Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Clause (2) of rule 24 of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules
  • Public Instruction. S. 36(2) of the Kerala Education Act
  • rule 24(2) of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules
  • S. 7(6) of the Kerala Education Act, 1958.
  • KERALA EDUCATION ACT
  • rule 24 the rule
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Clause (2) of rule 24 of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules
  • Public Instruction. S. 36(2) of the Kerala Education Act
  • rule 24(2) of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules
  • S. 7(6) of the Kerala Education Act, 1958.
  • KERALA EDUCATION ACT
  • rule 24 the rule
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the manager and owner of an aided upper primary school at Shoranur, an institution founded by his grandfather over 60 years earlier and later managed by the petitioner's father until his death in June 1966. Although young and with health difficulties, the petitioner assumed management responsibilities. On 27-5-1971 the petitioner sent a notice (Ext. P1) to the Director of Public Instruction (2nd respondent) stating his intention to close the school with effect from the academic year 1972–1973, expressly invoking rule 24 of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules. After receiving no reply for several months, he sent a reminder on 29-11-1971. On 31-12-1971 the Assistant Educational Officer, Shoranur (3rd respondent) informed the petitioner by letter (Ext. P3) that permission for closure had been declined by the Director and enclosed a copy of the Director's proceedings purportedly passed on 31-7-1971 (marked Ext. P4).

The petitioner filed a writ petition seeking: (a) quashal of Ext. P4; and (b) a writ of mandamus (or other appropriate writ) directing the 3rd respondent to accept from the petitioner and the Headmistress all records and accounts maintained in the school on or immediately after its closing on 31-5-1972.

The petitioner challenged the validity of rule 24(2) of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules as being ultra vires section 7(6) of the Kerala Education Act, 1958. In their counter-affidavit the respondents contended that the manager has no legal right to close an aided school without permission of the competent authority and that the Director validly refused permission; they also refuted the petitioner's claim that rule 24(2) is ultra vires.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether clause (2) of rule 24 of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules is inconsistent with, and therefore ultra vires, section 7(6) of the Kerala Education Act, 1958.
  2. Whether the State Government, by introducing rule 24(2), exceeded its rule-making powers and thereby impermissibly amended the substantive provision contained in section 7(6).
  3. Whether rule 24(2) vests uncanalised or arbitrary discretion in the Director of Public Instruction in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution (raised by the petitioner as a separate contention).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Section 7(6) of the Kerala Education Act restricts a manager's right to close a school only by requiring one year's notice expiring with 31st May; rule 24(2) imposes further conditions and is therefore inconsistent with the statute and ultra vires.
  • By adding clause (2) via notification, the State Government has effectively amended the parent statute and usurped the legislature's primary law-making function.
  • Rule 24(2) confers uncanalised and arbitrary power on the Director to grant or refuse permission without guiding principles; this also leaves the affected party without remedy because the Director's order is declared "final".
  • The petitioner had complied with section 7(6) by giving the requisite notice (Ext. P1) and thus was entitled to close the school.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The manager has no legal right to close down an aided school without permission of the competent authority.
  • In the present case permission to close the school was validly refused by the Director under rule 24(2).
  • The contention that rule 24(2) is ultra vires was strongly refuted in the respondents' counter-affidavit.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ferrier v. Wilson, 4 C.L.R. 785, 791 Principle that if the legislature prescribes conditions under which an act is lawful/unlawful, a subordinate authority cannot, by making rules, alter that law as declared by the legislature. The court relied on this authority to support the conclusion that a rule (rule 24(2)) which alters the substantive effect of section 7(6) of the Act is ultra vires and cannot be given effect.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by recognising the petitioner's ownership of the school and the generally accepted right of an owner to close an institution, noting that reasonable restrictions may be imposed by the legislature under Article 19. The only statutory restriction in the Kerala Education Act identified by the court is section 7(6), which the opinion quotes in full:

“(6). No manager shall close down any school unless one year's notice, expiring with the 31st May of any year, of his intention so to do, has been given to the officer authorised by the Government in this behalf”.

The court observed that section 7(6) requires only that the manager give one year's notice expiring with 31st May to the authorised officer. Subject to that compliance, the statute preserves the manager's freedom to close the school.

The court then examined clause (2) of rule 24 (added by notification dated 11-5-1965), which provides that "The Director may, after considering all aspects of the question, grant permission for the closure of the school and recognition of such school shall lapse. No application for withdrawal of the notice after the issue of permission shall be entertained unless adequate reasons are adduced to the satisfaction of the Director. The order of the Director in the matter shall be final."

The court found that the rule-making authority, by introducing this clause, vested the Director with discretion to grant or refuse permission and made the manager's right to close the school dependent upon the Director's permission. This, the court held, imposes additional restrictions not found in section 7(6).

Analysing the legislative scheme, the court considered the scope of the State Government's rule-making power under section 36(2) (clauses (a) to (m)) and the general power in section 36(1) to make rules to carry the Act into effect. The court concluded that the impugned provision did not fall within the enumerated matters of section 36(2) and could not be justified as a rule "to carry into effect" section 7(6). Imposing an additional substantive restriction by rule amounted to altering the law enacted by the legislature, which is beyond subordinate rule-making power.

The court relied on the authority in Ferrier v. Wilson to underscore the established principle that subordinate legislation cannot contradict or alter the conditions prescribed by the parent Act. Applying that principle, the court held rule 24(2) to be ultra vires.

The petitioner’s separate contention that rule 24(2) conferred arbitrary powers on the Director contrary to Article 14 was acknowledged; the court found this contention to have considerable force but did not decide the Article 14 point in detail because it was unnecessary in light of the finding of ultra vires.

Since the petitioner had complied with section 7(6) by serving Ext. P1 notice, and the Director's refusal (Ext. P4) was based solely on rule 24(2), which the court held void, Ext. P4 was quashed. The court directed the 3rd respondent to take over the school's records and accounts expeditiously in view of the school's closure effective from the academic year 1972–1973.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Rule 24(2) of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules is ultra vires and void; Ext. P4 (the Director's refusal) is quashed and the Original Petition is allowed.

Direct consequences and implications for the parties:

  • The petitioner, having complied with section 7(6) by giving the requisite one year's notice (Ext. P1), is not prevented from closing the school by rule 24(2).
  • The Director's order (Ext. P4) declining permission on the basis of rule 24(2) is quashed.
  • The 3rd respondent is directed to take over from the petitioner the records and accounts relating to the school as expeditiously as possible, in view of the closure effective from the academic year 1972–1973.
  • The parties are to bear their respective costs.

Broader legal implications: The court grounded its decision on the established principle that subordinate legislation cannot alter the law as declared by the Legislature; however, the opinion does not purport to lay down a novel or broader precedent beyond applying that principle to the facts before it.

    Krishna Kumar v. State Of Kerala & Others

    1. The petitioner is the manager of an aided upper primary school at Shoranur. The school was originally started by the petitioner's grand-father more than 60 years ago. After the death of the founder the petitioner's father succeeded him as the manager of the school. He died in June 1966 when the petitioner was only 19 years old. In spite of his young age the petitioner had to take up the responsibility of administering the school as its manager and he took over the said burden. It would appear that the petitioner found it difficult to properly look after the management of the school, especially in view of the fact that he was not keeping normal health and was unable to move out freely on account of some defect in his knee joints. Hence on 27-5-1971 he addressed a letter Ext. P1 to the Director of Public Instruction, Trivandrum (2nd respondent) intimating the latter about the petitioner's intention to close down this school with effect from the academic year 1972-1973. It was expressly mentioned in Ex. P1 that the notice was being given by him as per rule 24 of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules. The petitioner's case is that he did not receive any reply from the 2nd respondent for several months and hence he addressed a reminder petition to the 2nd respondent on 29-11-1971. Thereafter on 31-12-1971 the Assistant Educational Officer, Shoranur sent the letter Ext. P3 to the petitioner informing him that permission for the closure of the school had been declined by the Director of Public Instruction and as an enclosure to the said letter the petitioner was furnished with a copy of the proceedings of the Director which purports to have been passed on 31-7-1971. The petitioner has produced a copy of the said order and it has been marked as Ext. P4. By this writ petition the petitioner seeks to quash Ext. P4 and he has also prayed for the issuance of a writ of mandamus or other appropriate writ compelling the 3rd respondent—the Assistant Educational Officer, Shoranur—to receive from the petitioner and the Headmistress of the school all the records and accounts maintained in the school on the date of closing or immediately after the closing down of the school on 31-5-1972. The petitioner has challenged the validity of rule 24(2) of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules on the ground that it is ultra vires S. 7(6) of the Kerala Education Act, 1958. In the counter affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents it is contended that the manager has no legal right to close down an aided school without the permission of the competent authority and that in the present case such permission has been validly refused by the Director. The plea of the petitioner that rule 24(2) of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules is ultra vires has been strongly refuted by the respondents.

    2. The petitioner is admittedly the owner of the school. Ordinarily, it is a right inherent in the owner of any institution or establishment to close it down if he finds it impossible or even inconvenient for him to continue to run it. This right is an essential ingredient of the fundamental rights guaranteed under article 19(1)(f) and (g) of the Constitution. Reasonable restrictions can however be imposed on the exercise of the said right in the manner authorised by clauses (5) and (6) of article 19 of the Constitution but that can be done only by the legislature by enacting a suitable statutory provision in that regard. The only provision is the Kerala Education Act which purports to impose a restriction on the right of the manager of a school to close down the institution is that contained in S. 7(6). That provision reads:

    “(6). No manager shall close down any school unless one year's notice, expiring with the 31st May of any year, of his intention so to do, has been given to the officer authorised by the Government in this behalf”.

    3. Under the said section the only restriction placed on the manager's right to close down a school is that he should give one year's previous notice expiring with the 31st day of May of the ensuing year, to the officer authorised by the Government in that behalf intimating his intention to close down the institution. Subject to compliance with the said requirement of giving one year's notice the statute has reserved freedom to the manager to close down his school. Clause (2) of rule 24 of Chapter V of the Kerala Education Rules has however imposed additional trammels on the manager's right to close down the school. Rule 24 as it originally stood contained only the clause which now stands numbered as clause (1) and its terms are in perfect conformity with the provision enacted in S. 7(6) of the Act. It was by a notification published in the Kerala Gazette dated 11-5-1965 that clause (2) was added to the rule. That clause reads:

    “(2) The Director may, after considering all aspects of the question, grant permission for the closure of the school and recognition of such school shall lapse. No application for withdrawal of the notice after the issue of permission shall be entertained unless adequate reasons are adduced to the satisfaction of the Director. The order of the Director in the matter shall be final.”

    4. By the introduction of the said new clause in rule 24 the rule making authority has proceeded to vest the Director of Public Instruction with a discretion either to grant or refuse permission to the manager for the closure of his school and the manager's right to close the school is made dependent upon the grant of permission by the Director. It is also declared that the order passed by the Director shall be final.

    5. The learned advocate for the petitioner contends that clause (2) of R24 is inconsistent with the provision contained in S. 7(6) of the parent enactment and that it is ultra vires for that reason. It is further urged that what has really been done by the State Government by the introduction of clause (2) in purported exercise of its power to frame rules is to amend the provisions of S. 7(6) and thereby to arrogate to themselves the primary legislative function. Another contention that is taken on behalf of the petitioner is that under the impugned rule the Director has been conferred uncanalised and arbitrary powers either to grant or refuse permission according to his fancy without any guiding principles being laid down in the rule as to how the discretion is to be exercised by him. In this connection it is also pointed out that the affected party is left without any remedy since the order of the Director is declared to be final.

    6. After hearing both sides and giving the matter my anxious consideration I can constrain to hold that rule 24(2) is inconsistent with S. 7(6) of the Act and is also beyond the rule-making power of the State Government. When the Legislature while enacting the parent Statute has thought it fit to impose only a limited restriction on the right of the manager to close down his school, it is not open to the rule-making authority to impose additional restrictions on the said right because that would amount to an usurpation of the function of substantive law making which only the Legislature is competent to perform. Under the terms of S. 7(6) of the Act the manager's right to close down his school is preserved subject to his complying with the condition laid down in the said section insisting on one year's prior notice. What has been done under rule 24(2) is to further abridge the freedom of the manager beyond what the parent enactment has authorised to be done by subjecting the right of the manager to close down the institution to a further condition that it will be dependent upon the grant of permission by the Director of Public Instruction. S. 36(2) of the Kerala Education Act enumerates the various matters with respect to which provision may be made by the State Government by framing rules under the Act. The impugned rule will not come within the scope of the power conferred by any of the clauses (a) to (m) of S. 36(2). Nor can the said rule be regarded as having been validly made in exercise of the general power conferred by S. 36(1) to make rules to carry into effect the provisions of the Act. As per S. 7(6) of the Act the manager is entitled to close down a school provided he has given the requisite notice under the said section. The making of a rule imposing an additional restriction on the manager's right cannot be regarded as a step taken by the Government for carrying into effect the provisions of S. 7(6) of the Act. On the other hand the said provision in so far as it abridges a right which is preserved by S. 7(6) of the Act is inconsistent with the said section.

    7. As pointed out by Griffith, C.J in Ferrier v. Wilson, 4 C.L.R 785, 791, if the legislature deals with a particular act, and prescribes the conditions under which it will be lawful and those under which it will be unlawful, the subordinate authority cannot, under the presence of making a rule alter the law as so declared by the Legislature. The principle is well-established that if a rule framed under the statute is in contravention of or inconsistent with any provision contained in the parent Act the rule must be regarded as ultra vires and cannot be given effect to. Judged in the light of the said principle rule 24(2) must be held to be beyond the rule-making power of the State Government and hence ultra vires and void.

    8. I find also considerable force in the contention advanced on behalf of the petitioner that under rule 24(2) a naked and arbitrary power has been conferred on the Director to grant or refuse permission according to his unfettered discretion without any guiding principles being laid down by the rule making authority and that on this ground the impugned rule has to be regarded as violative of article 14 of the Constitution. It is however unnecessary to go into this question in greater detail in view of my having come to the conclusion that the rule is even otherwise ultra vires and void.

    9. Admittedly, the petitioner has complied with the provisions of S. 7(6) by giving due notice as per Ext. P1 of his intention to close down the school. The 2nd respondent has purported to decline permission only on the basis of the provision contained in rule 24(2) which I have held to be ultra vires. Ext. P4 will therefore stand quashed.

    10. There will be a direction to the 3rd respondent to take over from the petitioner the records, accounts etc. relating to the school as expeditiously as possible in view of the fact that the school is being closed down by the petitioner with effect from the academic year 1972-1973.

    11. The Original Petition is allowed as above. The parties will bear their respective costs. A carbon copy of this judgment will be furnished to the counsel appearing for the petitioner on payment of the requisite charges.

    12. Allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Krishna Kumar v. State Of Kerala & Others
    (May 31, 1972)