which the jurisdiction of the family Court extends.

    Explanation - The suits and proceedings referred to in this sub-section are suits and proceedings of the following nature namely:

    (a) ……………………………………

    (b) …………………………………….

    (c) a suit or proceeding between the parties to a marriage with respect to the property of the parties or of either of them;

    (Emphasis supplied)

    5. Section 8 of the Act enjoins that where a Family Court has been established for any area, no District Court or any Subordinate Civil Court shall, in relation to such area have or exercise any jurisdiction in respect of any suit or proceeding of the nature referred to in the Explanation to sub-section (1) of Section 7 of the Act. So the main question for consideration is whether a suit of this nature will fall under clause (c) of the Explanation to Section 7(1) of the Act. If the suit will attract clause (c) of Explanation, then by virtue of Section 8 of the Act, the suit has to be transferred to the Family Court within whose jurisdiction the cause of action arose. The general principle is, every presumption should be made in favour of the jurisdiction of a Civil Court. In other words, the exclusion of jurisdiction of the Civil Court cannot be readily inferred. Exclusion of jurisdiction of the civil court should be either explicitly expressed or clearly implied. In the decision in Abdul v. Bhawani (AIR 1966 SC 1718) the Supreme Court observed:

    “It is settled principle that it is for the party who seeks to oust the jurisdiction of a civil Court to establish his contention. It is also equally well settled that a statute ousting the jurisdiction of a Civil Court must be strictly constructed.”

    6. In the decision in V.L.N.S Temple v. I. Pattabhirami (AIR 1967 SC 781) also this principle is reiterated. Clause (c) of the Explanation to Section 7(1) of the Act takes info its fold, a suit or proceeding between the parties to a marriage with respect to the property of the parties or of either of them. Therefore, it is not enough that the suit is between the parties to the marriage; but the same should be with respect to the property of the parties of either of them. Here, the subject matter of the suit belongs not only to the parties to the marriage, the plaintiff and the first defendant, but belongs to others also. In the context, it is necessary to remember that it is the contention of the first defendant - revision petitioner that his sisters art also entitled to a share. When contention is others are also interested in the subject matter of the suit like a suit for partition and they are also in the party array, simply because among the parties a husband and wife are also arrayed on rival side that cannot attract clause (c) of Explanation to Section 7(1) of the Act. To over come the said position, the learned counsel for the revision petitioner relied on the decision in Shorab Modi v. Mansata Film Distributors (AIR 1957 Calcutta 727) wherein while considering the question of stay under Section 10 CPC the court held that “same parties” mentioned in Section 10 CPC would mean “the parties as between whom the matter substantially in Issue has arisen and has to be decided”, and that complete identify of either the subject matter or the parties is not required. Evidently, the said decision cannot have any application with respect to a matter arising under the Act. Simply because for the purpose of stay under Section 10, CPC complete identity of the parties is not required that cannot be extended in interpreting Sec. 8 read with Section 7 of the Act which concerns the jurisdiction of court. As noticed, a statute ousting the jurisdiction of the civil court has to be strictly construed.

    7. What the learned counsel for the revision petitioner urged was, since the second defendant did not contest the matter and the contest being only between the husband and wife, clause (c) of Explanation to Section 7(1) of the Act would be applicable. That argument cannot be accepted for the temple reason that as per clause (c) of Explanation to Section 7(1) of the Act, which has to be strictly interpreted, that subject matter of the litigation should belong to the parties to the marriage or of either of them. As noticed here the case is the property belongs to others also, then certainly clause (c) of Explanation to Section 7(1) of the Act will have no application. When that is the finding, Section 8 of the Act cannot oust jurisdiction of the Civil Court to try the suit. The conclusion reached by the learned Sub Judge does not call for any interference. The revision is without merit and the same is liable to be dismissed which accordingly is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Krishnan Nambudiri v. Thankamani
    (Feb 18, 1994)